r/github • • 16h ago

Discussion Title: GitHub keeps asking for 2FA code despite password reset – recovery codes not accepted and stuck in reconfiguration loop

I'm having a frustrating issue with my GitHub account and would appreciate some help.

Here's what happened:

  1. I forgot my GitHub 2FA recovery codes.
  2. I was still logged in on multiple devices initially.
  3. I didn't remember my GitHub password, so I reset it successfully.
  4. However, GitHub continued asking for a six-digit 2FA authentication code.
  5. I have an old downloaded "github-recovery-codes.txt" file containing recovery codes in the correct 10-character format, but I haven't been able to use them.
  6. When I select More options, the only option I see is Reconfigure 2FA on this account.
  7. This takes me into a loop. I never get an option to begin account recovery.
  8. I also have a passkey listed in my GitHub security settings, but attempting passkey sign-in redirects me back to the 2FA page.
  9. Now, during the reconfiguration process, GitHub displays:

"Verify your recently configured two-factor authentication method. Enter the verification code."

It asks for a six-digit code, not a recovery code.

My questions:

- Is GitHub asking me to verify a newly configured authenticator app?

- If I don't have access to that authenticator, is there a way to cancel the reconfiguration and return to the original recovery process?

- Why does the 2FA recovery interface only show the reconfiguration option?

- Is there any legitimate way to recover my account without the original authenticator or valid recovery codes?

I have important personal projects and repositories on this account, so I really want to preserve it rather than create a new account.

I'd appreciate advice from anyone who has experienced this particular GitHub 2FA recovery loop.

I will not share my recovery codes, passwords, QR codes, or setup keys publicly.

1 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by