r/Fantasy • • 17d ago

Book Club r/Fantasy November Megathread and Book Club hub. Get your links here!

24 Upvotes

This is the Monthly Megathread for October 2026. It's where the mod team links important things. It will always be stickied at the top of the subreddit. Please regularly check here for things like official movie and TV discussions, book club news, important subreddit announcements, etc.

Last month's book club hub can be found here.

Important Links

New Here? Have a look at:

You might also be interested in our yearly BOOK BINGO reading challenge.

Special Threads & Megathreads:

Recurring Threads:

Book Club Hub - Book Clubs and Read-alongs

Goodreads Book of the Month: A Wall is Also a Road by Annalee Newitz

Run by u/PlantLady32, u/RAAAImmaSunGod

  • Announcement
  • Midway Discussion - November 16th
  • Final Discussion - November 30th

Feminism in Fantasy: Spear by Nicola Griffith

Run by u/Moonlitgrey,  u/xenizondich23, u/Nineteen_Adze, u/evil_moooojojojo, u/Merle8888,  u/doctorbonkers,  u/Lenahe_nl, u/sarahlynngrey, u/ohmage_resistance

  • Announcement
  • Midway Discussion - November 11th
  • Final Discussion - November 25th

New Voices: The Heresy of Thieves by Mia V. Moss

Run by u/HeLiBeB, u/cubansombrero, u/ullsi u/undeadgoblin

  • Announcement
  • Midway Discussion - November 9th
  • Final Discussion - November 23rd

HEA: Hammajang Luck by Makana Yamamoto

Run by u/tiniestspoon, u/xenizondich23 , u/orangewombat, u/OutOfEffs

  • Announcement
  • Midway Discussion - November 12th
  • Final Discussion - November 25th

Beyond Binaries: Returns in December with A Slice of Mars by Guerric Hache

Run by u/xenizondich23, u/ohmage_resistance, u/recchai, u/C0smicOcurrence, u/Lenahe_nl, and u/sarahlynngrey 

Short Fiction Book Club: 

Run by u/tarvolon, u/Nineteen_Adze, u/Jos_V

Readalong of Earthsea:


r/Fantasy • • Sep 30 '26 Bravo

Announcement Upcoming Changes to r/Fantasy's Recurring Threads

185 Upvotes

Currently on r/fantasy, we have a selection of recurring threads - Monthly Book Discussion, Daily Recommendations and Simple Questions, Tuesday Review, Friday Social, the Sunday Self-Promo, Monday Show and Tell and Writing Wednesday.

The majority of these see a lot of use, however the last two -- the Monday Show and Tell and Writing Wednesday threads -- see little to no use on a weekly basis. We have also received a lot of feedback from you to this effect from our recent State of the Subreddit post, and from general comments on the subreddit. Therefore, we have come to the decision to discontinue these threads going forward.

However, this post is not all about things we will be removing: we will be debuting a new weekly discussion thread on the subreddit tomorrow! The Tuesday Review thread is currently a place to share reviews for all modes of speculative fiction, however it is largely dominated by discussion of books. To encourage discussion of not-a-book media, the new Thursday Not-A-Book thread will be an equivalent to the Tuesday review thread but focused on all types of speculative media that are not books - this could be films, TV, comics, audio dramas, games, or the like. This thread is not intended to stymie discussion elsewhere of non-book content - standalone posts on this topic are still welcome and encouraged.

This new recurring thread will debut tomorrow - we hope to see you there talking about all the things you have enjoyed recently outside of the realm of books!


r/Fantasy • • 6h ago

r/Fantasy r/Fantasy Daily Recommendations and Simple Questions Thread - November 18, 2026

35 Upvotes

Welcome to the daily recommendation requests and simple questions thread, now 1025.83% more adorable than ever before!

Stickied/highlight slots are limited, so please remember to like and subscribe upvote this thread for visibility on the subreddit <3

——

This thread is to be used for recommendation requests or simple questions that are small/general enough that they won’t spark a full thread of discussion.

Check out r/Fantasy's 2026 Book Bingo Card here!

As usual, first have a look at the sidebar in case what you're after is there. The r/Fantasy wiki contains links to many community resources, including "best of" lists, flowcharts, the LGTBQ+ database, and more. If you need some help figuring out what you want, think about including some of the information below:

  • Books you’ve liked or disliked
  • Traits like prose, characters, or settings you most enjoy
  • Series vs. standalone preference
  • Tone preference (lighthearted, grimdark, etc)
  • Complexity/depth level

Be sure to check out responses to other users' requests in the thread, as you may find plenty of ideas there as well. Happy reading, and may your TBR grow ever higher!

——

tiny image link to make the preview show up correctly

art credit: special thanks to our artist, Himmis commissions, who we commissioned to create this gorgeous piece of art for us with practically no direction other than "cozy, magical, bookish, and maybe a gryphon???" We absolutely love it, and we hope you do too.


r/Fantasy • • 4h ago

Bingo review Complete Fantasy Bingo Card for 2026, with Short Reviews.

19 Upvotes

This is the fourth time I am doing the r/fantasy Bingo and writing reviews for all of the books, but probably the earliest I have finished it : This time it only took me seven months and a half !

Summary : 

I will first write a short summary, to highlight the new books and series I have read for Bingo and to which I gave 4 or 5 stars:

  • New books I liked by authors that I had not read before: Of Monsters and Mainframes by Barbara Truelove, Please don't tell my Parents I am a Supervillain by Richard Roberts, The Warden by Daniel M. Ford, and The Otome Heroine's Fight for Survival by Harunohi Biyori.
  • New books I liked by authors I had already read before, but that were not part of a series I was already reading: Traitors' Nest by Frances Hardinge, Barnaby the Wanderer by Raymond St Elmo, Unbearable by A. Lee Martinez, Eden by Stanislaw Lem, and Death Has Joined the Party by Rachel Aaron.
  • New books I thought were flawed but still interesting to read: Whoever Steals This Book by Nowaki Fukamidori, The Dragon Has Some Complaints by John Wiswell, The Birthgrave by Tanith Lee, and City of Others by Jared Poon.

General comments : 

  • Favorite Squares this year were Game Changer, Non-Human Protagonist, and First Contact, because I don’t usually read many books that fit these squares, but this year I read a lot of books that could have fitted them, and they were often fun to read or interesting.
  • Even though I finished the Bingo early this time, I struggled with finding and finishing the books for quite a few squares: Duology Part 1 and Duology Part 2, Vacation Spot, Older Protagonist, Trans or Nonbinary Protagonist. There was a surprising lack of duologies on my To Be Read pile, and the fantasy and science fiction genres sure lack books happening in places that sound nice to visit, or books with protagonists that are older than fifty, or nonbinary protagonists who are actual human beings and not, for example, snarky murderbots or three-gendered aliens.

Some other statistics : 

  • 3 of the books I read for Bingo were by Japanese authors, 1 was by an author from Singapore, 1 by a Polish author, and the other books were by English, American, or Australians authors. 8 of the books featured important LGBT characters.
  • 6 of the books I read for Bingo were published in 2026, and 11 altogether were published in the 2020s and 21 published since 2000s, so there is quite a recency bias in my reading. Only 1 book was a sequel, for the Duology Part 2 square (obviously), but 12 books were by authors I had read before. 

Short Reviews for all the books are below. 

First Row Across :

  • Trans or Nonbinary Protagonist: Magica Riot by Kara Buchanan (1 star).

A novel about a punk rock band of trans magical girls sounds like it could make for a good story, but in reality that book was almost comically bad. Simplistic plot, shallow characterisation, cliched villains, cringe dialogue, and the whole concept was played straightforwardly with absolutely no unexpected twists to the story, making for a rather boring read. The whole novel came across as being wasted potential, thoughtlessly lazy in its writing and corny beyond belief, and weirdly childish despite all the characters supposedly being adults. As is often the case, having good ideas does not matter if you cannot write them well, and that was the perfect example of why.

  • Judge a Book by Its Title: Whoever Steals This Book, by Nowaki Fukamidori (3.5 stars).

