Hey Niagara! 👋
Winter is just around the corner, and if you've lived in Niagara long enough, you've probably seen what a good winter storm can do to our trees.
So this week's question is:
“Can snow and ice damage a perfectly healthy tree?”
Absolutely!
And this is something that surprises a lot of homeowners.
A tree can be healthy, have no significant decay or structural defects, and still lose branches during a winter storm.
Unfortunately, trees don't get to head inside, turn up the heat and wait for the storm to pass like the rest of us. 😂
So why does that happen, and is there anything we can do to reduce the chances?
Let's get into it!
❄️ Snow and ice can add a tremendous amount of weight
Think about how much heavier a shovel full of wet snow is compared to light, fluffy snow.
Now imagine that weight across a whole tree canopy.
Wet snow can accumulate on branches, particularly on evergreens that hold their foliage throughout winter.
Freezing rain is another story.
Ice can coat branches from top to bottom, adding significant weight across the entire canopy.
And unlike snow, ice can cling to branches even when the wind picks up.
A branch that can comfortably support its own weight might not be able to support the additional load from a significant ice storm.
Even if that branch is completely healthy.
🌳 Some trees are more susceptible than others
Not all trees respond to snow and ice the same way.
Species, branch structure, age, previous pruning and overall condition all play a role.
For example:
Silver Maple and Manitoba Maple can be more susceptible to branch failures, particularly where they have developed weak unions or long, heavily extended limbs.
Eastern White Pine can experience significant damage from heavy, wet snow, especially when snow accumulates on its branches.
Spruce and Cedar can also suffer from snow loading, including bent or broken branches.
But remember, these are general tendencies.
A well-structured Silver Maple might handle a storm better than a poorly structured tree of a species normally considered stronger.
The individual tree matters.
🌲 What about weak branch unions?
This is one of the things arborists pay close attention to.
Some trees develop branches or multiple stems that grow very close together, creating narrow, V-shaped unions.
In certain cases, bark becomes trapped between the stems as they grow.
We call this included bark.
Unlike a well-formed union with strong wood connections, included bark can reduce the strength of the attachment.
Now add the weight of ice or wet snow.
That extra load can be enough to cause a weak union to split.
But not every V-shaped union is defective, and not every U-shaped union is automatically strong.
We need to assess the actual structure of the tree.
✂️ Can pruning help prevent winter storm damage?
Sometimes, yes.
Proper structural pruning can help reduce certain risks.
For younger trees, we can encourage stronger branch structure and reduce the development of competing stems.
For mature trees, selective reduction pruning may help reduce loading on particular limbs or unions.
But here's an important distinction:
Pruning can reduce risk. It cannot make a tree storm-proof.
And removing large amounts of healthy foliage or topping a tree isn't the answer.
In fact, poor pruning can create additional structural problems down the road.
Trees don't need a winter haircut just because the snow is coming. They need pruning that serves a purpose. ✂️
🧊 Should I knock the snow or ice off my branches?
This is a question we hear quite often.
And the answer depends on what you're dealing with.
Light, fluffy snow?
If it's safely reachable from the ground, gently brushing snow off a small shrub or young tree may help prevent branches from bending excessively.
But be careful.
Branches become more brittle in cold temperatures, and aggressive shaking or striking can cause damage.
Ice? Leave it alone.
Trying to knock ice off branches can cause them to break, especially when they're already under significant stress.
And standing underneath ice-covered trees is not a good place to be.
Generally, it's safer to let the ice melt naturally.
As tempting as it might be to help your tree out, sometimes the best tool for the job is a little patience and a warmer forecast!
⚠️ What if a branch breaks during a storm?
First, keep your distance.
A broken branch doesn't always fall all the way to the ground.
Sometimes it becomes lodged in other branches, leaving it suspended overhead.
We call these hangers.
They can be unpredictable.
A branch may look stable but shift or fall without much warning.
If a tree has split, developed a significant lean, or has large broken branches suspended overhead, keep people away from the area until it can be assessed.
And if branches are touching or near electrical wires, stay clear and contact the utility.
Never attempt to remove branches involving electrical lines yourself.
🌳 Does storm damage mean the tree needs to be removed?
Not necessarily!
We've worked on trees that have lost significant branches but were still reasonable candidates for retention.
And we've seen trees where a single failure exposed a much more serious structural concern.
It depends on things like:
- How much of the canopy was lost
- Where the failure occurred
- Whether the main trunk or structural unions were damaged
- The species and overall health of the tree
- Whether the remaining structure can be reasonably managed
- What's underneath the tree
Sometimes corrective pruning is enough.
Sometimes a more detailed assessment is needed.
And sometimes removal really is the most reasonable option.
A broken branch doesn't automatically mean a dead or dangerous tree.
The takeaway
Even healthy trees can experience damage during heavy snow, freezing rain and strong winter winds.
That's simply part of living in a climate like ours.
Proper pruning and good structural development can help reduce certain risks, but no arborist can guarantee that a tree will never fail.
If we get a significant winter storm here in Niagara, remember:
Don't stand underneath heavily loaded branches.
Don't try to break ice off your trees.
Keep clear of broken or hanging limbs.
And if you're unsure whether your tree has suffered structural damage, have it assessed before attempting cleanup.
The goal isn't to eliminate every possible risk.
It's to understand the tree, identify reasonable concerns and make informed decisions.
Next week we'll be covering:
Week 25 — “Why do some trees keep their leaves all winter?” 🍂🌳
Have you ever noticed an Oak or Beech tree holding onto its brown leaves long after the other trees have dropped theirs?
We'll explain a process called marcescence, why it happens, and whether it's something homeowners should be concerned about.
If you've got a question about your trees, feel free to drop it below!
A lot of these posts come directly from conversations we have with homeowners around Niagara.
— Driftwood Tree Service 🌲