I've sunk 1300+ hours into this game (please help)... over the years, I've helped many people with character builds and with all that experience, I wanted to contribute a more up-to-date analysis of the perks and traits in this game.
More importantly, I wanted to do so considering the fixes in YUP (Yukichigai Unoffical Patch, which is needed for the modern version of JSawyer) - And JSawyer (Game Director's balance mod, used my many many people on PC).
Most of the information around that I've seen really only considers the vanilla game, but let's be honest.. there's so many of us who DON'T play vanilla anymore, they at least use YUP. I haven't played Vanilla since the 500 hour mark, I only use JSawyer Ultimate. Many perks have been tweaked or have had bugged behavior/exploits removed.
Anyone that wants to TRY JSawyer or even YUP has to dig through the DOCS to find out all the things that have been fixed/adjusted. This is here to help with that.
What I am hoping is, this will help people with perk selection within the context of JSawyer and YUP.
In the year of 2026, I think it's healthy for the community to reevaluate things occasionally, even for an old game. Especially when the game is very often enjoyed as a modded experience by many long time fans like me.
You might be familiar with this old archived post regarding perks: reddit.com/r/fnv/comments/nskrdq/fallout_nv_perk_tier_list_complete_and_revised/
I have several disagreements and some other insights compared to this list, even when comparing perks to their Vanilla/bugged states. Additionally, I think ranking perks in a "tier list" is dated and weighing some over the other is often contextual, so I am sticking to a grading system instead.
Ranking general guidelines:
1 = Terrible, Never Take this
2 = Bad, Don't take this unless you have a specific reason.
3 = Decent, Usable and reasonable / has a useful application for a specific build
4 = Great, can be useful own it's own / is good for multiple builds
5 = Excellent, One of the best or most powerful / a defining perk for a build
0 = Dishonorable, Four Eyes & Here and Now! / the two worst possible things to take, you make your character worse!
Traits
Built to Destroy - 5/5 - Great for crit chance builds, 15% decay rate on weapons doesn't matter that much in the longrun.
Claustrophobia 1/5 - A lot of the time you don't notice this or you find out it's inconveniencing you slightly. It's not really worth the effort, use chems if you need to stat boost.
Early Bird - 2/5 - I don't recommend it for the same reasons as Clastrophobia, but it is slightly better.
Fast Shot - 5/5 - A great way to significantly improve your DPS as long as you are mindful of your weapon choices. Make use of strong semi-automatic weapons and use weapons with extremely low spread when you need to fight at longer ranges. Turns out 20% of 0.01 or 0.015 spread isn't very much.
Four Eyes - 0/5 - Roleplaying only, but really... don't even take it for that. It makes your character worse. -1 Permanent Perception hurts your character more that a temporary +2 PER bonus. The best use of PER in this game is for Perk Requirements, the temporary bonus does not consider this. The game "sees" your PER as 1 points less PERMANENTLY, this is WORSE for everything else besides the compass markers and a temporary +2 to PER skills per point. Don't take this, just wear glasses without it for style. Just like real life, needing glasses is only a drawback. For people who need to wear glasses, their PER score is worse than someone who doesn't need to wear them at all, regardless if the pair of glasses is on their face or not. I hope this really hits home how bad this is.
Good Natured - 4/5 - Really good since most characters only use one or two weapon skills, you get a lot of skill points back in exchange. This is better in JSawyer indirectly, since many perks that require multiple weapon skills have been fixed to require only one of the displayed skills.
Heavy Handed - 3/5 - This is good with certain weapons, Like Oh Baby! This is also good for explosive weapons focused characters, since explosives can't score a randomized critical hit. Increasing your melee damage can help you out if enemies get to close to you for you to blow them up.
Hoarder - 1/5 - Really bad, I don't think the bonus is worth the potential drawback. In JSawyer the values are changed to 15 + Carryweight at 75 units. It's still pretty bad.
Hot Blooded - 3/5 - Pretty reasonable for Melee/Unarmed builds in JSawyer, as the lower HP pool and 'healing over time only' will have you proc'ing this constantly as your HP pool goes up and down and allllll around while 10 people are shooting you with guns. -2 PER and -2 AGI don't matter to a pure melee character's combat ability at all.