This is another book with a good premise, but an unconvincing execution of it, but I liked it much better. A library belonging to a family of book collectors is protected from thieves by the curse of a fox god, trapping the thief and the town inside a book story every time a book is stolen, and the granddaughter of the family has to catch the thief and find the books to cancel the curse, along with a mysterious werewolf girl. The highlight of the book was in my opinion the strange worlds created by the curse (a surrealist fairy tale where pearls rain from the sky and the moon is the eye of a cat, a Noir detective story version of Fahrenheit 451, a Studio Ghibli-esque steampunk dystopia), but I felt that they were left underexplored. And the book suffered a lot from having bland and underdeveloped characters and a confusing overall storyline.

  • Translated: The Otome Heroine's Fight for Survival, Volumes 1 to 6, by Harunohi Biyori (4 stars).

This is a rather fun and easy to read litRPG series. The premise is that the heroine of an "otome" video game (a Japanese game aimed at teenage girls), upon learning the plot of the game (which is from her point of view her future life) from an insane reincarnated Japanese woman who tried to take over her body, decides to rebel against her future fate to become the Chosen One and marry the crown prince and instead runs away from the orphanage where she lived to become an adventurer. Because she would apparently rather live as a feral child in the woods and eats snakes and turns into a ruthless assassin murder hobo than become a princess.

This is quite an action packed series. While the heroine manages to stay rather likable and never does anything truly evil despite her ruthlessness and obsession with always growing more powerful, I felt like half the series was just her killing her various enemies in particularly gory ways. But the author managed to include enough character development and plot twists and worldbuilding to keep it from becoming too repetitive, and she is usually an underdog in those fights, so the series avoided the usual "overpowered main character" syndrome that most isekai light novels have.

  • Small Press or Self-Published: Please don't tell my Parents I am a Supervillain, by Richard Roberts (5 stars).

This book was a lot of fun. The daughter of two retired superheroes gains mad scientist superpowers and accidentally becomes a supervillain with her two nerdy friends, because they are all thirteen years old and stupid. The Japanese have a word for teenagers pretending to be edgy supervillains: chuunibyo, which literally translates as middle-schooler syndrom, and those three are obviously suffering from it, except they really have superpowers to get them into trouble: Penny enjoys making crazy inventions and gloating when they cause chaos while being terrified of her nice and overprotective parents ever finding out, Ray is trying to impress her doing stupid things because he has a crush on her, and Claire is basically along for the ride because she is apparently a groupie of every superhero and supervillain around. And together they just keep digging themselves deeper and deeper in the supervillain hole.

Not that anything actually bad happens to them. In the end, this is just a silly comedy parodying superhero stories, so the amount of darkness in it is very limited, and it even turns out that superheroes and supervillains actually have some kind of informal agreement for not trying to find out each other secret identities or even actually trying to kill each others because pushing into a corner someone with superpowers is a really bad idea. The overall mood reminded me of a mix of the Pixar movie The Incredibles, the comics book series Girl Genius, the manga One Punch Man, and A. Lee Martinez comedic fantasy books. But there is a place in literature for cozy entertaining books about people having silly but fun adventures, particularly given how rare good comedic fantasy writers are in the genre, and that book was very good at filling that niche. The rest of the series was equally fun to read.

  • Unusual Transportation: Bye, Bye Earth, Volumes 1 to 3, by Tow Ubukata (3.5 stars). 

That was a rather bizarre book. Post-apocalyptic science-fiction where science is so advanced that it is basically magic, set on the Moon in a country ruled by a mad Tree-God (actually an ancient AI called Deus Ex Machina) where bioengineered animal people constantly fight with living magic swords for their God’s entertainment in made-up but deadly wars while riding on giant turtles. The surrealist worldbuilding and twisted dystopian society kind of reminded me of Jack Vance books but without Vance’s beautifully purple satirical prose (instead, the prose was rather basic, although this may just have been the translation). 

The heroine, a teenage girl with a giant magical sword and apparently the last normal human in the world, wants to earn the God’s approval to become a nomad and leave the country (which is surrounded by magical barrier preventing that) to find other people like her. Therefore, she goes to the capital to fight in those wars for that, not knowing that her former master actually intends to use her to overthrow the system and kill the God « somehow » (he and his fellow conspirators love to meet each other to make cryptic statements about that, and the weirdness of the worldbuilding kind of gets in the way of understanding what is actually happening or what they are planning). Still, I kind of liked it. The protagonist Belle is rather likeable and the worldbuilding and side characters are interesting, although I think I preferred the anime adaptation that I saw some years ago to the actual books.

Second Row Across :

  • The Afterlife: Traitors' Nest, by Frances Hardinge (5 stars).

Frances Hardinge always writes books with some of the most creatively strange worldbuilding I ever came across, and in this case it is a medieval kingdom where castles keep switching places according a magical Game played by the ghosts of ancient aristocrats on obscure rules invented by the magpie spirit who cursed them. This adds new terrors to the already harsh lives of medieval peasants, and when a wandering castle strips a village from all its food and resources because its ruler knows that he will be gone long before he has to face the consequences (or so he mistakenly thinks), one farmer and his children decide to lead a peasant revolt, which ends with him as a dead new « Player » in the game and his children in charge of a new rebel castle full of peasants now trying to survive as the castle keeps teleporting around the kingdom while armies from the other Players try to crush their rebellion.

This was a good book, with a general theme of power being a curse without its holders realising it, of abuses of powers eventually backfiring on the abusers because they are self-destructive, and of how hard it is to actually be in charge while trying to do your best for the people who rely on you and not becoming corrupted. The main characters were generally likeable (and of course, it is because they were good people that they were eventually able to change the game) despite being quite out of their depths. However, what I particularly enjoyed were the creative tactics allowed by the very existence of the teleporting castles. It also made for some quite tense plot since you never knew what kind of crazy situation the cast would be thrown into next, or when.

  • Game Changer: Death Has Joined the Party, by Rachel Aaron (4 stars).

 As litRPG stories go, this one was definitely on the tongue-in-cheek self-parody side of the genre, but it was still a lot of fun. I particularly liked the crazy mimic girl eating everything and her antics, and the cynical evil lich who literally haunts our goody-two-shoes necromancer protagonist and made sarcastic comments on everything, including the protagonist's own naivety and idealism (which would have been a bit too much to take otherwise). And while the idea of a televised dungeon crawling death game / reality show is hardly an original one in the litRPG genre, it was handled very well here, with plenty of fun satire of the entertainment industry.

  • Vacation Spot: The Vampire Knitting Club, by Nancy Warren (3 stars).

This book had quite a cozy atmosphere, and I quite liked the club of good-natured but knitting-obsessed vampires, who reminded me somewhat of the Black Ribboners in Terry Pratchett's Discworld series. It was nice to have an urban fantasy series set in Oxford instead of Chicago or New York or London as usual. And it is always fun to have the protagonist trying to solve a murder when the murder victim is still walking around as an undead and trying to help find their killer, this is the kind of crazy situation that really can only happen in a fantasy mystery novel.

On the other hand, I very much guessed who the killer was as soon as the protagonist met them, so it quite failed as a mystery in my eyes. To be honest, the protagonist did not come across as very smart, so maybe it made sense she could not figure it out. I don't know if the author really intended for her to feel like such a dumb blonde bimbo, but I prefer my female protagonists to be smarter and tougher than that, particularly for a mystery series. And the love triangle was cliched and annoying. For that reason, I would recommend that book more to fans of cozy fantasy than to fans of mysteries.

  • Five Short Stories: The Ladies of Grace Adieu, by Susanna Clarke (4 stars).

A collection of dark « fairy tales » set in the world of Jonathan Strange and Mister Norrell, all written in different styles. Maybe because those tales were short stories, I thought they had better pacing than the original book and I enjoyed reading them a lot more.

  • Older Protagonist: The Lost Fleet: Dauntless, by Jack Campbell (3 stars).

