Congrats to Stevenson (PACT) for being ranked the 14th-best public school in CA on PACT’s 30th year since its founding:
https://www.usnews.com/education/k12/california/stevenson-elementary-248106While families' educational backgrounds do lift schools in the rankings, many schools with equal or higher educational backgrounds rank lower, so Stevenson’s teachers, parents, and students have many reasons to celebrate the work they do to make their school uniquely wonderful.
While Stevenson should celebrate this recognition, the school board should ask bigger questions at its upcoming December 17 board meeting about the future of choice programs. What is the reasoning behind offering each choice program, and why are the educational opportunities it provides not available at our neighborhood schools?
I believe the answers to these questions may differ significantly for Mistral and Stevenson.
While I wish all our elementary schools offered language study, particularly given how readily children in other countries demonstrate the transformative benefits of learning multiple languages (Spanish, hopefully one day, Chinese) at an early age, I believe it is important that families who want language immersion have that option at Mistral. It is also worth recognizing that Mistral serves a diverse student population (nearly double the district average; Mistral is 57% socioeconomically disadvantaged, district 31%).
Stevenson, however, raises a different set of questions. If families choose Stevenson because it is the district's highest-performing elementary school, that is a 100% justified reason for parents, but not a justified reason for a school board. Approximately 85% of Castro students are socioeconomically disadvantaged, compared with approximately 14% at Stevenson. The district and Stevenson staff and parents have worked on diversity outreach and weighted admissions; to be clear, no one is trying to exclude students from Stevenson. Outreach has failed for many reasons, including the perception that families must donate and volunteer (both of which are encouraged but not required, and any remaining impression of either does need to stop), lack of district transportation from Castro to Stevenson, and cultural familiarity/infamiliarity. There is a lot of agreement on this issue, so this particular issue doesn’t need as much attention as the second issue.
The second reason families give for choosing Stevenson is that their children's needs are not being met at their neighborhood schools. When families say their children need more hands-on projects, differentiated instruction, or social-emotional learning, these are needs that every neighborhood school can and should address. They should not require enrollment in a choice program, but as long as the “MVWSD Way” is a move towards more standardized instruction rather than PBL, differentiation, SEL, and parent involvement, so we should celebrate that Stevenson continues to offer a different approach.
What though is the long-term justification for maintaining Stevenson as a separate parent-participation, project-based, social-emotional learning choice school? If Stevenson is intended to serve as a laboratory for educational innovation, then the results of those experiments must cross-pollinate throughout the district. Successful practices should spread to our neighborhood schools rather than remain isolated within one campus.
But why was parent participation as a mission reason enough to found Stevenson in 1996, but not enough of a mission to continue it 2026? When PACT was founded before becoming Stevenson, it was a very small school that was actively run by teachers and parents, similar to many preschools; this is not the case now, as the district’s largest school. Running the district's largest school as a parent-involved school has policy and equity impacts the board has to respond to.
I would argue that, there is every reason to preserve Stevenson. As long as our other schools are not given the opportunity or support to embrace these educational philosophies and practices desired by families, families deserve the choice to seek them at Stevenson. Where neighborhood schools to embrace Stevenson’s PBL, differentiation, welcoming parent leadership, and SEL, I believe Stevenson could still have a compelling future role as a choice school, but a school dedicated to gifted education, particularly for twice-exceptional 2/e children, if and only if MVWSD can develop a rigorous and equitable identification process that does not disproportionately advantage students from particular ethnic, linguistic, or socioeconomic backgrounds. The world and Mountain View need schools that unlock the full potential of every child no matter their neighborhood.
I don’t think PBL, differentiation, parent involvement, and SEL are reasons for a separate school for the future of MVWSD, but as controversial as it may be, a truly diverse (neuro-friendly) gifted school and language immersion choice school very much meet the demands of the future.
That, along with dreams of Castro being a STEM school, but that’s a whole other discussion. Please share your own thoughts on this topic.
u/cozyportland (Chris Chiang)