r/npv • u/BrewerBeer • 11h ago
r/npv • u/Joeisagooddog • Feb 25 '23
Timeline of Path to 270+
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact (NPVIC) requires a number of signatory states that possess a majority of electoral votes (270 out of 538 EVs) before becoming effective.
Current pro-NPVIC legislative activity
Current anti-NPVIC legislative activity
Currently Enacted (222 EVs)
Maryland (10) - Signed by Gov. O'Malley on April 10, 2007.
New Jersey (14) - Signed by Gov. Corzine on January 13, 2008.
Illinois (19) - Signed by Gov. Blagojevich on April 7, 2008.
Hawaii (4) - Legislature overrode veto on May 1, 2008.
Washington (12) - Signed by Gov. Gregoire on April 28, 2009.
Massachusetts (11) - Signed by Gov. Patrick on August 4, 2010.
District of Columbia (3) - Signed by Mayor Fenty on December 7, 2010.
Vermont (3) - Signed by Gov. Shumlin on April 22, 2011.
California (54) - Signed by Gov. Brown on August 8, 2011.
Rhode Island (4) - Signed by Gov. Chafee on July 12, 2013.
New York (28) - Signed by Gov. Cuomo on April 15, 2014.
Connecticut (7) - Signed by Gov. Malloy on May 24, 2018.
Colorado (10) - Signed by Gov. Polis on March 15, 2019.
Delaware (3) - Signed by Gov. Carney on March 28, 2019.
New Mexico (5) - Signed by Gov. Lujan-Grisham on April 3, 2019.
Oregon (8) - Signed by Gov. Brown on June 12, 2019.
Minnesota (10) - Signed by Gov. Walz on May 24, 2023.
Maine (4) - Gov. Mills allowed bill to pass without veto on April 15, 2024.
Virginia (13) - Signed by Gov. Spanberger on April 13, 2026.
2027 - 2028 Legislative Session (65 EVs)
Nevada (6) - Democrats have control of the Assembly and the Senate. To gain a trifecta, they need to maintain control of the Assembly and the Senate in 2026, while flipping the governorship.
Current Nevada Assembly Breakdown: Democrats 27 - Republicans 15
Current Nevada Senate Breakdown: Democrats 13 - Republicans 8
(Alternatively, in 2026, Democrats could flip 1 seat in the Senate and 1 seat in the Assembly to achieve a legislative supermajority with which they could override the governor's veto during the 2027-2028 Legislative Session.)
Michigan (15) - Democrats have control of the governorship and the Senate. To gain a trifecta, they need to maintain control of the governorship and the Senate in 2026, while flipping 4 seats in the House.
Michigan House Breakdown: Republicans 58 - Democrats 52
Michigan Senate Breakdown: Democrats 19 - Republicans 18 - Vacant 1
Pennsylvania (19) - Democrats have control of the governorship and the House. To gain a trifecta, they need to maintain control of the governorship and the House in 2026, while winning 16 of the 25 Senate seats up for election in 2026.
Current Pennsylvania House Breakdown: Democrats 102 - Republicans 99 - Vacant 2
Current Pennsylvania Senate Breakdown: Republicans 27 - Democrats 23
Arizona (11) - Democrats have control of the governorship. To gain a trifecta, they need to maintain control of the governorship in 2026, while flipping 4 seats in the House and 3 seats in the Senate.
Current Arizona House Breakdown: Republicans 33 - Democrats 27
Current Arizona Senate Breakdown: Republicans 17 - Democrats 13
Wisconsin (10) - Democrats have control of the governorship. To gain a trifecta, they need to maintain control of the governorship in 2026, while flipping 5 seats in the House and 2 seats in the Senate.
Current Wisconsin Assembly Breakdown: Republicans 54 - Democrats 45
Current Wisconsin Senate Breakdown: Republicans 18 - Democrats 15
New Hampshire (4) - To gain a trifecta in New Hampshire, Democrats need to flip the governorship, 19 seats in the House, and 5 seats in the Senate in 2026.
