Hi everyone,
I've been troubleshooting a very strange PC power-management issue for several days, and I'm hoping someone with experience in motherboard power circuitry, ACPI, or PSU troubleshooting might have some ideas.
The problem started immediately after a technician replaced my GPU and PSU and cleaned the inside of my PC. Everything worked normally before that.
I've tried multiple operating systems, clean Windows installations, different power configurations, and hardware isolation steps without finding the cause.
PC specifications
\- Motherboard: Gigabyte Z590 UD AC, BIOS F6 (2021)
\- CPU: Intel Core i7-11700KF
\- GPU: Gigabyte Radeon RX 9070 Gaming OC 16 GB (previously RTX 3060 Ti)
\- PSU: Enermax Revolution III 850W Gold (previously GameMax)
\- RAM: 32 GB DDR4 3200 MHz (XMP)
\- OS: Windows 11 Home 25H2
\- Storage: 256 GB SATA SSD (original Windows), 512 GB SK hynix NVMe (second Windows installation), 1 TB HDD
The problem
Whenever I shut down Windows, the PC completes the shutdown process normally. The fans stop, all lights go out, and approximately 0.1–1 second later, the PC turns itself back on, without anyone touching anything.
It's not just a Windows restart command. The PC physically powers off momentarily before starting again.
Sleep has the same issue. The PC enters S3 sleep, the fans stop, and it immediately wakes itself up.
Both issues are intermittent. Occasionally the PC shuts down successfully, but most attempts result in it powering itself back on.
I've attached a video showing this behavior.
Troubleshooting already performed
Windows and software tests
\- Normal Windows 11 shutdown — fails
\- "shutdown /s /t 0" — fails
\- Shutdown from Windows login screen — fails
\- Windows Recovery Environment → Turn off your PC — fails
\- Windows 11 installation USB → "wpeutil shutdown" — fails
\- Windows 10 installation USB → "wpeutil shutdown" — fails
\- Completely fresh Windows 11 Home installation on a separate 512 GB NVMe SSD — still fails
\- Disabled hibernation and Fast Startup using "powercfg /h off" — no improvement
\- Removed old NVIDIA drivers using DDU before installing AMD drivers — no improvement
\- Temporarily disabled device wake permissions — no improvement
\- Checked "powercfg /waketimers" and "/requests" — no active wake timers or requests
\- "powercfg /lastwake" generally reports an unknown source or no recorded source
The fresh Windows 11 installation uses a different AMD driver version from my original installation, but reproduces the same issue.
BIOS tests
\- Loaded BIOS Optimized Defaults — no improvement
\- "AC BACK = Always Off"
\- "Resume by Alarm = Disabled"
\- "Power On By Keyboard = Disabled"
\- "Power On By Mouse = Disabled"
\- "Soft-Off by PWR-BTTN = Instant-Off"
\- Temporarily enabled ErP — no improvement
\- Restored ErP to Disabled afterward
I haven't updated the BIOS yet. The board is still on F6 from 2021.
Hardware and peripheral tests
\- Disconnected USB peripherals — still happens
\- Disconnected Ethernet — still happens
\- Temporarily disabled Wi-Fi — still happens
\- Tried HDMI instead of DisplayPort — no improvement
\- Different DisplayPort cables and monitor — no improvement
\- Tried different external PSU power cables — no improvement
\- Bypassed the power strip and connected directly to the wall — initially seemed fixed, but the issue returned
The technician may have removed the front panel while cleaning the intake fans, although I don't know whether the Power-button wiring was touched.
The really strange part: Ubuntu works perfectly
I created an Ubuntu 26.04.1 LTS live USB and booted into Try Ubuntu without installing it.
I performed repeated shutdown and sleep tests.
Ubuntu shutdown: 6/6 successful.
Using:
"sudo systemctl poweroff -i"
The computer shuts down fully and stays off. I even repeated the test without removing the USB stick, and it still shut down successfully.
Ubuntu S3 sleep: 5+ successful attempts.
"cat /sys/power/mem_sleep" reports:
"s2idle \[deep\]"
Using:
"sudo systemctl suspend -i"
The PC enters sleep, remains asleep for over 60 seconds, and resumes normally when I press the Power button.
No unexpected wake-ups or restarts.
This is what I find so confusing: Windows 10 PE, Windows 11 PE, and two separate Windows 11 installations reproduce the problem, while Ubuntu handles both S3 sleep and S5 shutdown correctly.
Windows Event Viewer findings
A detailed event-log investigation showed:
\- Clean Windows shutdowns followed by fresh kernel boots, rather than ordinary software restarts.
\- S3 resumes occurring shortly after sleep entry, mostly with "Wake Source: Unknown".
\- Some Kernel-Power 41 events with Power-button timestamps, although these may be related to manual troubleshooting.
\- At least one Intel Wi-Fi-triggered S3 wake, but the immediate-wake problem also occurs when networking is disabled.
What hasn't been tested
\- Physically disconnecting the case "PWR_SW" connector and substituting the Reset switch.
\- Testing another known-good PSU with its own cables.
\- Inspecting motherboard power-button signaling and standby-power circuitry.
\- Updating the motherboard BIOS.
\- Performing a completely isolated Windows installation with all other drives disconnected.
Post has been made with ai's help because it can explain better what we have tried so far, the only remaining thing would be a full on reinstall of windows on my C: drive, but given we have already installed it on a separate disk, and it still has this behaviour i am not sure what to do anymore
UPDATE — I found a reproducible pattern involving AC power. Possible PSU standby-power or motherboard wake issue.
I made a significant discovery after further testing.
If I completely disconnect AC power before starting the PC, the next Windows shutdown succeeds. If I leave AC connected afterward, the next shutdown causes the PC to power itself back on.
Here's the exact sequence:
- With the PC off, I switch the PSU OFF, unplug the AC cable, wait approximately 5 seconds, reconnect AC, and switch the PSU back ON.
- I power on the PC and boot directly into the Windows 11 installation USB (WinPE).
- I open Command Prompt using Shift + F10 and execute "wpeutil shutdown".
- The PC shuts down completely and stays off.
- I manually power it on again WITHOUT switching off the PSU or disconnecting AC.
- I boot into the same Windows 11 USB environment and execute "wpeutil shutdown" again.
- The fans stop, but the PC immediately powers itself back on.
Repeating the AC-disconnection sequence restores the successful first shutdown.
I've reproduced this pattern multiple times, including on my clean Windows 11 installation on a separate NVMe SSD.
Ubuntu Live still behaves differently: six successful shutdowns and more than five successful S3 sleep/resume cycles.
The PSU is a recently installed Enermax Revolution III 850W Gold. The technician also suspects the PSU, although we haven't verified that it's defective.