r/mildlyinfuriating • • 13h ago • Regret 2 Bravo 1

ಠ_ಠ Potluck etiquette is dead

Or at least it is within my friends group.

My parents always taught me to never show up to anyone’s house empty handed and to not cheap out on gifts. I have hosted as well as attend potlucks/Friendsgiving and it feels like there’s no etiquette anymore. These are the things I kept noticing:

  1. Not enough food. This doesn’t happen when I host because I usually provide everything and just ask people to bring drinks or desserts. But when other people host, they would make one main protein and not assign anyone else to bring a main dish. So we usually have a bunch of sides and desserts.
  2. Not enough servings of food. Someone would offer to bring mashed potatoes and would show up with one container for our group of 20+.
  3. Uneven contribution. A family of 5 show up with one dessert but would eat 5 servings of everything else. I feel you should contribute enough to cover how much your family is going to eat. Or people who would bring a grocery store jar of gravy to contribute when they are getting homemade turkey, fancy stuffings and bakery bought desserts.

And don’t get me started on people hog the leftovers or tried to pack plates before everyone is even done eating.

8.4k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

1.7k

u/Something_McGee 13h ago

Sorry to say this, but your friends just sound like idiots. A lot of these things are common sense and just plain etiquette (not just potluck etiquette).

The part about bringing enough to compensate for your large family makes no sense, though. You said it earlier... You're supposed to bring enough to accommodate the anticipated crowd. (Basically, way more than just your own family.) If everyone did that, there would be enough for all to have a full meal.

23

u/lazypotatosoup 13h ago

Right??? I just feel like it’s common sense.

495

u/judicious_thriller 12h ago

Potluck math only works when everyone slightly over-contributes. One freeloader throws the whole buffer.

→ More replies (15)

239

u/great_apple 11h ago • Bravo

The part about bringing enough to compensate for your large family makes no sense, though. You said it earlier... You're supposed to bring enough to accommodate the anticipated crowd.

I think the point is, if you have ten people showing up and it's five people plus one family of five... you can't have the five single people each bringing a dish to serve ten and the family of five collectively also only bringing one dish to serve ten. Logically that means each of the single people paid for food for 10 but each member of the family only paid for food for 2. If you're part of a large group you should be bringing multiple items, not just one 'group' contribution.

(Of course that's totally dependent on the group, I just think that's what OP meant generally)

→ More replies (9)

34

u/Napo5000 12h ago

Usually my go to is bring something I know I’ll like and enough that I can assume everyone else will like it and eat it and I can still fill up on it.

→ More replies (2)

99

u/Sweaty-Basket-6877 11h ago • Bravo

Compensating for being a large family absolutely makes sense.
They’re treating the family like one guest, but they are five.

A party with 20 individuals will end up with 20 different dishes to share. Take 5 of those people, and make them one unit, and now you’ve only got 15 dishes to share, but same amount of people to feed.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/OneMinuteSewing 12h ago

I don't bring a lot more, I bring maybe 50% more. But I don't bring 50% more than us of what I'd eat of that particular item, I bring 50% more of how much we'd eat total of all the elements. So if I'm bringing a salad, I'd bring six very full plates full (main + dessert for four people plus 50%)

I guess it is different if you are the only one bringing a specific element, e.g. dinner rolls. You need enough for each guest plus a bit more.

Otherwise often when we've come we're told "do not bring too much, we are going to have a lot of food".

10

u/Right_Pen_3241 10h ago

This.
This is actually why I will volunteer noodle salads, couscous salads, or rice salads: They are easy to just scale up!

Potato and Green add a bunch to my preparation workload when scaled up, so I will bring one of the others and just make quiet a bit too much.

→ More replies (1)

1.5k

u/Shitzme 11h ago • Regret Bravo

A lovely lady in my town decided to give up her Christmas day and host a lunch in town for those who are down on their luck or lonely.

She spent her own money on hiring out the town hall, and decorated it with a huge Christmas tree, tinsel on the ceilings etc.

She asked for donations of food, and recieved very little response. So again with her own money she provided turkeys, hams, seafood, pavlovas, trifles, puddings and numerous sides. Cooked and prepared it all herself.

Tonnes of people showed up, but not a single person actually stayed for the lunch which she had set up.

Families were rocking up and taking entire plates and platters of food and then leaving. She said one family of 5 rocked up, and the 3 kids excitedly showed her the brand new iPhones they got as gifts. The parents took the seafood and left.

She expressed her disappointment and shame in the community group and stated she'd never do it again. People bitched at her for not wanting to host ever again.

20

u/lazypotatosoup 11h ago

That is terrible! Those people better be offering to host if they are going to say that

509

u/crankyandhangry 10h ago

When you said that loads of people showed up but no one stayed for lunch, I initially thought you meant that lots of people came for an hour to show their support or be social, or that they were lonely rather than hungry. I can't believe people took food with them and left. That's really awful.

148

u/Action_Limp 6h ago

Kind of reminds me of those videos where you see people empty the candy baskets at Halloween. It's supposed to be a nice community bonding experience, but people just want to get theirs and fuck off.

→ More replies (6)

173

u/waistingtoomuchtime 8h ago

I was doing a 3 hour “feed the homeless”, an hour or 2 of food prep, and distributed downtown on a route for 3 hours where homeless had camps, with the bonus of clothes, blankets, shoes etc.

I did this for about 3 months, every Tuesday, at first it was great, then people asked for specific things, which if fine “I need shoes in a 8.5”, or a blanket that was water proof, water etc.

Once they got to know me it got very specific, like “I want black and red Jordan’s in a size 9”, or “I would like less peanut butter and more jelly, but my friend wants more peanut butter”, or we would have brand new packs of socks and underwear, and they don’t want any because they were not Nike Elite, “bring me Nike Elite”.

I get some want to be “normal” and have things, but it go the the pint when things we brought we nicer, they rushed the bus like they hadn’t eaten in a week, but in reality, they were ok, the6 just wanted anything that was cool we had to give away.

There was one camp where the Alpha Males took everything at first, and then used it as barter to all the rest. It was sad.

→ More replies (5)

47

u/Longjumping-Solid680 9h ago • Bravo

I've said it before and I'll say it again: More people should be eaten by Wolves.

→ More replies (3)

52

u/BroManTheBrobarian 9h ago

That whole situation is absolutely vile, but my jaw dropped to the floor when you said that people actually bitched and complained at her for saying she would never host again. The fucking nerve, “you’re so selfish for NOT letting me take complete advantage of you, and step all over your kindness”.

86

u/Strong_District_5894 5h ago

Because trash people act like trash. They aren’t going to spontaneously grow any common sense or propriety for one day. 

138

u/LickRust78 9h ago

And this is why selflessness, hospitality and just being a good human are dying traits.... people are shitty

→ More replies (5)

73

u/Secretstar2989 10h ago

People truly are the worst. I always feel bad when people with a kind heart are taken advantage of.

→ More replies (5)

19

u/Lemon-Cake-8100 7h ago

Many humans are not nice people... that poor woman's faith in folks must have really taken a hit. ☹️

50

u/DaBingeGirl 10h ago

That's really sad.

