This is the fourth time I am doing the r/fantasy Bingo and writing reviews for all of the books, but probably the earliest I have finished it : This time it only took me seven months and a half !
Summary :
I will first write a short summary, to highlight the new books and series I have read for Bingo and to which I gave 4 or 5 stars:
- New books I liked by authors that I had not read before: Of Monsters and Mainframes by Barbara Truelove, Please don't tell my Parents I am a Supervillain by Richard Roberts, The Warden by Daniel M. Ford, and The Otome Heroine's Fight for Survival by Harunohi Biyori.
- New books I liked by authors I had already read before, but that were not part of a series I was already reading: Traitors' Nest by Frances Hardinge, Barnaby the Wanderer by Raymond St Elmo, Unbearable by A. Lee Martinez, Eden by Stanislaw Lem, and Death Has Joined the Party by Rachel Aaron.
- New books I thought were flawed but still interesting to read: Whoever Steals This Book by Nowaki Fukamidori, The Dragon Has Some Complaints by John Wiswell, The Birthgrave by Tanith Lee, and City of Others by Jared Poon.
General comments :
- Favorite Squares this year were Game Changer, Non-Human Protagonist, and First Contact, because I don’t usually read many books that fit these squares, but this year I read a lot of books that could have fitted them, and they were often fun to read or interesting.
- Even though I finished the Bingo early this time, I struggled with finding and finishing the books for quite a few squares: Duology Part 1 and Duology Part 2, Vacation Spot, Older Protagonist, Trans or Nonbinary Protagonist. There was a surprising lack of duologies on my To Be Read pile, and the fantasy and science fiction genres sure lack books happening in places that sound nice to visit, or books with protagonists that are older than fifty, or nonbinary protagonists who are actual human beings and not, for example, snarky murderbots or three-gendered aliens.
Some other statistics :
- 3 of the books I read for Bingo were by Japanese authors, 1 was by an author from Singapore, 1 by a Polish author, and the other books were by English, American, or Australians authors. 8 of the books featured important LGBT characters.
- 6 of the books I read for Bingo were published in 2026, and 11 altogether were published in the 2020s and 21 published since 2000s, so there is quite a recency bias in my reading. Only 1 book was a sequel, for the Duology Part 2 square (obviously), but 12 books were by authors I had read before.
Short Reviews for all the books are below.
First Row Across :
- Trans or Nonbinary Protagonist: Magica Riot by Kara Buchanan (1 star).
A novel about a punk rock band of trans magical girls sounds like it could make for a good story, but in reality that book was almost comically bad. Simplistic plot, shallow characterisation, cliched villains, cringe dialogue, and the whole concept was played straightforwardly with absolutely no unexpected twists to the story, making for a rather boring read. The whole novel came across as being wasted potential, thoughtlessly lazy in its writing and corny beyond belief, and weirdly childish despite all the characters supposedly being adults. As is often the case, having good ideas does not matter if you cannot write them well, and that was the perfect example of why.
- Judge a Book by Its Title: Whoever Steals This Book, by Nowaki Fukamidori (3.5 stars).
This is another book with a good premise, but an unconvincing execution of it, but I liked it much better. A library belonging to a family of book collectors is protected from thieves by the curse of a fox god, trapping the thief and the town inside a book story every time a book is stolen, and the granddaughter of the family has to catch the thief and find the books to cancel the curse, along with a mysterious werewolf girl. The highlight of the book was in my opinion the strange worlds created by the curse (a surrealist fairy tale where pearls rain from the sky and the moon is the eye of a cat, a Noir detective story version of Fahrenheit 451, a Studio Ghibli-esque steampunk dystopia), but I felt that they were left underexplored. And the book suffered a lot from having bland and underdeveloped characters and a confusing overall storyline.
- Translated: The Otome Heroine's Fight for Survival, Volumes 1 to 6, by Harunohi Biyori (4 stars).
This is a rather fun and easy to read litRPG series. The premise is that the heroine of an "otome" video game (a Japanese game aimed at teenage girls), upon learning the plot of the game (which is from her point of view her future life) from an insane reincarnated Japanese woman who tried to take over her body, decides to rebel against her future fate to become the Chosen One and marry the crown prince and instead runs away from the orphanage where she lived to become an adventurer. Because she would apparently rather live as a feral child in the woods and eats snakes and turns into a ruthless assassin murder hobo than become a princess.