Kamikaze - 2/5 - I think you should consider Action Boy/Girl instead of this. -2 DT and -15% DR isn't the worst, but in JSawyer some armors gain DR which means that drawback can apply more often than Vanilla (you can only get DR from perks/drugs in Vanilla).
Loose Cannon - 1/5 - If you throw grenades, you should really use VATS since you'll be way more accurate most of the time (and your target stops moving in VATS). Limiting your range feels bad, you'll notice it. You can use thrown bladed weapons with this, but it just makes them harder to use because of how they arc, just skip it unless you really just want to cause as much chaos as possible with little regard for anything else.
Logan's Loophole - 3/5 - I know it's crazy to see how much it's fallen in the context of JSawyer, but this limits you to level 21 as your level cap. This is still worth taking for a short playthrough, and you CAN technically swap it out in OWB. It has uses, but it's not quite unanimously the best trait anymore like in Vanilla. Laser weapons builds can't take Laser Commander, Melee Builds can't take Slayer, etc. You actually feel like you have a draw-back for taking it now.
Skilled - 4/5 - +5 Skill points to everything is pretty solid, experience isn't limited. You will level up slower, but this won't hold you back from reaching max level by any means. You can't exploit this trait in YUP or JSawyer so actually have to commit to it.
Small Frame - 3/5 - If you want an extra point of AGI, you can take this. It's not the worst, but I don't bother with it.
Trigger Disipline - 2/5 - Pretty much only useful for long-range VATS builds if you want to do that.
Wild Wasteland - ?/? - ?W??E?? A(?R??$%???E{{NO$$##T))A??L>ON?E
LEVEL 2 PERKS
Black Widow / Confirmed Bachelor - 3/5 - A classic. This is a fine perk to pick at level 2, Male Humans and Ghouls are common enemy types. Usually narrow damage bonuses aren't worth it, but this one is fine. Especially at Level 2 when your options are more limited. Solid for RP.
Cherchez La Femme / Lady Killer - 2/5 - Another Classic, the reverse of the previous two perks. In JSawyer, this is boosted to +15% since Males are more common opponents. This makes it a little stronger, but BW/CB is still more relevant. Still totally fine to take at this level. Solid for RP.
Friend of the Night - 1/5 - I don't find the low-light vision to be super helpful and I find the 'filter' to be more annoying that anything else. You really don't need this, but you can take it if your actual sight is bad I guess? In my opnion, if you want to be sneaky... use your pip boy light, shut it off when enemies are close, use VATS to help determine where your target is (whether you want to actually use VATS or not). Tactics make this perk pretty useless, these are all tactics any build can use.
Heave ho! - 2/5 - This perk only effects thrown weapons with YUP/JSawyer, as intended. It's bugged to effect all arc'd projectile weapons in Vanilla. This unfortunately makes it less effective for explosive builds, but if you want to make a "Throwing" build for fun or are using Mad Bomber, it's a must-pick.
Hunter - 1/5 - This is probably the worst crit-related perk in the game. The only two enemies this will really matter against are Yao Guai and Lakelurks. The rest of the enemies this effects don't have that much HP to begin with or have a critical EMP weakness like Cyberdogs. (Mole Rats, Dogs, Coyotes, etc. Bighorners/Brahmin are passive). Don't take this.
Intense Training - 2/5 - This is only as good as you need it to be. If your build needs an extra point, take it. If not, skip it.
In Shining Armor - 2/5 - This actually works in YUP/JSawyer so you can take it if you plan on using Power Armor or some form of Metal Armor (Like the JSawyer exclusive Commando Armor). Energy damage isn't quite as common as 'ballistic' damage and a lot of people prefer Light Armor for critical builds. Still, +7 DT against most robot projectiles and factions that use energy weapons isn't the worst if you want to be 'Tank-like'. JSawyer adds Damage Resistance to heavier armor to make this playstyle a little more viable. I'd still skip it over other durability perks most of the time though.
Junk Rounds - 1/5 - Terrible, Even with it being buffed in JSawyer. Junk rounds are not worth using a perk slot for.