A spaceship captain awakes from hibernation a century after his supposed death in combat... only to discover that he is now a famous hero and in charge (by dint of extreme seniority) in charge of bringing the fleet that rescued him back home from deep inside enemy territory. It is a fun premise, but I found the execution unconvincing. The world building and prose were basic, the characters one dimensional, and the story generally had a very "video game" feel to it.

And for some reason, the protagonist is the only man in the galaxy who is still good at military strategy, tactics, logistics, and organization, because a century of war has turned everyone into bloodthirsty idiots who think charging blindly at the enemy is glorious rather than stupid. First, I dislike when an author makes their protagonist looks smart by making everyone else an idiot, but secondly I think that this should realistically be the other way round: people who have fought for a century should have learned to become very good at war and not the opposite. 

On the other hand, it was still a rather easy read with a likable protagonist who thinks he should still follow the Geneva conventions (or whatever is their equivalent in the far future) and spare POW lives even if he is the only one who still cares about that, and the space battles were quite interesting with their emphasis on how the speed of light would cause important delays in obtaining information and giving orders when fighting in space.

Third Row Across : 

  • Duology Part 1: The Doomfarers of Coramonde, by Brian Daley (3 stars).

The most fun part of this book is when the mad scientist turned wizard decides to summon an Armored Personal Carrier from the Vietnam war along with five very confused American soldiers to fight a dragon. Sadly, this is the only fun part of the book and only represents a quarter of it, with the soldiers being sent back soon afterwards. The rest of the book was a rather boring and incoherent mashup of very melodramatic epic fantasy tropes. It was like the author had no idea what kind of book they wanted to write and just stuffed it with anything he thought was cool.

  • Book Club: Greenteeth, by Molly O'Neill (2 stars).

This was a surprisingly boring book and it took me over a month to finish it, although I am not entirely sure why, because in theory I should have loved a book written from the point of view of a sarcastic fairy swamp monster. The ideas behind it were fine if a bit cliched (two fairies and a witch go on a quest to find a magic weapon to kill the ancient evil god threatening their home), but the pacing, prose, plot, and characterisation all felt so incredibly bland and unimaginative.

I also have no idea what made this story « cozy fantasy » in the mind of the marketing department, because I felt that it was very much an epic fantasy story, unless they think cozy means boring.

  • Published in 2026: The Dragon Has Some Complaints, by John Wiswell (3.5 stars). 

While this book is technically about a war between a free flying city-state of dragon riders against an evil steampunk empire, it is more of a comedic and cozy fantasy book, since it has as its protagonist an old crippled and amnesiac intelligent three headed dragon (with each head having their own personality), who infiltrates the flying city by passing himself as one of their tame dragons. Mainly the dragon is angry because the wars have destroyed the land and crippled him and he wants revenge, but he also has nowhere else to go and is slowly figuring out that the flying city is not responsible for the war. He also gets adopted by a crazy human girl (of the starry-eyed teenage girl who puts garlands of flowers on "her" dragon type), who helps heal him and fly again and to eventually win and bring an end to the war. 

The narrative bounces between the dragon slowly discovering the city and trying to figure out what is going on, some rather silly romantic drama involving his rider (the aforementioned crazy human girl), and some big fights right at the end to solve the war. It was rather fun, but I think I would have preferred if it had more world building (because while I understand that everything was filtered by the dragon point of view, I felt the world building was still a bit hazy over the edges and not always coherent, and the politics were rather simplistic and black and white) and less romantic drama (it was of the dumb misunderstanding kind where they love each other but think they hate each other for stupid reasons and that annoys me). Still, I liked the dragon and all his heads, and he is what made me like the book. One head thinks it is human, the other thinks it hates human but actually likes them, and the last one only thinks about food and head pats (so basically what my cat does with only one head). But it was fun to see them arguing with each other all the time and try to figure out what was happening. I always wondered how a creature with several heads would be able to make a decision.

  • Explorers and Rangers: The Warden, by Daniel M. Ford (4 stars).

Aelis is a newly-minted wizard straight out of magical college, starting her first job as a magic cop (or Warden). She is also an arrogant, spoiled aristocrat girl and first-of-the-class know-it-all overachieving student, and generally a pain in the ass to everyone around her, so of course one of her annoyed former teachers and new superior decided to sent her to be the Warden of Lone Pine, a tiny village in the middle of nowhere on the border with the orc-infested wilderness. 

But she is not one to let that deter her, particularly when the wilderness turned out to be full of cursed gold, ancient magical weapons, groups of nutjobs wanting to restart the war with the orcs, and evil undead spirits ! Not to mention the more mundane problems of annoying goats, superstitious peasants, war veterans with PTSD, and troublemaker adventurers. 

It was a lot of fun. Aelis is a fish out of water and annoying brat, but she is also a good person under all this and generally competent, so she will try her best despite being slightly out of her depth and having a tendency to make things worse by being recklessly. That made her rather human and likable. I also liked her friend Tunbridge the half-orc ranger, who is serious and dependable and the perfect foil to Aelis antics.

The story felt quite episodic at first, although slowly building up to a bigger plot. On the other hand, this book finished on a cliffhanger, and it turned out you have to read all of the three volumes published (as I finally did) to have a more or less complete story, so no standalone here. Worldbuilding also felt like it was from a standard Dungeons & Dragons low level adventure story, so I wish it could have been a bit more original, and I found Aelis love story with Maurenia not particularly convincing (love at first sight, and so on). But if you are just looking for a fun adventure series with memorable characters, this is a pretty good series to read.

  • Duology Part 2: Engines of Reason, by Adrian Tchaikovsky (3 stars).

This is the sequel to Elder Race, which I had really liked, but I did not find it as good. I think it suffered from the novella format and would have been better if longer, since it would have given it more time to develop the new characters and the plot, instead of the story relying so much on things that were happening off screen or in the past. As it was, the plot felt very barebones.

The story was also not as interesting as for the first novella: Instead of the dual storylines of fantasy quest / post apocalyptic sci-fi of Elder Race, we are getting a lot of politics and a new antagonist who claimed to be another "Elder", which could have been interesting if she had not actually turned out to be a fraud controlled by some mindless alien parasite machine of unknown origin. Not really where I expected the story to go after this.

Fourth Row Across :

  • One Word Title: Unbearable, by A. Lee Martinez (4 stars).

Some petty criminal and dumbass loser finds a cursed magic sword while digging his own grave and finds himself tasked with saving the world.

I did not find the book as funny as previous books by this author, probably because it was not as over the top absurd in its plot and worldbuilding, but I liked the mix of cynical Noir novel with magical realism and parody, and it was still quite fun to read and the characters were likable despite their faults. One thing I always liked about A. Lee Martinez is his willingness to always try writing different books from the ones he wrote before while still keeping his own style.

I still found the ending a bit predictable in retrospect, but it fitted the general theme of the novel about violence and lust for power being self-destructive. And it is always nice to have some books where problems are not solved by having a climatic battle with the bad guy.

  • Non-Human Protagonist: Of Monsters And Mainframes, by Barbara Truelove (4.5 stars).  

This was basically a science-fiction retelling of Dracula in space, from the point of view of the AI pilot of the spaceship Demeter. Except that the author got very creative with the plot and added werewolves, undead Egyptian mummies, Frankenstein's monster, Lovecraftian horrors, and a mad robot doctor to it, which was a lot of fun. While the plot could get quite dark, it was still very comedic in tone, as befit a book that leaned a lot on parody and pop culture references. I wonder why we don't have more books mixing science-fiction and horror fantasy like this.

  • Middle Grade: Castle Hangnail, by Ursula Vernon / T. Kingfisher (3.5 stars).

That was a rather cozy children book about a young witch trying to save a haunted castle and its inhabitants from demolition, written in a style that reminded me of a mix of Terry Pratchett and Diana Wynne Jones. I did like the characters and how whimsical it was, although the few villains were quite cliched. But I am probably too old now to truly love this kind of books.

  • First Contact: Eden, by Stanislaw Lem (4 stars).

