r/finishing • u/molard • 5h ago
Question Matching Stain Color
I have Diamond brand cabinets in my kitchen that were installed by the builder. These are Westburke in Buckskin color and I believe the wood is maple and birch. I custom built matching cabinets for a coffee bar, but I'm having trouble matching the stain. I've worked with Sherwin Williams over a week with four different trips and neither of their mixtures match (not even close).
I contacted the dealer that my builder used and another dealer in a nearby state. Neither dealer can tell me the details of the stain mix nor do they sell the stain other than touchup kits. I've also tried asking AI for a close formula, but that has failed also.
I understand that I won't match the color exactly, but I want close so it's not immediately noticeable. The attached photo shows my cabinets in the background. The left stain sample is the custom Minwax mix from Sherwin Williams, but it's too amber/yellow. The right sample is Minwax English Chesnutt (stain I had laying around) so everyone has a known color to reference.
Does anyone have a suggestion? I'm willing to mix my own stains or buy an off the shelf color and modify it. Thanks in advance!