TL;DR: My brother (Canadian, never a US citizen or resident) died in Oct 2026 leaving about $40k of US stock at Fidelity. Fidelity says it needs an IRS Transfer Certificate (Form 5173) to release it. The estate is under the $60,000 threshold, so per the IRS's own page this should be the Part B affidavit route, no Form 706-NA. But when I call the IRS, the agents don't understand the request or which form applies. Fidelity also mentioned a US address on file for me is causing the issue. Has anyone gotten through this, and what do I actually say to the IRS?
Background:
- Brother died Oct 4, 2026, in Canada. Canadian citizen, lived in Canada, never a US citizen or resident.
- He held US stock (about $40k total) at Fidelity. I have access to the account now, but Fidelity won't release the stock without the IRS letter.
- I'm the named beneficiary and the one settling the estate. Whether there is a will is still being confirmed.
What the IRS says (as I understand it):
- The IRS transfer certificate page says if the estate's US assets are under $60,000, no Form 706-NA is required — you fax a Part B package instead: the will, the death certificate, any non-US death/inheritance tax returns, and a notarized affidavit from the executor/personal representative listing all US assets with date-of-death values.
- Processing is 12-18 months, after which the IRS issues a letter saying no certificate is required.
- I should NOT file Form 706-NA — the IRS says filing it unnecessarily will delay the certificate.
What I've tried:
- Called the IRS general line (1-800-829-1040) — couldn't connect, high volume.
- Called the Estate and Gift Tax line (866-699-4083) — got through, but the agent couldn't understand the request or which form is needed.
- Fidelity told me on the phone that they need the 5173, and mentioned something about a US address being on file for me being what causes this. I've emailed them asking what US address they have, why it matters, and what they need to fix it. No reply yet.
My questions:
1. Has anyone successfully done the Part B affidavit route for a nonresident estate under $60k? What did you actually send, and did it work?
2. What words do I use with the IRS so the agent understands? Is there a specific department, form number, or phrase that gets me to the right person?
3. Does the "US address on file" thing actually matter, or is that a red herring? My address is in Canada.
4. Who is the right professional for this — a cross-border CPA, an Enrolled Agent, a US estate attorney? And roughly what should this cost for an affidavit-only case (no 706-NA)?
5. Is there any way Fidelity releases on the executor's affidavit alone while the IRS process runs, or do I just have to wait the 12-18 months?
Any experience or pointers appreciated. Not looking for formal legal/tax advice, just trying to figure out the right path and the right words to use with the IRS.