r/harrypotter • u/Walk_Strict • 8h ago
Discussion Looking at the trios OWL grades, I think we don’t appreciate just how skilled and talented Harry is
It’s kind of funny that Harry genuinely got an Outstandind for Defense Against the Dark Arts, and actually beat Hermione in OWLs for that class. But I feel like a strong case could be made that while Hermione was great in academics, Harry was more powerful and talented with magic.
The thing is Hermione does well because she’s disciplined, works hard, and applies herself to the best of her abilities. Harry has struggled with spells before, but when he actually does master them, he really masters them well. During the Triwizard tournament Hermione spent all night teaching Harry the summoning charm. It was mentioned that Harry actually struggled with it. But within a night Harry finally mastered it, and then after the first task, Professor Flitwick praised Harry during class about how amazing his summoning charm was. From what I remember I think accio is supposedly way more difficult to use on objects much farther away. But Harry managed to use the summoning charm under intense levels of pressure with battling a dragon, and doing it all in front of so many people, and he was still able to get his fireboat from all the way inside the castle, which again from a larger distance made it more difficult. When not long ago Harry struggled to even do it in the first place.
And don’t even get me started on the Patronus Charm. This especially proves just how talented he is, because even Amelia Bones, a high ranking Ministry official, was deeply impressed with the fact that Harry, a 15 year old kid, was able to master a full formed Patronus. And he fully mastered it at just 13 years old too. Meanwhile even Hermione at 15 struggled to do it and said it was the hardest spell she ever learned. I’m pretty sure even at 17 in the Deathly Hallows Hermione still then struggled with the spell in the whole ministry of magic sequence.
To put it into perspective, it’s not even in NEWT exams because of how difficult the spell is said to be. Many full grown adult witches and wizards struggle with doing it. And here you have Harry at 13 mastering it, and literally conjuring a full formed Patronus. And not only that he literally conjured a Patronus charm so strong that it drove away an insanely large amount of dementors at once.
Harry struggles with the academic parts of school, like studying and not procrastinating on homework, because he’s still in a lot of ways an immature teenage boy. But when he actually applies himself and he’s genuinely driven and wants to excel at something… he REALLY excels and surpasses most other people.
And honestly I could justify why Harry didn’t do as well in the other classes. For most of them he got E because he just in general wasn’t a studious person. Divination was just not his thing and honestly he didn’t even respect the subject much. History of Magic he just never even bothered to try. Astronomy I’d say he probably didn’t care for. I just notice that the classes he did the best in were the classes he was actually willing to put some level of effort. Keep in mind we see he didn’t really put much effort as it is, and was pretty similar to Ron with how much effort he put into classes, but he still managed to get Es for a lot of the main classes. If he actually put just a bit more effort I’m sure he would’ve gotten similar grades to Hermione.