r/fantasywriters • • 6h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Wednesday Weekly Writing Check-In

3 Upvotes

Want to be held accountable by the community or just brag about/celebrate your writing progress over the last week? If so, you're welcome to respond to this weekly writing check-in thread. Feel free to tell us what you accomplished this week, or set goals about what you hope to accomplish before next Wednesday!

So, who met their goals? Who found themselves tackling something totally unexpected? Who accomplished something (even something small)? What goals have you set for yourself this week?

This check-in is now open for you to promote your writing!

While our subreddit rules generally disallow self-promotion, that rule is loosened for this thread. In this thread, you may promote your fiction or non-fiction writing. You may include links, but be sure to write a few words as well telling us about what you've made!

However, this isn't a place to advertise services and software. r/fantasywriters is not a place to promote your vibe-coded codex app, nor is it a place to find clients for your copywriting business.

Examples of the kind of self-promotion that are allowed in this thread:

  • Linking to a self-published ebook on the Kindle or Kobo store
  • A web serial on a website like Royal Road, Wattpad, or AO3
  • A link to a specific blog post about a topic related to writing or storytelling, like an analysis of your favorite TV show

Examples of the kind of self-promotion that is NOT allowed in this thread:

  • Advertisements for products or services, including software like note-taking apps, etc. are not allowed (even if they are free)
  • Promoting or offering paid services like ghostwriting, coaching, editing, etc. is not allowed
  • Anything that involves an "affiliate link" or a "referral code" is not allowed

As a general reminder: while the restrictions on self-promotion are loosened here, all of our other subreddit rules remain in effect, including our prohibition on AI-generated content (rule 6), so please ensure that any work you self-promote here adheres to our subreddit rules.

Above all, this is a place for our community members to share their work. If you never participate in r/fantasywriters except to self-promote your own work in this thread, you're probably violating the spirit of this thread, and it might result in your posts being removed, or we might tell you to refrain from self-promoting until you've participated in the community in other ways.

Reminder: we also have Discord

Yes, we have a fantasywriters subreddit Discord!

Please note that the Discord moderation team is not the same team that moderates the r/fantasywriters subreddit. If you have any subreddit-related inquiries that require moderation attention, those are best addressed through Reddit's mod mail function.


r/fantasywriters • • 23d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Monthly Writing Group Connections Thread

6 Upvotes

If you would like to join a writing group or want more people for your current group, you're welcome to post below. We're here to facilitate both virtual writing groups (discord, email correspondence, etc) as well as in-person groups. Our subreddit's usual restrictions on self-promotion are relaxed in this thread: you are welcome to post links to discords, websites, etc. in this thread.

As a reminder, our subreddit also has an official Discord community. Please note that the team that moderates the Discord is different from the team that oversees this subreddit, and any subreddit-related inquiries (including questions related to this thread) should be directed to Reddit's mod mail function.

As always, please exercise appropriate caution when connecting with strangers online. Our moderation cannot oversee discussions that take place outside this subreddit or the official subreddit Discord. That being said, we do encourage you to use to let us know if you run into anyone who uses this thread to facilitate behavior that would violate our subreddit rules (for example, by asking you to critique AI-generated stories, which would be a violation of rule 6).

Suggestions for running an effective writing group

Fantasy author has an excellent writing lecture offering guidelines on how to run a successful writing group, which we highly recommend. Some key points:

  • Set clear expectations. Agree ahead of time how often you will meet, and how much time you expect everyone to spend contributing feedback.
  • Offer descriptive feedback, rather than immediately jumping to prescriptive 'solutions' and 'fixes.' Don't try to rewrite or "fix" someone's story for them unless they have specifically asked you to. Instead, try to engage with their story as a reader, offering your own reactions as a reader. As Brandon Sanderson puts it: "Saying 'I was bored?' Completely valid. There's never a time when 'I was bored' is not a valid response to something you were bored by. Saying 'you should add a fight scene' can be really bad advice. Sometimes it can be good advice if you really know the person, and what the writer is trying to do...but it can be bad advice. Saying 'I was confused?' Always valid. ... Be descriptive rather than prescriptive."
  • Give feedback that helps authors understand what parts of their story are working, rather than just trying to catch all the errors and mistakes.
  • Learn to listen and receive feedback. Don't interrupt by defending or explaining your work while someone is trying to give you feedback.

r/fantasywriters • • 4h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Would like feedback[Fantasy, 2000 words]

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

r/fantasywriters • • 1h ago

Question For My Story Palace vs Castle

3 Upvotes

Probably a waste of a post but I wanted to ask if you guys feel something small like this matters. 

In my novel my mc is a prince lives in a big “castle” (Duh). I've done a little research between the differences of a palace and castle. 

In basic terms. Castle= Generally more for defense. Palace= Generally more for luxury. I feel like both apply to my mcs home. Palace is likely the better fit but I however have just always referred to it as a castle. I have tried looking through some threads online to see if there some consensus on how to us the terms but I haven't really found a straight answer.

Should I change it to a palace for accuracy?

Could I use both terms throughout the novel interchangeably?

Is this a stupid question? 


r/fantasywriters • • 4h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic If your fantasy romance is spicy, do you let family read it?

5 Upvotes

Do you allow family members read your fantasy romance if it is spicy?

Or do you not tell your family about your books or if they know about your books do you specifically tell them not to read them, lol.

When it comes to family reading your fantasy romance spice: Do you feel differently if it is your parents? What about your adult children? Or maybe extended family?

Do you make a non-spice version for family?

I have been thinking about this because one of my adult children has asked to read the draft of the book I am working on because I told them about the fantasy plot and they are interested in that, but there is some spice so that just feels a little weird.


r/fantasywriters • • 4h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Feedback for my novel The Beacon – Prologue and Chapters 1 & 2 [Dark Fantasy] (4000 words)

1 Upvotes

Prologue
Tom threw his full weight into the weathered front door and slid the bolt into place as the creature reached the front steps of his cottage. He mentally willed the ramshackle door to hold. BANG!... The few inches of sun-bleached wood in the doorway were all that prevented the nightmare from reaching him. BANG!... Tom could feel the boards of the door begin to creak and bow under the blows. His wife, Heidi, had told him he needed to replace the drafty, sun-rotted thing last spring. She was dead now, her blood still covering the front of his smock. BANG! BANG! He could hear them now, not just the one who had ripped his wife apart. Tom had buried his axe into the thing's shoulder and driven it away from Heidi, but he had been too slow. He remembered her brown eyes looking up. No life, just dark voids where her light used to be. BANG! The top rusty hinge of the cottage door audibly cracked. A cacophony of bestial laughs began to echo outside, all around the cottage. Tom's mind began to panic like a cornered rabbit in a burrow. I need to get to the village… I need to run… I need to hide. The old fur trapper was surrounded; he'd never reach Hemlock and its thick timber walls. He turned, put his back into the door, and scanned the room. The root cellar or the stairs? BANG!... Tom looked up and saw a grey clawed hand snaking over the lip of the door near the broken hinge. Tom could hear the monster's moist, panting breaths through the door by his ear. Tom decided the cellar would be his best option. The old man went to move forward away from the door when suddenly the large, clawed hand on the top of the door quit pushing and suddenly pulled the door out into the darkness. Crash!... Tom heard the splintering of breaking wood, then suddenly he was on his back outside his home, looking up at the awning of his porch. 

Realization of his doom registered before he saw the creature. Tom stared up at the beams of his awning and began to scream, releasing his bottled-up terror all at once. His scream was cut short as a large, clawed hand came into his vision from above. The claws hooked down and into Tom's wide, screaming mouth. Tom felt the claws penetrate the upper palate of his mouth. Coppery blood exploded around the claws, and Tom could taste his own death. Eyes still wide in terror, Tom could only see grey fur as he felt the claws in his mouth suddenly pull his entire body free of the porch. Time slowed as the creature ripped him from the porch and out into the night. With a flick of the monster's clawed hand, Tom felt weightless as he flew through the air, not even noticing his own blood and teeth exploding from his ruined upper jaw. Time and pain returned to old Tom as he felt his right shoulder connect and break against the ground. The man rolled several times before coming to rest on his stomach. Blood poured from his ruined mouth as his last instincts of survival shot adrenaline through his body. Without any plan, Tom rose to his feet, pushed off the ground with his good arm, and searched for escape. As Tom scanned, a new terror gripped him. A primal fear that he did not know existed in mankind until this moment.

