I’m about to start the Beauty and the Beast sweater by Meghan Regan, which has a stranded Fair Isle yoke and body with plain stockinette sleeves.
I’m using the exact yarn specified in the pattern (Kim Dyes Yarn Tartlet Sport, 100% superwash merino).
The pattern calls for 28 stitches × 36 rounds per 4 inches in stranded colorwork, using US 6 (4 mm) needles.
However, US 6 seems way too large for me. I’ve been swatching with US 3 (3.25 mm), and here are my results after blocking:
Flat stockinette: 26 stitches per 4 inches
Fair Isle (speed swatch/faux in the round): 25.5 stitches per 4 inches
Both swatches were washed and laid flat to dry without intentionally stretching them. The Fair Isle fabric feels soft and flexible, and I really like the drape.
My actual chest measures 39 inches, and I’m aiming for a finished sweater circumference of approximately 42 inches.
I’m torn between two options:
Go down to US 2 (2.75 mm) and try to achieve the pattern’s 28-stitch gauge. But that would mean knitting with needles FOUR US sizes smaller than the designer recommends! I’m worried the fabric might become too dense.
Stick with US 3 and knit the instructions for the 40-inch size, accepting that my looser gauge will produce a larger sweater. Although, based on my calculations, it might actually end up closer to 44 inches rather than 42.
This is my first full Fair Isle sweater, although I’ve knitted Fair Isle hats and intarsia sweaters before.
What would you do? Keep going down in needle size until you match gauge, or adjust the pattern size to compensate? I’m particularly concerned about how changing the gauge might affect the fit of the circular yoke.
I’d really appreciate advice from anyone who’s dealt with a similar situation!