r/hyouka • u/Scared-Dance1118 • 6h ago
Discussion Hyouka new short story question
Does anybody know how many pages we will get in the new short story?
r/hyouka • u/itskhoi • Sep 19 '20
Greeting my fellow energy-conserving friends!
It has been more than 6 months since our last FAQ thread. Therefore I'm making a new one now. This version will be in text format, since infographic can sometimes be a bit hard to follow, and cost more of your precious energy. Well, same goes for reading I guess. But Houtarou himself also enjoys reading anyway. So let's dive in!
A: Not for now. The short reason being there is not enough source material to make a new season yet.
A: Hyouka was based on the Koten-bu (Classic Literature Club) novel series, written by Honobu Yonezawa and first published in 2001. It's not a light novel by the way, there were no character designs or any illustrations featured.
The anime was later adopted by Kyoto Animation in 2012, and directed by Yasuhiro Takemoto. It covered the first 4 volumes of the novels. The original character designs were made by Futoshi Nishiya. These designs later became the series' key visuals, influenced the manga and featured in the novels' covers. Tragically, both Takemoto and Nishiya passed away in 2019 during the arson attack on Kyoto Animation.
A: So far, six.
A: The novels were never officially translated or released in English. You can buy the Japanese version on various online stores. You could also search for the fan-translated version by Baka-Tsuki, they are pretty well-translated.
A: Yonezawa has confirmed on Twitter in September 2019 that he is working on volume 7.
Just to have a clue of how long we should expect to be waiting, it took Yonezawa 15 years to write 6 volumes. And the latest volume 6 was released back in 2016.
There was also a special volume named 'Honobu Yonezawa and the Classic Literature Club', which was released in 2017. It's a stand-alone novel talking about Yonezawa's creation process of the Koten-bu series. It also features one new short story called 'The Tiger and the Crab, or The Murder of Houtarou Oreki'. SPOILER: There is no murder. Shocking, I know.
A: Yes, there is a Hyouka manga written & illustrated by Task Ohna, using Nishiya's original character designs. It was released from 2012 to 2019 in 12 tankoubon volumes (book format). They covered pretty much the same stuff as the anime did (volume 1 to 4). Task Ohna is also working on a Hyouka manga sequel, which covers volume 5 & 6.
A: You can read some of them on MangaDex. Yes, only some of them. Sadly, the translating team dropped the project after chapter 10, and since then no team has decided to pick it up yet.
As for buying, it's a bit complicated. Much like the novels, the manga also remains UNLICENSED in English. Yet it was licensed in Germany and Italy by the end of 2013. Weird, I know. But if you really want to buy the manga in English, there's a workaround: The manga is also licensed in Malaysia and Singapore, and for some reason they have an English version of the manga there. While it's not an official English release, it's still better than nothing. Thanks u/dovahkrid for letting us know.
A: The sequel hasn't been released in tankoubon yet. But the chapters are being published on Shounen Ace. Unfortunately in July 2020, Kadokawa Shoten stated that the manga will go on hiatus due to Task Ohna's illness. It's not COVID by the way, just an undisclosed illness. So expect to wait for a long time.
Edit: The manga has now resumed after the 3-month hiatus! Task Ohna recovered from his illness by end of September. The manga will return in the Kadokawa's monthly Shounen Ace magazine's next issue on October 26th.
A: Exactly where the manga sequel started, which should be chapter 76 on MangaDex.
A: Well ain't that's a mystery. Are you curious now? You see, this is the reason why Hyouka is such a special series. You'll have to dive deep into it to figure out this question for yourself.
Q: WHAT??
A: Just kidding. This is because the manga was also published on Shounen Ace, which was divided into 75 chapters instead of 50 like the tankoubon volumes. So don't worry about it, there are no missing chapters. Just start reading at chapter 76 if you want to continue from the anime. It's not like you have anything else to read after chapter 10 either...
A: No. Just read them chronologically as normal. This isn't the Monogatari series.
A: As of now, no. They still have chemistry, but they haven't dated or confessed yet. Romance was never Yonezawa's priority in the first place anyway. He does tease a little bit once in a while, but that's about it.
A: Anybody is welcome on this subreddit regardless of opinions. As long as they are respectful, contributing, and within our rules.
But wait, before you submit a "I dislike Hyouka it's so boring" post. Mind you that it's generally a pointless idea to say that you dislike something, to a community which is dedicated to that very thing. Unless you can construct some solid, unbiased points to have a serious discussion about the series' strengths and weaknesses. Banking on "it's just my opinion" ain't gonna cut it.
A: Yes but we don't talk about that here.
Q: Why not?
A: You know why.
Q: No I don't?
A: Okay jokes aside, it's bad. Like really bad... Not only it failed as an adaptation, but also as a movie.
The movie covered Hyouka's first mystery surrounding Jun Sekitani and the club's anthology, just like the anime did. But unlike the anime, the movie's cinematography is boring, the music is uninspiring, and the pacing is terrible. The acting is kind of acceptable, but the dialogues are unbearable. You can still watch it if you are really curious. But even with Chi-chan's level of kininarimasu, I would still strongly advise you to avoid it.
