r/musicalscripts • u/sdb100224 • 16h ago
Submission [SUBMISSION] Stars in Your Eyes 1939 libretto
For the Musical Theatre scholars in the group I present to you a labor of love. I got my hands on a copy of the manuscript for the Ethel Merman/Jimmy Durante musical, STARS IN YOUR EYES from 1939. I venture to say the show was a flop as it only ran from Feb 9, 1939–May 27, 1939 (127 performances). With Music by Arthur Schwartz, Book by J. P. McEvoy and Lyrics by Dorothy Fields, this two act musical is set entirely on a movie studio sound stage and was staged by Joshua Logan. Other famous and semi-famous names in the cast included Mildred Natwick, Richard Carlson, Mary Wicks, Dan Dailey, Jerome Robbins, Nora Kaye (wife of Herbert Ross and formerly engaged to Jerome Robbins) and Maria Karniloff (later known as Maria Karnilova).
There is a recording of some of the songs on an album double-billed with the musical, Red, Hot and Blue that can readily be found online.
I’ve cleaned up a lot of the punctuation and some typos and added the poster as a cover but tried to keep it as close to the original as possible. Just for fun I also included a few of the technical pages at the end.
The show is very much of its time with cultural references from 1939. Merman was her brassy self as a difficult movie star and Jimmy Durante played a script editor or writer (I’m not sure) but his dialog was written almost verbatim as he spoke it and for those who know, was very much a part of his personality with the malapropisms. I didn’t go looking for the score but thought I would share this find with you.
--------
From the Dorothy Fields website: "The creative process was a troubled one, with the show’s original conception being radically altered by director Joshua Logan, who removed the left-wing political comment which had originally featured strongly. Songs were cut and replaced, and the piece emerged as a lively romantic comedy taking place in Hollywood.
Some serious songs remained, such as the rueful, resigned I’ll Pay The Check, delivered by Ethel Merman. The cast was a great asset, featuring not only Merman but Jimmy Durante; the pair had a show-stopping number in It’s All Yours, during which they repeatedly interrupted the chorus with wisecracks, jokes and ad-libs.
It’s All Yours was a throw-away number, but some of the other numbers represented Dorothy’s first foray into writing lyrics integrated with the characters and plot of a show.
The show was moderately well received by critics, but lasted less than four months."
--------
I love reading these vintage librettos and if you have anything similar, SHARE!
If you see something egregiously wrong with my cleaned up version, let me know and I’ll cross-reference my original scans to see if I can decipher any mistakes.