r/isaca • u/Specific_Lemon_6828 • 20h ago
Failed AAIR despite 5 ISACA certs and 15+ years in IT audit, and I'm genuinely questioning how this exam is built
I sat the AAIR this morning and got a preliminary FAIL. I'm still in shock.
Some context:
- 15+ years in IT audit and cybersecurity in the financial sector, currently IT Audit Manager
- Already hold CISA, CISM, CRISC, CGEIT and CDPSE
- Consistently scored around 80% across three full practice exams in exam mode
When I hit submit, I honestly expected something around 700/800. The real exam felt noticeably easier than what I had prepared for. I hesitated on maybe 3 to 5 questions. To fail, I would have needed to miss roughly 20+ scored questions, which means I got many "easy" questions wrong while being fully confident in my answers.
That is what bothers me most. With this exam, confidence and real-world expertise seem to be almost meaningless indicators. The problem isn't the questions you struggle with, it's the ones that look obvious.
I also noticed during preparation that several official practice answers were, at best, debatable. In some cases the rationale for the "correct" answer actually supported a different option.
My honest feedback for ISACA:
- For a $460+ exam aimed at senior practitioners, a scoring model where experienced risk professionals cannot tell whether they passed or failed by a wide margin raises real questions about item quality.
- The gap between practitioner judgment and "the ISACA way" seems even wider on the new AI certifications than on CISA/CRISC.
- Unscored pretest items are fine, but candidates deserve more transparency on how new exams are calibrated.
I won't be paying to retake it. I'll keep studying AI risk for my own work, but I've lost confidence that this exam measures what it claims to measure.
Has anyone else had a similar experience with AAIR, AAIA or AAISM? Felt easy, expected a comfortable pass, and failed?