I’ve been thinking about an alternative to a conventional wealth tax: instead of trying to value every mansion, private company, painting, yacht, etc., why not start by taxing very large holdings of debt?
Every debt is also an asset owned by somebody. Mortgages, bonds, business loans, consumer debt, government debt, student loans, and so on all have creditors on the other side.
My basic proposal would be:
- The first $10 million of debt claims beneficially owned by an individual would be exempt.
- Above $10 million, a progressive annual tax would begin at around 1%.
- The rate would rise as creditor holdings become more concentrated, eventually reaching something like 30% on the portion above $100 million.
- The tax follows the ultimate beneficial owner, not the corporation, trust, pension fund or shell company holding the debt on paper.
- A pension fund with $10 billion in bonds owned on behalf of hundreds of thousands of workers would therefore allocate those holdings among its members. Most workers would remain nowhere near the $10 million threshold.
- A family trust holding $500 million for three people would attribute the appropriate share to those three people.
The other part I think is important is transparency.
If the creditor cannot demonstrate who ultimately owns the debt, the maximum rate would apply until the ownership chain is disclosed.
That gives banks, trusts, funds and offshore structures a very strong reason to disclose who actually benefits from the debt.
Foreign residence wouldn’t eliminate the tax either. If you own a Canadian debt claim, the tax attaches to that claim. Moving to the Cayman Islands shouldn’t make a Canadian borrower’s debt suddenly exempt.
I’d also change what happens when debts are sold.
Suppose you owe $10,000 and your creditor sells the debt to a collection company for $2,000. I think the purchaser should only be entitled to recover $2,000 of principal, plus the contractual interest while that money remains outstanding and legitimate collection costs.
The debtor should also have the right to pay off the remaining purchase value at any time.
So if a distressed debt is genuinely worth twenty cents on the dollar when financial institutions trade it among themselves, the person who actually owes the money should eventually get the benefit of that market price too.
The buyer can still make money through interest and by taking the risk of buying distressed debt. What they shouldn’t be able to do is pay $2,000 for $10,000 of principal and then use the legal system to demand the entire $10,000.
Finally, I’d make deliberate concealment expensive.
If someone intentionally evades the creditor tax and a private whistleblower provides evidence that results in recovery, I’d impose a multiple of the evaded tax as the penalty and give a substantial portion of the recovery to the whistleblower. That gives accountants, employees and insiders a very strong incentive to expose hidden beneficial ownership.
The philosophy behind it is basically:
Tax usury, not usefulness.
I don’t want to heavily tax someone because they built a successful Canadian company, invented something useful, built housing or invested equity in productive businesses.
I do think there is a legitimate public interest in preventing a tiny number of people from accumulating hundreds of millions or billions of dollars in claims against everyone else.
And if this pushed large debt portfolios toward pension funds, credit unions, mutual funds and other broadly owned institutions, I’d consider that a feature. The creditor income would increasingly accrue to millions of workers rather than a very small creditor class.
I’m not suggesting this solves inequality by itself. I’m wondering whether it could be a first step that is easier to measure and enforce than a comprehensive wealth tax.
What am I missing? Would you support something along these lines, and what would you change?