Much smaller scale, but I've stopped participating in Halloween. I used to love it, I went all out on decor, but I had too many kids asking for specific candy, complaining if the handful I gave their friends looked bigger, adults using toddlers to get candy, etc. It just sucked the fun out of it. People are awful.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/funlovingfirerabbit 10h ago

Omg that's horrible. I am so sorry to hear that :0( I feel her pain

10

u/Optimal-Hunt-3269 9h ago

I hope she finds somewhere her beautiful heart will be appreciated

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (46)

737

u/ChickyBoys 13h ago

Potlucks should be planned. Tell people what to bring and make sure there's a good balance of mains, sides, desserts and snacks.

19

u/lazypotatosoup 13h ago

I tried that and people either didn’t sign up or just put that they are “maybe” going until last minute.

40

u/cicada_noises 12h ago

Sounds like an issue with the social circle itself. Flaky and cheap

16

u/lazypotatosoup 12h ago

Idk if it’s a generational thing where they just can’t commit to a social activity

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

276

u/False-Set-7900 13h ago

And nobody gets to cop-out with "I'll bring a bag of chips and a 2-liter of cola" when everyone else is bringing actual dishes to pass.

→ More replies (35)

38

u/According_Gazelle472 13h ago

Which rarely happens .My women's club has different women hosting each month and they never plan for how many people show up.One small pie or small plate of brownies for 20 women is just not going to cut it .It would be nice if they stopped bringing that Dollar Tree soda each month .And one woman salted everything she made to oblivion. Another woman brought a burnt store bought lasagna one time .

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (18)

194

u/Familiar-Collar1370 13h ago • Mindblown

An acquaintance hosted a party recently and there was no food and I was never offered anything to drink.

Literally nothing and these people are from the Midwest, which is notoriously casserole culture. I brought a dessert and people ate it off paper towels with their hands.

I laughed about the absurdity with my friends & family bc wtf? I can’t imagine having people in my home and not offering something.

And no, it wasn’t a means thing, these people are upper middle class.

34

u/lazypotatosoup 13h ago

That is crazy to me. How are there no plates in the house? I would die of embarrassment

27

u/Familiar-Collar1370 13h ago

Eventually they brought out some plates, but the dessert was half gone by then and 1-2 hours had passed since I arrived.

The entire thing was so bizarre.

→ More replies (2)

87

u/cicada_noises 12h ago edited 12h ago • Mindblown

I’ve started eating before I go to potlucks and even dinner parties because people don’t know how to host or behave. I went to a summer lunchtime bbq once and the “hosts” didn’t provide any food AND didn’t bother to buy gas for their bbq. The thought that a bbq would be needed for the bbq occurred to them after people started asking to grill things. The hosts had to leave their own party to go try to find fuel for their grill on a holiday weekend. They were gone over an hour. I left before they got back. As far as I know, nobody got to eat.

Another dinner party, the hosts bought a single pack of chicken drumsticks (about a dozen drumsticks or so) and didn’t also know how to cook them. They invited 20 people. They were trying to do the math as guests arrived of “how many people and how many drumsticks do we have, oh fuck”. There wasn’t any other food. The hostess was confused about her own decisions “I thought this would be enough…” I also left that “party” early and hungry.

ETA: these are all people in their 30s/40s who are well off with good jobs.

16

u/lazypotatosoup 12h ago

That’s my generation too! And I can see someone in my group doing that too if they had to host

→ More replies (10)

18

u/TheGreatAlibaba 13h ago

I always had drinks for people, but I don't always offer food. We used to have guys over every other week, but they all arrived at random times and knew to bring their own food. But when we had a set game night, I always made dinner or ordered food. But the expectations were always clear for each event.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

47

u/eugeneugene 13h ago

lol my friends group has a potluck every month. We have a google spreadsheet we reuse and people sign up in whatever category they want. The host makes the main dish. Works out fine every time we always have way too much food, and the host gets first dibs to pack containers of leftovers as thanks for making the main and letting us use their house. A little bit of effort in organizing goes a long way

15

u/lazypotatosoup 13h ago

Whatever generation you are, you guys are doing it right.

122

u/Pecan_Artist 13h ago

that's why you do a spreed sheet on Google docs. have folks sign up and make them responsible. I have had sucess with this approach. Ex-2 sweet potato pies, sheet pan of mac and cheese, lasagna, mashed potatoes in a sheet pan.

30

u/lazypotatosoup 13h ago

I wish. My group is so wish-washy that they wouldn’t say they are going until last minute.

54

u/RedRibbon3KS 13h ago

Maybe you need to find a better group of people. I get you. For my family gatherings I do multiple dishes (usually one or two mains, 3-4 side dishes). People have told me not to but the few times I haven't there was barely enough food and no leftovers.

7

u/lazypotatosoup 13h ago

100% we usually bring extra like 3 dishes for 2 of us. Cause we know we have slackers in the group

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

22

u/Direct-Discount-2663 13h ago

Or say " ... enough to feed 20 people" and 'if there are 1 to 2 people in your family, bring one dish; if 3-4 people, bring 2 dishes, etc."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

69

u/femmeinfloral126 12h ago

I went to a friendsgiving recently and had the opposite issue, we had wayyy too much food. Like 4 tables full of food for around 15 people, it was amazing and delicious and I was uncomfortably full haha.

12

u/lazypotatosoup 11h ago

That’s a great problem to have.

15

u/carterothomas 11h ago

Just to hop on the “too much” train: drinks. If you know that other people at the party are going to like what you drink ie; you know the host likes red wine or lots of people like IPAs and that’s what you’re bringing, bring more than enough to cover yourself and leave it if it doesn’t get consumed. If I’m hosting and someone brings over an extra bottle of red and I have it for leftovers or the next time I host as something to offer, that’s excellent in my book. I also have a beverage fridge in our upstairs bar/hang out area, I love being able to tell people to help themselves and “go shopping”. Beer, wine, seltzers, lots of NA beer and seltzer options, many of which were “leftovers” from previous get togethers. People love it.

→ More replies (7)

49

u/Cheap-Translator7731 11h ago

the last pot luck i attended was friendsgiving and someone LOUDLY and EARLY claimed mashed potatoes, like the minute the group chat was formed. guess who no showed??? cmon now… if ur not gonna gonna come pick like … corn or something idk.

14

u/lazypotatosoup 11h ago

UGH 😩 this is why I would delegate drinks and desserts when I host. Especially since some of my friends are ALWAYS late

→ More replies (11)

19

u/Striking-Basket-3891 13h ago

As a child of immigrants, not having enough food at a party or gathering is an insane concept 😂

5

u/lazypotatosoup 10h ago

That’s definitely me. But some of my friends are also children of immigrants or immigrants themselves and they don’t feel the same.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/LongjumpingJaguar308 12h ago

Now, this was like 8 years ago but we used to attend/host vegan potlucks and there were SO many times when it was my house mate and I both making real mains to bring to potlucks. Then maybe one person would bring a homemade dessert and everyone else brought chips and salsa or hummus. One time a few people came really late, and only brough chips and salsa and...they ate chips and salsa for dinner because you reap what you sow I guess.

We had to put our foot down and tell people to actually make something, dammit. And it worked out for a bit but then covid happened and we've not really had potlucks much since.

I think there has been serious erosion on younger people knowing how to cook, in general, though and some people might just be learning about vegan food, but even as of right now, the internet still works for recipes.

7

u/lazypotatosoup 10h ago

Did they eat chips and salsa cause everything else was gone? Or did someone tell them to? I would feel bad as host if someone is hungry in my house

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

27

u/Aggravating_Olive 12h ago

I recently helped plan a pot luck. It was between 4 families, 17 people total. I think we did a good job distributing mains, sides, and desserts. I think organization, communication, and follow through is important.