Light Touch - 5/5 - Excellent, a great perk for critical chance builds. Adds a flat 5% without considering the weapon's critical modifer, this makes it very strong from full auto weapons even with a low LCK score, but any crit build still wants this.
Old World Gourmet - 1/5 - I'm gonna be honest, I've only taken this on my "EATER" build that was also a Cannibal. It's not really practical, but it can be okay for RP.
Rapid Reload - 3/5 - A reasonable increase to reload speed. Most builds that use any reloading weapons can get some use out of it, But single-shot weapons like the Grenade Rifle, Gauss Rifle and the Sawed-off Shotgun get a pretty significant boost in DPS. Take this if you use low clip sized weapons. It's possible to reload-cancel by swapping weapons, so you don't even ever have to reload a weapon if you don't want to. However, if you use multiple ammo types, this becomes hard to use since the ammo type 'resets' to default. So how 'good' this is, really really depends. If you have an AGI of 8 or higher, you might reload fast enough as-is to your preferences. If your reloading FEELS too slow to you, take it. It's not a bad choice.
Retention - 2/5 - This one isn't very good unless you got all on on the Magazine perks with Logan's Loophole. All the other ones are more useful on their own. A lot of the time when you use a magazine you're using it for one task/check any ways.
Swift Learner - 1/5 - Terrible, XP isn't limited and there is a level cap. Taking this will make your character weaker at max level, even if you reach it faster.
LEVEL 4 PERKS
Cannibal - 1/5 - This is for Roleplaying only, it's not practical at all. Perfect filler perk for an ultra evil character or theme build. Them's Good Eating is much better if you want something like this.
Comprehension - 4/5 - Now this is a good magazine perk, +20 to a skill temporarily is extremely powerful for progressing quests and passing a variety of skill checks. Keep Speech at 20, use Naughty Nightwear, Party Mentants and a Meeting people. Suddenly you have 50+ Speech and can pass half the checks in the game. It's more powerful than it appears and this is also a must-pick for critical chance builds as well, since Police Stories get boosted to +10% critical chance.
Educated - 2/5 - This one has been a hot-topic for debate, but I think it lands somewhere in the middle in terms of usefulness. If you aren't a competition, you probably aren't finding all the skill books and not reaching the level cap of 35.. This can potentially allow you to reach skill ranks quicker. But I think this depends, again. I don't really think you need to cap out all the skills in this game, especially if you use Comprehension. I always skip it, but I don't think it's horrible or a complete waste.
Entomologist - 2/5 - It's a narrow damage perk. I wouldn't really take this under most circumstances, but 50% damage is a lot. Radscorpions/Giant Radscorpions are the tankiest thing this perk effects, the remaining enemies don't really have natural armor or large HP pools, so keep that in mind.
Rad Child - 3/5 - Since there is no penalty for RADS until 400 in JSawyer, this is actually an a great passive heal for outside of combat or solid regen if you're willing to take RAD penalties. The worst part of this perk is that you need 70 Survival, which I think is a tall ask, since I find that it's one of the least useful skills on average. But at least it stops at 70, Which is perfect for using a Comprehension magazine to reach 90 for all campfire recipes. If you plan on wanting that crafting pool, this should be absolutely considered. However, I've played this game for 1000+ hours before ever taking this perk and I never thought I needed it.
Run 'n Gun - 3/5 - Pretty decent, but I've found myself being able to skip it and not really notice that much of a difference. If you're kitting the enemy, you're probably close enough to the enemy to hit most of your shots. It's still passable and can be useful for running with SMGs or an inaccurate weapon like the 12.7mm Pistol.
Travel Light - 5/5 - Fantastic for Light Armor, always take this if you use it. Being able to run faster than any other human/ghoul enemy is useful, it's worth the 45 points of Survival for this.
Bloody Mess - 2/5 - Not worth it unless you have nothing else to pick. Okay as a filler perk, for a character with a low crit chance I guess.
Demolition Expert - 5/5 - Must-pick for explosive builds, It's been adjusted to boost damage a bit less in JSawyer, but also increases the blast radius a bit. I think this is a fine trade-off and it makes taking Splash Damage not needed.
