Hi there! I’m looking for some otome recommendations, there are so many choices out there and I’m hoping to find something that’ll really get me hooked instead of throwing out more and more money on something that I purchased based on vibes
Apart from those mentioned below, I already own Code: Realize and Cupid Parasite but haven’t played them yet. I’ve also been eyeing Virche Evermore, Taisho × Alice, and 9 R.I.P. I’d love to hear all suggestions. Gimme someone to simp for on the cold winter evenings 😤
Only English otomes, I have a Switch and a PC. No budget limit!
What games have you already played and what did you like and dislike about them?
I haven’t played that many, but here’s what I’ve tried so far:
Cinderella Phenomenon: One of my first otomes, and I liked it a lot! I replayed it at least twice. I found the plot really creative and engaging, and I loved how many interesting characters there were. I enjoyed most of the LIs, although I didn’t care much for Rod (I'm not generally that into younger or younger-looking LIs)
Collar × Malice: Enjoyed this a lot. I liked all the LIs and how different they were from one another. The plot wasn’t the most original or revolutionary for me, but the dynamics between the characters, the amount of interaction with the LIs, and how naturally the relationships developed made up for it. My favorites were Sasazuka and Shiraishi even though I didn't particularly like the conspiracy child-soldier thing with Shiraishi later on
Collar × Malice Unlimited: I enjoyed it, but found myself getting a little bored with the slice-of-life scenes. Nothing particularly bothered me, I just missed having some kind of more engaging plot to go along with the romance
even if TEMPEST: I finished Tyril’s route and dropped the game. I struggled to get invested in the story. The writing felt poor to me. While the individual plot points made sense kind of, the whole thing felt rather disjointed to me. It kept introducing new plot threads that seemed to come out of nowhere, and instead of making me curious, they just left me wondering what the point was
Olympia Soirée: I dropped it halfway through my first route (Yosuga). The romance felt like it came out of nowhere to me. I didn’t feel like the MC and LI had enough meaningful interactions for their feelings to make sense, so I just couldn’t buy into their relationship. The story itself seemed okay, but I wasn’t invested enough to keep playing
Mystic Messenger: I LOVE Mystic Messenger. I really liked the whole concept of real-time interactions, the pacing, and how naturally everything unfolded. The plot was also interesting to me. I loved the character dynamics and how involved I felt in everything that was happening. 707 was definitely my favorite LI
What’s more important in the story to you — plot or romance?
I’d say 50/50. I feel like a good plot makes a romance even better. I want a story that gives me a reason to care about both.
I like slow-burn relationships, believable chemistry, and seeing characters gradually grow closer. I don’t need constant romantic moments or fluff. I’d much rather have a relationship that feels earned. I LOVE romantic tension and a good buildup tho, moments where you can tell there’s something going on.
I’m also a fan of good worldbuilding. I love getting sucked into a world that feels interesting and fleshed out.
What character or plot tropes do you like? What preferences do you have in terms of genre and love interests?
I don’t think I have any particular must-have tropes. Good writing and convincing character dynamics matter much more to me. I’m fine with angst, darker themes, morally grey characters, and even yandere LIs. I do like a good slow burn though.
I also love when the whole cast feels like an actual group of people, with their own personalities and relationships. Banter, friendships, conflicts, all that stuff makes the story feel more natural to me.
I think I tend to like LIs with distinct personalities, interesting layers to uncover, and relationships that go beyond just straightforward romance. I really enjoy getting to know the LIs and slowly figuring out what makes them tick.
I do like fantasy, but I feel like so far I’ve enjoyed otomes set in more “normal” worlds more. I guess it’s because the fantasy ones I’ve played often just kept throwing random plotlines at me to make more stuff happen, even when half of it felt kinda unnecessary. I’m all for crazy fantasy stuff as long as it makes sense in that world and doesn’t feel like it’s there just for the sake of it. I think that’s partly why I loved Cinderella Phenomenon but couldn’t get into even if TEMPEST.
Do you have anything that you really dislike in otome games?
I like to believe I'm not particularly picky. If the story is good, I can put up with pretty much anything. Non-con is probably one thing I’d rather avoid in good endings. I can tolerate it in bad endings though.
I’m not a fan of “not like other girls” or damsel-in-distress type of MC, especially when that becomes the MCs entire personality. BUT I don’t need a super strong or badass MC either. I’m perfectly fine with shy, vulnerable, or even naive heroines, as long as they’re well-written, have a personality of their own, and their actions and relationships make sense
I'm also not particularly fond of time skips since I feel they disconnect us from the story and are sometimes kinda lazy BUT if the reason for the skip is logical then I'll be good with it
What do you consider value for your time and money?
I appreciate good art and a long, rich story. For context, I’m a huge Persona fan, so I’m used to long playthroughs with slow buildup. I don’t mind games without voice acting either.
---
Thanks for reading all this, hope it's not too much 😆 I’d loooove to hear what you’d recommend! ♡