A spaceship carrying a team of scientists crashes on a planet bearing an unknown alien civilization, but when they attempt to contact them to find help, they initially find only ruins, mass graves, and terrified rag clad survivors running from soldiers operating war machines. Obviously something bad is happening, but what can they do to stop it when they know nothing about those people and their society, cannot communicate with them properly, and have no idea what is really happening or how they could change it, except with their own violence and weapons that would likely not make things better ?

It is a very classical Golden Age science fiction book, full of interesting ideas but shallow characterization (the scientists are not even given names, but referred to by their titles, like The Engineer, the Physicist, and so on). It is also very dark, with some pretty obvious social commentary on totalitarian regimes, racism and genocide, political propaganda, the uselessness of violence to force social change, and other themes a Polish author writing in 1958 would have been way too familiar with, but that still felt relevant today. The other main theme is the difficulty of communicating with and understanding an alien civilization, with the scientists still unsure they have understood what was happening after they repair their spaceship and leave the planet, a theme that Stanislaw Lem would develop further in his later books like Solaris or Fiasco. At times it felt more like an horror story than a first contact one, with the strangeness of the world reinforcing the horror. I liked it, but felt it could have been better in some parts, like developing the scientist characters and their own conflict over how they should react to what was happening.

  • Murder Mystery: A Murder of Mages, by Marshall Ryan Maresca (3.5 stars).

As fantasy police procedurals go, this was a decent one, as well as an action packed easy read. Two police inspectors tracking a deranged serial killer in some 19th century-ish fantasy city. I quite liked the two protagonists, the competent but slightly autistic detective Mynox, who was struggling with having magic powers that he did not know how to use or understand, and his partner Satrine, a middle aged mother and former spy who became an inspector to feed her family after her inspector husband was beaten up by thugs and left disabled. That was more original characterization than I expected for this kind of story.

On the other hand, I found the worldbuilding itself rather bland and underdeveloped, with the fantasy elements somewhat lacking apart from the mage circles, but maybe it will become clearer if I read more books in that series. And I disliked the fact that Satrine lied and manipulated people to get her job as inspector, since it added a lot of unnecessary drama to the story and made her look foolish and dishonest, which seemed rather out of character for her given her often heroic behavior afterwards.

Fifth Row Across :

  • Cat Squasher: Barnaby the Wanderer, by Raymond St Elmo (5 stars). 

On the surface, the story felt a bit cliched (the naive farmboy is the Chosen Hero going on a quest to the Dark Tower to save the world from invasion with a bunch of misfits as loyal companions), but the author was obviously poking fun at those tropes, and the whole thing was written with an elaborate prose and a satirical tone that reminded me of Jack Vance and Tanith Lee books.

I personally enjoyed it a lot. The adventures were cool and the worldbuilding was quite clever, with all the “Saints” being obviously local gods (taken from Earth mythology) influencing the very culture of each country. And most of the characters were likeable, particularly our naive and good natured (but not as stupid as he seems) protagonist Barnaby, who kind of reminded me of Captain Carrot in Discworld. 

I also liked Barnaby’s talking demon-cat familiar, but that may be just because I love cats. Talking cat familiars may be a well-known trope, but it is one I like and I feel that there are not that many of them in the fantasy genre.

  • Feast Your Eyes on This: Calculated Whisk, by Lindsay Buroker (3.5 stars).

A retired mercenary and war veteran becomes a bookkeeper for a restaurant run by a dragon and former enemy, and helps him win a cooking contest while foiling the various plots of a jealous rival chef. As far as cozy fantasy stories go, this was more than fine, but I also found it somewhat unmemorable, with rather stereotypical fantasy D&D worldbuilding and an uninteresting plot, although I liked the characters and the silly sense of humor of the author.

  • Published in the 70s: The Birthgrave, by Tanith Lee (3 stars).

That was an odd book. A young woman wakes up under a mountain without her memories, in a postapocalyptic fantasy world that her people used to rule with their magic powers, oppressing the normal humans until a plague wiped them out. It could have been an interesting story, but while she inherited the powers of her people (whoever they were was not clear: dark elves, bioengineered superhumans, undead vampires, or advanced cyborgs ?), she is also a self-hating and self-destructive fool due to her forgotten trauma of watching her people die horribly as a child, so she keeps walking into trouble she could avoid and letting the men around her make all the decisions in her life and manipulating her, and often suffering horribly as a result. That made for some frustrating reading, particularly when she turned out to have been an unreliable narrator on top of that. While I liked some parts of it like the mad chariot race with the bandit king and the Shakespearian tragedy of the rise and fall of the ambitious warlord Vazkor, I did not enjoy much else of the book, or the literal deus ex machina ending.

  • Politics and Court Intrigue: Winner Takes All, by Simon R. Green (3 stars).

This book revolved around something you rarely see in the monarchy-obsessed fantasy genre: A democratic election. Captains Hawk and Fisher of Haven's City Guard are sent to protect an idealistic young candidate from the corrupt and thuggish incumbent who seems to think assassinating your opponents is how you win elections. 

While this was a cool idea for a fantasy book in theory, I thought it was rather undermined by cliched characters, wooden dialogue, and a plot that was heavy on action but with little substance, making the book feels rather shallow and little more than an entertaining but stereotypical pulp Sword & Sorcery novel despite its theme.

  • Author of Color: City of Others, by Jared Poon (3 stars).

This is a quite decent urban fantasy novel set in Singapore, with the protagonist being an overworked and workaholic gay bureaucrat from the city's department in charge of secretly solving magical problems, which is certainly original. He also complains a lot about bureaucratic inefficiency, toxic bosses, and a lack of means to do his job. You would think the people in charge of preventing cosmic horror piranhas from another dimension from eating the souls of all of Singapore's inhabitants would have a better budget and more people for doing that, but I guess governments never like to spend money on the actually important things they should be doing, and that is also true even in Singapore.

I rather liked the protagonist and his boyfriend and his magic that was focused on using his inner strength for healing his own soul and body and controlling his emotions and resisting curses rather than, for example, throwing fireballs around, and the general magical realism feel of the book. On the other hand, I wished it has been more tightly plotted. The second half of the book was a bit of a mess, with the antagonist of the first half completely vanishing from the story and a lot of time being spent on plans to save the world that did not work, which got kind of tiresome after the third one failed. Still, this wasn't too bad for a debut novel, so I will probably check the sequel when it is published.

 


r/Fantasy • • 3h ago

Nominate for our December Goodreads Book of the Month!

15 Upvotes

The theme is Holidays!

Please nominate speculative fiction books that are set during, or feature a holiday of some sort (it does not have to be Christmas!).

Nominations will stay open for a couple of days until the 20th-ish, then I will post the poll.

NOMINATION RULES

  • Make sure the book is by an eligible author. A list of ineligible authors can be found here (recently updated with the new Top Fantasy List info). We do not repeat any authors that we've read in the past year or accept nominations of books by any of the 20 most popular authors from our biennial Top Novels list.
  • Nominate one book per top comment. You can nominate more than 1 if you like, just put each nomination in a separate comment. The top 4-6 nominations will move forward to the voting stage.
  • No self-promotion allowed. If outside vote stacking or promotion is discovered, a book will be disqualified automatically.

As a reminder, the current read is A Wall is Also a Road by Annalee Newitz.


r/Fantasy • • 32m ago

Book Club Short Fiction Book Club: Survival Is Insufficient: Hopeful SFF (Nov 2026)

8 Upvotes

Welcome to today’s session of Short Fiction Book Club! We’re glad you’ve joined us. If you’re new here, we’re excited to have you! We talk about speculative short fiction on alternating Wednesdays here on r/Fantasy. We’ve had an extra busy November. If you missed either of these excellent sessions/stories, it’s not too late to join in: 
- Parents and Portals
- Earthsea Readalong: Tales From Earthsea Midway Discussion

Today’s Session

It’s been a long year, and hope has been in short supply for many of us. The title for today’s session comes from the novel Station Eleven by Emily St. John Mandel, who in turn borrowed it from Star Trek: Voyager. As she said in an interview: “It’s a quote I came across on an episode of Star Trek when I was a teenager, and it’s just stayed with me all my life. It’s most clearly applicable to Station Eleven—I thought of it as the answer to a question that the Symphony would probably be continually asked as they went to enormous effort to perform theatre and music in the post-apocalypse—but of course it’s also the reason why we write and read books.” Just survival isn’t enough; we need art and music and stories - and hope. 