Before him stood a dozen of them. The hulking creatures stared at him, unmoving, their eyes reflecting the moonlight, causing them to glow yellowish-green. Their large, powerful lupine maws were open, yellow fangs exposed, panting, breathing in the scent of his fear. Tom knew what they were, but he had never seen one. No one had seen them in this part of Kaliban in a thousand years.
Knolls.

The hyena-faced monsters continued staring, unmoving, at Tom. The old man felt his lifeblood pouring down his chin and onto his chest. He knew he was going to die, so why were they waiting? Suddenly, a whistle broke the silence. Tom turned toward the soft, melodic noise and saw a hooded figure in black robes standing behind the knolls on his porch, the whistle still held to the stranger’s lips beneath his hood. The hooded man released the whistle, which hung from a gold necklace. The small whistle swung like a pendulum as the man began walking toward Tom. 

As he approached Tom, the hulking knolls stepped out of the path of the stranger, who was most assuredly their master. The hooded figure glided toward Tom, and with each moment, the old man felt the malice of this unknown person press down upon his shoulders. Tom was on his knees now, staring up into the shadows of the hood. The man in black reached up and began pulling his black hood back. Tom braced himself for whatever abomination lurked beneath the hood of his executioner. Tom's eyes widened in shock, not terror, as the man revealed his perfect alabaster face. Not a man, an elf. A beautiful man with high cheekbones and emerald-green eyes. His hair was long and golden, fashioned in a topknot. A gold circlet rested upon his brow, fashioned with dark red rubies.

Tom attempted to ask the elf, “Who are you?” but only wet, ragged noises escaped the old man's ruined mouth. The elf seemed to understand what was asked of him.

The elf looked down on the pathetic human and said in a melodic voice, “I am Moros Erebus.” The elf then raised his right hand and made a claw gesture toward Tom. A small white orb of light appeared in Moros's hand. Tom looked on in shock as he felt something being pulled from his body. Red wisps began to appear between Tom's chest and Moros's glowing hand. Tom began to sob as he felt his body begin to feel heavier. Tom could feel his joints atrophy and his blood slow in his very heart. Tom's eyes rolled into his head, and he silently screamed as he felt his life—no, his very soul—ripped from his body. Tom's last thoughts were of his wife, Heidi, and how lucky she was to have just been ripped apart.

Chapter 1
Ward No-Name moved like a ghost through the shadowed twilight of the large redwood forest. The three-hundred-foot-tall canopy of the Gloom Wood kept the forest in perpetual dusk most of the day. The time was midmorning, and the large scout moved between the building-sized trunks of the trees, from shadow to shadow, scanning and patrolling for any potential danger to the caravan he had left miles behind him on the road.

Members of his mercenary band, the Dancing Badgers, thought he must use some old magical trinket from the Age of Lost or perhaps a wind stone to move swiftly and unseen. Because, how could a man of his size go unnoticed? Barely twenty, Ward was a brute of a man, standing over six feet tall and weighing nearly twice as much as his fellow scouts. However, even with his height and weight, Ward was always able to find the quietest, most direct paths when scouting. Ward would tell his brothers and sisters of the Dancing Badgers that his skill did not come from magic but from the many nights of his childhood spent sneaking through the halls of the orphanage to find the food stores in the kitchen pantry.

Ward saw a large outcropping of stone ahead and to his left. The moss-covered rock would make a good vantage point from which to survey farther down the forest road before he needed to report back to the caravan. The large scout moved from the shadow of the tree and glided toward the stones. His well-oiled leather armor fit snugly over a thin quilted tunic, allowing him to move almost silently. As Ward crossed the open ground, he absently flexed his fists inside his leather gloves. The diamond-shaped iron studs adorning each knuckle were a formidable weapon in the hands of someone of Ward’s size.
Something was off… Ward could feel it. His iron-studded hand dropped to the hilt of his short sword on his belt as he continued toward the large boulders. He reached the base of the stones and quietly ascended the rock face, gliding up over the stones, his green cloak making him look like a large green and brown lizard trying to find the sun. Ward reached the top of the rock outcropping and crawled to the edge to look east down the road and into the next valley. Quiet gloom, large rock outcroppings, and cathedral-like pillars of giant tree trunks were all Ward could see. The scout reached into a leather tube case he had strapped to his weapon belt, withdrew his scope, and began scanning the landscape before him.

Scopes were becoming more common thanks to the monasteries and their study of magic and the lost sciences. Most people could hardly tell the difference between the two. The scope had certainly seemed magical to Ward the first time his captain, Jonathan Mags, had given it to him and he had peered through it. That sense of wonder faded somewhat when Captain Mags showed him how the specially shaped lenses inside the tube magnified his sight.

Ward could understand lenses. Magic was another matter entirely.

Ward, still peering through his scope, was pulled out of his reverie when he realized he was not alone on this island of stone. He slowly brought his scope down as he felt a hot, vaporous breath near his right ear. The creature’s heavy panting suddenly assailed the young scout’s senses.

Ward slowly turned his head toward the creature… and was met with a long, wet, pink tongue that was dragged across the entire front of his face. Ward snapped into motion and rolled away and onto his knees, facing the intruder.

Golden eyes peered back at him in the unfading dusk, an almost human grin upon the young Vardren’s lupine face.

“Pike! How the hell did you get up here, you asshole? You scared the shit out of me,” whispered Ward.

The large dog looked back at his master with one ear up and his head cocked to the side with an amused look on his face. Ward was on his knees now, and even with his height, he was still looking up at the giant war dog’s donkey-sized head. Ward’s scowl melted away as he reached forward to scratch Pike behind his left ear, knowing it was the Vardren’s favorite spot. A silent ripple of pleasure ran down the large dog’s blue-mottled fur. As Ward scratched Pike’s head, he asked the dog if he had seen anything of note on his patrol ahead. Pike raised his head and signaled that he had seen something.

“What did you find?”

Pike gave a quick, quiet yip, implying that he had found people but did not know if they were a threat or not.

“Show me.”

Chapter 2
Elara Ashwood sat next to the dying campfire, enjoying the last bites of her honey porridge and bacon. The sun had still failed to show itself through the tall canopy overhead. El loved the midmorning, when the sun’s rays would shine down like golden beacons from the heavens through the treetops, even if she was currently sitting in a forest on the opposite side of the Claw Mountain Range from her home in the city of Ember. El looked around her little encampment. Her large merchant’s wagon, with its rounded, enclosed top and shingled roof, looked like a tiny cottage resting on top of two huge, heavy iron axles. She had the wagon custom-built so she could enjoy the luxuries of home while on the road.
El’s staff lay next to her on the ground, its obsidian tip resting among the dying embers. A small part of her mind was occupied with the ritual of drawing the fire’s energy into the stone. After decades of practice, El had become so proficient at the ritual that she could perform it while eating, reading, or even carrying on a conversation. Drawing energy into her stone had become as effortless and unconscious as breathing. 

The woman rose and brushed off her red robes, pine needles falling to the ground to join the countless thousands around her. She still needed to wash her breakfast dishes and give old Sam his rolled oats and hay. As if the great beast could read her mind, Sam gave a low rumble and a snort, his way of telling his master she was neglecting her duties. El turned toward the two-ton animal and smiled. The large, red woolly rhinoceros was haltered and staked next to one of the large redwood trees by the wagon.

“Calm down, Sam. I will get your breakfast.”

The woolly rhino gave another snort of indignation at the thought of continuing his unwanted fast. Woolly rhinos were not a common sight this far south on the continent of Kaliban. El had been extremely lucky to find and purchase Sam at auction twenty years ago. She had saved him from a hard life in one of the many dwarven mines in the Claw Mountains, much to the dismay of the dwarven merchants who had been hell-bent on purchasing the rare little calf.
El thought of the night those same disgruntled dwarven merchants had come for little Sam, hoping to slit her throat and steal him. A smile crept across El’s beautiful, ageless face as she remembered the dwarves’ shocked expressions when they realized they had attempted to rob and murder a pyromancer and not just some rich girl. Their screams had been brief when she shot a fan of searing fire into the three fools’ faces, leaving smoldering husks inside glowing plate armor.

