r/negotiation • • 16h ago

Told that I lowballed my own salary

9 Upvotes

TL;DR: Four months in to my new job and my boss and a coworker both said I low-balled myself, I'd like to ask for a raise

I work as a junior at a startup. I applied for this job on a whim and didn't actually expect to move through the process (so did not prepare well for the salary negotiation). During the interview process I gave 75-85k as my salary expectation, and they offered 85k - which I accepted. I've been working for about 4 months now, this is my first corporate job but I previously interned at a well known company.

  • A month in, a coworker told me they can see my salary and that I deserve higher pay.
  • Last week, my boss told me that when the role was created it was budgeted with a higher salary, and insinuated that I low-balled myself.

Both comments were casual and I think they were meant kindly. I like my job and boss, I recognize I have a lot of freedom and room for growth. I processed the first comment back then and took it as a lesson, but I'm upset again as even my boss mentioned it too.

I asked my boss the same day about performance reviews and got no direct answer. I also asked about bonuses. They said bonuses depend on revenue (which is not particularly great this year). I also know that since there were many rounds of layoffs recently everyone got a pay bump except for me (as I was still in my probation at the time), the CEO mentioned in a meeting that she would like to pay everyone the 75th percentile.

My plan is to ask my boss to set a time before the Christmas break for a 6-month performance (and compensation) review, is that reasonable?

TIA.


r/negotiation • • 4h ago

Should I negotiate ?

3 Upvotes

Hi all,

so I just received an offer letter for an analyst position after months of job searching (yay). During my interview with HR, I got asked for the compensation range I was looking for and I said 70-80k based on brief research and my skills/experience and I also have a master’s degree.

I then had a follow up interview with the hiring manager and he asked if i spoke to HR about salary and I said yes. He was like okay great. He went on to say that he makes sure his employees are paid because then everyone is happy yada yada, and in the end it’s not coming out of his pocket. Today I received the official offer of 60k, no sign on bonus either or anything.

I know I have limited experience as this is a new industry to me but I do learn fast and I believe I have transferable skills/experience. I just don’t know if it’s smart to negotiate in this market, given I’ve been looking for months and currently work part time.

I appreciate any tips, thanks!