Current New Hampshire House Breakdown: Republicans 214 - Democrats 178 - Independent 1 - Vacant 7
Current New Hampshire Senate Breakdown: Republicans 16 - Democrats 8
*The addition of Virginia, Nevada, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Arizona, Wisconsin, and New Hampshire to the NPVIC would increase the total number of electoral votes of signatory states to 287.
Longshots, But Achievable
Texas (40) - To gain a trifecta, Democrats must take the governorship, flip 14 seats in the House, and win 9 of 16 Senate seats up for election in 2026.
Current Texas House Breakdown: Republicans 88 - Democrats 62
Current Texas Senate Breakdown: Republicans 18 - Democrats 12 - Vacant 1
Georgia (16) - To gain a trifecta, Democrats must take the governorship, flip 11 seats in the House, and flip 7 seats in the Senate in 2026.
Current Georgia House Breakdown: Republicans 99 - Democrats 79 - Vacant 2
Current Georgia Senate Breakdown: Republicans 33 - Democrats 21 - Vacant 2
*The addition of Virginia, Nevada, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Arizona, Wisconsin, New Hampshire, Texas, and Georgia to the NPVIC would increase the total number of electoral votes of signatory states to 343.
r/npv • u/imaginenohell • Jun 23 '26
Hillary Clinton Blasts 2016 Election Loss to Drump in Netflix Docuseries: ‘The Electoral College Is an Abomination’
Another bad editorial
David Marcus has an opionion piece at Fox News about NPVIC. I didn't have high expectations, but some passages jumped out at me for being particularly bad:
One could argue, and Democrats often do, that we already have a situation in which only a handful of swing states decide our recent presidential elections. But importantly, which states are swing states is not set in stone, as it would be with a compact.
(emphasis added). How would you have swing states under NPVIC? The only thing analogous to a swing state that I can think of is: now that we're getting closer and closer to passing NPVIC, some lucky state will be the tipping point, the one that gets us past 270, activates the compact, and changes the way candidates campaign.
And then there's this gem:
The upside to the swing state system is that it forces national campaigns to focus on the diverse regional interests of places like Pennsylvania, Michigan and New Mexico instead of simply trying to appeal to the entire nation all at once.
So he likes the fact that under the present system, some states matter more than others? This is the one I can't get past.
Another fearmongering op-ed
tl;dr: the author compares the NPVIC to Prohibition, which had a lot of unintended consequences (like the rise of organized crime) and says that NPVIC might do the same.
"Chaos": The author points out that different states have different rules on who may vote, and predicts that this will lead to chaos and equal-protection lawsuits.
This seems no different from what we have now. If a felon in one state is prohibited from voting, and feels that his rights have been violated because felons can vote in other states, then it seems to me that they can already bring suit. The NPVIC doesn't change anything from a legal standpoint.
The author also posits some hypothetical scenarios in which nonparticipating states mess with the vote totals. For instance, what if a state switches to a ballot where you vote not for a presidential candidate, but for an Elector? Or what if a state only releases vote totals for the candidate who won the state's popular vote?
Under the first scenario, it seems to me that if a state doesn't publish official tallies for each presidential candidate, then it is effectively saying that it doesn't want a say in who is elected. Its citizens will get mad and pressure the state legislature to fix things pronto.
Under the second, I can't see the citizens of any state being happy with not knowing the complete vote tally. This seems like it could also lead to the equal-protection lawsuits that the article warned about earlier.
r/npv • u/Famijos • Feb 09 '26
Map that shows how to get this passed (2026 Update)
r/npv • u/CuriousOutLoud • Jun 08 '25
Does NPV reply to volunteers?
Hey y’all, I tried reaching NPV earlier this year to get involved with volunteering. After numerous emails, calls/voicemails, and filling out their volunteer form with no response, I gave up. Has anyone else had that experience or know why they wouldn’t have replied?
