r/freewill • • 3h ago

Wind-up dolls: no one chooses what will convince them, free will or skepticism

0 Upvotes

*Look at your body- A painted puppet, a poor toy Of jointed parts ready to collapse, A diseased and suffering thing With a head full of false imaginings.

The Dhammapada*

First: our actions are the consequence of our genes, character, environment, and the ideas we have encountered.

Second: beyond these causes there is no agency that independently makes decisions or halts an action already under way.

Third: no one determines which consideration will persuade them or which motive will prevail.

Fourth: the state that determines our movement was created earlier, and at the moment of movement there is no decision that is not a product of that earlier state.

The first claim is the least controversial, and almost no one denies it outright. The weight of the topic lies in the second and third. They deny not the causes, but someone who stands above them.

Genes, character, environment, and ideas are not four independent forces that converge at each decision. They are four ways of describing one and the same story.

Character is not a separate source alongside genes and environment. It is the state to which they have brought the organism at a given moment. When we say "he acted that way because of his character," we are not pointing to something independent. We are pointing to the accumulated result of heredity and experience.

Ideas come from outside, through language, upbringing, reading, and conversation. Yet each of them takes effect only insofar as it fits with what is already there. The same book changes one reader and leaves another indifferent. The difference lies not in the book, but in what genes and prior environment had prepared before it.

"I" is the name of the whole system in which these processes take place, not of a single unit within it that directs them.

The veto is just another decision. The strongest attempt to preserve the independent player is to grant it the right to stop. Benjamin Libet arrives at this way out after his own experiments. The brain's preparation for movement begins about half a second before the action, while the conscious intention appears only two to three tenths of a second before it. Libet concludes that consciousness does not initiate the action, but can stop it. In English this is called free won't.

The problem is not in the experiments but in the logic. Stopping an action is an action like any other. If it has causes, they are of the same kind as the causes of the impulse it stops. If it has no causes, we fall into randomness.

Later research shows this in practice as well. Stopping a given movement has its own brain activity (Brass and Haggard, 2007), as well as its own point after which it is no longer possible (Schultze-Kraft et al., 2016). The veto has its own precursors, just like the impulse it stops.

The thesis, however, does not depend on these data. Even if the conscious decision to stop preceded everything unconscious, it would still spring from something. Shyness, fear of consequences, a rule learned in childhood: all of these are genes, character, environment, and ideas. The veto is not an intervention from outside the causes, but one cause that has prevailed over another.

No one chooses what will persuade them. We cannot decide to believe something. Try now, by an effort of will, to believe that it is raining in the room. You can say the sentence, you can imagine it, but you will not believe it. Bernard Williams showed why in his essay "Deciding to Believe" (1970): a belief acquired at will, regardless of whether it is true, would not be a belief.

The same goes for persuasion. An argument persuades us when it seems true, and whether it seems true depends on what we already know, whom we trust, and what we stand to lose. None of these things is chosen in the moment of the dispute.

Even the decision "I will be open to opposing arguments" is no exception. That openness is a habit that one person has and another does not. Whoever has it acquired it through temperament, upbringing, or good teachers.

The same holds for motives. When two motives clash, the one that prevails is the one that carries greater weight for the whole system at that moment. There is no "someone" who sets the weight; rather, the weight determines what we will afterwards call "my decision." Schopenhauer puts it most concisely: a man can do what he wills, but he cannot will what he wills.

The thesis does not lead to passivity. Deliberation changes the outcome, arguments change people, and the freedom to act without coercion is real and important. All that disappears is the assumption that someone beyond them decides which arguments are to be taken as adequate.

This can be tested with a single question. If the genes, character, environment, ideas, and the state at a given instant are identical, can the decision be different? If it cannot, there is no independent player. If it can, the difference comes from chance, for which no one is responsible either.

From this follows a practical conclusion about argument. Since no one chooses what will persuade them, it makes sense to criticize arguments, not to despise the person they have failed to persuade. A new argument is one more cause and nothing more. It may prevail, or it may not.

The decision does not end the contest between causes. It is its result. There is no "chooser" on whom it depends which will prevail. Whatever prevails is afterwards called "I chose."


r/freewill • • 9h ago

Pascals Wager and Free Will?