Ferocious Loyalty - 3/5 - This is one of the few significant buffs you can give to a companion, so it's okay for that. If you're a 10 CHA build that lets Boone do all the fighting, this is actually fine. I don't play with companions, so this is always a skip from me. In JSawyer/YUP, CHA is fixed to also increase companion DT, as intended. So this effect becomes even better as a result since DT and DR are different types of damage mitigations.
Fortune Finder - 1/5 - I've never taken this perk. I think that speaks volumes from a 1300+ hour player.
Gunslinger - 3/5 - Great for VATS builds. Otherwise skip it. I don't think VATS builds are all that great in FNV, but if you build it, you need this.
Hand Loader - 5 / 5 - This is the best way to increase your damage as a Guns user. Always take this. Hand Loader ammo is worth using on some of the stronger enemy types and can sometimes let you kill things in one shot when a normal bullet would take two. Once you have a ton of money in the late game, you can pretty much always use Hand Loader ammo. If you are a Shotgun focused build, that might be the only time I consider skipping it, because the hand Loader ammo uses less pellets and is anti-synergy with And Stay Back. Shotgun Surgeon fixes the issue a with using buckshot ammo, so 3/0 and 4/0 Hand loader Ammo isn't worth it most of the time.
Lead Belly - 1/5 - This gains extra utility in JSawyer since it removes the negative effects of raw food. It's still a 1/5, dealing with small amounts of radiation should not be a problem for anyone.
Mad Bomber - 3/5 - This is a very 'fun to use' perk and gives you a way to create extremely cheap and effective explosive weapons. I would likely take this for any PURE explosives build. If you use them as a supplement to your main combat style, I'd skip it in favor of explosive 'launcher' weapons.
Shotgun Surgeon - 3/5 - If you are a shotgun build that intends to use And Stay Back, this is a must-pick. Skippable if you use shotguns with pulse slugs for utility or just don't use them as a primary weapon.
The Professional - 2/5 - This only effects Sneak Attack Criticals in YUP/JSawyer as intended, instead of effecting all critical hits in Vanilla. This is only good if you happen to be a one-handed gunslinger that's also a stealth build, or like to open up fights with a sneak attack. Personally I use a Sniper Rifle as a sneaky type and I imagine many others also do, so the usefulness of this perk takes a big hit. Real professionals have standards, and they almost always use precise two-handed weapons.
Toughness - 3/5 - One of the best filler perks. If you don't know what to take, take Toughness. Otherwise skip it until you reach the point of not knowing what to take.
Vigilant Recycler - 5 / 5 - Hand Loader, but for Energy Weapons ammo. Always take it as a Energy Weapons build for pretty much the same reasons as Hand Loader.
LEVEL 8 PERKS
Commando - 3/5 - Same deal as Gunslinger. Take it if you're a ranged VATS build.
Cowboy - 4 / 5 - +20% Damage is still just fine instead of 25% (JSawyer Adjustment). This perk includes some higher tier weapons and always applies. This is a significant enough boost in damage to be worth it. Only skip it if you aren't using anything it applies to.
Grunt - 4/5 - Same thing as it's counterpart, Cowboy, just with different weapons. If you're gonna use something on this list, it's a good pick. This perk got a few new additions like the Red Glare in JSaywer, so this only adds to it's viability.
Home on the Range - 1/5 - RP only perk, this is not worth sleeping at campfires for, there's enough beds.
Living Anatomy - 1/5 - Half the bonus of the Gender Killer perks isn't worth it by the time you can take this perk. Getting to see some additional enemy stats isn't worth it either. The game shows you if you aren't penetrating a target's armor (RED SHIELD MARKER), you don't really need to know the specific number, you just switch to something until you don't see that anymore.
Pack Rat - 5/5 - This is the best perk related to carryweight for JSawyer, Carry more ammo, more doctor's bags, stimpacks, weapon repair kits, etc. Barter has the second most dialogue checks in the game AND it nets you more money as gravy. Use Barter and take this, you won't regret it.
Quick Draw - 3/5 - This is a very good perk if you reload cancel. "My Heaven & Hell" build swaps between A Light Shining in Darkness and & Lil Devil with Fast Shot to great effect with 10 AGI and this perk. Still, outside of reload canceling faster animations matter in a real-time game, so this is never a bad filler perk. You WILL draw a weapon (unless you're fists only?) or need to switch weapons in the middle of a fight. A split second can matter!
