UPDATE: Thank you all for all the comments and suggestions, between autism allegations and contradictive tips, I think I found the answer.
I'll just ditch geometry, especially when it comes to recreating existing logos. I think the problem is that when I recreate something that already exists (especially on digital) I start thinking "mh, how did they make it? Is this where they started?" And start exploring and dissecting a possible geometry, somehow without assuming they could've just free handed it.
Because if I sketch on paper I only free hand, even when recreating logos in my notes. I unironically just needed a reminder that you can free hand a design, and trace it in digital. Literally just that.
This is strictly a problem that pops up when I recreate something in digital, where I got bound by the thought of how the logo might've been made, excluding the free hand way, blinded by the digital.
Thank you all for the tips and the comments which helped me untangle this, even though it was something so simple and silly, it did feel like a roadblock since I'm just starting out and still exploring, I'm glad of the support I received. Thank you again!
First post:
I've been learning logo design and anything that comes with it. I read and studied books, and now I've been starting to practice to learn a software and how to actually create a logo on it before starting to make my own original practices.
So to do that, I'm recreating existing logos. What I completely didn't expect is that I'm sooo focused on finding some sort of abstract geometry even where there isn't, or partially but not completely.
Like this Shell logo that's been kinda driving me insane, this is my second attempt and while it is recognizable, it's not too close either.
I sort of see some shapes and their connections, but then I force myself to keep it all geometrical, and not by any rules, just abstractly matching things?
What annoys me is that I know that a more mathematically correct logo isn't perfect oe better. Optical balance and geometrical balance are different, I know that sometimes even if something is mathematically perfect, doesn't mean that it will look good or balanced.
I also rarely care about it normally, I'm usually way more free handed and not "chained" by geometry and all that, which is why I'm surprised.
Sorry for the little rant but damn 🫠
(And the low quality process pic)