r/Kibbe • u/tipsyredpanda • 15h ago
discussion How should we understand the new exemplars vs. old icons/verified celebrities?
Would love a discussion on this with those who are interested in meta-analysis of the system.
Do the pre-Power of Style verified celebrities still fully and accurately reflect the nuances of David's current visions for the IDs? How should we understand them in the post-Power of Style era? Are they still useful reference points, or are they possibly misleading/distracting from David's current approach?
I ask because while the old verified celebrities certainly still "make sense" from the broader perspective of Kibbe's ideas encompassing the history of the system, I do notice the new exemplars (and verified celebrities) have offered me a fresh idea of each ID that I think indicates an evolution or refinement or even redefining of his conceptualization or communication of each ID. Like his definitions of the IDs feel both pared down and deepened? I would give examples but I'm not sure how to articulate the differences I've noticed yet. Just hoping someone else knows what I mean!
Like, if I'm trying to understand each ID better through verified celebrities, is it still helpful to focus very much on the pre-PoS celebrities, or am I better off trying to understand what he's communicating about each ID through his PoS exemplars?
(Obviously these thoughts were sparked by the Florence Pugh and Grace Kelly of it all, but I'm not interested in debating that--they both make a lot of sense in the post-PoS world to me, and that's what fascinates me about what his new exemplars are meant to communicate about each ID!)
Thanks!!
ETA: It seems David has spoken quite clearly about his intentions for the new exemplars and I just wasn't aware! I'd be curious then to hear anyone's thoughts on how their concepts of the different IDs has deepened, expanded, or been honed through the new examplars!!