Rad Resistance - 1/5 - Dealing with Radiation the regular ways is good enough as-is. Carry a Radiation suit if you really want to, but I don't bother. Just use Rad-X and Radaway.
Scrounger - 1/5 - I don't think you'll end up starved for ammo enough to justify ever wanting this.
Sneering Imperialist - 2/5 - A narrow damage boost perk, Skip unless you want it for RP.
Stonewall - 4/5 - Really good in JSawyer as it grants +10 DT instead of +5. This is actually better than Toughness, especially for a Melee build. Some of the most intense amounts of burst damage dealt by enemies is melee damage. Knockdown immunity isn't bad either.
Strong Back - 3/5 - It grants less carry weight than Vanilla, but it's still decent (Other items have had weight adjustments to make this fair). Another decent filler perk if you need one, but I think Pack Rat should be considered first.
Super Slam! - 5/5 - Most Melee/Unarmed Builds want this, extremely powerful and can make some fights a joke. If you're a full auto Melee Build (Like Chainsaws) then skip it since it doesn't apply, take a fire axe/blade of the west for Mauler instead. This perk is fixed to have Melee OR Unarmed as a requirement in JSawyer, so you get better skill diversity on top of it.
Terrifying Presence - 2/5 - Roleplaying only, and a very good one at that. It gets an extra point for pure badassery even if it technically sucks.
Tribal Wisdom - 1/5 - It's very narrow in what it does, even if it might be a little better than Cannibal. You are immune to poison after OWB if you stay Heartless, so this can be even worse than what the text says.
LEVEL 10 PERKS
And Stay Back - 5/5 - Super Slam! for Shotguns, this is excellent to use with buckshot ammo paired with Shotgun Surgeon, as each pellet has a 10% chance of knockdown, meaning it's even more reliable than Super Slam! If you want to bully the entire game, this is an option for that.
Animal Friend - 2/5 - CHA builds probably want this, but I don't really recommend it. 60% of enemies in that category aren't threatening, and the 'assist' you can get is niche at best.
Fight the Power - 2/5 - It's like the 'narrow damage' perks, but a lil' different. This one grants +5% crit chance and +2 DT. I really wish those bonuses where +5 DT and +10% crit chance, then it might be a consideration. As it is, I think it's just 'okay' as an RP perk for crit builds. Not worth it otherwise unless you take it right before the Battle of Hoover Dam.
Finesse - 4/5 - A hidden +5 LCK exclusively for crit chance. Crit builds really want this, but I don't think it's a bad pick up for any build really.
Here and Now - 0/5 - This is the only '0' perk on this list. This makes your character weaker at max level with absolutely no benefit inbetween. This should be deleted from the game. Experince isn't limited, there is a level cap.
Math Wrath - 3/5 - This is good for a VATS build, but I would say the accuracy related ones should be prioritized before this.
Miss Fortune - 2/5 - This is fine for a VATS build, but Miss Fortune isn't predictable in her behavior, so I don't recommend it. If you're gonna take this, note that Mysterious Stranger and this share the same 'proc', You're only rolling a 10% chance once for either Miss Fortune OR Mysterious Stranger to show up, so keep that in mind. I think Stranger is better, imo.
Mister Sandman - 1/5 - Silently killing someone in their sleep is not something you really find yourself doing very often. This is pretty much an RP only perk, as you can just use weapons and silencers/stealth boys instead.
Mysterious Stranger - 3/5 - I'll give this one a little more credit because unlike Miss Fortune, Stranger is predictable in what he does. He just deals huge damage and vanishes. A 10% chance for him to deal massive damage when using VATS is a reasonable effect for a VATS focused character. But I honestly haven't taken this perk since 2013.
Nerd Rage! - 2/5 - There's a chance this saves your ass, but there's also a chance for this to do absolutely nothing. Imagine get clocked at 22% HP and just dying, needing to be at 20% or less is very risky and I'm not sure it's worth it in Jsawyer with a lower HP pool. I could see this being a gimmick to enable low STR characters to gain a massive carry weight bonus, but again.. this perk is in an odd place in what it does.