El tended to her morning chores and then gave poor old Sam his daily rations. The rhino grumbled as he chewed.

“Calm down, you oversized cow. Three more days, and we enter the eastern hamlets of the Breadbasket. You can graze all day when we get there.”

El patted the rhino’s massive, shaggy belly. “You won’t starve, I promise.”

“We’re hungry,” said a weaselly voice from behind El. “Do you have anything for me and my mates to eat?”

A shiver ran down El’s back, but she quickly composed herself, turning with a smile on her face and murder in her heart in case these men had come looking for trouble. She found herself looking at four men. All of them had swords on their hips. One of them, a fat, balding man with a pockmarked face, rested a large crossbow casually over his shoulder. All of them looked filthy and road-worn, their brown breeches and grey cloaks threadbare and paper-thin. The speaker stepped forward. He was young, with greasy brown hair that hung to his neck, a hawkish nose, and small, darting eyes that reminded El of a shrew.

“Would you share your campfire with…” The shrew-faced man stopped talking, his eyes narrowing as he scanned El’s face, her blonde hair, her blue eyes, her long, thin ears…

“You’re a fucking elf!” squawked the shrew-faced man.

“I’m not fucking anything today, but yes, I am an elf. I was just packing up camp and readying myself to resume my travels. You are welcome to the fire and some food.”

As El gestured toward the fire, she glided toward the remains of the smoldering cookfire and her staff.
The shrew-faced man stepped over the fire, cutting El off from her weapon.

“Come now, elf. Surely you're not in such a hurry. We've been riding hard for three days. A hot meal, a little entertainment… I'm sure you could find a way to lift our spirits.” 

El looked at each of the four men in turn and saw on their faces what they thought a day of “relaxation” would entail for her.

“Gentlemen, I’m afraid I haven’t the time to entertain guests. I have important appointments to keep and must make my way east toward the hamlet of Windbottom. Judging by the haste of your journey west, I can only assume you’re fleeing the consequences of robbery, sheep-fucking, or perhaps both. So, if you would kindly return to your horses, I’ll pack up my camp and leave you with some supplies.” 

All four men’s faces reddened as they glared at El.
The shrew-faced man charged forward, hands outstretched like claws. “You fucking bitch! I’m going to take my time with you.”

El angled her right side away from the charging man, set her feet, and flicked her wrist to release her hidden dagger from its sheath. The pommel of the four-inch blade came to rest in her palm.

The shrew-faced man came within arm’s reach of El, his outstretched hands reaching for her throat. El dropped to one knee, letting his hands grasp empty air as she drove her dagger deep into his left thigh. The man cried out in pain and looked down in shock, his eyes widening as he saw the blade buried in his leg. “The fucking bitch stabbed me!” squealed the shrew-faced man.

El ripped the blade free in a spray of red mist. She rolled forward off her left knee toward the cookfire and her staff. El reached for the staff as the fat man screamed, “Hold, you whore, or I’ll shoot yer fucking eye out!”

The pyromancer looked up and saw the large crossbow leveled at her from twenty paces. She was fast, but not that fast. Her hand was spread flat, hovering inches above the staff. She could feel the power of her obsidian stone. She was so close.
The shrew-faced man lay on the ground behind her, screaming and clutching his wounded leg.

“Shoot the bitch!” screamed the wounded man.

The fat man shook his head. “No! I haven’t shagged anything but goats and sheep this whole year!”

“I fucking knew it,” whispered El under her breath.

The fat man and his two uninjured comrades began moving forward, forming a semicircle around El. The two men continued past her and went to the shrew-faced man’s aid.

The fat man moved forward, standing across the cookfire from her, the crossbow trained on her chest as a smile spread across his ugly, sweaty face.

“Are we having a party?” said a new voice from the road.

El looked around the rotund crossbowman and saw a large, clean-shaven young human in leather armor standing casually with his hand resting on the hilt of his short sword. Despite his youth, El deduced that the man was a capable fighter by the way he carried his large frame, moving lightly on his toes toward the crossbowman.

“Stop right there, or I will shoot the bitch!” barked the fat man, his crossbow still pointed at El.

The big stranger held up his hands and gave the fat man a wide berth as he slowly moved into the crossbowman’s peripheral vision.

“What are you doing?” screamed the fat man.
His two unwounded friends drew their swords and watched the newcomer.

“Oh, just getting a good view.”

“A good view of wha—”

The fat man’s words were cut short as a blue-mottled mass of fur and teeth barreled into him, driving him to the ground. The fat man screamed and flailed as he attempted to fight off what El immediately recognized as a Vardren.

The camp exploded into motion.

The two uninjured men separated, charging toward El and the newcomer. El grabbed her staff and turned just in time to catch the downward stroke of a sword. She pushed the blade up and away and quickly came to her feet as the man stepped in again, this time with a slash. The pyromancer deflected the second blow and centered her mind as she kept the man’s sword at bay.

“I’m going to gut you, elf!” said the man as he continued swinging his sword with reckless abandon.

She felt the power of her stone connect with her mind, a wellspring of energy rising within her. El blocked the man’s latest chop and felt the ashwood staff snap in half under the mighty blow, leaving her holding the top half of the staff.

The man stopped his attack to grin evilly at El. His grin melted away as he saw the black stone of the broken staff glow bright red. He looked from the stone to the elf woman, who now returned an evil grin of her own.

Flame exploded from the head of the broken staff, engulfing the man’s head in a searing, red-hot beam of fire.

* * *

Across the encampment, Ward drew his short sword and moved to intercept the second bandit. The man charged at full speed, likely hoping to overwhelm his larger opponent. Ward danced sideways, letting the man overreach and slide past him, his sword leading the way like the tip of an arrow.

The large scout turned and set his feet as the bandit turned to face him, this time approaching slowly. The man’s sword was twice the length of Ward’s short sword. Many warriors would consider this a disadvantage for Ward; however, Ward preferred the short sword. It kept fights close, giving him an advantage with his size and strength.
The bandit came on with a series of slashes and stabs, attempting to strike the scout from a distance. The man was skilled, and Ward had to focus to keep the long strikes at bay. Ward maintained his defense until the man overcommitted on a thrust. Ward slapped the incoming blade wide, sparks flying and a clang echoing through the trees as the bandit’s sword and arm swung outward.
Ward drove his left fist in hard and fast, his iron-studded knuckles connecting with the man’s mouth and nose. Blood exploded from the man’s nose and mouth. The bandit stumbled back blindly, waving his sword in front of him to prevent a follow-up strike. Ward paused and watched the man blink away tears and spit gobs of mucus-coated blood from his mouth.

“You broke my nose!”

“It’s an improvement,” said Ward as he flew in to finish the man.

The man raised his arm overhead to strike. Ward stepped inside the bandit’s reach, caught his descending sword arm in his left hand, and drove his short sword up through the man’s diaphragm and out through the back of his rib cage.
The man looked up into Ward’s eyes, seeing for the first time the killer he was. Ward pushed the man back and let him fall off his blade and onto the ground.

Ward turned and saw the fat man lying on the ground, his throat ripped out. Pike turned toward him, his muzzle covered in blood and gore. The scout looked toward the elf, who was standing over the other man, his face nothing but bone and charred flesh.

Ward looked toward where the bandit leader had fallen and saw that the man was on his feet, pulling a throwing dagger from his belt. As Ward yelled for the woman to look out, he heard a loud snapping of leather and cord from behind the bandit.

A wall of red bellowing fur suddenly crashed into the injured bandit, driving him to the ground beneath two tons of primal rage. The bandit leader screamed once as a large, three-toed rhino foot descended onto his back and pressed down.
Ward looked on in morbid fascination as the man’s mouth opened incredibly wide, blood and bile erupting from his gurgling, dying mouth. The woolly rhino continued over the dead man, slowing his charge to a meandering walk as he approached the elf.

The elf woman wrapped her arms around the beast’s towering, four-foot-tall horn and began praising the huge beast like it was nothing more than a puppy.
She pushed off the rhino’s large head and turned to regard the big scout and the Vardren.

“Welcome to the Ashwood Trading Company. Can I interest you in some of my wares?”

Pike and Ward just looked at each other in confusion. 