But I've also been on the other end with a friend who has a history of showing up empty handed. Even if he says he'll bring something, we just plan on him not bringing anything at all just to save us from annoyance. He will also be the first to get to-go containers. I'm irritated just typing this out.

3

u/lazypotatosoup 12h ago

That’s frustrating. At that point I would ask him to chip in money or something. I had one guest bring a box of entenmann's cake but pack up 3 plates next to him as he continues eating.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

23

u/FartsWithNeighbours 13h ago

There's a difference between potluck and hosting.

"this doesn't happen when I host because I usually provide everything and just ask people to bring drinks or dessert" that is hosting at your house.

A potluck is when everyone should bring something to contribute.

6

u/lazypotatosoup 13h ago

I gave up on relying on people to bring things when I host. They either forget to bring it or bring low quality/quantity of it. So I asked them to bring drinks and desserts so at least we can have a variety

→ More replies (2)

2.7k

u/Long-Report8274 13h ago • Bravo

This sounds more like poor planning

1.3k

u/SockSock81219 13h ago • Bravo

Right? This is why our high-strung aunts ran Thanksgiving like the gd Navy. It wasn't just rampant anxiety and control issues, people!

362

u/lazypotatosoup 12h ago • Bravo

I wish we have a high strung auntie in the group. But it would probably be me and that’s just make my anxiety flare up

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (5)

194

u/Forward_Prune_8740 13h ago

💯 I have a volunteer position in my kids’ activity that often requires me to organize potlucks. I send out a sign up genius with very specific categories and numbers needed. I asks for a certain number of main dishes, side dishes, fruit and veg plates, desserts, drinks and ice, paper plates etc with specific numbers. If I don’t see enough signed up for a certain category I bring those things to fill the gaps. If I don’t plan carefully everyone will just grab a plastic container of cookies at the grocery store and assume someone else will bring the real food. For a family or friends meal I’d at least send a group text.

36

u/lazypotatosoup 12h ago

It’s always the grocery store cookies default! And no one ever eats those.

→ More replies (7)

56

u/throwaway-lid1997 11h ago

Poor planning explains having mostly sides and desserts, but packing to-go plates before everyone has even finished eating is just pure audacity.

36

u/AdministrationOk8888 13h ago

Yeah and/or shitty friends

42

u/StOnEy333 13h ago

Exactly. If you notice these things going wrong in your friend group, say something to them when the planning starts.

→ More replies (7)

11

u/Icy-Adhesiveness2556 13h ago

I feel you on this. My friend group has been trying to plan a Christmas party since September and just got the date settled on but not the location. They either bring not enough food, nothing to drink or want to split the cost of food amongst families even though they are families of 4 and 5 and mine is just my husband and I. I was always taught to never show up empty handed and to help clean up. Maybe it's a cultural thing?

8

u/lazypotatosoup 13h ago

It’s a mix of cultures. And it’s a mix of who is generous and who is stingy.

22

u/SpMarfy 13h ago

hmmmm can I ask the age groups of all the people involved?

9

u/lazypotatosoup 13h ago

Oh we are all working adults 30-40s. Some coming with their kids as well

6

u/StrangerGeek 12h ago

OP I hear you. The past few potlucks I've attended in this same age range have been woefully undersized. One had like a giant 20lb Christmas ham for a Hanukkah/Christmas combo potluck and then a bunch of 4 serving micro sides.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/Proper-Resolve-7916 12h ago

Tonight I'm making 4 dozen ham balls and a pumpkin cheesecake for the work potluck tomorrow. I don't expect to be bringing home leftovers. Gotta show these youngins how it's done! Plus, I'm the new guy so I'm maybe overreaching a little.

2

u/lazypotatosoup 10h ago

lol way to go. You won’t be the subject of any mildly infuriating potluck posts

22

u/Wavy_Pattern 10h ago • Mindblown

I understand why people are saying OP needs to plan better, and if it’s the whole group, your friends just might not like potlucks, but some people are just dense.

I have a friend group where I frequently host friendsgiving. I made a Google spreadsheet and a list of suggested items to choose from if you don’t have a “go-to.” We always end up with leftovers. (Gen Z)

But man, if there aren’t a couple people who show up with nothing.

My friend has celiac. He speaks highly about how he’s never gotten “glutened” from my cooking. Everyone in the friend group knows to clean their kitchen, not use convection bake, not use wooden utensils, and use certified gluten-free ingredients, which are often more expensive. We had homemade gluten free turkey, gluten free mac and cheese, gluten free stuffing, gluten free gravy and cranberry sauce, gluten free dinner rolls, gluten free pie, gluten free cocktails, etc. He brought a small bag of cuties to friendsgiving.

3

u/lazypotatosoup 10h ago

Gen Z and their spreadsheets! I love that for you (minus that one friend of yours)

10

u/markhachman 10h ago

Convection baking can gluten someone??!

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/lazypotatosoup 10h ago

Right?? My parents’ generation would never ask anyone to bring food but that’s always the unspoken expectation that people generally bring something for the host/event.

10

u/libraryblue 11h ago

I'd you're someone that doesn't really cook/bake, and you don't have much disposable income, should you just decline these types of invites? Genuinely asking! I could see this being a result of people not having the funds and time but still wanting to be social maybe?

12

u/lazypotatosoup 11h ago

No, there’s definitely room for all levels here. You could offer to bring ice or soft drinks. Or even offer to come early to help set up or stay late to help clean. But don’t pack any leftovers unless the host insist. Funds are definitely not the issues in my friend group as we are all working adults

11

u/HeWhoHasTooManyDogs 10h ago

Packing leftovers anywhere but at your parents/grandparents without being verbally told to take some leftovers, is wild.

6

u/lazypotatosoup 10h ago

You would think it’s common sense but apparently not. Especially with my single guy friends.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/According_Gazelle472 13h ago

Or bringing one can of corn in a small bowl for about 50 people and then turning around and eating enough for 3 people!

4

u/lazypotatosoup 13h ago

100% and packing plates to go too!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/QuirkyCookie6 13h ago

This might just be yall

I attended a potluck recently and even though I was just assigned dessert, I also brought a ready made appetizer, because potlucks of this sort don't start with the communal cooking until like an hour past start time, and you're screwed if you show up hungry.

Anyways, everyone gorged themselves, took home enough food for a few days, and I think the host still had enough food for a week.

2

u/lazypotatosoup 13h ago

Yea, maybe it’s just my friends group. It gives me hope the etiquette is still alive out there

→ More replies (1)

1.8k

u/pittsburghfun 6h ago • Heartwarming

Every pot luck that I have attended, there is an over abundance of food! You need new friends!

318

u/Bethw2112 4h ago edited 4h ago

Moochers don't get subsequent invitations to parties, within reason. Like we don't expect elders to bring a shit ton of food and bust their butt to wash dishes, they've done their time of hosting.

→ More replies (2)

49

u/LostInGradients 4h ago

I know, might be cultural too. I live in the US, and we mostly do family potlucks. Mostly Filipino and French families, so people that like to host and cook a lot. But to be fair I did do a few more typical Americans potlucks and food was also abundant.

I have yet to see a large event where everyone doesn’t leave with basically an extra meal.

Most people plan for what their family would eat plus a bit more, and the host usually plans generously.