A: Well... if you already finished the anime/manga/novel then the best you could do is to spend time with us here. You can discuss, ask questions, make hypotheses, enjoy fan arts, etc., and have fun together!
A: We don't have any Discord server at the moment. Any posts that claim they have a Hyouka discord are definitely not from us. So be wary.
A: This pretty much comes to personal preferences. Hyouka is quite different, in term of mystery genre. It doesn't have an evil mastermind behind a shadow organization. It doesn't have a gruesome murder in a locked room to be solved, or a grandiose heist to be stopped. No. Hyouka, despite its genre, is all about the characters and how they interact with each others, as well the the world around them. You can say it's more slice of life than mystery. The mysteries of Hyouka are just layers, used in Yonezawa's way of storytelling. They seem mundane, but they are all real and grounded.
The most popular recommendation after Hyouka is perhaps OreGairu, which is pretty good and similar to Hyouka in many ways. It also used romance much like how Hyouka used mysteries. OreGairu actually focused more on interpersonal relationships & school lives, rather than just being another romcom. But it still managed to be very funny, and you can feel the tension of love between characters. It's a cool show. Check it out.
Personally, I would also recommend Tsuki ga Kirei, another anime that's also very real and grounded like Hyouka. But instead of dabbling in mystery, it's all about romance - the one thing that Hyouka currently lacks. That makes it's the perfect show to cure your post-Hyouka depression in my opinion. Much like Hyouka, there is no antagonist here. No melodramas, no huge misunderstandings, and no cliche character tropes either. It's just an honest and down to earth show, about a bunch of nice kids dealing with their first loves/crushes. Also, it's the only anime I know that features parents. Yes, REAL parents that are not either loli moms or crazy otaku dads. It's a good show. Check it out too.
And here are some bonus fun facts (that you probably already knew) before the FAQ ends:
When all creation radiates pure, clear, and bright,
And we learned what grass bloomed this sprout.
When the air of summer starts to rise,
All creation teems with life, and trees and grasses grow full.
Sound pretty cool, right? Well they are not actually poetry at all, in fact they don't even rhyme in Japanese. Well it's not like rhyming is that big of a deal in Japanese poetry anyway (because of the language's phonology). But also it's not like I have studied enough Japanese to know if something is poetic or not in the first place! So don't let me stop you from posting those on Instagram.
Anyway, they belong to something call Koyomi Binran (暦便覧) - a book published in the Edo period that was some sort of "guideline" to the Japanese 24 solar terms. It is a bit complicated subject, you can check out this website to see the full descriptions if you know Japanese. But I'll try to give you a more "simple" explanation regarding this.
You see, solar terms originated in China, and then spread to many Asian countries including Japan. Think of them like a seasonal period that matches a particular astronomical event, or signifies some natural phenomenon during a year. Oh yeah, getting dizzy yet? Don't worry, it'll only get dizzier from there. For example: Episode 1's eyecatch is Rikka , which occurs around May 6th in the solar calendar, or April in the lunar calendar. Yes, there are TWO calendars now. DEAL WITH IT. Rikka is the period where crops enter their peak season for growth, the winds are refreshing but also getting hotter, and you can feel the signs of summer in the air. This also tied with the theme of episode 1, being the reborn of the Classic Literature Club. And everything's getting hotter as Chi-chan's getting closer to Houtarou. ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
And that was just ONE of the TWENTY TWO episodes. I'm not going to go any further since I'll probably embarrass myself and bring shame upon my Japanese teacher. So the important takeaway here is that every single episode in Hyouka represents one of the 24 solar terms, and each episode have an eyecatch which gives description to the solar term it represents.
Phew! That's a wrap on this FAQ. If you have more questions, feel free to ask. If you find something that you think is incorrect or disagree with, don't hesitate to comment either. I will update the list accordingly as the thread goes.
And finally, one more last thing....
We hope you will always enjoy your time with us here. Have fun and stay curious!
r/hyouka • u/1tobedoneX • Sep 20 '24
Over the past few months, Mery had deleted all of her posts from Twitter, and then more recently scrubbed her Pixiv (which still remains online as of writing, just with no posts available) and outright deleting her Twitter account.
To my understanding, this seems to be an extension of what has happened several months ago with Mery requesting that her artwork not be reposted; due to unwarranted criticism and false rumours.
In my personal opinion, it is a massive shame that the situation had devolved in this way, and I'm sad that it has lead to her portfolio being scrubbed. I wish Mery nothing but the best and that she can achieve the peace that she desires; and whilst I mourn the fact that she's deleted all of her work, we will have to respect her wishes; and we encourage everyone NOT to bug or DM her to explain the situation or convince her to change her mind. I also feel obliged to mention that Mery herself (at least from what remains of her public presence on the internet) seems to be safe and well.
Now onto what this means for this subreddit:
Again, this is a very unfortunate scenario; but at the end of the day, the best possible thing that we can do is to respect Mery's wishes, leave her alone, refrain from spreading rumours and witch hunts, and to avoid causing her any further trouble.