This session was inspired by a comment a few seasons back, when someone asked if we could please read some slightly happier stories. Absolutely, we thought to ourselves! Sure thing. This will be so easy! Reader, it was not actually that easy. It turns out a *lot* of great SFF short fiction relies on depressing premises and the turn of the knife to really make an impact. But it was great fun to put together this slate. I hope (see what I did there?) that some of these stories bring you hope as we head towards 2027.

Simons, Far and Near by Ana Gardner (Cast of Wonders, 5,900 words)  

Days after a solar hurricane fried Western Europe, nations across the world gathered their brightest grade-schoolers, and they launched us into space with promises of glory and cake.

Solar storms were worsening ahead of schedule, said government men in wrinkled suits, as they pulled us from our underground shelters and stuffed us into armored tanks. The exodus ships, forced to launch early, weren’t ready to sustain endless space travel. 

Fortunately, we learned as we marched up the launch ramp, Earth had a few shuttles ready for immediate departure. Sure, they had poor radiation shields and leaky engines, but wouldn’t you know it? Shuttle travel damaged the body worst after puberty. Kids had great odds of surviving a trip across the solar system.

The Book That Wasn’t by Sally Sultzman (Cast of Wonders, 1,700 words)  

The school library is as close to a refuge as you get, but the librarian still looks at you like she knows there’s something off about you, and you hate that she might be right.
  
Then one day, the day, that day, that librarian is gone, replaced by a sub that looks…familiar. But not really, she’s definitely not the kind of person you’ve ever seen in your small town before. And she puts specific books into your hands. Very specific books. The kinds of books you could never ask about out loud, certainly not of the regular librarian because then she’d know she was right about you and tell your parents, and that–you don’t think you’d survive that.  

But this librarian sub–old, tall, and imposing with wild white hair and a generous smile–just knows what books other kids also want, but those books are never as…personal as yours are. She gives you kind smiles and says things like, “You’re doing so well, just hold on a little bit longer,” as she gives you another book that you’re not allowed to read, not even allowed to know exists, and it… it helps.

Where Would You Be Now? by Carrie Vaughn (Reactor, 8,900 words)  

Kath sat on the roof of the beat-up Tesla S, legs draped down the back window, shotgun in both hands, looking out into the dark for whatever might hurt them. They’d come forty miles or so to an encampment in what had once been a park with a picnic area and duck pond. A playground with a plastic slide and jungle gym was still intact, though weeds came up through the bark mulch footing. A collection of trucks and campers clustered here, circled together with space for a campfire in the middle. The fire was banked now. Some tents and lean-tos had been set up a little further out, along with a couple of rickety sheds. In summer, people didn’t need much more shelter than that. Winter, the camp would pick up and move south, if they could get the gas for it. Getting hard to find gas, though. The place was starting to look permanent. One of the trailers had a chicken coop built next to it, and a couple of roosting chickens were visible, feathers plumped out. The camp probably housed about thirty, but this late, everyone had gone to bed.
 
The packed-dirt mounds of four graves were lined up outside the circle of campers. The doctors didn’t ask about them, the ones they couldn’t help.

Turned away from the light, Kath kept watch.

Upcoming Sessions 

We’ll be here Wednesday, November 25th for our usual Monthly Discussion, and then on Monday, November 30th we’ll cross over with the Earthsea Readalong for the final discussion about Tales of Earthsea. Our next slated session will be hosted by u/Tarvolon:

It’s no secret that there are a few parents among the SFBC regulars, and that’s led to quite a few stories that center parent/child relationships. Turns out that’s a topic with a broad range of possibilities that makes room for lots of fantastic storytelling—who knew? We’re going back to the well for our first December session, but this time, rather than choosing a particular speculative premise and examining how it affects these relationships, we’ll be focusing specifically on the task of trying to shape children into the people they must be for the world ahead. So on Wednesday, December 2, come join us as we discuss the following stories about Molding Young Minds:

Laws of Night and Silk by Seth Dickinson (Beneath Ceaseless Skies, 7,200 words)

Kavian can pretend this girl is her daughter through drought and deluge, but the truth is the truth: Irasht is a weapon, and never any more.

In the Foothills by Rajiv Moté (Reckoning, 3,200 words)

The war had taken nearly everything from Dozan, but by leaving him his little daughter Ayula, he also found something he’d lacked most of his life: a sharp, crystalline sense of purpose. As they fled the Char-ravaged flats for the foothills, all of Dozan’s will bent toward keeping his daughter alive, and keeping the war from seeping into her as it had into him, because surely the war couldn’t last forever. She would have to fit into the gentler world to come.

Fostering by Ray Nayler (Vice, 3,700 words)

I stand at my kitchen window, watching Emre in the yard. He’s observing a lizard crawling along the cinderblock wall. The lizard pauses as it makes its slow way across the wall and does a few push-ups. I can’t see that from where I am standing, but I know lizard behavior well enough to fill in what is missing. I spent a childhood watching lizards crawl across that wall. 

And now, onto today’s discussion! Spoilers are not tagged, but each story has its own thread. We’ve put a few prompts in the comments, but feel free to add your own if you so desire.


r/Fantasy • • 6h ago

Review Wickhills by Premee Mohammed: A Spy Novel in a Weird City

19 Upvotes

I'm a big fan of weird cities (though perhaps not as big a fan as some). So when I heard about this spy thriller set in one I got quite excited. And I don't think it disappointed.

Wickhills is a classic kitchen sink city with plenty of odd secrets. At first it appears to be just a fantastical coastal port with a medley of non-human races and a functioning tram system, but as the book unfolds it becomes clear the city expands farther than you might expect, and is riddled with oddities of geometry and impossible architecture (Class 3, unmonitored, inhabited). And perhaps more importantly to the plot it is governed by an ostensibly civilized and democratic-ish council and Mayor's office who helm the self interested entity that is "the City"

But enough about setting. A good book needs a good story and good characters as well. We follow Ferec, an agent of the shadowy (though also mundanely bureaucratic) intelligence / counter-terrorist agency of Seaborne. He's been working for ten years, more than most, and knows the city better than almost anyone. He's helped defuse riots and rebellions and gang wars. And he doesn't think too hard about it.

And a strange mission gets dumped in his lap by his handler. Recover and guard a strange man seeking asylum from another city (wait... what do you mean there's only six cities and nothing in between on land since THE DISPERSAL). And then the plot explodes as shadowy forces of all sorts, both external and internal start hunting Ferec and his team and they can trust no one.

I've mentioned that Wickhills itself as a setting is a weirder city than it first appears. In particular, it is much larger than one might expect, with endlessly unfolding weird corners. This does have the effect that as a reader one doesn't often experience revisiting a neighborhood / street / attraction that has already been visited. On a purely logical level this actually makes a good bit of sense, and Ferec's internal narrative is clear that these are places he knows and is revisiting and this is executed well, but it does leave me with a certain sense that I'm unsure if I ever really see a character bounce off of an understood hard edge of Wickhills' nature.

In a similar vein, though I don't want to dwell on it too much I think that the overall medley of weird architectures, modern technologies and different creatures didn't quite get folded into the narrative as effectively as I might have hoped. Ferec's handler and several of his teammates / partners in crime are non-human and this doesn't quite act on the narrative in as interesting a way as it might.

All that said the actual star of the show, rightly, is Ferec's internal conflict over his role as a Seaborne agent. He is a shadowy, unaccountable force acting upon the people of the city, at the behest of the City for the good of the c(C?)ity. The people don't know he or his bosses exist, and he barely knows why his bosses have told him to do what he does. And crucially in the plot of the novel, various parts of this chain of hierarchy break down. Is this a job just for his handler and not for the City? Would other city agencies approve? Who is we working for and against.

