r/ithaca • u/Low_Rise5492 • 2h ago
Let's recap the public hearing on Terawulf last night. Reminder tonight is the vote!
jobleads.comWhat a massive showing of support last night. Would love to hear your perspectives and help us all understand a couple of things ahead of tonight's vote...!
A few points stuck out to me. I think this issue has shed light on a potentially problematic planning board member. He came up a few times from speakers who attending the planning board meeting. Maybe we will dive into this later.
But let's get into it. Overall split - I’d put it roughly 80% for banning and 20% against the ban… maybe 2 speakers undecided; hard to tell. Recap of speakers later down thread.
What is most concerning (and I think needs clarity) is that a woman identified as “Gabby B.,” a TeraWulf VP of community engagement (BTW, they are actively hiring for this role) announced she had a petition against the ban signed by owners of more than 20% of the affected land. She said that means four board members must vote yes for the ban to pass. She said the signers own “nearly a third of the land in Lansing.”
I'd like to understand that better, if anyone can clue me in.
Another oddity? One speaker said he’s the second-closest neighbor to the site, and that the closest is the project manager for this plan. He said that both of them have families and wouldn’t put their own homes at risk. I was unaware of this - but it sounds like a conflict of interest?
It is not uncommon for incentives to be dangled to those closest to the site. It's happening in PA - residents were offered $10k each..... I assume something of the sort is happening here. One man has said on social media and at the hearing that he will be right next door and he's totally cool with it all. I just find that weird, sorry.
Two of the opponents to the ban were TeraWulf executives. They were booed. Audience was scolded. Rinse and repeat. It did get a little spicy at times.
I will sound like an ageist, but I think it's time we get more young blood into these seats of power. Just a general comment.
Most common concerns mentioned:
Higher electric bills & strain on the grid. Speakers cited NYSEG rate requests and Cornell research showing data centers push up wholesale power prices. One speaker noted that residents were encouraged to be eco-friendly - and many who switched to heat pumps now depend entirely on the grid. I thought that was a good point.
Noise, especially over water. Speakers said sound carries across the lake, and several brought up infrasound and diesel generators. Several lake residents said they can already hear conversations on the far shore (good reminder to watch what you say, I guess!)
TeraWulf’s record and lawsuits. Speakers raised the company’s legal challenge against the town, its tax fight at Lake Mariner, the CEO’s threat to sue, and its records requests (FOILs) that cost the town money.
The lake, water, hunting and wildlife. Speakers mentioned drinking water drawn from the lake, algae blooms, coal ash at the old plant and the neighboring wildlife area and hunting. Climate and emissions concerns, light pollution.
Doubts about AI itself. Concerns ranged from privacy and surveillance to warnings about extinction.
Quality of life and tourism. Wineries, wedding venues and “dark skies” came up. Some said they moved here specifically to embrace the country life.
Property values. One person said lake property values in her neighborhood have dropped 7% since the project was announced. I didn't verify this, just relaying what was said.
Why some support the project:
Taxes. One speaker said town taxes have risen 15% a year for three years, with 20% to 22% expected next year. Several speakers mentioned schools and town services.
The ban is too broad. One warned the wording could cover medical IT systems in the village (I think that is a reach)
Legal risk. Cost of legal bills, etc.
Process. One said that hearings overrepresent the most vocal residents and called for a townwide poll, but to be honest...their speech felt off. Forced? Scripted? I can't put my finger on it, but it didn't sit right for some reason. It almost felt like they were reading something that someone wrote for them and they were reading it for the first time. I get nervous speaking publicly so I can see when others are. It wasn't that, in my opinion.
Anyway, thank you to all who have been following this and doing what they can. It's cool to see people of all ages/generations get behind something together. I'm a pragmatic person. I can see why people would want xyz even if I don't agree with it. But no one who is advocating for this project seems to have a good enough reason to share. The vibes are off, man.
We will likely never know for sure, but I think we all know why.