Cheers, everyone. Stay curious, and I wish you all well.
r/hyouka • u/Scared-Dance1118 • 6h ago
Does anybody know how many pages we will get in the new short story?
I got her a while back. I love her “lolita” style outfit, seriously my favorite out of all her figures. All her scales are quite expensive though in after-market; I hope with the new figure being released we are able to get some affordable scales of her. I want more hyouka content. (◞‸◟)
r/hyouka • u/BlackBricklyBear • 8d ago
r/hyouka • u/Shadow_Hunter2020 • 11d ago
Scheduled for release in May 2027.
r/hyouka • u/RazzmatazzStatus9992 • 12d ago
I lost hope for any new content for Hyouka a long time ago, so I stopped checking the subreddit for a while—but upon returning, I read that something is going to be released, right? Could someone explain the details please?
r/hyouka • u/FinagleHalcyon • 12d ago
omw to buy a boat
r/hyouka • u/SilentPoetry4325 • 13d ago
Episode 18, Are the Mountains Sunny? (連峰は晴れているか), was released along with the anime in 2012, but the source material was not released until 2016 in the 6th installment of the Kotenbu novels, Even Though I'm Told I Now Have Wings (いまさら翼といわれても). How did Kyoani have this material to make the episode?
r/hyouka • u/Unlikely-Round5287 • 15d ago
Badly wanted to immerse more into Japan's history, culture, and scenery that are usually seen in the visuals of a series. To be a student of Kamiyama High would be a dream-- the sunlit classrooms, the school festival, and vibrancy of club activities. Outside of school setting, we see how biking to the Chitanda household was also stunning.
I just can't get enough of it. Trying to chase the feeling ever since. In the end, I just rewatch both series.
r/hyouka • u/EmmieL0u • 16d ago
Like tutle says I went to watch my comfort show and it's no longer on crunchyroll??
r/hyouka • u/Waste-Maize-746 • 16d ago
Never been much for online discussion. But I always played out this analysis in my mind. It's regarding Houtaro's Birthday 🎂 in book 5 of the Novels. And how the story goes out of its way to explicitly specify that no one wants to celebrate Oreki's birthday. Which sounded insane to me when I first read it 😑
Satoshi doesn't even know where Houtaro lives!! And he casually mentions something about how Houtaro would've want a birthday celebration. But like, dude!.. You have never once hesitated to meddle in his business uninvited🏃♂️🚴♂️ How is this a line you wont cross!!! It feels out of character.
And then we have Mayaka who feels like the least guilty culprit 😇 because of her frenemies/tsundere dynamic with Houtaro. But I dont know if it was the lack of anime visuals and voice acting, but her tone definitely came off as more rude than playful😢
And then we have Miss sunshine and rainbows Chitanda 🌈✨️, who has no problem taking residence in Oreki's personal space and is the emotional core of the group. But even she's like "Yeah... maybe let's not..." 😅 Which is so out of character! Especially since it would be Oreki's first Birthday with her in the picture. So she wouldn't even know whether or not he would appreciate it.
Again, all 3 felt out of character to me 🙍♀️🙍♀️🙍My cope at the moment is that the Novel versions of the characters are much more realistic and complex which the anime took and made them more bubbly in line with anime archetypes 🙍 ≠ 🙆 I haven't read the novels covered by the anime, so I wouldn't know. (I would like the opinion of someone who has 🙇♂️)
There's also the possibility that this was just some overcompensation on the part of the writer ✍️ who wanted to endure the audience to the new character Oohinata 👩🎨 And he tried to achieve that by making our original cast look more distant from Oreki 🚶♂️🚶♀️🚶♀️💔🙎♂️
Also. The consideration that the other 2 finding out that Chitanda visited Oreki's house is treated with such dire concern was off putting 🥷 I know that it was supposed to come off as a playful scenario 🤡🌈✨️ But it just came across as a genuine concern and that Mayaka and Satoshi couldn't be trusted with it ⛈️☔️😿
But who knows. Maybe the translation I read was just bad 🤷♂️
r/hyouka • u/NyaohaSuperfan • 17d ago
r/hyouka • u/FarCritical • 18d ago
r/hyouka • u/Rosalyo • 20d ago
With the new short story coming this november as a continuation, how do you think the plot will play out?
r/hyouka • u/Sad-Card6010 • 21d ago
Don’t get me wrong, I still think Hyouka is a good anime. I love the characters, the atmosphere, and the whole mystery solving aspect of the series. However, I feel like the story could’ve done a lot more with its characters and their development, and story itself.
r/hyouka • u/PalpitationSignal937 • 26d ago
So far I've read until v5 from novel+manga.
It's almost clear that Houtarou hold feelings for Eru, if I'm not mistaken?
Then how about Eru? I have a feeling she does too, but can't point my finger at it / figure where it shows that exactly.. Or perhaps I just forgotten... If you have a moment / text which could show that clearly (or vaguely) do share!
For as far as I could see, it feels like everything she does to him is out of her pure kindness? (like how she is with everyone) yet he still get somewhat of special treatment? so idk..
Do enlighten me, I'm curious.
(or should I just hurry and read v6 already..)