r/PokeGrading • • Sep 12 '26

Do not promote apps / services via DM or comments

3 Upvotes

From now on if you want to promote your app or service you may do a post for this (as long as you do not spam). Do not ever promote your thing in other people’s posts, comments or DMs or we will ban and report.

If someone is soliciting you (such as Prestigious_Hair2530) please make sure to report them at https://www.reddit.com/report


r/PokeGrading • • Dec 10 '25

Toxicity, trolling and being rude will result in being banned from this subreddit

46 Upvotes

Despite this being one of our few rules here the mod team has seen a significant increase in people being toxic to each other.

We do not care if you love or hate any specific grading company and welcome constructive discussion around any of them.

If you cannot post or comment in a civil manner do not say anything at all. If someone disagrees with you that’s fine, don’t descent to insulting them.

If you see any post or comment breaking this rule, report it and the mod team will deal with it.


r/PokeGrading • • 2h ago

The Data Speaks — PSA Is UNGRADEABLE (for vintage)

Thumbnail
elitefourum.com
81 Upvotes

Recently a vintage collector on the Elite4 forum published a report summarizing his psa submission results for 1,250 cards spread across 21 submissions in the last five years. Each submission was essentially the same, being entirely composed of shadowless base set from sealed theme decks and all pulled straight from pack to sleeve. The results are eye-opening, but probably not too surprising to many on this sub. What's significant about the results is that for a change there's data to back up what many of us have suspected for some time now.

It's worth taking a look at the full report because there is so much more data and nuance to be picked up than in this simplistic chart below but the main takeaway is that his psa 10 count went from 58% submitted in 2022 to the current rate of only 4% submitted this year.

Year graded Cards (n) PSA 10 PSA 9 PSA 8 or lower
2022 618 58% 38% 3%
2023 240 60% 35% 5%
2024 74 43% 51% 5%
2025 none graded
2026 313 4% 56% 40%

r/PokeGrading • • 4h ago

Would PSA send it back?

Thumbnail
gallery
94 Upvotes

Gave an arm and a leg when this bad boy entered the playground. Time hasn’t been nice to it, but I still love it dearly.

But the question isn’t if I should grade it or not, because obviously I should, but would they even give me a grade? There’s no way of checking if it’s genuine lol


r/PokeGrading • • 4h ago

2004 Charizard EX Fire Red Leaf Green. Is this PSA grade justified?

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Hi all,

I just got my 2004 Charizard EX Fire Red Leaf Green graded from PSA (6), and was wondering if the grade is justified, and whether or not I should consider regrading it? I understand that folks are saying vintage cards are graded harshly, but is this a fair score?

It was Priority Tier so there are no grader notes for this one, but I have attached some photos that I have taken prior to submission and the final-view photos from PSA. I know it is not a 9 or 10, but I was expecting at least a 7 or 8.

I'm curious to know what the community thinks. Thank you.


r/PokeGrading • • 1h ago

Should I grade?

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

I’d really only expect about a five, but I’ve never graded and wanted opinions on if it could even earn itself a 5. I do want to raise value but also just want it encased because it looks great.


r/PokeGrading • • 1d ago

To the Card Shop owner who told me “this would 8 I’ll buy it though”, thanks for convincing me to grade it.

Thumbnail
gallery
324 Upvotes

Just received the notification that it’s on the way back from CGC, thinking about going to the shop to show the guy😭 Pop 4👌🏼

Edit - before you go in the replies and say “he meant PSA 8” I told the guy I was gonna go with CGC and he said they would still give it an 8.


r/PokeGrading • • 3h ago

Bought a card I was hoping to grade (shooting for an 8) Wondering if I got sent a fake.

3 Upvotes

It’s the holo, not the reverse so the whole card shine has got me worried. Should I send it back to the seller and leave feedback on eBay or am I in my head about this?


r/PokeGrading • • 1h ago

Beckett returns

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

Got my cards back
First time grading
Frustrating due to 8.5 centering causing big money damage


r/PokeGrading • • 3h ago

Found my old cards and believe I boiled it down to these 41 holding enough value to potentially grade.

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

I’m a novice at this but most of these cards seem to be in very good condition. Of course they are my cards so there may be a little bias in my judgment. What are your thoughts?


r/PokeGrading • • 32m ago

Grade this Charizard or not?

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

I wanted to send this in to get graded because from afar it looks perfect. I really tried to sit down for a while and just pick it apart, so I’ve noticed some flaws (pointed some out in red markups), but I don’t know know if it would still be worth grading or not. It’s not a 10, but 8 or 9? Help/advice would be deeply appreciated!


r/PokeGrading • • 48m ago

Thoughts?

• Upvotes

I’m thinking a PSA/TAG 9 due to centering. No other flaws. What do you think?


r/PokeGrading • • 54m ago

Should I get this graded?

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

I know Japanese cards have much better print quality than English. I was thinking about sending in a few cards to grade as well. I’m just unsure about this one as of right now. Let me know thank you!


r/PokeGrading • • 1h ago

Should i grade this?

Thumbnail
gallery
• Upvotes

Found this card in my old stuff and wanna know if its worth spending the time and money grading it.


r/PokeGrading • • 1h ago

PSA 10?

Post image
• Upvotes

I have a BGS 10 and BGS 9.5
Should I leave it as it is or crack the 9.5 and submit to PSA.
I hear crossover grading is a bad idea


r/PokeGrading • • 11h ago

Raikou EX Special Illustration Rare came back as 10!

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/PokeGrading • • 2h ago

Worth Grading? Just found these I’ve had since 99’

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Any opinions if these are worth grading? No idea what they are worth? Any input is appreciated. Thanks!


r/PokeGrading • • 2h ago

The most perfect card I've ever owned...

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/PokeGrading • • 1d ago

Keep it as it is or take the chance and send it to PSA?

Post image
124 Upvotes

r/PokeGrading • • 4h ago

Ripped a 25th UPC

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

All the cards were junk, but wondering if I should grade the metal


r/PokeGrading • • 4h ago

Può prendere psa 1?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/PokeGrading • • 8h ago

What would you grade this Espeon?

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

r/PokeGrading • • 5h ago

Just pulled from Delta Reign!

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/PokeGrading • • 5h ago

Never graded potentially DMG cards. Need help!

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

This Rayquaza ex is very nice, though it has some light creasing. I have never sent in non-NM cards, so I’m wondering what you all think PSA would grade this at?


r/PokeGrading • • 5h ago

Any ideas on potential grade?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Opened 1 pack of delta and got the chase lol safe to say i won’t be opening any more packs from this set.