This internal conflict, and the ways it echoes against the inter-institutional or inter-city conflicts that we slowly realize might be behind everything, is quite effectively managed.

Overall, a fun read, with a strong atmospheric voice.

Bingo Squares: Politics (HM), Published in 2026, One Word Title


r/Fantasy • • 5h ago

Has anyone done a samurai/spaghetti western style story in a more fantasy setting?

13 Upvotes

I have spent a lot of time in my head imagining what it would look like and it looks awesome!


r/Fantasy • • 1d ago

Forget pet peeves, what's a minor peeve that briefly breaks immersion but doesn't make you stop reading?

506 Upvotes

I'm thinking "pothole", not "collapsed bridge". Something that brings you out of the story just long enough to be annoyed, but then you dive right back in.

The one that prompted this post was I just read (again) someone using "plant magic" to affect mushrooms. Fungi are no more plants than animals are! If you can use your magic to control mushrooms, it's not plant magic! It's small technical inaccuracies like this that make me shake my head at how little attention the author paid in school. Not enough to make me DNF the book, though, if the story is good.

Anyway, what's your minor peeve(s)?


r/Fantasy • • 12h ago

I just got done reading and listening to the Bear and the Nightingale by Katherine Arden and LOVED it!

22 Upvotes

It's the first book in the Winternight trilogy and a perfect November read for me.

I loved it so much and it's an easy 5/5 book for me. Vasya is such a fresh, loveable protagonist. I loved the writing style a lot; it's shocking to me that it was the first book Arden ever wrote cuz her prose is BEAUTIFUL!

I'm a big fan of the historical fiction genre and of mythologies, but I've not read much about the Russian history. This book taught me a lot about the Russian cultures and mythological creatures and I'd love to know more about them.

I read and listened to this book at the same time and liked the narration a lot; Kathleen Gati does the accents so well.

I'm definitely gonna continue the series.

I'd love to know your thoughts on this book if you've read it, and, with no spoilers, would also love to know how y'all rank the books in the trilogy.

Have a good day/night!


r/Fantasy • • 14h ago

Good one-off, standalone (or sort series equivalent) books for someone coming off of Malazan?

32 Upvotes

So the Broken Earth trilogy I would count as a "series" that I might reasonably count as a "standalone" book. I loved that one.

But after finishing a huge ~10,000 page epic like Malazan, I'm eager for some solid, epic, intricate, and ideally emotionally devastating fantasy. Something with stakes and laughs and characters I'll love and villains I'll hate and a world to get lost in. Something I'll wish had more but be bittersweetly glad it doesn't.

Tigana is what I'm probably reading next. But anyone else have ideas?

I suppose I'll take suggestions for the next big series but that's a ways off I think.


r/Fantasy • • 5h ago

Outstanding fantasy media for a cold wintertime?

5 Upvotes

Hello there! I am currently reading Tolkien slowly - and have done so through the autumn, which is just an incredible time to read the legendarium.

That being said, I'd appreciate some other fantastic wintertime fantasy ideas. Classics like Skyrim (and, apparently, Icewind Dale, which I have not played) are really popular. There is a big snow scene in the "Dungeons and Dragons: Honour Among Thieves" movie (which I adore).

I'd welcome your suggestions across media for some cozy wintertime fantasy! Thanks a lot, and all the best of the season! (And, yes, I know astronomical winter starts on 21 December, but I like to get in front of things!)


r/Fantasy • • 4h ago

How would I explain the Ramayana to someone unfamiliar with the ancient Indian epic ?

3 Upvotes

I'd describe it as:

The Lord of the Rings + The Odyssey + Shakespearean drama.

The Lord of the Rings: An expansive mythological world filled with kingdoms, supernatural beings, powerful warriors, epic battles and the eternal conflict between good and evil.

The Odyssey: A fourteen-year exile, an extraordinary journey through forests and unfamiliar lands, encounters with mythical creatures, separation from loved ones and the struggle to return home.

Shakespearean drama: Family conflicts, palace intrigue, manipulation, betrayal, difficult moral choices, ambition, tragedy and the downfall of a powerful king.

But the Ramayana has something more: its spiritual and philosophical exploration of dharma(righteousness), devotion, duty and sacrifice .

These are comparisons to help newcomers understand its scale and themes, not claims that the epics are identical.


r/Fantasy • • 12h ago

Lost Generation type of post-war fantasy

14 Upvotes

Looking for a fantasy recommendations where the events take place after a great war against a Dark Lord and now we follow people trying to pick up the pieces and rebuild their society in the wake of the devastation.

In particular, I'm looking for the dilemma of veterans. Having thousands of traumatized war heroes trying to reintegrate into society. Especially for the magically gifted warriors who now have to deal with peace time where their destructive powers and skills won't be as desirable.


r/Fantasy • • 22h ago

Looking for Lesser Known Fantasy Recommendations

69 Upvotes

I am looking fof lesser known fantasy recommendations. I am having a hard time finding new fantasy books that really grip me! I’ve been through most of the popular recommendations and would love some older classics or more modern lesser known fantasy recs. I love books with political intrigue, extensive plotting, and detailed characters. I do not care for modern settings or modern sounding prose. I put a list of books/ series I like and ones I don’t care for below. I also really appreciate Eastern inspired fantasy it’s always a fun reprieve from all of the western stuff.

Likes:
Realm of the Elderlings
Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn
A Song of Ice and Fire
The Empire Trilogy (Riftwar Cycle)
The Curse of Chalion
Everlasting
Captive Prince
She Who Became the Sun

Dislikes:
Throne of Glass
Fourth Wing
Priory of the Orange Tree
The Blade Itself
The Kingkiller Chronicle


r/Fantasy • • 18h ago

Good Fantasy Books with Good Audiobook for people who like "filler"?

16 Upvotes

I'm trying to wean someone I live with off of AI-generated audiobooks on YouTube.

Any book that's entertaining and does low-stakes "filler" well would work, like something you could read or listen to without having to necessarily focus too much, but preferably something that's also interesting

Preferably something that gets straight into the action and has something interesting in each chapter, no long build up or drawn out worldbuilding or drawn out political setup.

They loved the Dungeon Crawler Carl books and read all 8 in a few weeks, so I might get them the Cradle series by Will Wight. But more recommendations would help.


r/Fantasy • • 1d ago

Books like The Devils without the mcu dialogue

87 Upvotes

I really liked the gritty alt history setting and playing with tropes, but I found the constant quipping very annoying. What should I read?


r/Fantasy • • 11h ago

Bingo review Bingo update 3: the girl with a thousand faces, roadside picnic, hell's paradise, the woods all black & all this twisted flory

4 Upvotes

Finished my third set of squares:

- the afterlife

- published in the 70's

- author of colour

- trans/non binary protagonist

- politics

These are just some thoughts as I'm by no means a great reviewer. Would love to know yours as well if you've read any of these or what you've read for any of these squares.

- The afterlife: The girl with a thousand faces by Sunyi Dean, 4 stars.

Damn. What a book. I appreciate the way this was crafted/split up wich made things slowly slot in together and get revealed. I loved the plot twists and speculation that were part of that. I also really appreciate the real history mixed in with a more folk lore feel and that supernatural layer added on top with the ghosts and the feelings that come with it as well as the representation of generational trauma. Less of a fan of the ending/a certain voice but overall really well done. I also heard a lot of people not really liking the second person POV that's a part of this book but I actually didn't mind it.

- Published in the 70's: Roadside picnic by Arkady & Boris Strugatsky, / stars.

I decided not to rate it as I ended up dnf'in it originally but decided to pick it back up again. I don't think this was for me. It really struggled to keep my attention so often times I found myself lost and having to go back. Overall fell flat to me but at the same time I don't feel like I actually picked up much of the story because of it so no rating/review aside from here as it didn't feel fair. That said this normally does not happen to me. I liked the concept and idea but I didn't really connect with the writing.