Night Person - 1/5 - Not useful at all really. I'd rather take Intense Training for a permanent increase rather than timed temporary ones.
Plasma Spaz - 4/5 - JSawyer adds an extra +20% attack speed bonus in addition to lowered VATS costs, making this much more useful for non VATS builds. +20% Attack speed is no joke, add Rushing Water and Fast Shot for a total Plasma Seizure in your enemy's faces. It's also good in conjunction with Math Wrath if you go the VATS route.
LEVEL 12 PERKS
Alertness - 1/5 - Bad for the same reasons as Night Person.
Fast Metabolism - 1/5 - Not worth a perk slot, even if it sounds good on paper, espcially since Chemist will double your stimpack healing in comparison.
Heavyweight - 3/5 - This is good if you carry multiple weapons this appiles to, otherwise take any of the other carry weight perks instead.
Hit the Deck - 3/5 - +25 DT against explosives isn't bad. If you happen to be an explosives build, this is worth take just for your own Splash damage. Not sure if I would invest into 70 Explosives just to take this though.
Hobbler - 2/5 - This would be a 3/5 but it requires an awful 7 PER to take it. Pretty much every strong build wants exactly 6 PER or 1 (Minimum) PER, depending on if you are investing into critical chance/VATS. Shooting legs is actually a decent tactic against fast moving enemies, If you happen to have 7 PER, this is worth a look.
Ghastly Scavenger - 1/5 - Roleplaying only. You might as well go fully crazy with Cannibal and take this too, if that's your aim.
Life Giver - 2/5 - A bit more reasonable in JSawyer as the HP pool is significantly reduced. Take this as Toughness Rank III if you need another filler perk.
Long Haul - 1/5 - It's a funny gimmick, but you really don't need this.
Piercing Strike - 5/5 - All melee attacks turn into Armor Piercing rounds, a must pick for melee builds. Even better in JSawyer since you can meet the requirements with Melee OR Unarmed.
Pyromaniac - 4/5 - If you use the weapons it effects, it's a must-pick. Otherwise skip it. +50% damage is too strong to ignore.
Robotics Expert - 2/5 - Of the narrow damage dealing perks, this is one of the better ones, as it gives an interesting way to combat robotic enemies in addition to a damage bonus. I usually skip this one, but any Scientist-like character will like this one for RP.
Silent Running - 3/5 - Makes you better at stealth, take this if you want to be a sneaky type. 50 Sneak is a good skill level to stop at (for sneaking in improved hold-out weapons into places), so if you happen to do that, you can also pick this perk up to become a pseudo-stealth build.
Sniper - 3/5 - A must-pick for VATS builds and it's not bad for any build that occasionally uses it. But I would skip it unless you're spec'd into VATS.
Splash Damage - 2/5 - This one loses out on usefulness in JSawyer, since your blast Radius increases with Demolition Expert. You're likely to injure yourself repeatedly with all ranks of Demo Expert + this, so I don't recommend it unless you really want the biggest boom possible.
Unstoppable Force - 1/5 - Not worth it. The worst part of the enemy blocking is the recoil, not the lack of damage and a lot of the time blocking doesn't even come up in combat. I can't recommend this even for a dedicated melee/unarmed build.
LEVEL 14 PERKS
Adamantium Skeleton - 2/5 - Some of the other durability related perks are better than this, but it don't think it's total garbage. I guess this can be 'Toughness IV' but I doubt you want 4 filler perks on a single character.
Center of Mass - 4/5 - This perk is really good, but not for the reason you're thinking. For Melee, Explosives and Unarmed characters, this is almost always bonus damage in VATS, since VATS attacks almost always hit the torso coincidentally (it doesn't matter what the 'target' is in VATS, only contact with the torso). The only problem is this perk requires Guns 70. So if you are willing to get to Guns 70, this is actually great for all your special attacks in VATS or for using Grenades and the like. Otherwise this is understandably skippable due to the mismatch with how this perk functions best, and it's required skill.
Chemist - 5/5 - Excellent, this is like Fast Metabolism with much more benefits. All chems, healing items and magazines have their durations (and effects if they are restorative) doubled.