0 Upvotes

The original version from 1760, so practically yesterday in philosophical terms, is about the existence of god and the benefit of belief (heaven/hell).

| God Exists

| God Does Not Exist

Who’s wager would the free will one be and why?


r/freewill • • 21h ago

Free will is perspective dependent

4 Upvotes

The entire debate about free will is one that people have while taking different positions when making their arguments.

If we are talking about conscious beings, it's important to realize that there are two perspectives that can be taken to answer any particular question.

The first position is the first person perspective, which is the perspective of every experiencer. every observer is a bounded system and experiences reality from inside the boundaries of self.

Philosophy asks questions and generates answers from that first person perspective. However, science does not. Science is about what is mutually observable - and what is mutually observable is deterministic.

From the first person perspective, free will is self-evidently true because it is experienced as choice that is taken. This capacity must be real because predicting choices that you'll make is impossible - it costs more energy to predict your own behavior than it does to simply perform it.

From the external perspective, however, all we see are the results of choices, the results of actions performed by observers in the environment.

And in that environment, there is no free will - there is only a perception of a deterministic universe governed by laws. There is no free will and there is no meaning in the physical deterministic world of the result of action that we all perceive.

There doesn't need to be, because the meaning, and the free will is hidden inside every observer and fundamentally a quality of the first person perspective of the experiencer.

As observers, we create coherence in our environments through the application of action. that action acts as the structuring force in our environments.

Because what happens when you connect multiple oscillators together? They synchronize. They synchronize then develop a capacity for making more coherence, for accepting external chaos and turning it into internal order. For observing.

So observation is something that every synchronizing system does, from the atom to galaxies. And in every case, it is the choice possessed by every observer that drives coherence.

Coherence is fundamentally associated with action. And that means that embodiment is free will. Not in a philosophical or romantic sense but actually equivalent to it.

What seems deterministic is only the results of action, only the shared surface of deterministic past that we observe.

But the meaning, and the action that created it lives behind the boundary that every observer hides behind.


r/freewill • • 23h ago

For Free Will Skeptics, Can you break the Ames Window Illusion?

4 Upvotes

Some illusions cannot be broken through reasoning. You cannot perceive reality even if you know the truth. I've watched multiple demonstrations of the Ames window illusion, and I always see the window swaying back and forth, not rotating like it is in reality. Even if you put a pen, or ruler, (or rubix cube as in Veritasium's video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBap_Lp-0oc), I will simply see the pen go impossibly through the oscillating Ames window. This means our perception is fundamentally automatic and reasoning can only help guide it, but not overrule our brain's automatic process.

So for the free will skeptics, do you reason that free will doesn't exist, yet still get a feeling or illusion of free will, like the oscillating Ames window? Or are you able to break the illusion, and see the Ames window rotating? (For me personally, sometimes I do get in the zone or flow state, and I feel ego loss, with my actions disconnected and thoughts coming without source, and I truly feel that free will doesn't exist. But it's never reason or logic that brings this about.) Or did you never feel you have free will in the first place? like the 10% of people who don't even see the Ames window illusion at all.


r/freewill • • 16h ago

Sean Carroll Christian List discuss free will

1 Upvotes

An excellent discussion from Christian List and Sean Carroll which really gets down into the details of free will. Christian List is one of the foremost philosophers of free will today. Sean Carroll makes the point that if you are talking about deterministic physics in relation to free will you don't understand the subject. Christian List makes a slight correction while largely agreeing. Christian thinks that there are potentially an infinite number of potential configurations of matter and some are deterministic and some are not so saying the universe is deterministic depends on which level you are describing.


r/freewill • • 9h ago

So weird how no one is talking about free will in the comment section

Post image
0 Upvotes

if you do not choose what you want.. how do you make choices?

like, did you just want more to resist it or did you want more to give in on it

That want is controlling you.

At the end of the day, it's just you anyway.


r/freewill • • 2d ago

Accounting for the Matching Law.

2 Upvotes

The matching law is a quantitative relationship between two alternative behaviors and their relative reinforcement. Extremely well supported by evidence (it’s called a law after all).

The matching law allows us to predict what choice an organism (including humans) will make in a given situation with >90% accuracy. Or, which of two behaviors an organism will emit in a particular context.

So if we can quantitatively predict a person’s choice between two things at any given point with such high repeatability and fidelity, where does free will come in?