→ More replies (1)

91

u/UnderwaterScubaMiner 4h ago

Tbh, maybe its because I live in the South, but I was thinking the same thing. At my work potluck, they were begging people to take to go plates because there were way too many leftovers.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Pseudo_ChemE 4h ago

Midwestern and Mexican - also too much food. Pots and pots of heavy food. We’ve agreed to pare it down but the truce is always broken. We’ve even assigned singular food items to families, they still bring stuff from other categories.

18

u/RayDonovan1969 6h ago

Came here to say this 👆🏼

→ More replies (15)

345

u/MrsJ_Lee 6h ago

My SIL showed up for thanksgiving for 18 people with a can of corn and a can of peas still in the can in a grocery bag. She was bringing the vegetables.

124

u/HereNorThere123 5h ago • Bravo

Long time ago when our extended family still got together, you were assigned something.

This is why.

They knew if they assigned “hot veggie” to certain people, they’d literally bring cans and expect the host to prep. So those people got “X buns and 2 sticks butter.” 😂 Or, “4 liters Sprite.”

→ More replies (4)

124

u/Beck316 6h ago • Bravo

39

u/Queenpunkster 5h ago edited 4h ago

Someone once showed up for a taco party with uncooked bell peppers and wanted to sautee them. I had converted my stove into a bar bc…party needed counter space. She was v unhappy with that situation.

Edit: somehow this became a convo about what should/shouldn’t go on a taco. As a reminder, a food doesn’t have to be authentic to be enjoyable! Part of the fun of taco night is seeing what wild stuff goes together when folded in a tortilla (or baked on cheese and bread when I do pizza night).

→ More replies (46)

61

u/KayDeeFL 5h ago

For a Christmas Eve dinner (Seven Fishes, and yes, there were seven different dishes) I asked my sister and her husband to bring white wine, "like a sauvignon blanc." She brought ONE bottle and then poured nearly half of it into her own glass.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (14)

441

u/RebeccaEduc 5h ago • Mindblown

BIL showed up to family get together with a 1 package of Oreos (20 guests) . He volunteered to bring a dessert. (For those of you who like Oreos, you would have only gotten 1 1/2 cookies.)
What made me more mad was his excuse, “I’m a guy what do you expect?”

195

u/GloomyGal13 4h ago • Bravo

Weaponized Incompetence

→ More replies (6)

87

u/Big-Film-6914 4h ago

I had a guy show up with his teenage sone with 3 hot dogs and 3 hot dog buns.  When i called him out on it he said his wife always did that (fairly recently divorced).  But its insane.  

→ More replies (7)

76

u/HobbitDruid 4h ago

I’m a guy and I baked an entire cheesecake for our Friendsgiving this year- unfortunately it was a bit underbaked 😅 but we live and we learn lol

→ More replies (10)

184

u/SomeAussiePrick 4h ago • Bravo

As a guy... I'd bring a fucking cake if I said I was bringing dessert. Probably two cakes if you're talking 20 guests. Are they going to be gourmet shit? Probably not. But there'll be enough store bought mudcake for everyone to enjoy a decent slice.

Ergo, fuck your BIL.

→ More replies (20)

38

u/belladorka 4h ago • Bravo

That’s why we stopped doing anything organized at work. They expected the 4 girls in the office to make a huge spread and the warehouse guys would come in and eat everything. Didn’t even offer to bring soda or chips.

27

u/standingdesk 3h ago

I guess if you’re a guy and offering literally nothing else, then I expect straight cash homie

13

u/PuzzleheadedClue5205 3h ago

Napkins and paper plates next year. But tell them the Costco size packages. At least the host would be stocked up for the season

10

u/doctordoctorpuss 3h ago

What a fucking loser. I’m a guy, and the last Friendsgiving I went to, I brought two homemade apple pies. I take great pride in my cooking and baking, and I know that’s not everyone’s bag, but being a guy is no excuse. Let Anthony Bourdain’s ghostly hands whack this dude in the nuts

9

u/Pernicious_Possum 3h ago

I hate dudes using being a man as an excuse to be a moron. Maybe for them it’s not an excuse? Maybe they’re just morons

→ More replies (28)

387

u/sofluffyfluffy 6h ago • Bravo Mindblown

I’ve stopped inviting a certain relative to holidays after she showed up to a 20+ person potluck with a SINGLE UNCUT bell pepper to share for her “veggie tray”. I respect potluck etiquette and don’t invite people who don’t reciprocate with the same effort.

47

u/HerAirness 4h ago

My mother in law agreed to bring coconut shrimp as an appetizer for the first Thanksgiving I hosted. She showed up with a frozen box of shrimps that needed to be cooked at 425°, even though the turkey was occupying my only oven at 300°. Another time my cousin in law agreed to bring the salad. She showed up an hour late with a head of iceberg lettuce, unpeeled carrots in a bag, & a can of olives. We did not have the shrimp nor the salad, and I completely stopped asking them to bring anything. Just ridiculous.

→ More replies (9)

61

u/Expensive-Proposal71 5h ago

This is the way. If people are gonna be bad guests I don’t invite them. I am a good host that usually throws big BBQs, briskets etc. several times a year and usually only ask people to bring alcohol or some desserts/fruit/snacks for the rest of the day.
I will accommodate if someone wants to bring a side or something else happily.

But show up 5 minutes before the food is arriving empty handed and then leave without doing any dishes and best believe you are gonna wonder where your next invite was.

→ More replies (1)

54

u/timinator232 5h ago

At that point bring nothing, I’ll be more understanding

One time we had a pool party and a guy in his 40s brought an open handle of room temperature plastic bottle vodka. Never talked to him again. 

→ More replies (2)

78

u/NerdGirl23 3h ago

Everyone needs to be schooled by old church ladies who made real food in “feed an army” quantities and fucking pitched in to clean up.

36

u/Glittering-Paper4516 3h ago

That’s the thing. I’m not religious but I miss the community of church. And younger generations don’t learn the logistics of preparing for large groups, and they don’t learn the etiquette or pride in contributing. 

So many families do not have communities- they’re isolated within themselves. So no one learns and these things become lost. 

→ More replies (6)

69

u/FinalMidnight 6h ago

I think your friend group just sucks. Or maybe it’s because they have and involve kids. Any time our friend group does something similar we have way too much food and the host has to practically force people to take leftovers home with them.

→ More replies (1)

308

u/Unlucky-you333 3h ago edited 2h ago

I have been hosting Friendsgiving at my house for the last 6 years.

One year I made a spreadsheet to ensure no one brought the same dish since that was an issue the year before. Someone brought Mac n cheese even though they weren’t supposed to (someone else signed up for it) because “I like the way I make mine better” they did not bring what they put down on the spreadsheet.

Another year one of my friends brought 4 people I have never met before and did not invite. I obviously did not account for these 4 extra people so I barely had enough food for them. They did not bring anything. They took plates home with them without asking.

two years ago I invited like 20 people and the dinner went great, we all had fun. but not a single person stayed to help clean up. It’s not that I expect the help but when my parents had dinner parties a few people would always stick around to pick up trash or whatever or when my friends have dinner parties I usually help them do their dishes and stuff.

Last year I decided to just cook all the food myself because I was tired of potlucks going wrong. 9 of the 14 people that came did not bring anything. No wine or beer, no candles or basic host gifts, nothing.

