When I first discovered decades worth of
the greatest Batman comic books & storylines in my early teens I always had John Carpenter music playing in the background while I read. The 2 things: the comics & Carpenter/Howarth compositions have become co-mingled in my memory. For the Return of the Dark Knight & Year One it was The Fog & Escape From New York. For The Killing Joke it was Halloween 3. Brilliant nostalgia! I've always felt Carpenter was a natural choice & would have made an incredible Batman movie.
So I've decided to imagine a world where The Thing was a massive runaway success & Carpenter was allowed to make his version of Firestarter wich was even bigger & Starman in 1984 was also a critical & financial smash & Warner.Bros/DC handed him the keys to one of their best loved & bejeweled characters & he becomes the first ever filmmaker to bring to life a dark & mature Batman: The Movie in 1985.
So who would Carpenter have cast? Here are my ideas:
° BRUCE WAYNE/BATMAN Played by KURT RUSSELL. I can see how Oscar winning Actor William Hurt & Carpenter's Starman lead Jeff Bridges may have been good choices for the role but come on! It's a no-brainer that Kurt Russell would embody Batman in a Carpenter movie because he would have been an excellent choice regardless of the Director. But he & Carpenter had sure fire magic & a rapport & would have delivered the goods. I can see Kurt as an everyman Bruce then indulging his wilder, darker side as Batman. His Batman would have been somewhere between Elvis & Snake Pliisken.
° PETER O'TOOLE As THE JOKER. Another no-brainer for me. I can't see Jack Nicholson as a Carpenter Directed Joker but I can see how David Bowie or even Tim Curry may have worked. But as well as being one of cinemas most legendary performers, O'Toole resembled The Joker of the comics physically - especially in the artwork for The Killing Joke. O'Toole would have given the character gravitas & just like Heath Ledger & Joaquin Phoenix, would have been showered with critical praise & popularity with the public & may have taken home some prizes come awards season.
° JAMIE LEE CURTIS As VICKY VALE. I can see future Batman franchise performers Kim Bassinger & Michelle Pfeiffer playing Vicky but I've gone with Jamie for the role. She wouldn't have been simply a damsel in distress she would have been much more an 80s action heroine who could look after herself & I'd love to see her teamed with Kurt. Plus, by the mid 80s she would have been a strong candidate for worlds sexiest actress.
° ROBERT DUVALL As OSWALD COBBLEPOT/ THE PENGUIN. This would have been an absolute trip & Duvall would have been a real live wire in the role because he is definitely capable of portraying the multi faceted qualities the character needs. He would have made the Penguin very sinister beneath the surface.
° C. THOMAS HOWELL As DICK GRAYSON/ROBIN. I think theres alot of talented actors in 'The Brat Pack' of the 80s but Howell ticks all the right boxes the character needs & his chemistry with Kurt on a buddy level would have been off the scale.
° REBECCA DE MORNAY As SILVER ST CLOUD. Seeing how the Batman artists at DC based Silver's looks on Rebecca it stands to reason that she would have been a brilliant fit for the character.
° TOM ATKINS As COMMISSIONER GORDON. I mean COME ON! Atkins was perfect for that character going on the way he was drawn & his character traits in the bigger picture. He was obviously a favourite of Carpenter's & I think he would have been terrific.
° DONALD PLEASCENCE As ALFRED. I think a British actor like Denholm Elliot would have been great, as would two of Carpenter's heroes: Peter Cushing & Christopher Lee. But I've gone for Donald because he & Carpenter always worked excellently well with one another.
° JON LITHGOW As HARVEY DENT. That would have been as close as it gets to perfect casting. Lithgow looks very much like the Harvey Dent of the comics & it would have been interesting to see him both before & after the character arc over a number of movies
° ADRIENNE BARBEAU & JAMES BROLIN As MARTHA & THOMAS WAYNE. Carpenter's then wife would no doubt have been utilized somewhere in such a big movie & the character of Martha Wayne would have been a masterstroke of casting & Brolin, the father of a future Thanos, always had that golden age Hollywood leading man charisma.
So these are just some of my ideas & I'd love to hear everyone elses choices.
Can you imagine how amazing a 1985 Carpenter Directed & Dean Cundey filmed Batman movie would have been? Carpenter working with Alan Howarth on the musical score?