THANKS FOR READING WOULD YOU READ MORE? Be honest :)


r/fantasywriters • • 11h ago

Question For My Story Inconsistent POV Between Books

3 Upvotes

Hello!

I'm having some self-doubt about my POV choice and would love to hear your thoughts. I've had to change POVs partly because the original three POV characters end up in one place together, meaning there's too many in one place and not enough in others. Also, I just really wanted to hear from some of the characters. Some background if you're willing to read on:

Its a trilogy that has three main arcs.

  1. The "princess" arc. She's a POV character in all three books. Her story is about growing into leadership and righting the wrongs of her predecessors. Also, wyverns and weapons and adventure.
  2. The "soldier" arc. His/their arc is about prioritising loved ones and not giving up everything for power. His/their POV switches each book. Book one the soldier, book two his betrothed, book three the platonic warrior soulmate.
  3. The "violinist" arc. My problem. The violinist is a gentle soul who experiences severe trauma in book one, her mental state gradually degrades, and in the final chapter of book two she becomes the book three antagonist.

These characters and personal arcs all intertwine in the main plot of repelling an invasion, and their paths cross a lot; these characters have impact on each other and aren't fully separate plots.

I'm writing book two now with the princess, the soldier's betrothed and the violinist as POV characters, but the violinist POV has to switch in book three, 1) because she's an antagonist and it just feels off to have two heroes and their antagonist, but more importantly 2) her head will not be an enjoyable place to experience POVs in. I'm planning to switch her POV in book three to a companion who's on an antagonist to protagonist arc.

But... Is it off to have the princess for all of them, swap the soldier out in all of them, but keep the violinist for two and change her in the third? Does it make sense given that she ends book two as an antagonist? Or should I swap her POV in book two? What would you do as a writer, or think as a reader? I have tried to imagine what this would look like and it would require rewriting several book two arcs to be able to give the violinist some coverage from someone else's POV, but I'll do it if it ends up being the better option.

Thanks so much for any thoughts. And if this story sounds very cringe, please know I've simplified and flattened it a LOT to explain it here.


r/fantasywriters • • 8h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic My mcs backstory feels too convoluted

0 Upvotes

I’m planning out my story rn. And my mcs backstory feels way too complicated, like he’s lived through a shit ton before the story starts. Originally I was planning on him starting off as bit of a blank slate with an ordinary life then going through the plot, but I realised it just felt like, “some random guy goes through traumatic stuff for no reason”… so i decided to give more of a history to him so now I feel like I have more of a clear arc for him now, which involves him making amends / being forced to confront his previous baggage due to the stories events. But the thing is now I feel like his character has no clear premise. I’ve tried streamlining it, but I feel like I like the convoluted backstory better. But I don’t know if it’s inherently problematic or if it can be executed well. How much backstory is enough for a mc? Could flashback scenes be utilised well?


r/fantasywriters • • 17h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Excerpt from Chapter 4 of Wolf's Bane [fantasy/romance, 446 words]

5 Upvotes

I'm writing a fantasy novel about werewolf hunters vs werewolves. My FMC is participating in an arena-style trial of combat against captured werewolves. The wolves are released in rounds, first one, then two, then three wolves at a time. She survived the first two rounds and killed one wolf in the third round, and now she has two wolves left.

I've written a very... creative sequence of events for how she tackles these two wolves, and two people now who've read this scene feel like it's just too far on the disbelief side. I'm trying to find that balance between taking the reader out of the story with how outlandish it is vs typical fantasy epic battle shenanigans that you just accept. I've rewritten it several times trying to make it feel right.

Note that my FMC does have slightly enhanced supernatural senses and strength, but the reader would not know this yet, so it needs to be something the average person probably couldn't pull off but believable enough that you start to think she could pull it off if there's something special about her, slightly tipping off the reader about her secret heritage without saying it out loud.

Also note that my FMC is wielding a bow and does have a sword but she is specifically trying not to use it because her mother faced this trial with only a bow and survived, so she's trying to prove a point and purposefully putting herself in more danger than necessary to do it.

Excerpt:

" It takes every single ounce of my will to drag myself to my feet. The wolf that clawed me stalks to the left, while the injured one takes the right, flanking me again as I tighten my grip on my bow.
But can you really take down three of them before they knock that thing out of your pretty little hands?
For some goddess-forsaken reason, Arlen’s voice in my mind is the catalyst that launches my limbs into action.
I pull back the arrow right as the wolf on the left dashes toward me, sinking it into its right shoulder, but not deep enough to sever an artery.
Three arrows left.
It barks out a whine, staggering into its injured side, but it’s still coming for me. I run toward it, sending a quick glance to the other wolf that’s begun circling behind me out of my field of view, and take a very briefly-calculated risk.
I grip my bow in my left hand and yank an arrow out of my quiver with my right, then pounce at the wolf. Wounded and furious, it opens its jaws to snap at me, but I duck low and stab the arrow straight up through its skull, its breath hot on my face.
I turn, pivoting with the heavy corpse as I crouch almost beneath it. Bracing my bow hand against the wolf's head, I angle myself toward the incoming wolf, the dead one hanging off the arrow between us. It soars at me, a vicious snarl ripping from its throat, just as I slide the arrow's notch into place on the bowstring.
With the wolf’s head still on the shaft, I draw back as far as I can, the skull catching on the bow hilt and getting dragged up the shaft with a sickening sound to the end of the arrow, almost completely off of it. As the black shadow of fur obscures the sun, I release. The arrow tears through the skull and sinks into the snarling beast's chest, lodging there.
Both wolves collapse on top of me, and that arrow gets shoved right back into my torso, just beneath my ribs.
I let out a garbled cry as the full weight of the wolves crushes me, burying me under a mountain of dark, bloodied fur.
Pain. Singing, blinding, agonizing pain.
My lungs struggle for air, unable to expand. Fire courses through my veins, radiating from my entire right side until it consumes all of me. I can’t think past it. I don’t exist outside of it.
Darkness and pain are all I am for what I can only perceive to be a very long time."

Questions:

  1. Can you see the sequence in your mind?
  2. Is it believable given the context above?
  3. Does it take the reader out of the immersion or does it feel like an epic fantasy hero move?
  4. Is it one of those "just crazy enough to work" things? Or just crazy?

I'm looking for both the perspective of the average reader who doesn't pay much attention to how or why something works as well as the enthusiasts who will pick apart the sequence like Mythbusters on a mission.

EDIT: There is an updated revision in the comments now!


r/fantasywriters • • 9h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Chapter 1 of Anger and Danger [Dark Fantasy, 2192 words]

1 Upvotes

Chapter One

The clash of wooden training swords filled the entire yard, keeping time with the shouts of the village's swordmaster, Witz Rick of House Dak. Whenever he roared, “Strike!” the wooden blades crashed against one another with all their might. And whenever he barked, “Guard!” the yard filled with the thunder of boots as the trainees retreated three paces from their opponents.

Witz Rick was a knight who had travelled leagues upon leagues, only to be sent here for reasons no one seemed to know. He was plainly no northerner. His eyes were brown, and his raven-black hair fell in waves to his shoulders. Even if one allowed for the possibility that someone in all of Skarim might have dark hair and eyes, his nose was far too small and straight. No hump, no hollow, not a blemish to be seen. Some said it was because he had never taken a proper blow to the face. Others argued that perhaps he was simply too good a fighter to let anyone land one.

Ejvoy wasn't usually one to study another man's face. But then, this knight was a stranger. And a knight, besides.

Ejvoy turned to his sparring partner, Marco. In a low, slightly hoarse voice, the sort that hinted he was coming of age, he asked, “Hey, melon-head. What's with the black eye? Get into a fight?”

Marco grinned. Ejvoy watched as he gave his sword an ostentatious twirl, against the rules. “Remember the former lord's daughter? The third one, I mean.”

Ejvoy shrugged. “Why should I care about some girl younger than me? Besides, she's the daughter of a...” He lowered his voice even further. “Lord.”

“Strike!”

The wooden swords clashed again, the sound of wood against wood ringing across the yard.

Ejvoy leaned closer to Marco and continued, “It's not as if she's going to become my wife or anything. Besides, that lord doesn't even live in this village anymore. Does he? No. They've given him some enormous castle near the Frostwoods. The Frostwoods! You understand what I'm getting at, don't you?”

