r/fantanoforever • • 28d ago

Subreddit Rules Rule 2 Reminder

93 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

Polite reminder that rule 2 exists, which is to specify the album/artist name when making a post if either is not on the album and/or photo. This has been a problem that has been popping up more than we would like, as of late. Even if the album or artist is well known, please do not assume that everyone will know who they are/what the album is. Having the name helps the discussion by allowing people who dont know these artists or albums to find them easily so they can start listening to them.

Thank you.


r/fantanoforever • • Sep 23 '26

Subreddit Rules Rule Updates and State of the Subreddit

79 Upvotes

Hi all!

Over the past couple of years, the content on this subreddit has changed - often to the detriment to the quality of the forum. Over the past couple of days, the mod group have discussed freshening up our guidance on a range of topics, to respond to these changes. In effort to improve the subreddit, we have updated our rules on politics, drama, AI, and low effort posting.

Fundamentally, this is a music subreddit about a music reviewer. We want to maintain the best parts of discussion we see on this forum, and try and reduce the worst parts. The intention of the updated guidance is to do exactly that. To be precise - we want to reduce the amount of Fauxmoi discussion posts here. There are other subreddits for that discussion.

There have also been some changes to the types of posts that are allowed - requirements around body text as well as post flairs have been turned on, as well as the introduction of bot bouncer to reduce bots on the subreddit.

If anyone has any further suggestions for improving this community please reach out!


r/fantanoforever • • 8h ago

Discussion Every gta vi radio host

Post image
376 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 9h ago

Recommendations I'm starving for albums that sound like this pls

Thumbnail
gallery
182 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 7h ago

Discussion Worst Thing You Can Say: Day 33

Post image
67 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 4h ago

Discussion Artists Whose Music Feels The Most Like This

Post image
32 Upvotes

My pick: Porter Robinson


r/fantanoforever • • 6h ago

Discussion EPs that are as great as (or sometimes better than) any of an artist’s full length releases

Thumbnail
gallery
41 Upvotes

ATDI- Vaya: it’s got a unique, darker and more atmospheric sound compared to their full lengths. Does it replace any of their great full lengths? Definitely not, but its unique style and tone makes it just as worthy of being put right next to Relationship of Command or In/Casino/Out in conversation for their best output. 198D remains my favorite song they ever made

Black Flag- Nervous Breakdown: just four tracks, but four of the most iconic and memorable punk songs of all time. Barely breaks the 5 minute mark but within those 5 minutes the genre itself has rarely sounded better than this. Compared to the others in my own list, this one is the place where I can most confidently say it’s the best thing the band ever put out

Still Life- split EP with Jara, and Slow Children At Play: while their first full length “From Angry Heads With Skyward Eyes” is already incredible and marks a transitionary sound between Downcast style hardcore and outright emocore with bigger progressive song structures, their mid-90s EPs go a step further and really show off a lot of their more evolved songwriting and experimentation between hardcore, emocore, and even outright post-rock at times, simultaneously bringing in more diverse atmospheres, more rich melodies, harshly contrasting dynamics, but never sacrificing the visceral hardcore roots. These two short EPs really show some of the best that the entire emo genre has to offer

Archers of Loaf- VS The Greatest Of All Time: the worst thing I can say about this is that the opening track is a step behind the rest, but nonetheless these are some of the best melancholy, dreary, gritty, but heartfelt alternative rock songs you could come across, all gathered on one short little EP. This is music to listen to on public transit as you stare out the window on a rainy day. Most of their music is like that, but this one just focuses and concentrates that specific feeling


r/fantanoforever • • 8h ago

Recommendations Albums covers like this?

Post image
51 Upvotes

I just like stylized cityscapes


r/fantanoforever • • 3h ago

Discussion Do you consider "Obscured by Clouds" to be part of the "classic" Pink Floyd era? Since it was released after Meddle and before Dark Side.

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 14h ago

Discussion Albums with fantastic music but absolutely yikes subject matter?

Post image
135 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 12h ago

Discussion With U2 back in the spotlight, I`ll always hold the opinion that this trilogy of albums that they released in the 90s is one of the greatest achievements in music. The reinvention and creativity were insane. Also, anybody here actually prefers Zooropa or Pop over Achtung Baby?

Post image
61 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 6h ago

Discussion Favourite meta/self-referential songs?

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

My picks:

In Bloom by Nirvana - The songs about a guy who likes Nirvana’s songs (but it generally refers to punk music) and sings along but refuses to listen to what the lyrics actually mean, critiquing superficial fans that couldn’t care less about what the music is trying to say

My Iron Lung by Radiohead - The ‘iron lung’ refers to their hit Creep which they didn’t really like and felt didn’t represent them as a band, yet gave them massive mainstream success and financial freedom

Hey Ya! by OutKast - I can’t do one of these and not mention this song, everyone knows it but anyway it’s a happy upbeat song with depressing lyrics about how love fades yet people decide to stay together due to societal pressure although they may not be happy in their relationship, the song’s written to be upbeat specifically to reflect the ignorance people generally have with this. “Y’all don’t wanna hear me you just wanna dance.”

Glass Onion by The Beatles - “Glass onion” is a metaphor for looking at something that seems complex and layered but is actually quite simple. Lennon in the song relates this to previous Beatles songs like Strawberry Fields Forever or I Am The Walrus where people tried to look for a deep meaning in the lyrics when they were generally self-explanatory or meaningless. He also plays into it by singing “Well here’s another clue for you all, the walrus was Paul,” which also unintentionally played into the “Paul is dead” theory


r/fantanoforever • • 6h ago

Discussion 2026 Albums with Great Drumming?