This is quite an action packed series. While the heroine manages to stay rather likable and never does anything truly evil despite her ruthlessness and obsession with always growing more powerful, I felt like half the series was just her killing her various enemies in particularly gory ways. But the author managed to include enough character development and plot twists and worldbuilding to keep it from becoming too repetitive, and she is usually an underdog in those fights, so the series avoided the usual "overpowered main character" syndrome that most isekai light novels have.
- Small Press or Self-Published: Please don't tell my Parents I am a Supervillain, by Richard Roberts (5 stars).
This book was a lot of fun. The daughter of two retired superheroes gains mad scientist superpowers and accidentally becomes a supervillain with her two nerdy friends, because they are all thirteen years old and stupid. The Japanese have a word for teenagers pretending to be edgy supervillains: chuunibyo, which literally translates as middle-schooler syndrom, and those three are obviously suffering from it, except they really have superpowers to get them into trouble: Penny enjoys making crazy inventions and gloating when they cause chaos while being terrified of her nice and overprotective parents ever finding out, Ray is trying to impress her doing stupid things because he has a crush on her, and Claire is basically along for the ride because she is apparently a groupie of every superhero and supervillain around. And together they just keep digging themselves deeper and deeper in the supervillain hole.
Not that anything actually bad happens to them. In the end, this is just a silly comedy parodying superhero stories, so the amount of darkness in it is very limited, and it even turns out that superheroes and supervillains actually have some kind of informal agreement for not trying to find out each other secret identities or even actually trying to kill each others because pushing into a corner someone with superpowers is a really bad idea. The overall mood reminded me of a mix of the Pixar movie The Incredibles, the comics book series Girl Genius, the manga One Punch Man, and A. Lee Martinez comedic fantasy books. But there is a place in literature for cozy entertaining books about people having silly but fun adventures, particularly given how rare good comedic fantasy writers are in the genre, and that book was very good at filling that niche. The rest of the series was equally fun to read.
- Unusual Transportation: Bye, Bye Earth, Volumes 1 to 3, by Tow Ubukata (3.5 stars).
That was a rather bizarre book. Post-apocalyptic science-fiction where science is so advanced that it is basically magic, set on the Moon in a country ruled by a mad Tree-God (actually an ancient AI called Deus Ex Machina) where bioengineered animal people constantly fight with living magic swords for their God’s entertainment in made-up but deadly wars while riding on giant turtles. The surrealist worldbuilding and twisted dystopian society kind of reminded me of Jack Vance books but without Vance’s beautifully purple satirical prose (instead, the prose was rather basic, although this may just have been the translation).
The heroine, a teenage girl with a giant magical sword and apparently the last normal human in the world, wants to earn the God’s approval to become a nomad and leave the country (which is surrounded by magical barrier preventing that) to find other people like her. Therefore, she goes to the capital to fight in those wars for that, not knowing that her former master actually intends to use her to overthrow the system and kill the God « somehow » (he and his fellow conspirators love to meet each other to make cryptic statements about that, and the weirdness of the worldbuilding kind of gets in the way of understanding what is actually happening or what they are planning). Still, I kind of liked it. The protagonist Belle is rather likeable and the worldbuilding and side characters are interesting, although I think I preferred the anime adaptation that I saw some years ago to the actual books.
Second Row Across :
- The Afterlife: Traitors' Nest, by Frances Hardinge (5 stars).
Frances Hardinge always writes books with some of the most creatively strange worldbuilding I ever came across, and in this case it is a medieval kingdom where castles keep switching places according a magical Game played by the ghosts of ancient aristocrats on obscure rules invented by the magpie spirit who cursed them. This adds new terrors to the already harsh lives of medieval peasants, and when a wandering castle strips a village from all its food and resources because its ruler knows that he will be gone long before he has to face the consequences (or so he mistakenly thinks), one farmer and his children decide to lead a peasant revolt, which ends with him as a dead new « Player » in the game and his children in charge of a new rebel castle full of peasants now trying to survive as the castle keeps teleporting around the kingdom while armies from the other Players try to crush their rebellion.