Marco's eyes widened slightly. “Why would you even think about marrying her? You've got quite the ambition. The most you could hope for is to walk beside her one day, and even that's only if you become a knight like that fellow.”

Ejvoy smirked and raised an eyebrow, looking rather pleased with himself. “And then swear an oath to the southern fools' god? What was his name again? Pri... I can't even remember. I don't want Lord Da getting angry with me for saying it.”

Marco shrugged, making his sword slip a little. “Damn it... Anyway, as I was saying. If we don't become knights, we'll have to join the army or the King's Guard and swear never to take a wife. And if we never marry, well, we'll die without one.”

Ejvoy nodded and answered at once. “No. We could become Rangers. Or go looking for the mages. Maybe even leave this continent.”

Marco laughed and said nothing more.

Witz Rick was drawing closer, making corrections as he went from one of the twenty-five pairs of trainees to the next. At last, he reached Ejvoy and Marco.

Ejvoy kept his expression straight, but a smirk crept across Marco's face.

Rick looked them over. “It's a wonder to me how you fools, who piss yourselves before you can even manage a proper greeting, ever learned to fight like civilised warriors.”

Marco snapped back, “Hey! My father was one of the most civilised farmers in the whole North!”

Witz Rick answered without missing a beat. “Frederick Torres. Executed for raping a three-year-old girl. Yes. From what I've read, he was a fine, civilised man.”

Marco's face hardened. He dropped his sword and stood before the knight with both fists clenched. “My father never did that! They framed him!”

Witz stepped closer. “Has no one told you? Ah... poor boy. You've got a pretty little sister, don't you? Shame she's a royal bastard.”

Ejvoy could hear Marco's breathing grow heavier, each breath coming faster than the last.

“Stop!” he shouted. “He's going to pass out!”

Witz raised a hand. “Could you shut up?”

Then he turned back to Marco.

“You want to tell me you're nothing like your father? That you're a good man? Then pay your father's debt. Go become a border guard.”

Witz's face twisted with contempt. He stared at Marco with such naked hatred, such barely contained fury, that Ejvoy blurted out, “Can you hear that?”

Shouts, screams, and cries were echoing through the village.

Ejvoy turned around.

A deep, heavy silence had fallen over the yard. Everyone was listening to Witz and Marco. Even Marco's old friends had moved away from him.

Marco stamped his foot and ran towards the gate, shouting and weeping. Ejvoy's eyes remained fixed on his back.

Marco passed through the gate. Then, all at once, he stopped. He looked to his left, raised his hands, and began backing away.

Something flashed past Ejvoy's eyes, swift as a shadow, and knocked Marco to the ground.

It was enormous. Something like a gigantic bat, grown even larger than a man. The creature bent over Marco and opened its mouth.

Then a spear struck it in the neck.

Ejvoy looked up. Witz stood with his arm extended, his posture making it perfectly clear who had thrown the spear.

“Run!” he shouted.

Ejvoy's breathing grew ragged. He could hear it roaring in his ears, and, unfortunately, it was the only thing he could hear. He opened his mouth and clutched at his throat, trying to pull away the hand that was choking him. But there was no hand there.

He could feel his heart pleading to escape its prison of bone.

Then, all at once, the sounds around him sharpened. He saw his shoulder shaking. A hand was resting on it. He turned and found the face of its owner.

Witz.

Ejvoy looked around.

The creatures were pale, reddish-grey things. Their eyes glowed like molten lava, and their teeth were as long as fingers and sharp as swords. They had short arms and long legs, and moved on all fours, their backs arched high above the ground. Membranes stretched between their arms and bodies, forming wings like those of bats.

There were three or four of them.

Ejvoy glanced at the other trainees, and his breath caught.

Their bodies lay scattered across the ground, mutilated beyond recognition. Some were missing their kidneys, others their necks. Some had lost their heads, others their arms. Many had been reduced to little more than bones.

He turned to Witz Rick.

“What... happened?”

His fingertips trembled. Without thinking, he tightened his grip on the wooden sword, fighting with everything he had to keep from wetting himself.

Witz Rick had raised his sword.

“I don't know. Run!”

Ejvoy ran with all his might.

He burst through the gate of the village training yard, moving as though a monster were on his heels. Perhaps one was. Perhaps all those damned, malformed creatures were after him.

With every step, he pushed himself to run faster, driven by the hope that he might escape, that he might finally put some distance between himself and the village.

The sun had shifted slightly.

He kept running.

At last, he glanced over his shoulder. The moment he did, he wished he hadn't.

A monster was chasing him, racing on all fours like the creatures old grandfathers told their granddaughters about to frighten them. Strange sounds kept spilling from its throat, throwing Ejvoy's concentration into disarray. And, as if his luck could possibly get any worse, his foot caught on a stone buried beneath the snow.

He fell hard.

He cursed and tried to get up. Brushing the snow aside, he turned to see how close the creature had come.

It was right behind him.

But its steps slowed. It let out a low growl and bared its teeth.

Ejvoy shut his eyes and waited for death.

Then the growling was abruptly cut short by a muffled sound.

When Ejvoy opened one eye, he found a blood-soaked sword only inches from his face. He scrambled backwards.

A hole had opened in the creature's neck. Blood poured from it, and the monster crashed heavily to the ground.

A giant of a man stood before him. He had a blond, distinctly northern beard, braided and re-braided so many times it was hard to tell how it had first been worn. In his right hand he held a longsword; in his left, a shield that rose as high as Ejvoy's chest.

A patch covered his left eye. A scar ran from above that eye down to the top of his cheek. His remaining eye was the colour of cold, dark forests.

He wore the brown leather armour of the Northern Rangers.

The man dropped to one knee and surveyed the surroundings. He picked up a handful of blood-stained snow and sniffed it.

“Are you the only one left alive?”

Ejvoy quickly shook his head.

“No, no. Witz Rick is still alive...”

His gaze drifted towards the training yard's gate, carrying a faint hope.

Thankfully, Witz was still alive. He limped towards them, his face twisted in pain, dragging one leg behind him.

He looked at the giant, one eyebrow drawn into a frown.

“Oscar? Why am I not surprised to find you here?”

Witz Rick never took his eyes off Oscar. But he reached out, seized Ejvoy by the wrist, and pulled him behind himself with a strength that seemed impossible for a man so exhausted.

“I don't know what's going through your head, Ranger. But don't even think about my students. Or else...”

He drew a heavy breath, a thick cloud of steam spilling from his nostrils. Then he gestured towards his sword and pulled Ejvoy further behind him.

Witz Rick glanced at the boy.

“Do you even know who this man is?”

Ejvoy, who had been too stunned to speak until now, rubbed his palm with his thumb. His voice trembled, perhaps from the cold, perhaps from fear.

“He saved me...”

Ejvoy looked at Oscar.

The Ranger shrugged.

“Don't make me out to be the villain, Witz. I'm only doing what they tell me to do. You know who I mean. Don't say it in front of the boy, either. If you really want him to have a decent life, let him marry. Put the damned sword away.”

Then he turned back to Witz.

“Can I have a word with you? Two minutes.”

Witz Rick glanced at Ejvoy. A few seconds passed in silence. Then a soft, almost gentle smile appeared on his face.

“Don't move.”

He followed Oscar away.

Ejvoy couldn't hear what they were saying. But after a while, he saw Oscar place a hand on Witz Rick's shoulder and lean closer.

Ejvoy looked towards the yard. Witz Rick had told him not to move, but he ignored the order and began walking towards the gate.

His heart was pounding. He wanted to scream, but it felt as though someone had stolen his voice.

Inside the yard, all his friends and companions lay scattered across the ground. Some had been torn apart. Others were simply dead.

But many were worse off.

They were still alive, crying out for help.

Tears gathered in Ejvoy's eyes. He slowly backed away, then clapped a hand over his own mouth.

He returned to where Witz and Oscar were talking. That was when he noticed a distant shape approaching.

It looked like a woman carrying a sword.

Female swordsmen were rare in the North.

He turned to get a better look. A rider was coming towards them. Not so far away that Ejvoy could barely make her out, but far enough that she would not reach them in the blink of an eye.

“Witz?!”

Witz turned towards him at once. Ejvoy pointed at the approaching woman.

Witz looked in her direction and frowned.

