r/fusion • • 6h ago

Fusion Power by 2028? Helion’s Microsoft Deal Meets the Physics

Thumbnail technology.org
5 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 6h ago

Cost is the monkey, not plasma physics!

Thumbnail
x.company
0 Upvotes

https://x.company/blog/posts/tackle-the-monkey-first/

https://x.company/blog/posts/three-things-i-learned-from-turning-seawater-into-fuel/

I thought I would share these two articles from X (aka Google X labs). I mentioned them in another post.

Astro Teller’s rule: if you want a monkey reciting Shakespeare on a pedestal, train the monkey first. Building the pedestal looks like progress, but it was never the hard part.

This is the perspective from Astro Teller, CEO of X the 'Moonshot lab' division of alphabet.. where Waymo was developed. It is a useful perspective of how long-shot projects can be developed with an aim for commercial viability.... while being clear eyed about the viability and 'go/no-go' decision making for a project.. especially around cost.

The core lesson to learn is that you should focus your efforts on the most difficult-to-solve problem of a system.. and defer the more tractable problems for later. Not the other way around. "tackle the monkey first". For cost-sensitive technologies, that monkey is often cost. When it is, recognize it and work on the cost problem with clear eyed cost analysis. Dont just focus on the fundamental physics when the problem is cost.

The example here is project Foghorn... a project where engineers were trying to make liquid fuel by extracting carbon from seawater and turning it into fuel. While they had a workable chemistry/physics path, they did not see a way to make it cost effective. They quickly identified cost as the 'monkey' in the project, and spent half of their resources on cost modeling, until they had enough clarity to determine if the cost targets could be met. When they determined cost targets would not be met, they abandoned the approach because they did not want to waste resources further developing a prototype for something that was not commercially viable. The technical prototype was the 'pedestal'...

This is a lesson the fusion community needs to learn.

In my opinion, many of the companies claiming near term commercial viability in fusion are focusing on the pedestal (plasma physics), when the monkey is the cost challenge of a commercial system, complete with its neutron handling, breeding, heat exchangers, cryo, magnets, indirect costs, etc....

To win this market, a cost target of ~$50/MWh must be achieved. To even enter the market, <$100/MWh is needed. This is CFS' statement, and I agree with it.

I have seen no published, independently reviewable technoeconomic analysis from any of the main tokamak/stellarator companies that shows a path to the target.

I am a physicist so I love to look at physics... but even I recognize that the monkey is not plasma physics.

The monkey is cost.. and no one is showing a path.


r/fusion • • 4h ago

Industry leaders want Canada to choose whether it builds its own fusion future or buys it from abroad ("Theranos-type risk" mentioned)

Thumbnail
betakit.com
2 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 4h ago

Spotify Billionaire Ek works with secretive UK-based Europa Fusion Industries, founded by former Head of Machine Learning at Pacific Fusion

Thumbnail
bloomberg.com
3 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 9h ago

Fusion power is about to start working, says Bob Mumgaard

Thumbnail economist.com
42 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 3h ago

Nuclear fusion supply chain

3 Upvotes

Are there fusion-specific supply chain bottlenecks (as opposed to general grid/power electronics supply constraints that would affect any power plant)? Wondering both in terms of current experimental development as well as if, in the future, we have a viable fusion process and want to scale it commercially.


r/fusion • • 5h ago

Mike Ford of PPPL joins Thea Energy as Senior Vice President of Nuclear Engineering

Thumbnail
linkedin.com
2 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 5h ago

Tokamak Energy performs the first magnet coil test for STEP: 77K "sub-scale" model TF coil

Thumbnail x.com
4 Upvotes

r/fusion • • 10h ago

Realta Fusion to receive up to $15M in state tax credits

Thumbnail
wpr.org
3 Upvotes