13 Upvotes

I promise this isn’t in reaction to the post yesterday about “unintentionally bad drumming” haha 😅. I’ve listened to most of the “classic drum albums”, and I’m just looking for something contemporary!


r/fantanoforever • • 2h ago

Fantano Vids Ecco2k - Echo ALBUM REVIEW

Thumbnail
youtu.be
6 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 14h ago

JOKE Anyone else see the footage from the APEC Summit and immediately think…

Post image
51 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 5h ago

Discussion I just discovered The Damned watching random Miami Vice clips. Been listening to ``In Dulce Decorum'' on repeat ever since. Any other music that sounds like this?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

It's a punk band originally but this particular tracks has some post-punk and new wave vibes. It's labelled on Wikipedia as Gothic rock.


r/fantanoforever • • 6h ago

Discussion Do you think the best music of the '70s, '80s, and '90s actually made the Top 40?

8 Upvotes

We've been looking through decades of music charts, and it's interesting how differently we remember popular music compared to what was actually charting at the time.

Some songs that dominated the charts have practically disappeared from conversations today, while others that barely made an impact commercially are now considered classics.

The '70s, '80s, and '90s are especially interesting because of how much the mainstream sound changed, from disco and classic rock to new wave, hip-hop, alternative, and R&B.

We've been working on a collection called Across the Charts that documents Top 40 hits across all three decades, and it's brought up an interesting question:

Which artists or albums from those decades do you think deserved way more commercial success than they actually got?

And on the flip side, which massive hits from those eras do you think have aged the worst?


r/fantanoforever • • 17h ago

Discussion What artists are you embarrassed to admit you used to love?

Thumbnail
gallery
53 Upvotes

As a young, impressionable, Christian teenager, I used to think For King and Country was the shit. In hindsight, they are quite emblematic of the problem with a lot of CCM (Contemporary Christian Music) artists. You see, these guys can't write a verse to save their lives. I'm not really sure if they can write a chorus either but the verses are so bad that, by the time you get to it, the chorus sounds like "God Only Knows" in comparison. Literally, the only reason these CCM songs have verses in the first place is to make the transition to the chorus (which is accompanied by a dramatic increase in intensity and volume) more epic. It's like Pixies, except it sucks. Unless you're 16.

The other artist on this list is Eric Clapton. Now you may say "But GaelicTuna, Eric Clapton is one of the greatest guitarists of all time and Cream was enormously influential on hard rock" and I would say you are absolutely correct. However, this wasn't me being in love with Cream, Derek and the Dominos or Bluesbreakers. This was me spending three years of my adult life thinking that Eric Clapton, Slowhand, and 461 Ocean Boulevard was the pinnacle of music. This was me thinking that the eight-minute noodling session known as "The Core" was on par with classic extended tracks such as "Free Bird" and "Hey Jude". In hindsight, it's quite funny because I only really listened to his greatest hits albums (I was still in my "what's the point of listening to non-compilation studio albums" phase) and now I realized that the work he did with Cream and Derek and the Dominos was a lot better than some of the stuff I was listening to ("Let it rain" still slaps though). At this point, Slowhand is probably his best solo album and, at best, his fifth best album overall.


r/fantanoforever • • 3h ago

Discussion How the Grammys Gave Nominees whose Names are the Beginning of the Alphabet an Unexpected Advantage

Thumbnail
cantgetmuchhigher.com
3 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 22h ago

Discussion Albums you thought would suck, but ended up ripping ass?

Thumbnail
gallery
95 Upvotes

Phil Spector producing the Ramones? Neil Young doing electronica? They shouldn't work, but I'll be god-damned if they aren't some of my favourites of their discographies. What are your pleasant surprises?


r/fantanoforever • • 19h ago

Discussion Stephen Wilson Jr. (age 47) has become the oldest person to win Best New Artist at the CMAs

Post image
50 Upvotes

r/fantanoforever • • 3m ago

Discussion What are some bands/artists you love, but don’t have an album that you love?

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

For me:

  1. Pixies: they’re one of my favorite bands, but I’d be lying if I said, even their best albums don’t have a few very underwhelming songs, but their musical sensibilities connect with me too much for that to matter.

  2. The Strokes: They have an unbelievable amount of hits in my book, but their most consistent albums, Is This It, Comedown Machine, and The New Abnormal, don’t have the absolute highs that some of their more mixed albums like Fioe, Angles, and even Reality Awaits have.

  3. Weyes Blood: there’s actually only a few songs of her’s that I truly love, but those songs connect with me on such a deep level


r/fantanoforever • • 6m ago

Discussion Performance or concert experience?

• Upvotes

Who’s the most recent artist you discovered and then went to see live? What encouraged you to?


r/fantanoforever • • 4h ago

Discussion If this album were made by anyone else, it would be held in significantly higher regard.

Post image
3 Upvotes

I originally posted this to r/emo and was overwhelmed by how many people seemed to agree. What do you guys think? My argument is in the original post. I should also add that when I say higher regard, I'm primarily referring to emo/hardcore discourse.


r/fantanoforever • • 3h ago

Recommendations Songs like “I’m still here” by John Rzeznik matching these points

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone

I’m looking for music that’s similar to songs like “I’m still here” by John Rzeznik (the song of Treasure Planet)

Songs that talk about themes of feeling lost in this world, becoming the man despite all the adversities, feeling misunderstood/misplaced in the current world,
Or songs in general with that type of rock music like that or “over you” by Daughtry

Can yall help me find some good music for that?