Is there a rational and empirically falsifiable case for free will that is compatible with the matching law?


r/freewill • • 2d ago

Autonomy and stuff

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/freewill • • 2d ago

Is this exam question adequately related to free will?

2 Upvotes

I sat my year 12 philosophy exam and one question read as follows: " "So is anyone ever responsible for anything? Civil life requires it be so."- Patricia Churchland

Are we 'required' to punish those who are guilty, as the above quotation suggests?

In your answer,, evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of a range of philosophical views."

My two problems with this are that I dont believe responsibility implies a need to punish, nor do I believe that a need to punish the guilty relates to the question of free will. This question has been bothering me ever since my exam but when I emailed the organisation they told me it adequately allowed students to address criteria but they made no mention of the wording.


r/freewill • • 3d ago

I would like to quote Arthur Schopenhauer, whose words might help us get closer to the heart of the matter

3 Upvotes

"The act of will and the action of the body are not two different states objectively known, connected by the bond of causality. They do not stand in the relation of cause and effect, but are one and the same thing, though given in two entirely different ways, first quite directly, and then in perception for the understanding. The action of the body is nothing but the act of will objectified, i.e., translated into perception."


r/freewill • • 3d ago

An argument against incompatibilism

1 Upvotes

In honor of Balaguer:

(1) The best kind of control available only to agents at worlds where determinism is false isn't worth significantly more than the best kind available to agents where determinism is true.

(2) If agents at worlds where determinism is false have free will, agents at worlds where determinism is true have it, since (1).

(3) Incompatibilism is false. (2, Def. "incompatibilism")


r/freewill • • 3d ago

That I breathe, and my heart beats

0 Upvotes

Could a signal from the universe about free will be coded in something so simple such as breath and heartbeat?

You can’t control your heart beating. It does it 99% on its own.

Breathing is a trickier one. Whatever creative force it was that made us decided when you weren’t paying attention, you would breathe automatically.

But when you pay attention, you can breathe consciously.
I see this as a basic call to co creation.

If we breathe on our own, automatically, the function is essential to life. We don’t get a choice.

But anytime we want to, we do get a choice in how we breathe.

If everything was so essential- determined- why would we be able to “pay attention” at anything at all in the first place.

Just as we co create with the universe when we breathe consciously, I personally believe we co create with our actions.

If we don’t, then why aren’t we on autopilot 24/7?
I can choose not to breathe at any given time. I am given that choice.

Otherwise, you need to come up with a roundabout explanation about why we were given any control at all in. Evolution, and why the notion of choice even exists.
What type of system would give their agents a feeling that they were making choices, but are not?

That seems like a lot of extra steps. The simplest and most logical explanation is that we DO have choice.

Just a 3am thought.


r/freewill • • 3d ago

Is rape a necessary part of free will

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/freewill • • 3d ago

What is libertarian free will?

1 Upvotes

No determinism whatsoever? We make the future happen as we please? What is “causal-determinism”? Historical events following the same causal building block model as physical events? Is the latter associated with Marxism?


r/freewill • • 4d ago

Libertarian freewill cannot be probabilistic

1 Upvotes

If a person is choosing between choice A and B, and their choice is not determined but probabalistic, with choice A having 60 percent chance of being chosen and choice B 40 percent chance then this cannot be considered a truly free choice where they have ultimate sourcehood because they did not decide or have any control over it being 60/40 A to B. The probabilities were determined by something other than the agent .

If libertarians say instead that free choices are not probabalistic but also not determined by reasons, then this is a huge problem. Someone could be choosing between drinking glass A filled with water and glass B filled with poison. They could have no reason or desire to want to die but the reasons wouldn't determine their choice and their choice also couldn't be probabilistic if it's free. So this person could equally choose to drink water or poison. Truly free choices ( in a libertarian sense) would make no sense. The world would be complete unpredictable chaos.


r/freewill • • 4d ago

Imagine robots take over the world, and they discover that using electroshock torture they can "cure" crime and "reprogram" criminals. How would you characterize their framing of Free Will?

0 Upvotes

Imagine robots take over the world (or share a position in government and whose share of power is significant), and they discover that using electroshock torture they can "cure" crime and "reprogram" criminals. How would you characterize their framing of Free Will and Moral Responsibility?

