r/paypal • u/CoderWolf161 • 5h ago
Help PayPal dispute failed despite providing requested information :c
So I purchased a Creality K2 Plus 3d printer. Long story short it has many faults, some potentially repairable, some inherent to the design. Even with fixes however it just doesn't live up to reasonable expectations.
Creality Service is completely brain dead, wasting time and hoping I'll give up. I went through PayPals dispute process and got to a stage where they emailed asking for:
"documentation supporting your claim the item is damaged or significantly not as described. You need to get a document (such as an estimate or invoice) from an unbiased third-party, such as a dealer, repair shop, appraiser, or another individual or organisation that is qualified in the area of the item in question (other than you)."
How is this practical? the printer is so heavy I can barely move it around the house, and PayPal wants me to take it out somewhere, ask someone if they mind spending potentially hours evaluating this printer as a favour?
I ended up finding someone who fits as an "individual that is qualified in the area of the item in question" that could come over. They wrote up a small document for me which I attached to the dispute.
Soon after the dispute was refused, with the email claiming:
"This decision was made because the dispute was submitted with insufficient information/documentation to support the claim and we were unable to obtain the required information/documentation after requesting it from you."
Throughout the whole process there was no response which wasn't generated. No human interaction. Noone I could ask what was wrong.
The email did contain this request for specific documentation but I followed the link back to the dispute expecting all the details would be there. The actual dispute page did not specify the documentation required so I didn't catch it at first, and attached a lot of information and images about how the printer had failed. Before receiving a response though, I caught the specific text in the email, had that documentation made, and went back to the dispute to add it, managing to do so within the specified time period and before a response had been made from PayPal.
So at this point I'm not even sure if it was somehow missed by not being in the first reply, or just wasn't valid somehow. Its all so frustrating, does anyone know whether I can continue the dispute?
This dispute is also a stage in the suggested legal process, so it seems unreasonable for PayPal to throw in this completely impractical process when I can provide all the documentation to show the printer is basically a paperweight.