r/interesting • • 3h ago • Bravo 1

Just Wow Delivering justice on her own

Post image

In February 2013, Kelsie Schelling, a 21-year-old woman who was eight weeks pregnant, drove from Denver to Pueblo, Colorado to meet her on-again, off-again boyfriend, Donthe Lucas. She was never seen again.

For years, the case went cold. Police suspected Lucas from the start, but without a body and with a changing, inconsistent alibi, they could not make an arrest. Schelling's mother spent years fighting to keep the case alive, organizing searches and maintaining a Facebook page, but the investigation stalled.

Then Lauren Suhr, a young single mother who had never met Kelsie Schelling or her family, read about the case and decided she couldn't let it go.

On her own initiative, with no law enforcement backing, Suhr messaged Lucas on Facebook, telling him she was new to the Pueblo area and looking to meet people. Over the following weeks, they grew close. What started as an intelligence-gathering mission turned into something more complicated. Lucas began to genuinely fall for her, and a real romantic relationship developed.

"In the back of my mind, I always kept that he is potentially a murderer," Suhr later told ABC's 20/20.

Over the course of their relationship, Lucas made admissions that would prove crucial. He confided to Suhr that he had lied to police, that it was him on Walmart surveillance footage moving Kelsie's car to a hospital parking lot and returning the next day to pick it up.

At one point, he got on his knees and proposed. Suhr accepted and wore the ring, while quietly relaying everything to investigators.

Lucas was arrested in 2017, tried, and convicted of first-degree murder. He was sentenced to life in prison.

https://abc7ny.com/post/kelsie-schelling-story-missing-abc-2020-donthe-lucas/10450498/

6.6k Upvotes

115 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 3h ago

Hello u/Conscious-Weight4569! Please review the sub rules if you haven't already. (This is an automatic reminder message left on all new posts)

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

449

u/Lanky_Lifeguard_2231 3h ago

Rare ethical honeypot

11

u/mississauga145 1h ago

All honeypots are ethical, for the one deploying the pot.

12

u/M0thM0uth 1h ago

I have a story of an ethical honeypot actually! She was one of my friends and was never like. High end, working for companies. Nah, if women suspected their partners were cheating, they could go talk to her and she would approach the suspected cheater. Flirting and hinting at offering more. Gathering evidence for the woman and confirming if they actually took up the offer or said "nah I have a GF"

567

u/charchavanni 3h ago

Respect. Risking their own life to bring someone to justice is another level of empathy, that too for someone they've never met.

113

u/Ol_Pasta 2h ago

I am not so sure. Yes, amazing work, BUT she's a young mother and risks her child's or children's life/ lives, too? Not happy about that part. But glad the pos Lucas is behind bars, which would have never happened without Suhr.

30

u/Ok_Positive3956 1h ago

She potentially saved another woman and her children doing what she did. I'm sure she knew to be cautious with herself and her kids around him. The real problem is the failure of police to put this guy away.

3

u/Ol_Pasta 1h ago

Totally agree, unfortunately trash like Lucas keeps getting away with horrible things. I'm just saying, this could have gone sideways really badly.

11

u/SmilingAmericaAmazon 39m ago • Bravo

Men with children risks their lives for other men and everyone calls them a hero.

A woman with children risks her life foe other women and gets chastised.

This blatant misogynistic tactic keeps women from organizing against the greatest threat to themselves - men.

0

u/Subject_Ad_2604 15m ago

No tactics here, just misandry on your part.

2

u/AvcalmQ 9m ago

This is one of those situations where both things are true and you just walk away with that existing.

Things can exist in contradiction

•

u/Subject_Ad_2604 2m ago

My remark was only about the interpretation made at the end; I don't see what you mean by contradiction

0

u/[deleted] 3h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

36

u/Suspicious_Aspect_53 3h ago

Empathy with the victim and the victim's surviving loved ones.

0

u/[deleted] 3h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/Suspicious_Aspect_53 3h ago

This is a pointless argument. Empathy and compassion are not dependent or exclusive. 

11

u/apathetic-taco 3h ago

It was just a word choice, not that serious. You’re free to use whatever words you want

1

u/Rosiepieinthesky 1h ago

Ugh, you’re such an apathetic taco sometimes.

13

u/StarfighterCommand 3h ago

Driven by…empathy.

72

u/MegamanSE 2h ago

Turns out he likely threw her body away in the landfill and the investigators refused to search it because it was too hard for them. Thats so sad.

18

u/MotherGeologist5502 1h ago

In the Mark Hacking case, he also put her body in the landfill. Police knew this, they knew where in the landfill and they stopped adding more trash to that area. It still took them many months of daily searching to find her body. I’m guessing they just didn’t think they could find her body with the volunteers they had. Very sad.

