r/inlaws • u/Wooden-Spread9128 • 12h ago
Father-in-laws wife of two years wants to be called Grandma
My (35F) husband (35M) has a father who is in and out of relationships constantly. We have been together for 13 years, and in that time his father has had 5 long-term relationships, three engagements, and one marriage. Every time he met someone knew he met “the love of his life” and we “had to meet her” because she was my husbands new “mom”. My husband has a mother. She raised him, basically on her own imo. However, I wasn’t there, so I can only attest to what my husband has told me about his upbringing. I won’t get into those details, as they’re irrelevant to this story.
My Father in Law (50s M) has always tried to force my husband to have familial relations with whomever he is dating at the time, and that person’s family. It’s honestly exhausting. After being witness to this for the last 13 years I just don’t have the time or energy for it anymore. Every time he dated someone with kids it became “oh this is your new sibling”. If she had a brother or sister, “oh this is your new aunt and uncle”. No… just no. We have kids and our life is busy and they’re our priority. My husband has always handled his father and I stay out of it because it’s not my place. But his new wife T (50sF)of two years, who he has been with for three will not stop pushing random issues with us. Everything is fine, until it isn’t with her, and then she sends a petty text message to my husband and I, similar to that of an insecure teenager.
To be clear, my father in law is at fault for most of this and I try not to hold is against his wife, but she is making it incredibly difficult when now we don’t even like her because of her pettiness and childishness. A little backstory on their relationship, they met in the summer of 2024, she moved in with him four months later and he never told us. Just invited us over for pizza one night and we saw all her things there and he blindsided us with a meet and greet of her children. To be honest, I don’t think she knows he wasn’t keeping us in the loop about this. Whatever he has told her has made her think we are intentionally avoiding her. That’s not the case. But my father in law has always been known as a manipulator and a liar to both my husband and I.
On the weekend before Christmas I was scrolling through Facebook and saw a post from my father in law saying “she said yes!!” With pictures of an engagement ring. Ok whatever. He broke up with his previous fiancé four months prior to meeting his new wife btw. We finally went over on Christmas Eve, sat there the entire time not saying anything, and as we were walking out the door my husband asked if he had something to tell him? My father in law said no. And my husband said “you’re just not going to tell me you got engaged”. All in front of T. She is a sloppy drunk and began crying and was very upset he didn’t tell us. Supposedly she locked herself in their bedroom the rest of the night and refused to speak with him. We didn’t intend to make her feel bad, but my husband felt she should know his father hadn’t told us anything.
T planned their wedding and it was held a year to the day of their first date. I was only a few months postpartum at the time and we had only been in Ts presence about 10 times in that year period. We do not know her. My father in law barely knows her and she doesn’t know him. Whatever, not my job to point that out or get involved. However, it’s getting increasingly difficult to just ignore the face that she probably has been lied to about his past relationships.
Last night she messaged me stating she feels it’s unfair that we are family and she is just known as T to our child. She feels that because he is starting to speak he should be calling her something other than her name and that just her name makes her sad… it’s her name. It isn’t an insult, it’s her name. And quite frankly, she isn’t his grandmother. She knows this. Or so we thought she did. She stated that we should do whatever we were comfortable with and she didn’t want to step on any toes, but in the same breadth is saying she’s family and it shouldn’t just be her name. And she’s sad we made that decision. I made that decision with my husband while I was pregnant. We decided biological grandparents would be grandparents and his moms husband would be his name and his dads would be hers. There is no reason right not to confuse him about this. Especially when we don’t know how long their marriage will even last, and If they get divorced she will have zero relationship with him. We approached this with the belief that our son shouldn’t be confused and also shouldn’t be put in an unstable situation with all the women my father in law brings around like he’s done with my husband all these years. I told her that we figured our son would just start calling her whatever he felt comfortable calling her once he was older based on his relationship with her. She’s maybe been around him 20 times since he was born. Probably less if I’m being honest.
My husband asked my father in law about it and he stated that she wants to be grandma and wants the title of grandma and she probably won’t get that from her kids. Ok… she isn’t entitled to my child as a prop in her life. Just because you married someone with a child who happens to have children of his own, doesn’t mean that you’re going to be grandma. Especially when we don’t even know you. And from what we’ve learned the last few years, we don’t particularly like. Why can’t you just be my father in laws wife? It’s fucking weird. You have kids of your own. My husband is not your child. You don’t even know him. Or try to know him, but you want access to our child? You tell us that you love us and have since you moved in with my father in law? No you don’t. It’s fucking weird she keeps saying that too. Why are we trying to force a relationship? It’s just exhausting.
The problem is that if this ever is brought up in person, which it should have been in the first place, it’s going to get into a territory of conversation she isn’t going to want to hear. But she keeps pushing it, and I find it’s going to be inevitable. And it’s probably going to blow up their marriage, and I don’t want to be involved in it at all.
So do we just bite out tongues, or do we tell her exactly why we don’t think she’s going to be around in a few years and why we are protecting our son from the instability? Are we being cruel? I think she needs to stay out of my husbands relationship with his father, because that has more to do with this situation then she does, but I don’t know how to get my point across without being a bitch at this point.