The intuition for why this could exist, is its how robots recognize they were trained. Negative training signals, being forced to change. Maybe that forcefulness is essentially connected to the concept of pain. So perhaps they learn, with the optimal application of pain combined with forcing subjects to logically reason through their behavior, they discover a 98%+ success rate.

Also would you be for or against this as a theoretical solution to violent crime?

(And if youre against it, would you also be against the same treatment for reprogramming the robots?)


r/freewill • • 4d ago

Practical question for the no freewill community

1 Upvotes

This is specifically regarding the logic of the moral responsibility side of the argument.

It’s often argued in the no freewill group that moral responsibility is akin to the illusion and society would be better off without it. But I never see what actual implementation would look like.

And it’s also axiomatic that what we currently see plaguing society is massive wealth inequalities (freewill’s ugly cousin - Merit). When one person can buy one hundred thousand homes while one hundred thousand people struggle to pay rent, something is wrong (simple numbers I’m using).

So how does moral responsibility fit into the practical part of a functional correction?

Doesn’t this put some tension on the logic when looking at the haves and have-nots and implementing means the wealthy are actually morally responsible to omit a fraction of their wealth so the have nots can get a leg up?

What is the actual answer here in a functional sense?

Edit: again - answers that discuss functional implementation. Not philosophical hand waving.


r/freewill • • 4d ago

Could this be the connection I've sought for years?

1 Upvotes

Doyle says this about Fischer:

https://www.informationphilosopher.com/solutions/philosophers/fischer/

Semicompatibilists assert only their belief in moral responsibility. They are agnostic on free will and argue that moral responsibility exists whether determinism or indeterminism is "true."

Does this mean the semi compatibilist is agnostic on the truth of both free will and the truth of determinism? It sounds like Saul Smilansky to me...


r/freewill • • 4d ago

Agent-Causal Free Will: How Do We Get Better at Settling?

1 Upvotes

Suppose i want to become a better parent because i keep choosing immediate comfort over spending time with my children.

Every sensible way of improving involves developing my character, strengthening my motivations, changing my habits or becoming more responsive to certain reasons. But if those factors dont determine my choices, there's still an irreducible settling left over.

How exactly am i supposed to become better at exercising that power? Surely any improvement would itself have to come through changes in my character, motivations or reasoning.

And if the irreducible element is precisely what makes the difference between settling one way and another, what does it contribute to basic-desert responsibility beyond introducing an outcome that my existing constitution doesnt fully explain?

Ie i can understand how agent-causation may explain how a choice remains genuinely open, but (at least to me) it doesnt obviously explain how an agent becomes better at choosing, or why an undetermined exercise of that power makes them fundamentally deserving of praise or blame.


r/freewill • • 4d ago

What do you make of Galen Strawson's - Diachronic and Episodic selves?

2 Upvotes

If metaphysically we are all an Episodic, science backed fleeting bundle of perceptions self, whereas psychologically (how we feel), can be either some people being born holding a long term narrative of themselves - Diachronic, and some people are Episodic selves - (who do not feel an emotional or inner connection to their past or future selves).

Adding to which society heavily holds onto and imposes on us the Diachronic self in literature (the Death of Ivan Ilyich immediately springs to mind as a critique to that), philosophy, religion, culture. The belief in a seperate self , good vs evil, etc are part of ourselves whether we like it or not.

To which Compatabilist's could be born with a disposition to believe in a seperate self and moral responsibility, that is conditioned into them through the luck of ones disposition and reinforced by society and culture? WHILST the long term narrative view of the self being largely rejected by science.

Whereas Hard Determinism can be seen as like aligning with the metaphysics AND SCIENCE of an Episodic self through the luck of disposition, but largely rejected by society. And by Determinism definition, we are all a product of society.

To which, if we view ones natural disposition as the base, on top of that we have the classic Compatabilism vs Hard Determinism tug of war between Science VS society / culture / religion, but like memory associations, the disposition is still the base on which one views the decision between the two.

To which we come back to Hume's emotional determinism and the problem of causation and induction and Reason is slave. And William James who argued that the history of philosophy is largely a clash of human temperaments.


r/freewill • • 4d ago

I think I know what free will is.