This was a good book, with a general theme of power being a curse without its holders realising it, of abuses of powers eventually backfiring on the abusers because they are self-destructive, and of how hard it is to actually be in charge while trying to do your best for the people who rely on you and not becoming corrupted. The main characters were generally likeable (and of course, it is because they were good people that they were eventually able to change the game) despite being quite out of their depths. However, what I particularly enjoyed were the creative tactics allowed by the very existence of the teleporting castles. It also made for some quite tense plot since you never knew what kind of crazy situation the cast would be thrown into next, or when.
- Game Changer: Death Has Joined the Party, by Rachel Aaron (4 stars).
As litRPG stories go, this one was definitely on the tongue-in-cheek self-parody side of the genre, but it was still a lot of fun. I particularly liked the crazy mimic girl eating everything and her antics, and the cynical evil lich who literally haunts our goody-two-shoes necromancer protagonist and made sarcastic comments on everything, including the protagonist's own naivety and idealism (which would have been a bit too much to take otherwise). And while the idea of a televised dungeon crawling death game / reality show is hardly an original one in the litRPG genre, it was handled very well here, with plenty of fun satire of the entertainment industry.
- Vacation Spot: The Vampire Knitting Club, by Nancy Warren (3 stars).
This book had quite a cozy atmosphere, and I quite liked the club of good-natured but knitting-obsessed vampires, who reminded me somewhat of the Black Ribboners in Terry Pratchett's Discworld series. It was nice to have an urban fantasy series set in Oxford instead of Chicago or New York or London as usual. And it is always fun to have the protagonist trying to solve a murder when the murder victim is still walking around as an undead and trying to help find their killer, this is the kind of crazy situation that really can only happen in a fantasy mystery novel.
On the other hand, I very much guessed who the killer was as soon as the protagonist met them, so it quite failed as a mystery in my eyes. To be honest, the protagonist did not come across as very smart, so maybe it made sense she could not figure it out. I don't know if the author really intended for her to feel like such a dumb blonde bimbo, but I prefer my female protagonists to be smarter and tougher than that, particularly for a mystery series. And the love triangle was cliched and annoying. For that reason, I would recommend that book more to fans of cozy fantasy than to fans of mysteries.
- Five Short Stories: The Ladies of Grace Adieu, by Susanna Clarke (4 stars).
A collection of dark « fairy tales » set in the world of Jonathan Strange and Mister Norrell, all written in different styles. Maybe because those tales were short stories, I thought they had better pacing than the original book and I enjoyed reading them a lot more.
- Older Protagonist: The Lost Fleet: Dauntless, by Jack Campbell (3 stars).
A spaceship captain awakes from hibernation a century after his supposed death in combat... only to discover that he is now a famous hero and in charge (by dint of extreme seniority) in charge of bringing the fleet that rescued him back home from deep inside enemy territory. It is a fun premise, but I found the execution unconvincing. The world building and prose were basic, the characters one dimensional, and the story generally had a very "video game" feel to it.
And for some reason, the protagonist is the only man in the galaxy who is still good at military strategy, tactics, logistics, and organization, because a century of war has turned everyone into bloodthirsty idiots who think charging blindly at the enemy is glorious rather than stupid. First, I dislike when an author makes their protagonist looks smart by making everyone else an idiot, but secondly I think that this should realistically be the other way round: people who have fought for a century should have learned to become very good at war and not the opposite.
On the other hand, it was still a rather easy read with a likable protagonist who thinks he should still follow the Geneva conventions (or whatever is their equivalent in the far future) and spare POW lives even if he is the only one who still cares about that, and the space battles were quite interesting with their emphasis on how the speed of light would cause important delays in obtaining information and giving orders when fighting in space.
Third Row Across :
- Duology Part 1: The Doomfarers of Coramonde, by Brian Daley (3 stars).
The most fun part of this book is when the mad scientist turned wizard decides to summon an Armored Personal Carrier from the Vietnam war along with five very confused American soldiers to fight a dragon. Sadly, this is the only fun part of the book and only represents a quarter of it, with the soldiers being sent back soon afterwards. The rest of the book was a rather boring and incoherent mashup of very melodramatic epic fantasy tropes. It was like the author had no idea what kind of book they wanted to write and just stuffed it with anything he thought was cool.
- Book Club: Greenteeth, by Molly O'Neill (2 stars).
