Backstory: I'm 39F, divorced for over 10+ years, and this is the first Thanksgiving in five years that I'll be bringing a boyfriend home. My brother (44) also recently divorced in August after 26 years of marriage.
We went years without speaking to my brother and his family after establishing some boundaries. We eventually reconciled for my dad's sake after he suffered an aneurysm not too long ago. For context, my brother's marriage was extremely dysfunctional, and we're honestly relieved that it's over. Things have been good since we reconciled, and we're all talking and spending time together again.
Anywho, onto the actual issue.
My boyfriend is an INTJ to the core. For the first time in a long time, I'm in a genuinely happy and secure relationship.
And I understand that he's different. Think blue-collar town, and then a college-educated man walks in who actually reads, has intellectual interests, and enjoys his own hobbies. He's not your stereotypical guy, and I get that he might not be everyone's cup of tea. But being different doesn't make him fair game for ridicule.
I brought him home to meet my family a couple of weeks ago, and ever since, my brother has made it his mission to announce that he's concluded my boyfriend is "gay." Mind you, he has met him just this one time, and as soon as he walked out the door, he made the announcement. Since then he has been brought up in every single conversation.
Whether it's in our family group chat of 25+ people (siblings/spouses + our children) or when we're all hanging out in person, we could be talking about dogs, food, the weather, literally ANYTHING, and somehow my brother will find a way to bring up my boyfriend and make another comment about him being gay. Without fail.
I'm honestly at my wits' end. I find it incredibly disrespectful, not only toward my boyfriend but toward me and my relationship. I’m constantly having to defend him/us; I don’t mind because I’m just protective in general of what’s mine.
The irony is that I could bring up how my brother's mentally unstable ex-wife cheated on him for over a year 12 years ago- he caught her and they had another baby to “save their marriage”. She’s called him a worthless POS to his face and around us/others; has put him in jail multiple times to where he can go to prison now if he's ever arrested again; took everything he owned in the divorce, and had another boyfriend before the ink was even dry.
…But apparently, bringing up his past is off-limits because it's hurtful and he's threatened to "off" himself before. Yet when it comes to my boyfriend, my brother (and the four nephews he's recruited to join in) are "just joking” (according to my sister) and I'm apparently supposed to not take it seriously.
My boyfriend doesn't have a social circle and is very much a loner. He's also originally from a few states away, so I genuinely thought it would be nice for him to spend the holiday with my family and get to know everyone. He's struggled with acceptance in the past, and the last thing I want is for his first Thanksgiving with my family to feel uncomfortable or like he's being scrutinized.
I was planning on spending around $250 of my own money to cook for our thanksgiving dinner, but now I'm seriously considering skipping it altogether. I'd rather take my boyfriend out to dinner and maybe catch a movie instead. I'm sure he'd enjoy that, especially since it would be a more relaxed evening without draining his social battery.
The part I'm struggling with is that I don't want him to know the real reason I'm considering changing our plans. I don't want him to feel unwelcome, think badly of my family, or feel like he's somehow the problem. I know my parents and my other siblings aren't responsible for my brother's behavior, and I genuinely love my family.
But I also feel like I shouldn't have to spend a holiday defending my relationship or worrying about what someone is going to say next. Please help.
So, what would you do? Would you skip Thanksgiving altogether, or would you go and address the comments beforehand? And if you decided to skip, how would you explain the change of plans to your boyfriend without hurting his feelings?