I apologize if this kind of question has been beaten to death on here, I just really need some advice on what to prioritize moving forward and would appreciate advice from people who understand the current landscape of science in general.
Quick background: I'm set to graduate in 2027 with a Bach in Biochemistry (GPA ~3.6). Over the summer I started doing undergrad research in a lab at my university to help fill out my resume but it turned out I fit in with the graduate students in the lab really well! Based on conversations with the grad students, its sounds like I will likely be offered a PhD position in the lab after graduating. The thing is, I cant decide whether to accept it or not.
To save everyone's time, I'll just list my pros and cons of accepting the offer.
Pros:
- I get along with and enjoy hanging out with the grad students in my lab and in the other labs in our department. Assuming this doesn't change, I could definitely build a solid social network, something I've heard can be hard to find in other labs.
- The professors/ PIs I've gotten to know are all friendly and I don't get the sense that there are a lot of big egos to deal with (an issue I hear can be prevalent at other schools).
- The university is in my home town, so I will be close to family (support available, can spend more time with them compared to moving out of state).
- I hear the job market and grad admissions are pretty competitive right now, a guaranteed position is a solid path to a PhD while I wait out the storm (if it ends by then of course).
- Tuition will be much lower staying in-state vs going out of state (most should actually be covered by the university from what I understand)
- Position is paid (~30k a year, so budget would definitely be tight though)
Cons:
- Funding has been sketchy the whole time I've been in the lab. I'm worried this could present issues long term.
- I came back to college after dropping out and being a sad chud for 4 years. More time in school means I'm giving up even more working years than I already have (I would be in my mid 30s when I finish my PhD).
- I'm not very excited about the research topic. I don't hate it, but its not something I'm passionate about, at least at the moment.
- The PI/ Lab isn't very "high impact". Odds of getting my name on a notable publication don't look very good if the trend continues.
- I've wondered if I may be able to get into a school that will open more doors for me. My GPA is admittedly not stellar (got super depressed, ended up dropping out, came back and got straight A's since if it matters) but I'm hoping some of my extracurricular work will help improve my odds a little bit(~1 year research experience, got asked to TA for upper division classes, solid letters of rec).
- Part of me wants to get out of the town I grew up in (predominantly religious area but I'm not). Accepting means putting this off for another ~6 years.
- I've heard doing your PhD at your undergrad university can be frowned upon.
In your opinion, what factors do you think I should prioritize? Am I looking a gift horse in the mouth here?
If I did go for higher tier schools, do you think I would have a shot given my GPA and limited research experience? Would it be worth giving up the positive culture at my current lab for a more impactful subject/institution, even if it means working with a group that I may not mesh with as well?
Finally, given the current landscape of science as an industry, is it wise to get a PhD at all or should I work for a few years and return to school if I feel it would help my career?
Currently, I am trying to find a good balance between my mental health and career success. I've spent many years working my way out of depression and want to build a life that keeps me at a healthy place mentally while also ensuring I'm not passing up opportunities that may jeopardize that in the short term but will help bring stability in the long term. I know that's a pretty vague and fine line to walk but I guess that is part of what I am looking for advice on.
Thank you for reading, and thank you for any advice you have to offer. If there is anything I need to clarify, just ask.