As sad as it makes me, I’m not doing it anymore. It’s not worth all the work to end up with a mess to clean up by myself and having to pay for the whole meal and all the drinks. People don’t act right anymore >.<

ETA: anyone who was an “offender” was not invited to the following year. I’ve realized over the years that a lot of these people are actually not my friends for one reason or another. My circle is much smaller now but they are good people! Unfortunately many of them moved away or have busy lives with kids now so it’s hard to coordinate a day where we can all be together to celebrate.

32

u/debomama 3h ago

I'm sorry people are so clueless and ruin it for everyone else.

30

u/Maximus_Robus 3h ago

Looks like you really need to find better friends. Next time only invite the people who actually contributed anything.

→ More replies (17)

171

u/KayDeeFL 5h ago

This, and when you invite people for a holiday, do ALL the work (buy, prep, cook) and when the meal is over and it's time to clean up, EVERYONE moves to the living room to relax leaving you to do it all. Yep. That was the last holiday dinner where everyone was invited. (12 people, Christmas Eve). Now, I have a lovely dinner for just a few (no more than six).

48

u/SnooPineapples6489 4h ago

This makes me feel so validated because this is my family only it’s for 30 people. I honestly am thinking of doing pizza Christmas because I’m sick of how much work it has become with no help.

→ More replies (12)

53

u/Ishmael75 5h ago • Heartwarming

I realized a few years ago that all the dudes in my wife’s family will scurry off to the living room. Since then I’ve been staying in the kitchen to help with the cleanup and dishes.

But you are right cleanup after you’ve hosted and made the food is such a letdown.

Me helping makes my wife happy so it’s 100% worth it!

→ More replies (2)

26

u/Faeri 4h ago

I'm very glad I picked up helping the host from my mother. Would never let the person who cleaned their house and cooked an entire meal for me have to clean the kitchen by themselves. Same with bringing food--I can't remember the last time I showed up somewhere empty-handed. I try to bring homecooked but if I can't I'll stop by the store and grab something easy.

I'm cooking Thanksgiving dinner for my in laws this year and I'm making it very clear, if I'm cooking a 5 course meal yall are cleaning the kitchen!!! 

→ More replies (1)

30

u/Reasonable-Horse1552 4h ago

I was left to do all the clearing up one Christmas, I was heavily pregnant, newly disabled and using a wheelchair and had the flu. Because people had vaguely helped cook dinner they thought they'd done their bit to help and just buggered off. I said never again after that.

→ More replies (6)

14

u/shifty_coder 3h ago

I started taking over the cooking for holidays at my parents’ house. After watching the same thing happen to my mom nearly every year she hosted, I absolutely delegate tasks to people while cooking and cleaning.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (25)

135

u/DemmyTheLion 10h ago

I participated in a work potluck once. I stayed up for hours making a ton of very nice meatballs, and got them all set up in a big crock pot to stay warm. Brought rolls and cheese too so people could make mini subs. Went and the only other food there was a small cooked box mac and cheese and 2 bags of chips. No one even brought drinks, and there were like 50 people participating. Never took part in one again.

77

u/BlindSkwerrl 9h ago

So 47 people turned up for a free feed?
Whoever sent out the memo must have been unclear.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/azbarbell 9h ago

I like what my work does, it's more of a fundraiser though. Everyone is welcome to participate, there's a sign up sheet and if you don't participate you can still eat just pay $5-$10 bucks. We don't expect much so we do get people that'll just buy something like a cheese tray or some sort of platter from the grocery store.

→ More replies (1)

43

u/bluemooncommenter 2h ago • Heartwarming

I went to a party recently with a bunch of middle aged women (one of those where everyone dresses like Mrs. Roper from the 70's TV show Threes's Company, in curly wigs and muumuus)...it was glorious. Everyone brought a tasty dish - some savory, some desserts, there were labels available to mark what your dish was, there was a special cocktail for the event, a party agenda (which it turns out that 'lets go around the room and introduce yourself" is a lot more fun, interesting and less corporate retreat when done as two truths and a lie), and everyone helped to clean up and left the home spotless. Absolutely glorious.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/marzbarz79 3h ago

Okay, but whoever makes the turkey/main should make the gravy. You use the drippings in the gravy.

→ More replies (5)

36

u/muffledvoice 3h ago

Potlucks rank up there with sharing the road and obeying traffic laws for experiences that reveal how people fail at community and consideration for others.

Which is to say, they tend to fail at it.

→ More replies (3)

33

u/917caitlin 11h ago

Your friends are bums! I attend potlucks frequently and it’s like everyone tries to outdo everyone else.

→ More replies (3)

29

u/SharkoftheStreets 7h ago

Could it be OP's friend group? I've run potlucks with multiple friend groups and even my wife's family and never had any of the issues described.

57

u/Grouchy-Poetry-7927 5h ago

When we do Thanksgiving at my house, I had a cousin that would show up, and need to fully prepare her side dish while I'm balls deep with the oven full and stove packed. Please bring you item fully prepared! It's one thing to pop something in the oven, but this was infuriating

→ More replies (6)

4

u/ChaserOfThunder 8h ago

Went to a friend's potluck today. I'm also starting to hate these events, but for opposite reasons. There's 3 specific roles of people that show up every time my friends throw a potluck that lead to a lot of tossed out food, and I fucking hate wasting food. My issue is still being expected to bring a massive serving despite there already being an excess. Debating on just not going next time.

4

u/lazypotatosoup 8h ago

Oh no, that is so wasteful. Do you have community fridges around that you can leave leftovers in?

→ More replies (1)

53

u/Certain-Climate8619 5h ago

potlucks only work when everyone has the same baseline of shame. once two or three freeloaders realize nobody will confront them, the whole thing turns into a charity buffet.

→ More replies (1)

175

u/Single-Kangaroo1180 9h ago • Bravo

As someone who has been in a lot of random people’s homes (paramedic working ambulance for a decade), I detest work potlucks. You cannot judge a person’s cleanliness nor hygiene by their income, clothing, neighborhood, nor exterior of their home. Too many nice looking houses with well manicured yards…with absolutely disgusting kitchens when they have to call someone into their home for an unexpected visit. Going to a work potluck and only snacking on prepackaged food, what I cooked, and maybe something from one or two coworkers (whose homes I have visited)…all without offending anyone else is stressful and not a fun meal. I would much rather pool money and order a pizza or food delivery from a mutually selected restaurant.

27

u/aboxofkittens 7h ago

The lady who organizes the ones where I work (and brings in some of the food) doesn’t wash her hands after peeing. I stopped eating the food after I saw her wet her hands and leave

→ More replies (3)

25

u/Cut_and_paste_Lace 5h ago • Regret

My perception of people was completely obliterated when a close family friend that always brought elaborate dishes to parties became terminally ill. My husband was an in home caregiver and went to help him out and discovered his home (which he just never invited anyone to before) was stacked sky high with hoarding, including the kitchen, and it was the dirty kind, not just accumulated stuff.

This man was the most cultured, elegant, well spoken gay man I had ever known and I had always admired and looked up to him. To realize he was living this way, which he confessed to my husband he had painstakingly hidden all those years, was absolutely shocking.