This was a surprisingly boring book and it took me over a month to finish it, although I am not entirely sure why, because in theory I should have loved a book written from the point of view of a sarcastic fairy swamp monster. The ideas behind it were fine if a bit cliched (two fairies and a witch go on a quest to find a magic weapon to kill the ancient evil god threatening their home), but the pacing, prose, plot, and characterisation all felt so incredibly bland and unimaginative.
I also have no idea what made this story « cozy fantasy » in the mind of the marketing department, because I felt that it was very much an epic fantasy story, unless they think cozy means boring.
- Published in 2026: The Dragon Has Some Complaints, by John Wiswell (3.5 stars).
While this book is technically about a war between a free flying city-state of dragon riders against an evil steampunk empire, it is more of a comedic and cozy fantasy book, since it has as its protagonist an old crippled and amnesiac intelligent three headed dragon (with each head having their own personality), who infiltrates the flying city by passing himself as one of their tame dragons. Mainly the dragon is angry because the wars have destroyed the land and crippled him and he wants revenge, but he also has nowhere else to go and is slowly figuring out that the flying city is not responsible for the war. He also gets adopted by a crazy human girl (of the starry-eyed teenage girl who puts garlands of flowers on "her" dragon type), who helps heal him and fly again and to eventually win and bring an end to the war.
The narrative bounces between the dragon slowly discovering the city and trying to figure out what is going on, some rather silly romantic drama involving his rider (the aforementioned crazy human girl), and some big fights right at the end to solve the war. It was rather fun, but I think I would have preferred if it had more world building (because while I understand that everything was filtered by the dragon point of view, I felt the world building was still a bit hazy over the edges and not always coherent, and the politics were rather simplistic and black and white) and less romantic drama (it was of the dumb misunderstanding kind where they love each other but think they hate each other for stupid reasons and that annoys me). Still, I liked the dragon and all his heads, and he is what made me like the book. One head thinks it is human, the other thinks it hates human but actually likes them, and the last one only thinks about food and head pats (so basically what my cat does with only one head). But it was fun to see them arguing with each other all the time and try to figure out what was happening. I always wondered how a creature with several heads would be able to make a decision.
- Explorers and Rangers: The Warden, by Daniel M. Ford (4 stars).
Aelis is a newly-minted wizard straight out of magical college, starting her first job as a magic cop (or Warden). She is also an arrogant, spoiled aristocrat girl and first-of-the-class know-it-all overachieving student, and generally a pain in the ass to everyone around her, so of course one of her annoyed former teachers and new superior decided to sent her to be the Warden of Lone Pine, a tiny village in the middle of nowhere on the border with the orc-infested wilderness.
But she is not one to let that deter her, particularly when the wilderness turned out to be full of cursed gold, ancient magical weapons, groups of nutjobs wanting to restart the war with the orcs, and evil undead spirits ! Not to mention the more mundane problems of annoying goats, superstitious peasants, war veterans with PTSD, and troublemaker adventurers.
It was a lot of fun. Aelis is a fish out of water and annoying brat, but she is also a good person under all this and generally competent, so she will try her best despite being slightly out of her depth and having a tendency to make things worse by being recklessly. That made her rather human and likable. I also liked her friend Tunbridge the half-orc ranger, who is serious and dependable and the perfect foil to Aelis antics.
The story felt quite episodic at first, although slowly building up to a bigger plot. On the other hand, this book finished on a cliffhanger, and it turned out you have to read all of the three volumes published (as I finally did) to have a more or less complete story, so no standalone here. Worldbuilding also felt like it was from a standard Dungeons & Dragons low level adventure story, so I wish it could have been a bit more original, and I found Aelis love story with Maurenia not particularly convincing (love at first sight, and so on). But if you are just looking for a fun adventure series with memorable characters, this is a pretty good series to read.
- Duology Part 2: Engines of Reason, by Adrian Tchaikovsky (3 stars).
This is the sequel to Elder Race, which I had really liked, but I did not find it as good. I think it suffered from the novella format and would have been better if longer, since it would have given it more time to develop the new characters and the plot, instead of the story relying so much on things that were happening off screen or in the past. As it was, the plot felt very barebones.