- Author of colour: Hell's paradise (vol 9-13) by Yūji Kaku, 4 stars.

This was a really enjoyable ride throughout the whole series. Stunning art and great samurai and ninja type action with the enemies being plant like and immortal due to "tan". Really cool concept. I liked how we got a story were people had to set aside their differences and see further than society or their own world they live in. I felt like the characters on both sides of the conflict, you get to know and find out their motivations. I also adored the ending and how we got to see how things are after the events of our story. Well thought out in my opinion.

- Trans/non binary protagonist: The woods all black by Lee Mandelo, 3 stars.

I liked the atmosphere and historical setting. Found it interesting to see Leslie's place in it as a trans man and how women were still limited and looked down on and where Leslie was placed in that.

Not a 4 star because I'm not a fan of the whole "my boy" thing with him actually being quite a bit younger. Same with the turn of events with, let's say, the monster to avoid spoilers.

- Politics: All this twisted glory by Tahereh Mafi, 5 stars.

Book 3 in a series.

Kamran who?? I'm so down to see how Alizeh and Cyrus' paths continue to interwine and to see Alizeh set out to do what she has to next book and claim her birthright.

I really enjoyed the relationship growth between Cyrus and Alizeh throughout this book, as well as the side charcaters and what they're up to and how they're reacting to all this. Interested to see what the whole deal with Hazan is about.

Love that there were secrets that have been revealed but more left to uncover. Those last final lines too. Sign me up for some vengeance and as always I mesh so well with Mafi's writing. To me it feels beautiful to read without dragging the story down. It feels like you really get to know what's going on mentally and emotionally while also being beautiful to read. Very atmospheric/lush feeling which I really enjoy with being in Tulan and the magic around. 10/10, no complaints.


r/Fantasy • • 1d ago

AMA AMA: I'm Rob J. Hayes, author of The GodEater Saga, an EPIC Fantasy where People. Eat. Angels. Ask me anything!

109 Upvotes

Hi all!

My name is Rob J. Hayes and it's been a while since my last AMA. I've been publishing for about 13 years now and I have 26 (I think) books published, including Never Die, The Heresy Within, Along the Razor's Edge, and the SPFBO-winning Where Loyalties Lie.

I'm an avid card gamer, reader, watcher of 80s/90s cinema, and I am the owner of the grumpiest beagle in all the land. Her name is Korra, but I call her the Potato.

And I will be giving away a fancy Wraithmarked SPFBO-champion special edition of Where Loyalties Lie to one commenter. All you have to do to enter is include a book recommendation in your comment.

I'm here today because my Kickstarter for Phase 2 of the GodEater Saga is currently live!

The GodEater Saga is an EPIC Fantasy trilogy of trilogies being written and published concurrently. Which means I wrote all 3 books 1s at the same, and all 3 book 2s at the same time. The trilogies are told across 3000 years and are set in a world where humans can steal magic and immortality by eating angels.

My current Kickstarter is for Phase 2, so special editions of all 3 books 2s, but re-prints of the book 1s are also available. Here's a cool graphic!

And here's a link to the campaign: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/god-eater-saga/the-godeater-saga-phase-2-special-editions

And lastly a link to read the first chapter of book 1, HERALD: https://robjhayes.co.uk/herald-preview/

And that's it. Hi! Ask me anything.


r/Fantasy • • 15h ago

EPIC modern-tech secondary-world fantasy?

7 Upvotes

I started writing a trilogy in 2012 and incidentally made my world modern without any examples of how others have done it. I eventually gave up on writing (I’m a reader, not a writer) but I’m always on the lookout for ModTech fantasy since there are more than when I started.

I first started with Patricia A McKillip’s Kingfisher, then The Divine Cities. The Green Bone Saga is my favorite. I wish Steel Crow Saga by Paul Krueger had sequels…

The “problem” is that none of them strike me as “epic fantasy” in the way that A Song of Ice and Fire (my primary influence) is. I love the Green Bone Saga, but you don’t get information/lore going back centuries/millenia. The Divine Cities has gods, but basically everything is limited to the respective cities. At worst, there are examples like The Sword of Kaigen (which I loved btw) which is for all intents and purposes a slightly modified version of irl Japan—not in the way that Westeros is a fictional kingdom inspired by medieval England.

ASOIAF was my primary influence (along with Pokemon) so my books (I wrote parts of books two and three despite not finishing book one) drew heavily from weaving in lore and worldbuilding throughout. I have parallel cross-country journeys, centuries-old covenants with the gods, bunch of languages, conflicting accounts of mythology, original megafauna, beings that have been present since the formation of the world, rituals dating back to Old not-Valyria…

I basically started from taking a story idea I had and setting it in “my own version of ASOIAF’s world”, which quickly resulted in making the world modern with smartphones and bullet trains. Pokemon was the only version of a modern-tech (essentially) secondary world. In 2016 Final Fantasy XV came out was like a game version of what I was looking for in epic ModTech (minus more sci-fi elements).

Is there anything that’s basically ASOIAF but with smartphones? The Ember Blade by Chris Wooding hit a LOT of the same emotional beats and themes as my book, and I consider it a medieval twin to my book, so making it a modern secondary world would’ve been perfect.

I know there’s a Brandon Sanderson book that’s like ‘90s tech, but I really don’t like Sanderson as a writer and I’m not sure how “epic” it is in contrast to his main(?) series. People have brought up the Craft Sequence, but that struck me as more secondary-world urban fantasy and not epic fantasy. Similarly, the Tarot Sequence has something like a parallel world/dimension/region to our own, but that was way too urban fantasy for me.

Thank you.


r/Fantasy • • 1d ago Bravo

Deals Throne Hunters by Phil Tucker is finished, and books 1 to 5 are free this week!

47 Upvotes

Title. I've only read the first book of this series but I liked it very much, and Tucker's Immortal Great Souls series is one of my favourites at the moment.

For people who need their Cradle fix to be a little more pathetic, drunk, and dungeon-y.

Free on Kindle, I've checked the US and UK stores.


r/Fantasy • • 21h ago

Review Book Reviews: 52 Book Club, SFF Subset

19 Upvotes

Well r/Fantasy, you have created a monster. You lured me into last year’s Bingo and now I'm a little bit obsessed with book challenges. In addition to 2026 Bingo, I also decided to try out the 52 Book Club this year. I’m not on any of the social media platforms where this challenge is promoted, so I’ve decided to share the results with my book buddies here.

While this challenge was not restricted to speculative fiction, I will stick to only discussing the SFF entries in this post. If you want to see the full project, feel free to check out my post on r/books. I’ve also listed the bingo prompts each book could be used to fill in case anyone is looking for inspiration.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Xw8jYeYRYEggLDPPaYfR1ZZibx8CAhbypEKsDHcpVR0/edit?usp=sharing

Favorite Fantasy:

Brigands and Bread Knives by Travis Baldree

  • Prompt: Includes a Map
  • Bingo: Explorers and Rangers (HM), Non-Human Protagonist (HM)

This is the third book in the series and by far my favorite. Probably because it really pushes the boundaries on how much peril can be included in a book and still call it "cozy". I like a little peril, thanks, and felt the story contained enough found family, quirky characters, and happy resolutions to retain an overall heart-warming feel. Anyway, Fern the bookseller is having a mid-life crisis. Becoming drunk one day, she falls asleep in a conveniently placed cart, thus falling headfirst into a grand adventure with a legendary hero. Add in a creepily grinning goblin, mad murder chickens, and a sentient breadknife and I'm sold.

Favorite Science Fiction:

High Vaultage, by Jen and Chris Sugden

  • Prompt: Grumpy Sunshine Trope
  • Bingo: Unusual Transportation (HM), Afterlife, Murder Mystery, Politics/Intrigue (HM)

It’s the late 1800s and Even Greater London has expanded to include all of Southern England, facilitated by a mysterious form of electricity (that has frozen the Thames in its thirst for energy, don't worry about it) and armies of engineers hellbent on building the future, no matter how many neighborhoods they have to mow down along the way. Tucked into this chaos, a resurrected ex-detective and a promising journalist have come together to form a detective agency and are soon embroiled in a series of mysterious bank heists, missing persons, and murders. Altogether, a fun story set in an interesting world. The interplay between the jaded detective and his enthusiastic sidekick is familiar but well-executed here. There's quite a host of quirky side characters and wacky technology to keep you entertained along the way.