“Is she with you?” he asked Oscar.

Oscar let out an incredulous laugh.

“Do women look like the sort who'd follow me around? I adore you, you know that?”

Ejvoy took a step towards the woman.

“Hey! What the hell do you think you're doing?”

He turned at the shout and saw Witz striding towards him at speed. The knight pulled him behind himself.

“Stay back.”

Ejvoy looked up at his face. For a few seconds, they stood close enough to feel each other's breath in the cold air.

Then Oscar spoke.

“If your little performance is over, I should tell you she's here.”

Ejvoy looked towards the woman.

She wore grey armour and a long crimson cloak. A long sword hung from her waist, and she sat astride a black horse. Her hair was brown, her lips the colour of fresh blood, and her eyes the grey of a stormy sky just before the rain.

The woman looked at the three men.

“Ah... I am Witz Matilda of House Lima.”

She glanced around the yard. Ejvoy heard her murmur:

“By the grace of Prizos...”

Then she turned towards Witz and Oscar.

“And I have some important news.”


r/fantasywriters • • 6h ago

Critique My Idea Writer's block on killing my characters for an isekai [dark fantasy]

0 Upvotes

So I had an idea for an isekai story, but I'm fumbling how to kill them off in the "real world". Like most isekai stories, the real plot is the fantasy world.

And I need to transport five friends. Instead of the traditional hit by a truck, I was thinking a slasher story. Parody the typical slasher story, 5 twenty somethings at a cabin and they get picked off. Except this is just the isekai, so the plot is kinda on fast forward so everybody dies faster.

The only concern is does it feel like a wtf moment. I introduce the killer and slasher story and then promptly set it down and forget about it. But I don't want to to devote too much time on the "real world" since that's always the least interesting part of any isekai.

I'd considered making the main villain multidimensional, but then that requires him having grander motives that span the multiverse. Whereas now he's just an evil overlord of the planet.

I'd also considered giving one of the characters a hero moment where they take the killer out with them, as common in these slasher stories, and then the killer is isekai'd with them. He would basically become a miniboss of sorts. Thoughts on that?

I've gone back and forth on making the killer supernatural. At first he was a vampire, but again, I just threw something at the wall and left it. 'Holy crap, vampires were real in the real world? Well, we're not there anymore, so who gives af." Then I considered having him be generic campfire killer ghost story powers. Like Jason Vorhees before they put the deadite lore. Buf that kinda has the same issues. Could just make him a normal serial killer. That solves most issues. Kinda random though. But then, he was always random. And not anynore random than "cross street hit by truck".

Idk. Thoughts?


r/fantasywriters • • 10h ago

Question For My Story Using nautical terminology in a fantasy world?

0 Upvotes

I'm writing a pirate-themed fantasy novel and I have tried to use all the correct words and terminology, but I'm having trouble deciding whether or not that's helping or hurting the story overall. It takes place on a different world, so I don't think it'd be that big a leap in logic to say they wouldn't have the same terminology we have on earth, but I also know there's a surprising number of purists out there who would refuse to read it if the right words aren't used.

Another problem is the general readability of the story. Here's a paragraph I just wrote. Am I right in thinking that using "she" and "her" for both the character and the boat is kind of confusing?

The ship was named The Crossbow.
Serenade curled her lip. She was a pauper’s boat, far beneath a divine being like her, but she wasn’t in any position to refuse right now. She would make do, commandeering the ship and wringing her for every ounce of comfort she could until they reached her destination. At that point, she might consider turning control back over to her captain if the crew was properly respectful. If not, she would be more than happy to send this ramshackle pile of timbers down to the depths where she couldn’t offend her eyes any longer.


r/fantasywriters • • 10h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Do you read more than you actually write? And how much of what you read is similar to what you write?

1 Upvotes

I find myself watching a lot of writing lectures on YouTube and then writing immediately after. However, I honestly don't read as much these days because I end up comparing my own writing or overanalysing the sentence structure or pacing, and becoming unable to actually enjoy the story. I wish to know how other writers go about their reading-writing ratio. And, when you choose a book in a specific genre to read, do you ever consider how the themes in the story align with what your own story is about, or whether the prose in the book you've chosen is something you wish to adapt in your own writing?


r/fantasywriters • • 16h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic How do you move out of being a pantser to a planner?

1 Upvotes

I've found that writers tend to divide people into two groups. Pantsers who write when they feel like it and the words just flow out of them and planners who make everything in their head or in an outline in advance. I think I'm pretty much a pantser. I get very bored if I have every plot twist and character dynamic set up beforehand. The thrill of not knowing what the next chapter will be about, the gang could get drunk, the gang could die, the gang could have a surprise birthday party, keeps me going and I'm led to believe that this is a bad habit that I need to break.

What are your thoughts on it?


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Dark Moore [Epistolary Dark Fantasy, 732 words]

3 Upvotes

Hi all, this is a workshop piece I wrote to figure out tone and setting for a larger work.

Is this something which you would want to see expanded? Is there anything especially good or bad which distracts from the settings tone.

Thank you!

- A hidden clearing?
Lewellyn the Porter first suggested the existence of the Panopticon. Hidden in the bowels north of Ruma. Below are excerpts from his expeditions attempting to further understand the causeways below.

6/30

"In through a sepulcher just outside of Ruma we went down. Myself, two other Cyvonauts, an Attenuate (possibly a haruspex) as well as three quiet fellows of the Hermorphics.

In many instances during our sojourn upon the causeways, we entered tombs undisturbed since epochs forgotten. Vacuous humours passing by in fleeting remembrances. The fear, joy, anguish, and longing beset on my mind from the skin of those halls shall not eagerly diminish from memory. The desperation for an observer to the plights of those forlorn ancient chambers may consume ones every waking memory whole. What is one as lowly as me to do against such lust for companionship?

Of my company, one was a man of the mountains, hailing from Cvetko. I awoke during one of our brief rests earlier than I wished, disturbed by remnants of nostalgia. While I prayed to Lethe, I saw through the lantern dappled shadows his figure rocking rhythmic and ruminative.

His face, chiseled from many years gone, wrenched in effort. Eyes tightly sealed. Lips fluttering whispered phrases upon the air. A rising and falling of shoulders encircled by lengths of cord. Woven tapestries hung about his crossed legs in folds of knots and string, brilliant colours sparkling in the haze of our chem-light. How does a souls entire history hang there, passing through his calloused fingers?

I observed this rhythmic rogation of reminiscence on for some time. Upon reaching the termination of thread, He packed away his tapestried recollections. Perhaps later I might learn the minds weaving of the Babaroga, the men of the mountains.

6/32:

"Our movement along the vascular roads below has labored against many difficulties. Firstly, it is unknown the eons passed since another mind blessed forgotten sepulchers buried below years of umbral digestion. Lyubov supposes that without the creation of new memories a body may begin devouring their own mind unto a blinding torpor. Awaiting the moment a new soul brushes against theirs.

Secondly, due to the first, no remnants illuminated our paths. Anamnesis fled from me. I am a stranger within my home, the causeways. Passages are maws opening to devour us where nothing but smooth stone should have met my hands. As if an architect has trespassed in the little hours of the night and added a room to the second story of a home. As foreign a notion to my senses as a third eye or arm. These new paths tell me I am not welcome.

We began implementing antiquated wayfaring. Imploring upon Chur, Miloneste, or any presence to guide us further. Watching for currents upon the air with our pipe smoke. Lyubov, learned in old prayers, offered murmuration’s into the air. Digesting the miniscule divinations before us. I requested an old vesper I heard among the sepulchers in Getica.

Sat there, ruminating among our smog sung silence, I watched torch beetles glinting along seams within the stonework. The glow from their abdomens gave form to the hallucinating shapes within the dark. Glistening spots shining below as the constellations above. Capturing them within a jar to light your way is a joyous memory for many younger Patuljak.

6/33:

"The mind cannot persist within voids of visual and auditory stimulation. These causeways are filled with Palinopsia. Vision distorted, I leered into the umbral dark. Viewing shapes structuring into stories of my past. Facades of structures distant, distorted by distance and time.