The story was also not as interesting as for the first novella: Instead of the dual storylines of fantasy quest / post apocalyptic sci-fi of Elder Race, we are getting a lot of politics and a new antagonist who claimed to be another "Elder", which could have been interesting if she had not actually turned out to be a fraud controlled by some mindless alien parasite machine of unknown origin. Not really where I expected the story to go after this.
Fourth Row Across :
- One Word Title: Unbearable, by A. Lee Martinez (4 stars).
Some petty criminal and dumbass loser finds a cursed magic sword while digging his own grave and finds himself tasked with saving the world.
I did not find the book as funny as previous books by this author, probably because it was not as over the top absurd in its plot and worldbuilding, but I liked the mix of cynical Noir novel with magical realism and parody, and it was still quite fun to read and the characters were likable despite their faults. One thing I always liked about A. Lee Martinez is his willingness to always try writing different books from the ones he wrote before while still keeping his own style.
I still found the ending a bit predictable in retrospect, but it fitted the general theme of the novel about violence and lust for power being self-destructive. And it is always nice to have some books where problems are not solved by having a climatic battle with the bad guy.
- Non-Human Protagonist: Of Monsters And Mainframes, by Barbara Truelove (4.5 stars).
This was basically a science-fiction retelling of Dracula in space, from the point of view of the AI pilot of the spaceship Demeter. Except that the author got very creative with the plot and added werewolves, undead Egyptian mummies, Frankenstein's monster, Lovecraftian horrors, and a mad robot doctor to it, which was a lot of fun. While the plot could get quite dark, it was still very comedic in tone, as befit a book that leaned a lot on parody and pop culture references. I wonder why we don't have more books mixing science-fiction and horror fantasy like this.
- Middle Grade: Castle Hangnail, by Ursula Vernon / T. Kingfisher (3.5 stars).
That was a rather cozy children book about a young witch trying to save a haunted castle and its inhabitants from demolition, written in a style that reminded me of a mix of Terry Pratchett and Diana Wynne Jones. I did like the characters and how whimsical it was, although the few villains were quite cliched. But I am probably too old now to truly love this kind of books.
- First Contact: Eden, by Stanislaw Lem (4 stars).
A spaceship carrying a team of scientists crashes on a planet bearing an unknown alien civilization, but when they attempt to contact them to find help, they initially find only ruins, mass graves, and terrified rag clad survivors running from soldiers operating war machines. Obviously something bad is happening, but what can they do to stop it when they know nothing about those people and their society, cannot communicate with them properly, and have no idea what is really happening or how they could change it, except with their own violence and weapons that would likely not make things better ?
It is a very classical Golden Age science fiction book, full of interesting ideas but shallow characterization (the scientists are not even given names, but referred to by their titles, like The Engineer, the Physicist, and so on). It is also very dark, with some pretty obvious social commentary on totalitarian regimes, racism and genocide, political propaganda, the uselessness of violence to force social change, and other themes a Polish author writing in 1958 would have been way too familiar with, but that still felt relevant today. The other main theme is the difficulty of communicating with and understanding an alien civilization, with the scientists still unsure they have understood what was happening after they repair their spaceship and leave the planet, a theme that Stanislaw Lem would develop further in his later books like Solaris or Fiasco. At times it felt more like an horror story than a first contact one, with the strangeness of the world reinforcing the horror. I liked it, but felt it could have been better in some parts, like developing the scientist characters and their own conflict over how they should react to what was happening.
- Murder Mystery: A Murder of Mages, by Marshall Ryan Maresca (3.5 stars).
As fantasy police procedurals go, this was a decent one, as well as an action packed easy read. Two police inspectors tracking a deranged serial killer in some 19th century-ish fantasy city. I quite liked the two protagonists, the competent but slightly autistic detective Mynox, who was struggling with having magic powers that he did not know how to use or understand, and his partner Satrine, a middle aged mother and former spy who became an inspector to feed her family after her inspector husband was beaten up by thugs and left disabled. That was more original characterization than I expected for this kind of story.
On the other hand, I found the worldbuilding itself rather bland and underdeveloped, with the fantasy elements somewhat lacking apart from the mage circles, but maybe it will become clearer if I read more books in that series. And I disliked the fact that Satrine lied and manipulated people to get her job as inspector, since it added a lot of unnecessary drama to the story and made her look foolish and dishonest, which seemed rather out of character for her given her often heroic behavior afterwards.