Favorite Magical Realism:

When I Sing, Mountains Dance, by Irene Solà

  • Prompt: A Diacritical Mark on the Cover
  • Bingo: Translated (HM), Afterlife, Vacation Spot (the Pyrenees), Older Protagonist (HM), Non-Human Protagonist

A small village built high in the Pyrenees bears witness to personal joys and tragedies of its residents alongside the peripheral effects of political upheaval. Told by quite an eclectic cast of narrators (from locals and new arrivals to ghosts to the fungi growing beneath their feet), this book is beautifully written (and translated) and wonderfully unique. I will definitely be seeking out more from Solà.

Favorite Horror:

Leech, by Hiron Ennes

  • Prompt: Literary Device: Personification
  • Bingo: Older Protagonist, Non-Human Protagonist, Murder Mystery (HM)

The Institute has a monopoly on medical care, and its doctors belong to a hive mind. When one body in a remote chateau dies, another is sent up to investigate the cause. As a pathologist by day, author Hiron Ennis brings their biological knowledge to bear in this bizarre and eerie tale of parasites and symbionts and the intricacies of consent. I personally found this book delightfully weird and am eager to pick up anything else they care to write.

Favorite Calling-it-Speculative-is-a-Stretch:

Tilt, by Emma Pattee

  • Prompt: Featuring a Natural Disaster
  • Bingo: One-Word Title (HM)

A 9-months-pregnant woman is scrambling to buy a crib at Ikea when the city is hit by "the Big One", the massive earthquake that experts had been predicting for years. Stranded, she must pick her way across the destruction in search of her husband and safety. Some categorize this book as a survival thriller, but I don't agree. Yes, it is a major natural disaster, and there are certainly some gruesome and heart-rending scenes tucked into the rubble, but the story has much more of a contemplative tone than a suspenseful one. Jumping between the present and the past, Annie contemplates earthquakes (both physical and metaphorical) and what it means to live a full life when faced with disaster. This book was beautiful, funny, deeply sad, and ultimately a great read.


r/Fantasy • • 23h ago

Book Club FIF Bookclub January Voting Thread: Women in Translation

24 Upvotes

Welcome to the January FIF Bookclub voting thread for Women in Translation!

The nomination thread can be found here.

Voting:

Once again, I decided to use approval voting this month. Instead of a multiple choice form where you choose the book you most want to read, I'm going to be using a check box form where you can check any book that you want to be chosen for the book club. All your votes have the same weight, and the book that was checked/chosen by the highest number of people will be read in March.

You can also let me know what you think of this method in the comments. I wanted to try it as a compromise between simple methods like First Past the Post and more complex ones like Ranked Choice Voting, but I'm curious if other people will agree with this.

We also have seven options instead of five, because several were tied with the same amount of upvotes. So here are the seven options to choose from:

Amatka by Karin Tidbeck, translated from Swedish by Karin Tidbeck

WELCOME TO AMATKA…where everyone has a role, language has strange properties, and nothing – not even the very fabric of reality – can be taken for granted.

Vanja Essre Two is sent to the wintry colony of Amatka on an assignment to collect intelligence for the government. Dissent is not tolerated in Amatka, nor is romantic love, but Vanja nonetheless falls for her housemate Nina, a true believer in the colony’s ways. But when Vanja is drawn into a resistance movement, she must choose between love and a revolution, which promises liberation at the cost of tearing the world as they know it apart.

I Who Have Never Known Men by Jacqueline Harpman, translated from French by Ros Schwartz

Deep underground, forty women live imprisoned in a cage. Watched over by guards, the women have no memory of how they got there, no notion of time, and only a vague recollection of their lives before.

As the burn of electric light merges day into night and numberless years pass, a young girl—the fortieth prisoner—sits alone and outcast in the corner. Soon she will show herself to be the key to the others' escape and survival in the strange world that awaits them above ground.

Like Water for Chocolate by Laura Esquivel, translated from Spanish by Carol Christensen and Thomas Christensen

Earthy, magical, and utterly charming, this tale of family life in turn-of-the-century Mexico became a best-selling phenomenon with its winning blend of poignant romance and bittersweet wit. The number one bestseller in Mexico and America for almost two years, and subsequently a bestseller around the world, Like Water For Chocolate is a romantic, poignant tale, touched with moments of magic, graphic earthiness, bittersweet wit - and recipes. A sumptuous feast of a novel, it relates the bizarre history of the all-female De La Garza family. Tita, the youngest daughter of the house, has been forbidden to marry, condemned by Mexican tradition to look after her mother until she dies. But Tita falls in love with Pedro, and he is seduced by the magical food she cooks. In desperation, Pedro marries her sister Rosaura so that he can stay close to her, so that Tita and Pedro are forced to circle each other in unconsummated passion. Only a freakish chain of tragedies, bad luck and fate finally reunite them against all the odds.

Shubeik Lubeik by Deena Mohamed, translated from Arabic by Deena Mohamed

Shubeik Lubeik--a fairytale rhyme meaning "Your Wish is My Command" in Arabic--is the story of three characters navigating a world where wishes are literally for sale; mired in bureaucracy and the familiar prejudices of our world, the more expensive the wish, the more powerful and therefore the more likely to work as intended. The novel's three distinct parts tell the story of three first class wishes as used by Aziza, Nour, and Shokry, each grappling with the challenge inherent in trying to make your most deeply held desire come true.

Tainaron: Mail from Another City by Leena Krohn, translated from Finnish by Hildi Hawkins:

Mail From Another City is the first American publication by the internationally acclaimed Finnish author, Leena Krohn. TAINARON consists of a series of letters sent beyond the sea from a city of insects. TAINARON is a book of changes. It speaks of metamorphoses that test all of nature from a flea to a star, from stone and grass to a human. The same irresistible force that gives us birth, also kills us. Nominated for the prestigious Finlandia prize, this is the perfect introduction to the work of a modern fabulist.

The Wall by Marlen Haushofer, translated from German by Shaun Whiteside

First published to acclaim in Germany, The Wall chronicles the life of the last surviving human on earth, an ordinary middle-aged woman who awakens one morning to find that everyone else has vanished. Assuming her isolation to be the result of a military experiment gone awry, she begins the terrifying work of survival and self-renewal. This novel is at once a simple and moving tale and a disturbing meditation on humanity.

We'll Prescribe You a Cat by Syou Ishida, translated from Japanese by Madison Shimoda

Tucked away on the fifth floor of an old building at the end of a narrow alley in Kyoto, the Nakagyō Kokoro Clinic for the Soul can be found only by people who are struggling in their lives and who genuinely need help. The mysterious clinic offers a unique treatment to those who find their way there: it prescribes cats as medication. Patients are often puzzled by this unconventional prescription, but when they “take” their cat for the recommended duration, they witness profound transformations in their lives, guided by the playful, empathetic, and occasionally challenging yet endearing cats.

CLICK HERE TO VOTE

And remember, this is approval voting, you can choose multiple books.

Voting will stay open until Friday, November 20th, at which point I'll post the winner in the sub and announce the discussion dates.

In case you missed the announcement, the midway discussion for Spear was canceled, but the final will be had on the final is still going up on November 25.

What is the FIF Bookclub? You can read about it in our Reboot thread here.


r/Fantasy • • 18h ago

Acts of Caine Spoiler

8 Upvotes

Hiiii I have a very specific question about book 1, I don't know if I missed the answer/ it was not answered/ it will be revealed later (I'm 1/3 in second book). How did Caine manage to go through the Rebirth (I think it's called that but I read the book in Polish so it may translate differently) Ritual successfully? And how did he not therefore become one of Ma'elKoth Children? Thank you for the answers!