Aside of hurting for him, knowing he had been silently suffering all those years, my brain immediately went racing to the dozens and dozens of meals I had eaten that he had prepared in a tiny little patch cleared out in the middle of a wasteland.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (14)

21

u/minikin_snickasnee 12h ago

I know that feeling! Our friend group usually does a great job with potlucks - I state what main I'm providing and we provide soft drinks (sodas, juice, various Keurig pods) and in addition to a food item, if they want a specific drink (diet, etc) to bring. And if they need specific food (like our friend with celiac) to bring their own plate and not be expected to also bring a dish to share, as I know cross-contamination happens.

We usually get a good variety of sides and sweets. Our friend group ranges from early 30's to late 50's.

Now, we tried to host a D&D group as well. I don't play, but my boyfriend does and I was happy to host. I knew some were younger and maybe didn't have many funds, so I tried to provide simpler plans (taco bar, baked potato bar, etc.) and asked people to sign up for one item (like shredded lettuce, diced tomato, diced onion, sour cream, etc) when we provided seasoned ground beef, shredded chicken, black beans, rice, corn tortillas and soft drinks. A list was emailed out. Maybe two people responded.

Two separate people each brought a bag of tortilla chips. One couple brought a small can of nacho cheese. One just showed up with their appetite. Someone else brought a can of olives. Someone brought a bag of flaming hot Cheetos.

One of our "regular friend group" people texted me earlier in the day to ask if I needed her to pick up anything. She brought lettuce, sour cream and a small package of shredded cheese. And, since the other guests didn't even open their cans of food or ask if, say, we had a can opener or serving utensils or anything, I fussed around in the kitchen to prep everything for them.

The next time we hosted, I did the baked potato bar - same shit happened. I had left out some serving bowls, utensils, the can opener and a small crock pot to warm the cheese sauce. I admit I was a little curt in handing "canned item people" the can opener and gesturing to the serving bowls and utensils, saying "take your pick". Same couple brought small can of cheese sauce again. "Crock pot can be plugged in there".

Both times, our guests (minus the one friend who helped) were reluctant to help set out their food AND didn't clean up after themselves. Trash can was very obvious in the kitchen, but they left plates, utensils and cups (paper and plastic) on the table, on the counter, and one person left their soda cans on the floor. Spilled food? Didn't bother to clean it up.

Boyfriend tried one last time (I did not want to help) after a discussion about what kind of food they wanted (meal versus snack foods) and it was another clusterfuck. I really felt like we were being taken advantage of, so we declined to host again.

→ More replies (2)

40

u/RecbetterpassNJ 6h ago

My Grandparents used to say, “if you’re invited to someone’s house, you should be ringing the doorbell with your elbow.”

→ More replies (5)

40

u/pineappledumdum 3h ago

I generally feel like almost everything etiquette-wise is dead now.

→ More replies (10)

167

u/mynipplesareconfused 6h ago • Bravo

My husband's office party left a sour taste in my mouth. We're foodies and we love sharing food with others. He had a potluck at the office and I offered to make pastelitos de pollo for it. These took a long time to make, I do batches of like 75 at a time.

Well, he took them to his potluck. I asked him to let me know what other people brought and how people liked the pastelitos. The only people to eat it were those from the countries who eat it anyhow. All the white coworkers were "terrified" of them. (It's fried dough with chicken and chili/bell pepper/onion puree, definitely ingredients these people eat at home) I could have handled that if they had brought actual food in.

No one else brought in a dish. It was all big box store cookie and veggie trays. My dish was the only hot one. I told him if that's how potlucks are at work, we aren't doing them anymore. A wasted effort for the lot of them. But I did make some friends with his Columbian coworkers and now they call my husband "the empanada man".

59

u/lipp79 2h ago • Bravo

White guy here and you had me at, "It's fried dough with chicken and chili/bell pepper/onion puree". Sorry the other pasty people didn't like your pastelitos.

→ More replies (4)

134

u/Positive_Throwaway1 2h ago edited 1h ago • Bravo

As a white person, let me say: fuck these other white people. I was at a potluck once where the Latina wife of a coworker made stewed goat. It was fucking amazing, and there were people surprised that I was eating it because it was stewed goat. Tired of these Live Laugh Love sign-from-Homegoods-Hobby Lobby-having motherfuckers out there fucking up shit for the rest of us who LIKE FOOD THAT DOESN'T COME IN A GODDAMNED CLEAR PLASTIC CLAMSHELL.

Assuming this happened in the US, I'd love to know where.

→ More replies (27)

32

u/All4YouLikeJanet 4h ago

I've learned you really have to know your audience with these kinds of potlucks. Your dish sounds amazing and I would have probably happily eaten as many as many as possible if someone served them to me. Like you, I also prefer...nicer, tasty, real food.

That said, I know what kind of people my husband works with and I know they are not foodies at all. So he gets sent with cake balls, trashy dips, and quasi-homemade stuff. His co-workers go crazy for that stuff. I will grant it tastes good, it's just not what I prefer to eat.

→ More replies (7)

11

u/in-my-wise-woman-era 2h ago

Uhm, I LOVE trying homemade food from other countries/cultures

37

u/chattykatdy54 3h ago • Bravo

A lot of people don’t eat home cooked food at potlucks. My church has fellowship after worship service on Sunday. People bring all kinds of baked goods. I only eat the food brought by people who I trust to be hygienic when cooking. You know, no cats on the counter, no licking the spoons and reusing them , etc.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (76)

19

u/abeille_verte 12h ago

Showing up as a family of 6 with a single bag of chips then watching the two adults and 4 kids help themselves to seconds - leaving entire platters empty is just fucking rude. I am speaking from experience (with extended family) 

→ More replies (2)

18

u/Sufficient-Reply9525 13h ago

I only do potlucks with my close friends. If I haven't seen a person in a while and we want to see each other, we catch up in other ways.

You're right, OP, people are changing. Where I work the employees used to get together and plan a potluck for every season (summer, autumn, winter, spring) and we had an issue with people showing up to eat, but not bringing anything to share. We finally implemented a rule that if you don't bring anything, you can't eat. These grown ass adults (all 30+) threw tantrums claiming it wasn't fair! We no longer have potlucks.

As far as friends, cut off the moochers. Your blood pressure will thank you 😁

18

u/SamIAm7787 9h ago

When inviting people, make all of this clear. Maybe assign items and then say, "enough to feed X amount of people". If you're not comfortable assigning, ask if they have a "famous dish" they make, or what they would be comfortable bringing (as to not overwhelm their cooking skills or budget). But you could also add a line for the group in general that their contribution should match the fact that they are getting a full Thanksgiving dinner.

There's a nice and tactful way to word all of this, but I'm too tired to think about it and type it out for you, lol.

→ More replies (2)

35

u/selinakyle45 13h ago

I feel like if you’re doing a dinner potluck like for thanksgiving you need to tell people what to bring. 

Most potlucks I host are more snack based so folks aren’t showing up expecting a full dinner and people can bring like hummus and chips which is easy to scale up. 

17

u/OkHistory3944 12h ago

Serving etiquette is non-existent at any buffet offering in general. I work at a place where food is frequently brought in for the shifts, often at a time which splits the two so the later shift has a chance to get food when they first come in. Someone usually (me) is appointed to be the bad guy, telling grown ass men they cannot pile their plate to high heaven or make a carton of “left overs” because the next shift hasn’t gotten a chance to eat yet. The amount of adults who are incapable of thinking of others is alarming.

32

u/Unreel123 7h ago

Who are these losers you are having potluck with, and how did you meet them.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/CaramelSecure3869 4h ago

Oh the taking leftovers like scavengers infuriates me!