Fifth Row Across :
- Cat Squasher: Barnaby the Wanderer, by Raymond St Elmo (5 stars).
On the surface, the story felt a bit cliched (the naive farmboy is the Chosen Hero going on a quest to the Dark Tower to save the world from invasion with a bunch of misfits as loyal companions), but the author was obviously poking fun at those tropes, and the whole thing was written with an elaborate prose and a satirical tone that reminded me of Jack Vance and Tanith Lee books.
I personally enjoyed it a lot. The adventures were cool and the worldbuilding was quite clever, with all the “Saints” being obviously local gods (taken from Earth mythology) influencing the very culture of each country. And most of the characters were likeable, particularly our naive and good natured (but not as stupid as he seems) protagonist Barnaby, who kind of reminded me of Captain Carrot in Discworld.
I also liked Barnaby’s talking demon-cat familiar, but that may be just because I love cats. Talking cat familiars may be a well-known trope, but it is one I like and I feel that there are not that many of them in the fantasy genre.
- Feast Your Eyes on This: Calculated Whisk, by Lindsay Buroker (3.5 stars).
A retired mercenary and war veteran becomes a bookkeeper for a restaurant run by a dragon and former enemy, and helps him win a cooking contest while foiling the various plots of a jealous rival chef. As far as cozy fantasy stories go, this was more than fine, but I also found it somewhat unmemorable, with rather stereotypical fantasy D&D worldbuilding and an uninteresting plot, although I liked the characters and the silly sense of humor of the author.
- Published in the 70s: The Birthgrave, by Tanith Lee (3 stars).
That was an odd book. A young woman wakes up under a mountain without her memories, in a postapocalyptic fantasy world that her people used to rule with their magic powers, oppressing the normal humans until a plague wiped them out. It could have been an interesting story, but while she inherited the powers of her people (whoever they were was not clear: dark elves, bioengineered superhumans, undead vampires, or advanced cyborgs ?), she is also a self-hating and self-destructive fool due to her forgotten trauma of watching her people die horribly as a child, so she keeps walking into trouble she could avoid and letting the men around her make all the decisions in her life and manipulating her, and often suffering horribly as a result. That made for some frustrating reading, particularly when she turned out to have been an unreliable narrator on top of that. While I liked some parts of it like the mad chariot race with the bandit king and the Shakespearian tragedy of the rise and fall of the ambitious warlord Vazkor, I did not enjoy much else of the book, or the literal deus ex machina ending.
- Politics and Court Intrigue: Winner Takes All, by Simon R. Green (3 stars).
This book revolved around something you rarely see in the monarchy-obsessed fantasy genre: A democratic election. Captains Hawk and Fisher of Haven's City Guard are sent to protect an idealistic young candidate from the corrupt and thuggish incumbent who seems to think assassinating your opponents is how you win elections.
While this was a cool idea for a fantasy book in theory, I thought it was rather undermined by cliched characters, wooden dialogue, and a plot that was heavy on action but with little substance, making the book feels rather shallow and little more than an entertaining but stereotypical pulp Sword & Sorcery novel despite its theme.
- Author of Color: City of Others, by Jared Poon (3 stars).
This is a quite decent urban fantasy novel set in Singapore, with the protagonist being an overworked and workaholic gay bureaucrat from the city's department in charge of secretly solving magical problems, which is certainly original. He also complains a lot about bureaucratic inefficiency, toxic bosses, and a lack of means to do his job. You would think the people in charge of preventing cosmic horror piranhas from another dimension from eating the souls of all of Singapore's inhabitants would have a better budget and more people for doing that, but I guess governments never like to spend money on the actually important things they should be doing, and that is also true even in Singapore.
I rather liked the protagonist and his boyfriend and his magic that was focused on using his inner strength for healing his own soul and body and controlling his emotions and resisting curses rather than, for example, throwing fireballs around, and the general magical realism feel of the book. On the other hand, I wished it has been more tightly plotted. The second half of the book was a bit of a mess, with the antagonist of the first half completely vanishing from the story and a lot of time being spent on plans to save the world that did not work, which got kind of tiresome after the third one failed. Still, this wasn't too bad for a debut novel, so I will probably check the sequel when it is published.