r/nycfood • u/sol5377 • 6h ago
The Greek FroYo Wars in NYC! My personal rankings...
- MYKA - They were one of the originals that got huge in Spain and Europe. I first tried their froyo in Mexico and it kind of blew my mind because of how different their tart was than traditional froyo in the usa. It was creamier and tasted way more premium. And the toppings (pistachio, olive oil, honey) took it over the top. I tried their 159 7th Ave S West Village location a bunch of times, long lines and all, and it cemented things for me... Myka is my favorite of the bunch.
- FIRA - Recently opened in Williamsburg Brooklyn (294 Bedford Ave) with a set-up and taste much like Myka. They have some unique toppings that Myka lacks and they said their froyo has 10g of protein per cup so that's interesting. The froyo was excellent here. A close 2nd for me.
- MIMI's - Mimi's seems to have been inspired by the famous Yo-Chi brand in Australia, right down to the color scheme and self-service set-up. It's really good though and there's lines at peak times. Mimi's has a sit down area which Myka lacks. There's also more candy style toppings here and way more flavor options. You can't go wrong with any of the top three.
- CULTURE - One of NYC's OG's, their greek frozen yogurt is more fruity and less creamy (and less thick). They have lots of fruit topping options and syrups. It's different from the top three but still good. 60 w 8TH St.
- GO GREEK - Located at 683 Broadway, their style is a hybrid one where you fill your own cups with greek froyo and then the workers add the toppings for you. Their yogurt wasn't as good as the top three and their toppings were a bit lacking (no pistachio sauce?)
- MADISON FAIRE - These folks were the second ones in NYC (after Culture) to offer Greek Froyo. They started with a dubai chocolate offering over tart. It was a strange mix at first but then it grew on you. They recently opened their 2nd location on 1 W 8th street. Their froyo is probably the creamiest out of the lot and, perhaps, the sweetest too.
There's a bunch more popping up seemingly every day all over NYC. Many restaurants and dessert shops are even adding greek froyo to their mix. I saw it in Glace yesterday but couldn't try it.