Jury Rigging - 5/5 - I know this one has been a hot debate for a long time, but I really do this it is one of the best utility perks. The amount of convenience you get from this perk changes the entire game and allows you to flip the economy on it's head. If you take this and repair expensive weapons with cheap ones, you will never run out of money if you keep adventuring. Armor repairs are suddenly become almost free. Thing is, Repair is already a very reasonable skill to focus on, so it's 90 Repair requirement doesn't feel restrictive, especially to those who already want Hand Loader (which requires 70 Repair). You can skip it if you want, but why would you want to?
Light Step - 1/5 - This is worthless to veterans and sometimes helpful to beginners. Take that as you will, I never take this.
Purifier - 3/5 - Abomination-typed enemies are some of the strongest in the game, making this easily the best 'narrow damage' perk if you happen to be Melee/Unarmed. Always a consideration if you happen to fight face to face with these things.
LEVEL 16 PERKS
Action Boy/Action Girl - 3/5 - This gives you a lot more Action Points than raising your AGI stat, so if you want that for a VATS build, this is a fine choice.
Better Criticals - 5/5 - One of only reasons to put points into PER in this game, this is an absolute staple of all critical chance builds, the big pay off.
Chem Resistant - 1/5 - Addiction is RNG (random number generation) any ways, taking this doesn't mean you won't get addicted and if you do get addicted with this perk you will feel bad. Don't bother, see a doctor when it happens. In my last play-through I was getting addicted to Med-X, Psycho and Slasher constantly, that was one of the best characters I've ever made, it didn't matter.
Meltdown - 4/5 - Great for Energy Weapons characters if you want to use both Laser and Plasma weapons. In JSawyer, this effect only applies to Plasma weapons, giving you much more control over how it's used. In Vanilla, I found it to be too dangerous for friendly fire at times, but limiting it's use makes using Plasma weapons more interesting.
Tag! - 1/5 - Not worth a single levels worth of skill points, Tagging a skill does nothing special. This is only slightly better than Here and Now. This is absolutely terrible.
Weapon Handling - 2/5 - I think you should decide where you want your STR score to end up based on the weapons you want to use, however, if you really want a low STR character to work, this can help you out. But remember, most characters end up with +3 STR by the end of the game (Implants, OWB), so make sure you really need this if you decide to take it.
LEVEL 18 PERKS
Computer Whiz - 1/5 - Don't take this, just give up after 3 attempts and you'll never lock yourself out of a terminal. This kind of thing shouldn't exist in a game where you can save at any time.
Concentrated Fire 3/5 - A pretty reasonable accuracy perk for VATS builds. This is better in JSawyer, since you need 60 Guns OR 60 Energy Weapons, not both.
Infiltrator - 1/5 - This is bad for the same reasons as Computer Whiz.
Paralyzing Palm - 5/5 - A slam dunk if you're an Unarmed focused build. If this procs, your target is dead, 30 seconds is a long time in a fight.
Walker Instinct - 1/5 - Terrible for the same reasons as Alertness and Night Person.
LEVEL 20 PERKS
Atomic! - 2/5 - Since the Coyote Steak Exploit doesn't work, you can't use this 'on demand' like you can in Vanilla. It doesn't always work, but when it does, it is arguably very strong. Still, I don't think you really need to take it, but it can be fun to use for some of the late game areas like Courier's Mile.
Explorer - 1/5 - This only good exactly once when you don't know all the map locations. It's absolutely skippable, especially in this day and age with so much information at our finger tips.
Eye For an Eye - 3/5 - This is actually decent for Melee focused characters, as fixing your limbs in the middle of combat with a doctor's bag is often not worth it since you might easily get crippled again. Melee Characters get hit, shot, and smacked all the time. End fights faster when you get crippled, then heal up after. This is not a 'build around me' perk and many people who view it that way are quick to dismiss it. Take this with your next Melee only build, you won't regret it.
Grim Reaper's Sprint - 3/5 - Significantly worse than it was in Fallout 3, but it was extremely broken. Now this is just 'okay' for VATS builds.
Mile in Their Shoes - 1/5 - Extremely narrow and the bonuses are not good.