I’m disappointed because I’ve been wanting to volunteer with them for years and finally have the capacity to do so.
Thanks!
r/npv • u/imaginenohell • Feb 11 '25
What activism is currently happening to enact NPV?
Swing state here and I’m looking into doing a ballot initiative for the compact to circumvent the legislature (who refuses to take it for a vote).
I’ve reached out to my lawmakers and the National Popular Vote website and their socials.
I tried the Green Party and ranked choice voting through multiple avenues and get crickets. RCV is on their platform but I can’t find any effort to enact it. NPV seems to have more momentum.
My question is how do I connect with others doing this work. I can rally people to sign the state ballot initiative—no problem there—but need an attorney to write it for my state.
I also need to know the other states are doing the same. Otherwise, it’s a waste of my time.
Where are the advocates? Thanks
r/npv • u/Lag_Incarnate • Nov 07 '24
Current 2024 election map if enacted and pending states followed NPV
r/npv • u/clinging2thecross • Nov 06 '24
Future of National Popular Vote Interstate Compact
In the 2024 election, it looks like every state which has passed the contract went Democrat this election but, due to the Trump winning the popular vote, Trump would’ve gotten an additional 209 electoral votes. Do you think this will affect the future of the NPVIC?
r/npv • u/dude_from_ATL • Nov 02 '24
Hear me out: now is the time to get swing states on board the compact!
People in swing states are so sick of the political ads right now, if you market joining the NPV compact as a way out I think they would overwhelming sign petitions to bring it to a vote. Essentially pitch the compact as a way to make candidates campaign across the entire US and not just our state.
r/npv • u/npvic4me • Oct 24 '24
National Popular Vote bill featured on The Daily Show
Check it out: Is America Ready to Bid the Electoral College Farewell? | The Daily Show
If you haven't written your state legislator about this, now is the time!
https://nationalpopularvote.com/write
r/npv • u/Traveledfarwestward • Oct 15 '24
When was the last time a presidential campaign fought to win your state?
State shenanigans
One category of criticisms of the NPVIC is what I think of as state shenanigans. For instance, North Dakota, as I recall, had a bill that would have withheld the state popular vote from the public until after it was too late for the NPV states to do anything about it.
The Cato Institute mentions the 1960 election, in which Alabamans did not vote for presidential candidate, but rather elected Electors. Since the constitution leaves elections pretty much up to the states, it's possible that one or more states might do something like the above, just to mess with the NPVIC or as some kind of protest.
How big a concern is this? The NPVIC text says,
At least six days before the day fixed by law for the meeting and voting by the presidential electors, each member state shall make a final determination of the number of popular votes cast in the state for each presidential slate and shall communicate an official statement of such determination within 24 hours to the chief election official of each other member state.
The chief election official of each member state shall treat as conclusive an official statement containing the number of popular votes in a state for each presidential slate made by the day established by federal law for making a state’s final determination conclusive as to the counting of electoral votes by Congress.
If I'm reading this correctly, this means, in effect, that if North Dakota were to withhold its vote totals until after the deadline, the member states would have to count this as if no votes had been cast in North Dakota at all. That is, North Dakota would effectively be saying that it doesn't want to have a say in the election. Likewise if Alabama were to switch back to direct election of Electors: there would be zero votes cast for any presidential candidate, and thus Alabama would effectively be withdrawing from the election.
