r/govfire • • 17h ago

FEDERAL PSA for Open Season: on 39 FEHB plans, Self Plus One costs more than Self and Family for 2027

11 Upvotes

Links first:

Disclosure: I built it and run FERS-Ready. The FEHB tool is the free part.

What the tool does. Everyone compares FEHB plans on the biweekly premium, which is the number that tells you the least. This ranks plans on the total for a year: premium, plus what you'd expect to pay out of pocket, minus any HSA or HRA money the plan puts in. You pick:

  • your state, coverage (Self Only, Self Plus One, Self and Family) and whether you're an employee or a retiree
  • how much care you expect (a healthy year, a typical one, managing a condition, worst case), or add your own: a monthly prescription, weekly therapy, an out-of-network provider
  • your current plan, so every other plan shows what it would save or cost you vs. yours, and what changed since 2026

It also counts the tax you save on your own HSA contributions, handles plans that cap one person's costs below the family max, and lets you filter by provider network.

New this week, and the reason for the PSA: when you pick Self Plus One, the tool now catches plans where Self and Family is cheaper, prices them at the lower rate, and tags them "Self & Family saves $X/yr." Someone using the tool asked for it after noticing they kept flipping between the two settings to see the real order.

The PSA. For 2027, 39 of the 118 FEHB plan options charge more for Self Plus One than for Self and Family. On the worst ones the gap is $1,984 a year.

You're allowed to enroll Self and Family with only one family member. OPM says it directly on its 2027 premiums page: "Enrollees who wish to cover one eligible family member are free to elect either the Self and Family..." enrollment or Self Plus One.

On all 39 of these plans the 2027 deductible and out-of-pocket max are the same for both enrollment types, and HSA/HRA deposits aren't lower on Self and Family. So for a two-person household on one of these plans, Self Plus One is the same coverage for more money.

The extra cost is the same dollar amount for employees and annuitants. Kaiser Washington High, for example: employees pay $76.29 more per paycheck for Self Plus One ($500.13 vs $423.84), retirees pay $165.30 more per month ($1,083.62 vs $918.32). Both come to $1,984 a year.

The 39 plans (sorted by how much extra Self Plus One costs; each links to the plan's page):

PlanWhereSelf Plus One codeSelf and Family codeExtra per year for Self Plus One
Kaiser Washington, HighID, WA543542$1,984
Kaiser Fresno, HighCANZ3NZ2$1,984
Kaiser Northern California, HighCA593592$1,984
Kaiser Mid-Atlantic, HighDC, MD, VAE33E32$1,984
Altius (Aetna Health of Utah), StandardID, UT, WYDK6DK5$1,631
Aetna HealthFund CDHPAL, AR, DC, FL, GA, LA, MD, NC, TN, VA, WVF53F52$1,586
Aetna HealthFund CDHPIA, ID, IL, KY, MN, MS, MT, ND, NE, OR, PA, WYH43H42$1,572
Aetna HealthFund CDHPAZ, CO, KS, MI, MO, NM, NV, SD, UT, WAG53G52$1,558
Altius (Aetna Health of Utah), HighID, UT, WY9K39K2$1,552
Kaiser Northern California, StandardCA596595$1,548
Aetna HealthFund CDHPCT, DE, MA, ME, NH, NJ, NY, RI, VTEP3EP2$1,531
Aetna HealthFund CDHPAK, CA, HI, IN, OH, OK, SC, TX, WIJS3JS2$1,530
Aetna Open Access (Capital Region), HighDC, MD, VAJN3JN2$1,497
Aetna Value PlanAK, CA, HI, IN, OH, OK, SC, TX, WIJS6JS5$1,470
Aetna Open Access, BasicNJJR6JR5$1,399
Aetna HealthFund HDHPAll 50 states + DC226225$1,389
Aetna Open Access, BasicDE, NJ, PAP36P35$1,382
Aetna Open Access, BasicNYJC6JC5$1,379
Aetna Open Access, HighDE, NJ, PAP33P32$1,346
Aetna Open Access, HighNYJC3JC2$1,338
Aetna Open Access, HighNJJR3JR2$1,252
Aetna Value PlanAZ, CO, KS, MI, MO, NM, NV, SD, UT, WAG56G55$1,237
Altius (Aetna Health of Utah), HDHPID, UT, WY9K69K5$1,218
Foreign Service Benefit Plan, HighNationwide (eligibility limited)403402$1,214
Aetna Value PlanAL, AR, DC, FL, GA, LA, MD, NC, TN, VA, WVF56F55$1,176
Kaiser Southern California, HighCA623622$1,128
Aetna Value PlanIA, ID, IL, KY, MN, MS, MT, ND, NE, OR, PA, WYH46H45$1,120
MHBP, StandardNationwide456455$1,092
Aetna HMO, HighCA2X32X2$1,062
Aetna Value PlanCT, DE, MA, ME, NH, NJ, NY, RI, VTEP6EP5$1,031
Presbyterian, Standard (Central)NMPS6PS5$870
Kaiser Northwest, HighOR, WA573572$699
Kaiser Georgia, HighGAF83F82$671
Presbyterian, Wellness (Central)NMPS3PS2$653
Presbyterian, High (Central)NMP23P22$648
Panama Canal Area Benefit PlanNationwide (eligibility limited)433432$522
Geisinger, StandardPAGG6GG5$310
Baylor Scott & White, StandardTXA86A85$288
Baylor Scott & White, StandardTXP86P85$163

Few things to know before you switch:

  • Self and Family covers all of your eligible family members. If you and your spouse are the only ones, nothing changes about who's covered.
  • Foreign Service Benefit Plan and Panama Canal Area Benefit Plan have their own eligibility rules, so they're only an option if you already qualify.
  • To switch, enroll in the plan's Self and Family code during Open Season (Nov 9 to Dec 14). Employees do it through their agency's benefits system, retirees through OPM Retirement Services Online.
  • These are 2027 rates. The inversion isn't guaranteed to stay, so check again next Open Season.

Check your own plan in about a minute: open the comparison tool, pick your state and Self Plus One, and any plan with this pricing shows the tag and the Self Plus One price it replaced. Premiums are from OPM's 2027 rate tables; if you spot one that doesn't match, tell me and I'll fix it.