Hey everyone,
I’m a self-taught beginner learning without a teacher. My current setup is a Roland digital piano and Piano Marvel, plus I have a classic Romanian beginner method book (Maria Cernovodeanu – Mica metodă de pian), which feels a bit too much like being thrown straight into playing pieces without enough structured explanation when you don’t have a teacher guiding you.
I’m trying to pick a solid adult method book to pair with Piano Marvel and decide between:
Alfred’s Basic Adult All-in-One Course (Level 1)
Faber Adult Piano Adventures All-in-One (Book 1)
From what I’ve gathered so far (and from AI/research), there seem to be some real trade-offs for someone learning solo:
Alfred is integrated into Piano Marvel’s library, which sounds super convenient for real-time feedback and rhythm, but I’ve read concerns that it can keep you in fixed hand positions (like C position) too long, risking finger-number habits instead of real note/interval reading, or leaning heavily on basic block/oom-pah accompaniment early on.
Faber is often praised for clearer explanations for self-learners, landmark notes/intervals, and more balanced hands early on, but it isn’t in Piano Marvel, so I’d be splitting my routine between the book and the app.
My main worry is not learning properly or picking up bad habits from either choice—whether that’s weak sight-reading, stiff technique/rhythm, or gaps in theory that a digital app doesn’t catch.
For those who learned or are learning on your own:
How and where did you actually learn? (Which books, apps, YouTube channels, websites, or routines worked best for you, and what did you skip?)
If you used Alfred or Faber alongside an app like Piano Marvel, how did you combine them without getting stuck in bad habits?
Did you feel one of them left noticeable gaps in your fundamentals (reading, rhythm, hand independence, theory)?
Anything you wish you had watched out for earlier as a self-taught beginner?
Thanks in advance for any honest advice!