r/negotiation • u/coconutchickpeacurry • 16h ago
Told that I lowballed my own salary
TL;DR: Four months in to my new job and my boss and a coworker both said I low-balled myself, I'd like to ask for a raise
I work as a junior at a startup. I applied for this job on a whim and didn't actually expect to move through the process (so did not prepare well for the salary negotiation). During the interview process I gave 75-85k as my salary expectation, and they offered 85k - which I accepted. I've been working for about 4 months now, this is my first corporate job but I previously interned at a well known company.
- A month in, a coworker told me they can see my salary and that I deserve higher pay.
- Last week, my boss told me that when the role was created it was budgeted with a higher salary, and insinuated that I low-balled myself.
Both comments were casual and I think they were meant kindly. I like my job and boss, I recognize I have a lot of freedom and room for growth. I processed the first comment back then and took it as a lesson, but I'm upset again as even my boss mentioned it too.
I asked my boss the same day about performance reviews and got no direct answer. I also asked about bonuses. They said bonuses depend on revenue (which is not particularly great this year). I also know that since there were many rounds of layoffs recently everyone got a pay bump except for me (as I was still in my probation at the time), the CEO mentioned in a meeting that she would like to pay everyone the 75th percentile.
My plan is to ask my boss to set a time before the Christmas break for a 6-month performance (and compensation) review, is that reasonable?
TIA.