r/GoingToSpain • u/TheRealBuckShrimp • 3h ago
Housing Some thoughts about the Spain housing crisis from a frequent traveler
“Here we go” you’re probably thinking. Background is I love Spain and don’t want to be a part of the problem. Some people will tell me the only way to do that is to stay out, only stay in hotels, or, if I stay long term, only work at a local Spanish company so I can’t “out compete” locals when it comes to rent.
For the time being I’m staying home, so hopefully that avoids making anything worse. (Though I’m sure some business owners who enjoyed my spending money with them might disagree.)
I’ll say as well that Spain’s approach to immigration seems directionally more sensible than that of the US. Here, immigrants have spurred our economy to new heights, yet we seem hell-bent on shooting ourselves in the foot by prohibiting them, and our economy is suffering for it. In the US they’re demonized as contributing to housing prices when their contribution is a rounding error, whereas in Spain tourism and immigration by foreigners with money has contributed appreciably to the housing shortage.
For fun, I decided to do some research and see, if I were king of the world, or at least in the hypothetical in which Spain’s leaders had the very bad idea of asking me for advice, what I’d say.
Build more housing.
There’s the reputation that this didn’t work, because of the construction boom. And the 2021 census found 3.84 million homes “empty”.
I’d push back against this via two avenues.
First, geography: banco de españa’s 2024 annual report showed only around 400k of Spain’s vacant houses were nearby cities with more than 250k people. And the comparisons are stark: the area with the most total dwellings per 100 resident households was ávila, with 243. By comparison, Madrid, Barcelona, and las palmas, 3 of the hardest-hit by the housing shortage, have 118, 116, and 115, respectively.
TLDR: the bubble homes were mostly built far away from the people who need them.
Second, the recent trend lines are clear: in 2025 Spain added close to 240k households, and built only 92k homes. Between ‘21-‘25, segun the banco, there’s a cumulative construction gap of 750k between new homes and new households.
TLDR: the trend lines are widening the gap as the rate of home construction falls farther and farther behind household formation.
“But even if they built new housing, landlords would just rent it to foreigners with more buying power.”
Which is why I have a modest proposal: tax the living crap out of us. Impose a tax so high it’s as difficult for us as a local to afford relative to buying power. If landlords earned no more renting to foreigners, who move frequently and often have no provable local income than to locals, who have stability and verifiable incomes, that might shift the balance. That, together with new construction, could potentially break the price increases.
There are several logistic challenges to this.
What if someone is a traveling nurse earning a local wage? Should they have to pay the wealthy foreigner tax?
No. People could apply for “gold cards” for certain approved visits.
What’s more, levying the charge based on use and location of apartments would be easier to enforce and possibly more fair than targeting foreigners specifically. Charge a percentage of rent on each temporary stay in an entire apartment in a “distressed area” (like the city center in Malaga or my beloved Born).
Owners could claim one primary residence and get an exemption by proving they live there more than six months out of the year.
Those are just some ideas.
Btw I’ve reviewed the rules and think this post is de acuerdo with them, but mods can feel free to nuke it if I’ve somehow run afoul.
PS if you’re going to downvote I’d love a comment about what you disagree about. Same in the opposite direction for upvotes.