I saw a face. Leering from the border of our chem-lit camp. Half obscured by the threshold of a collapsed tunnel. The isolated dot of reflection from its eye the only constant. Licking at our visages, taking in the seven bodies to  its cerebral gut. I fought desires to turn my gaze fully to our staring guest. Ordering my mutinous neck muscles to stand firm at their post. There is no one here. If there is someone, they are no longer here in any way that matters. Yet every time I chance a glance over into the void of the doorway, reflective discs await to answer.

Lyubov, Svarog bless her, found our way, and moved us along. Heading unto our destination, far too long did the hairs on the back of my neck know they were seen.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Brainstorming How would you describe directions in a fantasy world without using the 4 cardinal directions?

85 Upvotes

Sorry this might sound as a dumb question. But I'm new here and currently writing my own lore settings. During the process I came up with this question: why many works just naturally bring up those 4 directions without telling how people find out the way and what's the mechanism behind it. I know we have it because planet earth has magnetic fields, and liquid metal inside. But what if there is a world that dosen't have these? Or it's not a sepherical planet at all? It is convenient to use cityward or mountainwaed this kind of things. But I still tried to come up with a worldwide one. I have tried to look up some concept systems like traditional Indian ways (they have 10 ) and some Australian tribes that use opposite to your face. One good example is from Discworld, but I wish there is one for a medival-like fantasy world with magic in it. So if there is any good ideas or recommended works that could cover this topic, please just comment. Thanks a lot!

PS: the 4 directions here mean East, West, North. South

(Please forgive my language. I'm not a native English speaker.)

(Thank you for all of your advice. I appreciate every suggestion here.)


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Critique My Idea Can anyone critique my synopsis? (Rural Knight, 653 words)

2 Upvotes

Title: Rural Knight

A rebellion is brewing on the distant and rural Mount Werald. Mutant factions are rallying under the same blood-red banner, crying for revenge against the New Hyperion State. The State isn’t too concerned. Instead, they find it an opportunity to send Chazik Amadarde, an egotistical young knight-in-training, on a fool’s errand with the promise of being fully accepted into the knight order if he can complete a simple quest — capture the rebel leader, Dendara Silver Smile.

After being loaded up with top-of-the-line experimental technology, he travels alone for seven days before reaching the mountain and getting to work. Chazik’s search is hampered by the need to flex his electrifying magic, but, with the help of a shaman, a strange old man, and a pig-faced kid he recruits as a squire, he is directed towards a village overrun with bandits.

There he meets the mayor, who pleads the woes of the village. However, Chazik is unsympathetic and laser-focused, ignoring his words and demanding to know where Dendara is hiding. He then finds himself tied up as the mayor reveals himself to be a rebel general. He is presented to a spectacled, red-headed woman who claims to be Dendara and offers to recruit Chazik into the rebel army. He refuses the offer, instead challenging the woman to a fight where his electric magic is overpowered. Chazik is beaten, thrown in a dog cage, and has to be rescued by the pig kid's family.

After finding a place to hide, Chazik’s ideals are shaken. He starts to question why he was given this quest in the first place, but quickly shakes off his doubts, loudly promises to set the pig kid's village free before recruiting him as his sidekick and squire. The old man he met before appears again, revealing himself to be a mysterious knight stationed on the mountain who is also working against the rebels. The old man then orders Chazik to be useful and find what the rebels are planning in an underground village full of fish people.

To sneak in, Chazik and Babe disguise themselves as rebels and join a rally meant for new recruits. Here, Dendara makes a roaring speech before revealing her secret weapon — a giant robotic war machine in the shape of a metal knight, with the stamp of the New Hyperion State on its chest. In Chazik’s shock, their disguise is seen through, and he has to once again escape the rebel army by the skin of his teeth.

They stumble towards the dry side of Mount Werald and into the home of migrating fairies. The fairies heal their injuries and reveal to them the true plan of the rebellion. Dendara is searching for three magic stones to obtain a wish. Chazik and Babe retreat all the way back to Frieda’s farmhouse, where, after having his pride thoroughly crushed, he finally accepts defeat and opts to call for backup from the New Hyperion State.

Chazik and Babe travel to an old, dilapidated knight outpost where they find the old man. The old man reveals the true nature of the mountain: a dumping ground for what the New Hyperion State deems as trash. Chazik is told to run away with the magic stone, foiling Dendara’s plan, but he refuses.

The shaman is kidnapped, held hostage at the peak of the mountain. Chazik confronts Dendara one final time and challenges her to a final duel before the entire rebellion. The knight is overpowered again; the rebel leader makes her wish; but with the help of all those he has met on his journey, he connects to the power of the mountain and is able to defeat her.

Having won the battle, Chazik decides not to return to the New Hyperion State, understanding that he’s been unofficially exiled. His ideals are still ironclad, though, and he establishes an order of Rural Knights dedicated to protecting the mountain.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Where do you write the map of your story

0 Upvotes

Hello guys i was about to start my first ever novel, when I sat to write the first chapter, i realised I have to write what the first arc and other arc is, what the whole story is, everything about the characters their powers, their background, etc etc. and other details that I must have when writing so I don't forget or write something different down the line. I was wondering where to write all this stuff, like in a book, MS word or something other docs app ? So I came here to ask where you (most likely experienced) guys write this stuff and how, like is there a way to keep a record of all this. Or do you guys even do something like this or just start writing the novel directly.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Untitled [Sci-Fi, 4438]

3 Upvotes

Edit: 4438 characters

Introduction to my story - looking for advice

Been trying to figure out how to introduce a story I've been worldbuilding for a while. Grammar/punctuation might be off. Apologies for that. Mobile might kill the formatting too.

Curious what people think/feedback.

--

A young man in baggy clothes was sitting on the roof of a house. He didn’t trust the slanted roof tiles; multiple times that day he’d barely avoided slipping off the buildings, so he had decided that sitting just by the chimney flues was probably the safest option. He shuddered - the chill of the wind at first light wheezed past his ears, and with a futile attempt to protect from the cold, he pulled his hat further down to try and cover them. Rubbing his hands didn’t help either, he’d had this pair of gloves just a week and they were already starting to come apart.

A hand suddenly gripped the drainpipe, and the man threw a rope down the roof, spooling off the reel on his backpack. Hauling him up, his partner carefully made his way up to the chimney, hopped up onto the chimneystack and sighed heavily.

"Baz, that Mother was a right bitch.”

Baz's eyebrows raised slightly. “Not often I hear you cuss Sam, what's up?”

“Oh she was just one of those old bats who looks down on workers like us”.

“Well. Can't blame them, I think. Mothers have been at their posts for so long they forget what it was like to be in our position.”

Sam pushed a ticket into Baz's hand. A lion’s roaring icon stared back at him from the paper, stamped in red ink. He took the card and clipped it to his belt.

“Sam, what does a red lion crest mean?”, he asked.

“The stamp alone being in ink means it’s a noble house, but a red roaring lion means it’s the Manses.”

“Not quite. The Manses have a red lion in side profile. This crest is for the Gautiers.” Sam’s face twisted into a grimace. He had heard tales of the Gautiers, a particularly snobby and elitist family, with no interest to parley with peons and the common rabble and were very expressive about it. He kicked against the chimney stack in disappointment. There were tales of the Manse maids sneaking a stale spiced pastry out to workers sometimes, so their jobs pulled a high price amongst the Cleaners.

They descended from the building, passed an open window, and Baz got a brief glimpse into the room. At the far end, a young woman in a black dress and white apron stoked a fire. Upon meeting his gaze, her eyebrows raised in surprise and she hurriedly left.

Sam couldn’t help but notice the dirty footprints he left behind on the tiles in the garden as they went down a hidden path in a hedge. When he had a moment to look back, he saw two maids sharing a bucket and a mop, both with tense faces and a hurried pace cleaning up the path they had left behind.

They descended down a ladder under a manhole and into a dark room. Baz walked over to a rail, where a small cylinder attached to a rail sat. He scribbled on the ticket and placed it inside. The cylinder immediately sped off across the railings and quickly out of sight.

“You wouldn’t have seen those while doing your training, but-”

“I do know what those are, they’re supply dockets, you just wrote down what supplies we need, and when we get to the Gautier service platform, they’ll be waiting.” Baz grunted in confirmation.

