Hi folks, there have been some posts lately that are of a type that we want to filter but don't have a specific rule for. In many cases we will use mod discretion as a reason but these posts are common enough that we felt the need to be more explicit before we started filtering them on a more consistent basis.
Clarification of some of our submission and relevance guidelines
We want to clarify how we interpret and apply our existing content and relevance rules.
The purpose of r/Kelowna is to provide a place for meaningful discussion about Kelowna and the surrounding region. While we welcome a wide variety of subjects and viewpoints, not everything that happens locally or has some connection to the area necessarily makes for an appropriate submission.
Local relevance
A submission must have meaningful relevance to Kelowna or the surrounding region. It is not sufficient that something simply occurred here, involves a local person or business, or has some tangential connection to the area.
Consider whether the same submission could be made in the subreddit for another city or province without materially changing its subject or significance. If so, it may not be sufficiently relevant.
General discussions of national or international issues are better suited to communities dedicated to those subjects, unless there is a substantive local connection.
Outrage, speculation and public shaming
We are not a venue for alternate or social justice.
We have added a new rule specifically for this. We generally do not allow submissions whose primary purpose is to criticize, shame, ridicule or express outrage over the actions of an individual or business.
Examples include:
Dashcam footage submitted simply to criticize another driver's behaviour or highlight a traffic violation.
Screenshots of job advertisements accompanied by speculation or accusations that an employer is abusing the LMIA or Temporary Foreign Worker Program.
Submissions intended primarily to generate outrage over the actions of an identifiable individual or business.
We recognize that these subjects can involve legitimate public safety, employment and public policy concerns. However, simply documenting an incident or expressing an opinion about someone's conduct does not necessarily contribute meaningfully to a discussion about our community.
It is also important to note that /r/kelowna not allowing a post does not mean a person will not be held to account. In the majority of cases with posts like these there is already a method to report bad behaviour to police or other regulators. Disallowing it here is not indicating our tacit approval of the documented behaviour.
Are these topics completely off limits? No. They can still be discussed in comment threads of submissions that are more 'vetted'. This usually means a news story etc. but we describe some of the general criteria for sourcing below.
News reporting and documented local issues
We give greater latitude to independently sourced reporting, investigative journalism, government announcements and other material that provides credible evidence or documentation of substantive local issues.
For example, reporting about documented employer misconduct, local traffic safety concerns, investigations into local industry practices, or the effects of federal policies on our community may be entirely appropriate.
There is a distinction between sharing independently sourced information that provides a basis for meaningful discussion and submitting personal opinions, speculation or unsubstantiated allegations and asking the community to accept them as fact.
These guidelines are not intended to discourage criticism, controversial discussion or negative reporting. We welcome substantive discussion of difficult issues affecting Kelowna and the surrounding region.
Our intention is to maintain a subreddit focused on information and discussion that is genuinely relevant to our community, rather than becoming a general-purpose forum for outrage, speculation and complaints about things that happen to occur here.
As always, moderators reserve discretion when evaluating individual submissions. If you have questions, feel free to ask in modmail. Thanks for your attention.