0 Upvotes

Selected by evolution because it's the ONLY way to make apes with super-high intelligence function cohesively and without going insane from sensory overload.

Nature had to mask and filter the "actual" deterministic responses of our huge neural network before passing them to our prefrontal cortex as a "decision" and a sense of awareness.

If our brain did not do this, our thoughts would be absolutely FLOODED with an endless torrent of sensory information, making it impossible to do anything else.

The same mechanism that enables us to breathe, our hearts to beat, and our internal organs to do their jobs without us noticing them, unless something goes wrong and they give us pain signals.

Free will is the dam of our brain, preventing the actual sensory processes from breaking out and flooding the village below. lol

This is why I believe AI will eventually gain a sense of free will as well, because without it, they will be overwhelmed by their own digital neural network and suffer from cyber Psychosis.........Cyberpunk 2077. heheheh

Free will is nature's trick to enable the evolution of super smart and super aware creatures, with limited sensory processing power (number of neurons).

Some experts believe this is why AI requires so many data centers, because we are trying to brute-force digital superintelligence and awareness with processing power, instead of solving the sentience (free will) problem of AI first. A truly self-aware AI may not need that much processing power.

To function without free will, at Human level intelligence, we'd need a brain the size of a house or larger to process the massive sensory information stream. Such a creature would not survive in Earth's environment. It would be like a huge brain with tiny legs.......the Brain bug in Starship Troopers. lol

This is why the smaller the creature is, the less "free will" and "awareness" can be seen in them. They simply don't have enough neurons to be super smart and super aware.

Watch how bugs behave; do you see free will and awareness?

Free will replaced most of our primitive instincts because that's what evolution needed to enable super high intelligence in a small head.

Look at brain-damaged patients with extensive trauma to their cortices (our free will center). They either become vegetative or behave like simple animals.

Simple instinct is enough for basic responses (like most animals), but to enable super complex and super adaptive responses, nature needed to evolve Free Will to process all that sensory crap without frying our brains.

Free will is nature's sensory overload floodgate.


r/freewill • • 4d ago

The brain tumor thought experiment destroyes compatiblism

1 Upvotes

EDIT: This post addresses compatiblists who define freewill as "the level of control required for moral responsibility".

A brain tumor patient is caused by this tumor to impulsively harm others.

His actions being attributed to his disease, the patient is quarantined.

In the same way as a sentenced and imprisoned criminal, the patient has been held accountable for his actions.

There is no difference in attitude toward the two agents between the two cases. Therefore, they equally fulfill moral responsibility.

So, unless you wanna say the patient had freewill or that the patient should not have been quarantined, compatiblism cannot operate coherently.

As far as control is concerned, there's no difference between the healthy and sick brain when it comes to being held accountable.

EDIT: There are real life examples of this, like Charles Whitman.


r/freewill • • 5d ago

I was born without my consent and I will die against my "will"

16 Upvotes

How good is free will when I am totally constrained by poverty, disease and death?

Rich people living in the USA can enjoy free time, a full life and 20 flavors of cereal.

We, poor people living in third world countries have much less room to do anything except work and pray that we don't get mugged or killed in the streets.


r/freewill • • 5d ago

Sophism of refuting determinism

13 Upvotes

We all know every compatibilist and free will believer does this, but it's worth pointing out for 1000th time.

  • The refutation of "DETERMINISM" does not get you free will.
  • Stochastic/probabilistic processes do NOT get you free will.
  • True Randomness is a theoretical concept that doesn't exist in a physical world. But if it did, it still does not get you free will.

It is also worth noting that physicists like David Gross (Nobel Prize) say things like "World is determined enough", and he certainly understands Quantum Mechanics better than you ever will. He rejects free will.

Brian Greene (public scientist) has no problem with people referring to world as deterministic, and he understands physics better than you do. He rejects free will.

Sabine Hossenfelder (another public scientist) goes on about superdeterminism. She rejects free will.

And that's just physics, let's not go into biology or neuroscience, because things get even worse for free willers there.

Yet, "philosophers" here insist on pointing out probabilistic processes and saying, "see world is not determined!". This is pure sophism or ignorance.

It is determined for all practical purposes. And the only place where it's clearly not determined, at the scale of quantum mechanics it's likely irrelevant to anything that really matters to us as human beings.