Is my understanding correct? Have I overlooked anything? If I'm correct, then I think we can ignore these sorts of shenanigans, because everyone wants their vote to count, and so there'd be tremendous pressure to just report the popular vote on time, and not play stupid games.
r/npv • u/degenpiled • Sep 01 '24
The 2030 Apportionment Forecast will put the current Signatory States + "Likely" at 261 instead of the current 273, meaning only TX, GA, or WI in the "Possible" category also becoming signatories would bring the NPVIC to 270+. Thoughts?
r/npv • u/very_loud_icecream • Apr 03 '24
Maine [Maine] Legislature sends national popular vote proposal to Gov. Mills
r/npv • u/very_loud_icecream • Mar 20 '24
Maine Maine house tables effort to ditch the electoral college
r/npv • u/very_loud_icecream • Mar 14 '24
Maine Maine Senate passes the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact
"Fraud-cabining" anti-NPV argument
The Cato Institute has an article arguing that the Electoral College is better than a National Popular Vote in cabining fraud. That is, if someone suspects electoral fraud, either at the precinct level, or from on high (e.g., coming from the governor's office or the Secretary of State), investigators can currently concentrate their efforts on a handful of battleground states. Under a NPV, they would have to investigate all fifty states.
On top of which, it's easier to commit fraud when one party controls politics. And since battleground states are split close to 50-50 between Democrats and Republicans, they're more likely to have members of both parties in the legislature and at the board of elections, so they can watch each other for signs of fraud. I hope I've represented their argument fairly.
On the face of it, this does sound reasonable. It's obviously harder to look for fraud in many places than in a few.
The flip side of this is: currently, no one looks for large-scale presidential election fraud in Oklahoma or Mayland because no one thinks there is any in those states. And the reason for that is, there's no point in committing presidential electoral fraud in Oklahoma or Maryland, because there's no way to alter the vote count enough to yield even one Electoral vote. Someone could fraudulently change 100,000 Oklahomans' votes, and it wouldn't change the outcome. Which is another way of saying that those 100,000 Oklahomans' votes don't really count. I don't think there's any way around this: either someone's vote matters, so there'll be the temptation to alter it fraudulently, or else it doesn't, in which case the system is unfair.
So then what happens under NPV, when fraud can plausibly occur anywhere, not just in battleground states? For one thing, if the election is close (like Kennedy vs. Nixon), that's exactly when you want a careful recount to make sure every vote is counted correctly. If it isn't close, and candidate A is a million votes ahead of candidate B, then you'd need to demonstrate a million votes' worth of fraud to close the gap. Fraud on a large scale would have to be widespread, which makes it easier to detect.
If someone tried to flip a million votes in New York City from blue to red, that would ring alarm bells, and cause people to look for fraud. If, on the other hand, someone tried to flip a hundred votes in ten thousand precincts, that's ten thousand places where someone might notice the fraud and discover the nationwide network.
Add to this the fact that states and counties likely already have an interest in preventing fraud: even if the presidential results are entirely predictable, other races might not. If a state already has procedures to ensure that the election for alderman is conducted fairly, the same procedure likely applies to other elections, including that for president.
r/npv • u/BeavisAsCornholio • Mar 06 '24
Maine Maine House Passes National Popular Vote by 74-67 Vote
myemail.constantcontact.comr/npv • u/PLament • Feb 07 '24
Virginia Virginia HB375 (NPVIC) continuing over to 2025
https://lis.virginia.gov/cgi-bin/legp604.exe?241+sum+HB375
I watched the livestream because I was curious what happened. One person spoke supporting the bill, a bunch of people piled on comments in opposition to the bill, then everyone agreed to just continue the bill in 2025. My representative was not in the subcommittee.
What can I, as a Virginian, do to show my support for a bill like this?
The "Vote Dilution" anti-NPV argument
I've seen a new-to-me argument against the NPV recently. It has appeared in several places, including this opinion piece in the Bangor Daily News:
My vote is currently one among 929,017 registered voters in Maine. If this compact passes, it will be one among 161.4 million voters nationwide.
Of course, this isn't an apples-to-apples comparison: if the NPVIC passes, the author will exchange his 1/929,000 power to decide whom his state votes for, for a 1/161.4M power to directly affect who gets to be the next president.
Does anyone have any good rebuttals to this argument, preferably in a form that will fit in the comments in an online discussion on the topic? Or, alternately, if you think the author makes a good point, can you support it?