→ More replies (3)

45

u/joker757 13h ago

There is a serious deficit of shame in society today. Bring it back to some kind of level after the overcorrection of the last 35 years.

28

u/LaceyLizard 13h ago

These things work because someone takes point and organizes who is bringing what. If no one does that then it's a flop.

→ More replies (3)

27

u/JuanFoYoMamma 11h ago • Bravo

Same with key parties. Potluck dinners and swinging should have kept going since the 60s.

→ More replies (7)

24

u/Fickle_Cricket3422 13h ago

Here is your bucket of chicken. Enjoy.

16

u/ManiacalShen 13h ago

A hot bucket of chicken is honestly a pretty great contribution. But even the laziest contribution that's still needed and used can be a good part of the pot luck ecosystem, as long as there's enough of it. It's the responsibility of the host to ensure a balanced spread

→ More replies (10)

87

u/StonedBooty 12h ago • Bravo

No one makes their food anymore, it’s all store bought

Went to my wife’s work 4th of July party and we were the only people that made the food we brought. Potato salad, macaroni salad, cake, etc all store bought still in the package and slapped on the table.

We made tiramisu and Watergate salad and felt very deflated when we saw all the hard plastic store stuff. Made me sad

28

u/caro9lina 12h ago

I know the feeling. I have lived in a neighborhood of mostly retired people for 30 years. The potlucks were amazing when most of the people were my mom's generation. All the food was homemade and delicious. Now most of the neighbors are my age and younger, and a lot of them are showing up with store-bought food in plastic containers. Most of these people are retired in recent years and their kids are grown. It seems as though they have time to shop and cook, but I guess most people have different priorities, and being proud of their cooking or what they offer their friends on a special day is just not important to them.

→ More replies (47)

55

u/Gryffindorphins 9h ago

Tbh, seeing the state some people leave the work kitchens in, and general hygiene habits (or lack thereof) I wouldn’t want to eat anything from their own kitchen anyway.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (66)

40

u/Angsty_Potatos 9h ago

Your friends would be shamed out of my group. 

We make spread sheets and tell people to account for the number of humans that will be in attendance so there is enough of everything 

→ More replies (3)

22

u/poopiesontoast 12h ago • Regret

Can someone tell me what the appropriate answer is when a friend offers to have you attend a potluck, but your fridge is empty and you don’t have money for groceries? I don’t wanna be a drag and say something like “I can’t afford to contribute to this.” And have them feel bad, nor do I want to continuously not attend things and make them feel like I don’t want to be around them… but most gatherings have these expectations and I just can’t afford it. Ya know?

55

u/chalkletkweenBee 12h ago

Tell the host your situation and offer to come over early and help setup, or help cook. Help how you can.

→ More replies (5)

21

u/Jooniebee425 3h ago

My husband signed up to bring sugar cookie cut outs. He came home and asked me to make them. I refused. He wrangled my son into helping but with the chilling, rolling, cutting, baking and decorating it took them several hours over two days. I think he learned his lesson.

→ More replies (1)

73

u/Crime_Dawg 3h ago

Y'all live in some trashy parts of town or have trashy friends / family. Every potluck I've done with friends has had such a ridiculous amount of food, we don't even come close to eating half of it. Nobody takes other's leftovers except their own, unless they just ask who made it. Tf kinda trailer trash potlucks are you having?

17

u/Stevie-Rae-5 3h ago

It never occurred to me that people would be entitled to leftovers from a dinner they didn’t host. That’s the truly mindblowing part for me.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/Informal_Ad2102 2h ago

From my experience it’s usually my most well-off “friends” that would show up empty-handed or with a bullshit measly offering. Particularly the ones that grew up with money. It’s the main reason I quit hosting and let a lot of friendships die.

→ More replies (9)

10

u/DranoTheCat 13h ago

Depends on your group of friends / social group. Building and maintaining that takes effort, but is so worth it.

Lots of people in the past decade or so seem pretty inept and incompetent at virtually everything social. I blame social media, but who knows.

60

u/NoOrchid2148 8h ago • Bravo

“Not enough servings of food. Someone would offer to bring mashed potatoes and would show up with one container for our group of 20+”

This is pretty normal though. Suppose 20 people attend a potluck. Suppose all 20 people brought 20 servings of one dish each. There would be 400 servings of individual foods, possibly 4 times as much as needed.

23

u/Escape-Volta 5h ago

This is the way.

I just attended a friendsgiving with 23 people where I made a corn salad. Probably enough corn for around 6 people. It was 90% finished by the end of the night.

When you have that many options, it’s just not realistic to assume you’re going to try everything there. I may have tried/tasted half the dishes people brought.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (32)

8

u/BobaEverythingBagel 13h ago

Time to make some Filipino friends. They’ll insist you pack multiple plates to go because there’s always way too much food.

7

u/jman2823 12h ago

I'm the same way, I always bring/make something for parties even if I'm told I don't have to bring anything. One of my cousins never got this common courtesy and she's old enough to know better especially considering everyone else in the family brings stuff. The worst was when she brought one package of those ready bake cookies (8 cookies total) unbaked, still in the package and expected to make it on the spot for a party of 20+ people...

→ More replies (1)

7

u/WeAreTheMisfits 3h ago

People aren’t taught to cook anymore. So they just don’t know how to cook I make desserts for my potlucks. Some people buy hot trays and some will cook. Others will bring the drinks or plates.

13

u/Elegant-Expert7575 8h ago

I work with a team of about 42 people.
I’ve been in the bathrooms with a lot of my co-workers, I know who washes properly and who doesn’t. No work pot lucks for me!

17

u/Odd-Wheel5315 13h ago edited 13h ago

Uneven contribution. A family of 5 show up with one dessert but would eat 5 servings of everything else.

This is actually a wonderful boon. Potlucks are cheap compared to eating out at restaurants. I'd rather cheap a-holes in my social circle out themselves by gorging at a potluck on something cheap I made. Instead of being included in a group dinner outing at a restaurant, and finding out their tactless behavior when they order 2-3 appetizers, down 3-4 alcoholic drinks, order an expensive entree, plus dessert, and then suggest we all split the bill evenly "to make things simple".

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Huge-Ad2263 11h ago

I think you just need different friends. I have a group where whenever we do potluck type events I have to beg them NOT to bring so much. Everyone wants to bring 2-3 different dishes and there's just too much food!

→ More replies (2)

21

u/rabbit_tomato_315 5h ago

OMG, I'm literally starting a new putluck dinner group because of this, and I want to make a clear set of expectations in the beginning so it's not awkward to kick someone out, 2 years into it. Especially since it was never an expectation in the beginning - it's more of a social thing than a cooking thing. But I do not enjoy putting the onus on a select few to prepare and bring homemade food while one person literally ONLY brings beverages to every meal.

We usually have 6 - 12 people attending each dinner every month via a rotating list of hosts, and we even have a sign-up sheet so people can indicate what they are bringing. For a long time now, only two of the households, including mine, would bring actual homemade food to the dinners; others would bring Trader Joe's salad mix or frozen dessert. Of course, I understand that life happens, but there is a difference between NEVER bringing anything homemade vs. occasionally needing to buy something to bring last minute.

So I'm starting a new one, and here are the expectations I have set:

  • A monthly dinner group for neighbors who are interested in cooking, baking, sharing, and conversing with other neighbors.
  • 6-8 people per dinner max, so we can have one conversation at a time.
  • Attendees must cook /bake and bring at least one item per household based on the sign-up sheet
  • Hosting duties rotate each month
  • No kids

Wish me luck because the new one starts in January.

