Disclosure: I'm the developer of Briskmail, a Mac app made only for Gmail and Google Workspace accounts. I'm asking because the answers shape what I build next.
The choices I see people using on a Mac:
- Gmail in a browser tab.
- Apple Mail with a Gmail account added over IMAP.
- A third-party mail app.
What I built talks to Gmail through Google's own API instead of IMAP. In practice that means labels stay labels instead of turning into folders, and snooze and Send Later are Gmail's own, so they match what you see on gmail.com and on your phone. It's a normal Mac app with Mac keyboard shortcuts, several accounts in one window, and AppleScript and Shortcuts support. Mail goes straight between your Mac and Google, with no server of mine in between.
It needs macOS 14 or later and costs $39 once. One honest caveat: Google is still reviewing the app, so sign-in shows a "Google hasn't verified this app" warning for now.
Two questions:
If you use Gmail on a Mac, which of the three setups above are you on, and what annoys you most about it?
What would a Mail replacement have to do before you'd trust it with your main account?
The app is called Briskmail if you want to look it up.