Ninja - 5/5 - This is significantly better in YUP/JSawyer compared to Vanilla. This grants a flat +15% crit chance, rather than multiplying your current crit chance by 1.15 (which is VERY different and much worse). Basically every melee build wants this unless you're an "Oh Baby" low luck build w/ Heavy Handed.
Solar Powered - 1/5 - This is like Rad Child and something like Walker Instinct smashed together. This is worse than Rad Child and not much better than all the other temporary SPECIAL boosting perks in certain conditions. Can't recommend this one.
Them's Good Eatin' - 2/5 - This is like if Cannibal and Old World Gourmet was actually useable/practical. It unfortunately has it's discovery chance reduced from 50% to 15% in JSawyer making it much less potent, a very large fall form grace for it.
LEVEL 22 PERKS
Laser Commander 5/5 - Perfect for the Energy weapons characters, and it effects your crit chance the same way as Light Touch does (it's static and unaffected by critical modifers), meaning this can turn Full-Auto weapons into crit machines. Still worth taking for almost any Energy weapons characters, the +15% damage unconditionally is excellent gravy.
Nuka Chemist - 2/5 - You take this to pair with Mad-Bomber for Nuka Grenades, otherwise skip it.
Spray and Pray - 3/5 - If you use companions, this is fine. It's pretty easy for them to die by friendly fire, least for me. That's why I don't bother with them usually, unless it's for questing.
Irradiated Beauty - 1/5 - Embarrassingly bad for this high level, dealing with Rads shouldn't be hard at level 22+.
Voracious Reader - 4/5 - Very good for critical chance builds, as having a way to infinitely renew your copies of Police Stories is very powerful. Using Comprehension, you can sort of become a 'bard-like' character with this perk by utilizing magazines. This requires INT 7, make sure you plan accordingly for it.
LEVEL 24 PERKS
- Please note that some perks have level reduction from here on for JSawyer's Level cap of 35.
Broad Daylight - 2/5 - It's better than Friend of the Night, but I still don't think it's worth it.
Certified Tech - 2/5 - Another narrow damage perk, but it sort of has Scrounger built in. Take Robotics Expert before this one, I think it's better. It also requires 90 Science in JSawyer, so it's another hurdle to jump through to take it.
Slayer - 5/5 - Extra attack speed is always good outside of VATS. Notably, it only effects the wind-up time of full auto melee weapons, but it will boost the potential DPS to every other type of melee weapon significantly. Requires 7 AGI, so make sure you plan for it as a Melee/Unarmed character.
LEVEL 26 PERKS
Nerves of Steel - 3/5 - Okay for VATS builds or those who like using VATS occasionally, but have a low AGI score/no other synergy.
Lessons Learned - 1/5 - It's bad for the same reasons as Swift Learner.
Tunnel Runner - 3/5 - Not bad at all for a stealth build. Sneaking faster is nice QoL, but it's not a must-have.
LEVEL 28 PERKS
Roughin' It - 1/5 - Well Rested 'sometimes' isn't worth a perk and especially not one that requires 100 Survival.
Rad Absorption - 1/5 - Insultingly bad for how high level it is, Removing Rads isn't a problem at level 28+.
LEVEL 30 PERKS
Burden to Bear - 3/5 - This is Strong Back II, take it if you need it.
Implant GRX - 5/5 - Turbo is insanely strong, getting free access to it is never bad. Worth the END 8 requirement, plus you probably want that score for more new Vegas Medical Clinic Implants.
LEVEL 34 PERKS
Ain't Like That Now - 4/5 - The best one for VATS builds, or for stacking attack speed buffs. Plasma weapons become insane because of Plasma Spaz's changes in combination with Fast Shot + Rushing Water. You can use a War Club's power attack repeatedly to move insanely fast as well.
Just Lucky I'm Alive - 5/5 - The first part of this perk isn't helpful at all, but the second part is literally just Better Criticals II. Take this one if you're a crit build, you won't regret it.
Thought You Died - 3/5 - This is the best one for pure Explosives builds, as it gives a flat damage bonus and additional HP. Most other characters would rather have the other two choices, but it's still reasonable.
Thanks for reading, please discuss! Remember, this is my opinion if you have some insight regarding perks with the context of YUP/JSawyer, please leave comment!