6

u/CpuJunky I mean, c'mon 13h ago

6

u/Horror-Atmosphere-90 12h ago

I used to work with a guy who would always bring the weirdest stuff to a potluck… one time he brought a (single, unopened) can of campbells soup. One time he brought a (single) combo meal from Popeyes. Finally we decided that all potluck items would be assigned going forward 🤪

6

u/sweetart1372 12h ago

lol my Filipino family has the opposite problem. "Why is there so much food?! Everyone take home a lot of leftovers! I don't have fridge room!"

6

u/Business_Statement_5 12h ago

So I think it’s your friend group ☹️

6

u/wizardlegz 7h ago

I read this as a Hobbit hosting a bunch of Dwarves lol. You sound like a good person OP, I personally would just try to organize with people more.

16

u/MustacheSupernova 6h ago

When you have no friends, you don’t have to worry about silly shit like this.

2

u/Thayes1413 12h ago

My wife’s cousin showed up to the whole family, about 25 people, Easter dinner with two unopened boxes of Rice-A-Roni one year.

2

u/lazypotatosoup 10h ago

😮😮😮😮how can they even show their faces anymore? I would be so mortified

10

u/asyouwish 6h ago

Ideas:

Use a sign up sheet. List the items needed and have people sign up. There are sites that do this or you can use a Google sheet.

Stop inviting all freeloaders.

Stop having takeaway containers. Leftovers are a privilege for those who host. You cooked for two days and now you can take a day or two off.

Stop having potlucks. Cater the meal and sell tickets instead. Or make everything yourself and host less often.

Try hosted events. This month these two families will host. They pick the theme, plan the menu, decorate, cook, and have it at one of their homes. Next month, two different families do all of that.

Consider a progressive dinner where three families host (apps, meal, dessert/coffee). Rotate through everyone.

Anyone who is a bad guest gets selected to host next.

Set it up commune style. Assign jobs to each family: plan, shop, pay, cook, clean, etc. Those who would rather pay more and work less can do that. Those who can't pay as much, can do more labor.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/kurizma 13h ago

We have the exact opposite problem.  We always tell people to bring less food.  We have to make sure we have zip lock bags  or containers for pwolle to take food home or force people to take home what they brought because the fridge won't hold it all.  

I think you need new friends.  

5

u/Impressive-Side-9681 12h ago

you need better friends. In my world, potluck attendees bring enough for at least 6-10 servings, and they aren't bringing 6-10 people.  Which means the more people you invite, the more food there is

5

u/madkins007 12h ago

CROWD-SOURCED MEAL (CSM).

The New, Universal Rules of A CSM Are...

  1. The host will decide if everyone is assigned a type of dish, has a sign up sheet for dishes, or guests bring whatever they wish.

1a. The host will also determine the number and age ranges of guests, as well as how formal the event is and other activities to be held (and may ask or deputize others to assist.) the host is responsible for sharing this information.

2. A "Dish" may be food, drink, or necessary supplies. All dishes should be of roughly equal value, and the value is commensurate with the audience and kind of gathering.

2a. Example- a few friends over for football would chip in about $5-10 bucks each. An informal office event would more likely be $10-20. A big family holiday might be $20-30.

3. Each invited prison is expected to bring enough of the dish to feed about a third of the invited guests.

3a. Young kids count as half. Teens, especially boys, count as 1.5 to 2.

4. You are responsible for bringing any serving utensils, special condiments or sides, etc unless previous arrangements have been made.

4a. Remember that stoves, power plugs, and counter/fridge space may be limited and plan accordingly. This includes before and after the event as well. An example might be everyone's needing to share an office or small apartment fridge before and after, or six people bringing crock pots.

4b. You are also responsible for bringing your supplies and leftovers home, again unless previous arrangements have been made.

4c. Leftovers remain the possession of the bringer unless they special decide otherwise. No one can make a plate for later, etc, without their permission.

5. It is the shared responsibility of the host and guests to communicate food allergies, and to mark food appropriately.

6. People who bring home-made dishes are encouraged, but not required, to share their recipe. It can be on paper, through a QR code, shared online, etc.

7. It should go without saying, but- observe all safe food handling rules and dining etiquette. Each owner should keep an eye on their contribution during the event.

9

u/StinkyCheeseMaam 6h ago

Potlucks require planning and deligation. I have started taking some over for my church (400-500 people attending these events sometimes) and I deligate the heck out of it. Emails and sign up sheets, follow ups, etc. At home even, my spouse and I have huge extended families, I assign dishes or again ask them to sound off what they're bringing in a group chat then make a compiled list and send it out so we are clear on the plan

12

u/AlexGdl19 5h ago

Every group needs a Monica...

→ More replies (2)

8

u/EmperorBamboozler 13h ago

Sounds like bad communication to me. Start a group chat, tell people what they need to bring and be specific. People are doing this because there isn't a standard, so set one. X people do main dishes, x people bring sides, x people are on veg or hors d'oeuvres. Every potluck keep it on this standard, if people know what to expect and have parameters of what is expected and they can plan/prepare accordingly.

Going by "vibes" is a death knell for a good potluck. Everyone should have the freedom to bring what they want but it should fit the needs (and theme if you have one) of the larger group. It'll stop 20 people showing up with dip, cause if you let people do whatever they want without direction that shit is gonna happen.

4

u/Daisydo789 9h ago

My favorite is when someone brings one bag of cheap rolls-at least get two and bring a tub of butter if you are being so tacky.

4

u/nottrynagetsued 8h ago

How tf are yall not communicating? How are yall friends with people who lack basic human decency?

4

u/Aggravating_Luck_354 5h ago

I usually go to potlucks of 20+ people, I am the baker, so I just bake 1-2 kinds of cookies with the similar base dough, that makes around 16-ish cookies a batch, and something that can be cut, like a sheet cake/loaf, etc. I am aware that it isn't enough if everyone wants to take a portion of each, however, there's still enough dessert if everyone decides to try 2 things. I wouldn't dare to show up with 16 cookies to a potluck with more people than servings 😅

4

u/drivingthelittles 5h ago

I do an annual barbeque every year that is potluck. It went very well until I invited my cousins and I opened the bag they brought and there was one freezer burned pork chop still frozen two freezer burned minute steaks still frozen. And half a bag of pie pierogies freezer burned also.

I had to make new rules and it was only because of my own family

4

u/itdoes_doesntit 2h ago

In our family, you always offer to bring something. Even if the host had it all planned out, at least a bottle or 2 of wine.

Those who did not actively cook the meal, willingly & cheerfully do clean up, which includes hand washing and hand drying, all food put in containers, and everything put away. Period. End of sentence.

If you’re a slug who does nothing, you get shamed. Or not invited back.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Penis-Dance 13h ago

I used to like potlucks but now I hate them. Once you know, you know why.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Material-Injury-1259 9h ago

my sons school was having a potluck - no one was bring buns i found out late about the event- the day of i was asked if i could bring buns- i went home and made 500 buns 2 for each attendee - imagine my surprise when most parents brought take out and not homemade!

3

u/lazypotatosoup 9h ago

Oh wow. Kudos to you for making 500 buns from scratch! I feel like most schools in our area only allowed packaged food with list of ingredients due to allergy

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)