206

u/DenialNode 3h ago

Glad that worked out. Don’t try this at home kids

74

u/PhysicIce7 3h ago

In an alternative universe she would have been his second victim

18

u/Helpful_Pirate261 2h ago

pretty sure this is the AU 😅

3

u/MostBoringStan 2h ago

Doctor Strange viewed 4 million outcomes and this was the one ☝️

2

u/Quirky-Glove-3199 2h ago

And/or her child/children

2

u/SFLoridan 2h ago

It's not the same vibe when it's your dad or brother

1

u/Feisty-Resource-1274 1h ago

And I feel like you really ought not to if you have kids at home

1

u/SmilingAmericaAmazon 37m ago

Men with children risks their lives for other men and everyone calls them a hero. A woman with children risks her life foe other women and gets chastised. This blatant misogynistic tactic keeps women from organizing against the greatest threat to themselves - men.

1

u/Feisty-Resource-1274 28m ago

Generally, men who put themselves in harm's way aren't single parents and don't go on undercover operations which involve their personal lives.

77

u/ayushchandal 3h ago

She really risked a lot just to make sure Kelsie wasn't forgotten.

16

u/ReX0r 2h ago

"with a changing, inconsistent alibi, they could not make an arrest. "
Shur Shurley Shirley Surely, this is the type of alibi that does not prevent an arrest.

4

u/procell 1h ago

but it kept changing! So nobody could know!

2

u/fermbetterthanfire 17m ago

Without physical evidence it would, a single hard lined alibi... if disproven, is more glaring... than faint hard to recall facts that keep shifting. Same bullshit reason that "I dont recall" shit works in congress.

14

u/_Happy_Sisyphus_ 3h ago

Risky strategy

61

u/ChemBro93 3h ago

No training as a detective btw. Cops are fucking useless.

32

u/autistic_homo 2h ago

The reason most criminals get caught isn't because detectives are geniuses like you see on TV. It's because the criminals are fucking morons, and most of the detectives are just of average intelligence. Get a criminal with average intelligence and its like the fucking battle of the minds.

1

u/b0w3n 18m ago

As a whole, smarter people typically don't resort to crime or need crime to deal with their problems (in the case of murdering someone). This is also why serial killers tend to be so prolific, they're much smarter and often times charismatic.

26

u/busy_monster 2h ago

Always remember: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/too-smart-to-be-a-cop/

Not the best and especially not the brightest 

10

u/Any-Worldliness-679 2h ago

I wish cops were merely useless.

12

u/rhino369 2h ago

Cops are pretty useless, but expecting them to fuck a suspect to get info is insanity. 

4

u/MikoSkyns 1h ago

We've seen cases of undercover cops immersing themselves in the drug world and romantically connecting themselves to higher up drug suppliers. Point being, if there are cops willing to do this, then there are cops that would be willing to do it for murder suspects too. They just don't want to use their resources for it. Drug Busts are sexy. Murder arrests are ugly.

1

u/capsaicinintheeyes 1h ago

Drug Busts are sexy. Murder arrests are ugly.

Hard disagree--at least for the public/media, I'd say cold-case murders getting solved get way more fanfare than raiding a stash house

1

u/SmilingAmericaAmazon 36m ago

Agree but there is no money in it

1

u/Ok_Positive3956 1h ago

No one is expecting that. They're expecting investigators to do their jobs and put the murderers away. You can do that without having sex with the suspect.

1

u/ThrustTrust 1h ago

Says you.

1

u/anxessed 15m ago

Well where’s the fun in that?

5

u/gorginhanson 2h ago

Yeah, why don't cops have sex with suspects to get them to confess

2

u/-Sanj- 1h ago

They do. They're called "undercover" cops

1

u/mississauga145 1h ago

Arrest me but make it sexy?

1

u/DoctorSpoya 1h ago

How do you plead?

On my hands and knees.

1

u/Candid-Mycologist539 1h ago

There are rules that cops have to follow when investigating that a regular person can disregard.

I'm glad that Justice was done, and the bad guy will go to jail.

1

u/PlanktonOwn594 1h ago

Most detectives couldn’t make a suspect fall in love with them

0

u/pr0b0ner 2h ago

They won't get engaged to anyone to get a conviction! Lazy bitches

33

u/HorrorIcy8441 3h ago

Wow, she is heroic. I'm so impressed

7

u/OsteoStevie 2h ago

A true girl's girl

6

u/TroyMatthewJ 2h ago

this is the kind of stuff I want in my GTA

5

u/dontworryaboutit26 2h ago

That’s a movie right there

7

u/Fun_Main_2588 3h ago

So brave! God bless her and keep her

3

u/guestpassonly 3h ago

holy shit...

6

u/freshstartactivated 3h ago

Got dicked down to deliver justice, what a woman!

10

u/SargeUnited 3h ago

She’s like the chief from South Park

2

u/Short-Feed9690 3h ago

This is crazy!

1

u/threebodysolution2 3h ago

like when lloyd punked harry

3

u/ThiccBanaNaHam 3h ago

Is this a random ass d&d reference? About laxative?

2

u/TerrapinRecordings 2h ago

I don't even remember a Lloyd and Harry in Dungeons and Dragons?

1

u/Imdoingscience 2h ago

Ethical honeypot.