The wind was even worse down here, they were in an exposed area on the side of the district. Piping and gears, railings and frames stretched from side to side of a huge corridor. Sam tried not to peer over the side, because despite the obscuring smoke below them, he knew there was no floor. A light flickered at a reel of paper on the wall. Baz tugged at it and tore off a strip. He mumbled to himself.

“Next district shift in two weeks, Dellian Gala in three weeks, need staff. Please send applications to Control.” He looked up, “Nothing new for us to worry about”. He had put his application in a month ago, he didn’t want to be docked rations again.

As Sam was looking at the wall on the other side of the corridor, a hatch opened and someone yelled across to them. The wind picked up and took his words. Sam gestured to his ear, the man tried to yell a second time, but no luck. The hatch slammed shut and their silhouette could be spotted every so often as they ran off. Sam continued to watch.

"Do you know what that guy was saying?” he turned to Baz. To his surprise, Baz had vanished. He looked around and checked the ladder, maybe Baz had forgotten something. When he returned to the service station, Baz had reappeared, with a small, cupcake. He grinned at Sam.

“What, did you think I had forgotten what day it was? We have a bit of time before that Gautier job, lets go find something fun to do for your birthday”.


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Places I can bounce ideas / brainstorm with others?

16 Upvotes

I’ve been in the process of writing my first draft for a while and some of my major struggles personally is not feeling super confident in my ideas and struggling to “fill in the gaps” for the why and how behind some plot points. I’ve kept my writing private from friends and family but it’s meant I’m limited with people and places I can bounce ideas around and brainstorm and get inspiration from others.

I think it would be helpful for me to be able to ask “why do you think this might happen?” Or “how could i go from Scene A to Scene B?” with real people (not AI) to get inspiration. Does such a forum exist?

Online is preferred, for in person recs I’m London UK based.

TIA!


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Tempted by a dreamworld... difficulty executing a scene

3 Upvotes

I'm currently working on a draft of a fairy tale style novel in which a character undergoes a journey through a supernatural landscape, encountering various mythological and fantastical beings and creatures on her way through her quest. One of these figures is a witch reminiscent of Baba Yaga or Utgard-Loki from Slavic and Norse folklore. During her experience with the witch, the protagonist finds herself in a dream or mirror-world, which she must escape to remain on path. I'm having difficulty understanding and completing this sequence, and am curious if others have written scenes like this and how they worked.

The protagonist is a peasant girl who has been dirt-poor her entire life. In the mirror-world, she is a princess preparing to marry an emperor. At the moment she enters the mirror, she has no memory of her real life but only a vague sense that she has forgotten something. In order to overcome the challenge set by the witch, she needs to remember her true life and accept her true purpose depsite the hardship, and reject the temptation to remain in the mirror-world as an empress.

Aspects of this chapter that I'm really struggling with include:

\* The tone. The rest of the story is very ethereal and dreamy. There are few characters and the landscape is sparse, allowing for a lot of internal meandering. This chapter is set in a palace, with numerous characters and people all around. This makes it more difficult to "vibes" my way through writing, which is the tone of the rest of the book.

\* The setting. The "setpiece" for this chapter is more in line with high and epic fantasy than the rest of the book, as well as medieval history. It's more difficult to navigate when I need the setting to actually feel somewhat grounded in history (moreso than the rest of the book). I've done some research into medieval royal weddings, but a cursory amount of reading isn't enough. I'm leaning into not caring so much, and justifying that the setting is merely a projection of the protagonist's mind, not a real grounded setting.

\* The progression. Even within the mirror-world, figuring out exactly how the protagonist navigates the challenge and overcomes it is difficult. At what point does she begin to suspect something is wrong? At what point does she actively begin to seek a way out? What is the catalyst? I'm leaning towards her having a vague sense of "wrongness" throughout, culminating in her meeting her betrothed and consciously rejecting him. But even there, I feel there should be some build-up to her realization.

I wanted to lay out some of the challenges I'm having and hear if anyone else has ever written a scene like this, involving any kind of hallucination or dream that challenges a character to escape through personal revelation and self-actualization. I haven't encountered a lot of them, but I know they exist. One of my main inspirations for this scene is the ballroom sequence in The Labyrinth, in which Sarah has a vision of herself dancing with the Goblin King. That sequence isn't quite as involved, but does depict the protagonist retrieving her conscious awareness and determination to remain focused on her quest over indulging in a fantastical vision of herself in a "mirrored world".


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Question For My Story Question : How to avoid describing things too literally ?

1 Upvotes

I'm currently writing a fantasy novel, but I have one very annoying issue that I can't seem to get rid of.

English is my second language, so I naturally started my first draft in French. Since I'm broke and motivated to learn, I also decided to handle a large part of the translation into English myself.

However, I've run into a problem. I tend to be way too literal when translating descriptions of scenes, emotions, and feelings.

A lot of sentences that work perfectly well as poetic prose in French end up sounding... bland or overly technical when translated into English. They're just not particularly enjoyable to read. I think this is partly because French can be quite poetic on its own, even in its more straightforward forms. But even when I make a conscious effort, I struggle to keep the meaning and imagery of my sentences while making them pleasant to read in English.

I have tried reading both American and British fantasy novels, as well as translated versions of them, to compare the prose and learn how to adapt my sentences. But I haven't had much success. It's as if I lose all my creativity the moment I start writing in English.

I'm also worried about losing my authorial voice in the process. I still want my writing to feel like mine, even if I'm writing in another language.

Does anyone have any resources they could recommend to help me improve? Or perhaps some advice or examples?

I have a feeling that part of the problem is that I tend to visualize things quite heavily when I write. I guess it could also be because I write sci-fi.

But it's not necessarily a problem in French, English just seems a little less forgiving when it comes to translating that kind of imagery directly.

I feel like this is even more important to avoid in fantasy, where descriptions and atmosphere play such a big part in making the world feel magical. I don't just want to describe things as they are.

Any help would be greatly appreciated!


r/fantasywriters • • 1d ago

Brainstorming I NEED HELP NAMING CHARACTERS LAST NAMES

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

So basically the title says it all but I need some help figuring out last names. The finished characters names are:

Ezra Redwing, Rowan Blackwell, Maeve Roseblood (might change her last name), and Robin Redwing.

Robin and Ezra are siblings. Maeve is the devil and will be Robins girlfriend when robin dies. Rowan and Ezra are a couple/will become one I haven't decided yet. The characters that need last names are:

Patches is a non binary clown, and Ace/Jade (unsure of name but they're a shapeshifter so I'll probably make them gender fluid or non binary but most likely gender fluid) (Ace and Jade are the same person I just need to pick one of the two or a different name for them)

EDIT: Also another character is Pepper who is patches adopted sister/brother/sib (gender undecided) so they need a last name for when they find out about it.

Also this is unrelated but HAMILTON IS AMAZING AND IF YOU HAVEN'T SEEN IT YOU NEED TO WATCH OR LISTEN TO IT ⭐️🏳️‍⚧️⚧️🏳️‍🌈👩‍❤️‍💋‍👩👩‍❤️‍👩👨‍❤️‍👨👨‍❤️‍💋‍👨✌️💗

EDIT: This is a very LGBTQIA+ work in progress so if you have a problem with queer people don't bother giving an opinion ⬇️

edit I cant post without saying "I have tried" so there !!!


r/fantasywriters • • 2d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Snippets of "Lamplighters" [Heroic Fantasy, ~3800 words)

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

Mae g'ovannen friends,

After finishing my first draft and trying to start the second one, I've been gripped by utter writing paralysis. I second guess every letter and word I put to the page, and I struggle to just keep working. I figured getting some other eyes on it might assuage the feeling of being a complete hack haha.

The important contextual information is that my main character Djina is the victim of a terrible crime, and joins a martial sisterhood to seek justice against the wishes of her father and those in power where she comes from. The story started as a "writing as therapy"-thing, but now I feel very good about what I've managed to create... Yet, those feelings of "is this even anything?" remain. I've never written anything long-form or as a narrative before either; complete first timer.

* Looking for general feedback. How's the immersion? Prose? Flow? Would you want to read it? Do you want to know more about this world and story? The characters? If there's a consistent grammar problem I haven't picked up on, please tell me that too! English is my second language after all. But small typos I'll be able to clean up myself.

* I'm including three snippets: one from chapter 1 and two from chapter 7. There are 20 chapters in total

Thank you so much for any and all help and perspectives.