A lot can be and has been said about how AI affects students; a lack of critical thinking, problem solving skills, motivation, etc... I think it's all true and I do think we bear some responsibility here.
That being said, I do not hear much about how AI has affected instruction. I am a graduate student in STEM and I am shocked at how blasé teachers have become;
- poorly constructed lecture slides
- a lack of precision on what is expected of us
- choosing breadth of topics over depth into any one of them
- never trying to engage the class
- never saying anything or getting upset when people talk in class, show up late, goof off on their phones or computers, etc.
I went to undergrad from 2013-2017 and everything was different. The entire contract between students and teachers was that as long as we worked hard, followed their lead, we would learn and get good grades. Now, It's almost as if they expect their students to use AI/cheat on HW and tests, so what's the point?
For example: I'm in a difficult upper level math course. The lectures are dense, fast paced, incomplete, and the teacher makes no effort to take the class temperature on whether or not people are really understanding anything, so he often just rambles into a bunch of blank stares. 50-75% of the students only come to class on quiz and test days, during which many of them shamelessly use AI (even during pen and paper portions). The teacher notices, but doesn't do anything about it.
The result is that the class GPA is artificially (heh) inflated in a class that would normally be curved. So the students who win are the extra gifted and the cheaters. The ones who lose out are the ones who work hard, but don't want to cheat. That's completely fucked.
I get we're all going through this hellish technological revolution together, but I do think we're justified in thinking we deserve better.