1

u/midgirlcrisis990 2h ago

This is the true girl's girl!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1

u/Expert_Echidna_1159 2h ago

Amazing conviction. I wonder if she got some action while on surveillance duty

1

u/Maximus_Dick 1h ago

Always women having other women’s back

1

u/ICPcrisis 1h ago

Now that’s a honey trap if I ever heard one 

1

u/Mysterious_Law_7269 1h ago

Holy shit! I hope someone hired her to work undercover, though i guess not if shes famous now.

Damn.

1

u/ConstructionAlone816 43m ago

He must have been disappointing in bed

1

u/derekgdobosz 36m ago

I love this. We all just want the bad guys to go down

1

u/Showdown5618 28m ago

Good work. That was potentially very dangerous.

1

u/LopsidedUniversity30 13m ago

This needs to become a show.

1

u/Silent-Gear4609 13m ago

Dangerous move.

1

u/LopsidedUniversity30 12m ago

Honeypot for the good side!

1

u/codetaku0 5m ago

She's clearly a hero and incredibly brave and clever for all of this, but

and with a changing, inconsistent alibi, they could not make an arrest.

This doesn't make any fucking sense at all. It's worded in a truly absurd way. Don't act like police making this claim have a point. Only a consistent alibi makes sense for preventing an arrest.

•

u/Ok_Communication5221 4m ago

I can’t even convey how badass that is. Big respect.

•

u/MadamVoid 1m ago

Girl’s girl final boss. May her pillow forever be cool, her bank account full, and everything else good.

1

u/DiscourseDestroyer 3h ago

i need to know her zodiac sign lol

1

u/Red_Velvette 1h ago

Please don’t do this. It’s incredibly dangerous and she could have been the next one missing.

1

u/Caffinated_butthole 30m ago

I haven’t watched or read anything about it. But what if she wanted to really date him, didn’t know anything about the pregnant lady, started dating that went into a serious relationship, she found out about the case on her own or he started confiding in her, and then turned him in? Still admirable, but to engage in a serious emotional and physical relationship with a possible murderer while risking your life and your kids’ lives just to possibly help with a stranger’s case seems far fetched.

0

u/mississauga145 1h ago

This lady is deranged, right? We can agree what she did, regardless of the outcome is not the actions of a mentally stable person?

-1

u/TataBehaa 25m ago

Yeah Sounds like she added some Razzle Dazzle to this story... Probably a criminal chaser, he pissed her off and she turned him in.... Ijs

-1

u/Brave-Quote-2733 2h ago

Now that’s a girls’ girl!! I swear, as a white woman, we as a society do not deserve the loyalty, kindness, brilliance, and strength of black women. We should be protecting them at all costs.

0

u/JumanGxplorer 1h ago

Can’t get over the fact that they were in a romantic relationship. 🤢
I mean ty, but to what extent…

-2

u/Eman_Resu_IX 3h ago

Did she keep the ring?

0

u/MoriKitsune 3h ago

Not sure, but if she did he could probably sue for the value of it. It was a gift, but it was given/accepted under false pretenses, so 🤷

-31

u/BlueHawk75 3h ago

I skip right over these memes with large font two color shock messages.

33

u/CharDeeMacDennisII 3h ago • Popcorn Bravo

But, you didn't skip right over it. You stopped to comment.

1

u/BlueHawk75 2h ago

PSA friend

10

u/GardenRafters 3h ago • Popcorn

You done got got

8

u/Tiberius_Kilgore 3h ago • Popcorn

Weird. Seems like you’re here in the comments.

-4

u/ThisMeansRooR 3h ago

Is that Charles McDowell before the neck implants?

2

u/Mister_Goldenfold 2h ago

booty so good, you’d confess to murder

-2

u/overdosingOnPie1313 3h ago edited 3h ago

I feel like all the commenters are just ignoring that she genuinely fell for a man she was convinced from the start, had murdered his pregnant ex.

edit: oops. Read it wrong.

7

u/justentropy4 3h ago

Where does it say that? The text only states that he fell for her. 

4

u/overdosingOnPie1313 3h ago

Oh shit. I misread it. My bad.

4

u/Juoreg 3h ago

She didn’t?

She said they dated for a year when, on his porch, he started hyperventilating and crying. Then, he proposed to her. She said
she'd have to think about it and drove home.

"At that point I was kind of done," Suhr said. "I felt like I was [in] pretty deep. Deeper than I think I ever wanted to be... I didn't want to get in any deeper than I had already gotten into."
Suhr said she never fell in love with Lucas and never saw him again, only reaching out to him to tell him she was ending their relationship

3

u/GothGreyAyyLover 3h ago

reading is hard

3

u/overdosingOnPie1313 3h ago

Especially when you're low on sleep!

0

u/[deleted] 2h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/Chance_Vegetable_780 2h ago

Wrong. The Black woman pictured is the incredibly brave hero. The tragically murdered girl is not what you assumed, she is a 22 year old white woman Missing - Kelsie Schelling 2013

7

u/Own_Butterscotch_129 2h ago

It was a white girl that was murdered and the woman in the photo is who got the guy convicted.

Try again?

12

u/Severe-Curve4640 2h ago

Ironic, the murdered woman was a college aged white girl