r/politics • ✔ Bloomberg Government • 1h ago • Bravo 2 Heartwarming 1

No Paywall Seven Freshmen Democrats Vote Against Jeffries’ Leadership Bid

https://news.bgov.com/bloomberg-government-news/seven-freshmen-democrats-vote-against-jeffries-leadership-bid
7.8k Upvotes

818 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1h ago

As a reminder, this subreddit is for civil discussion.

In general, please be courteous to others. Argue the merits of ideas, don't attack other posters or commenters. Hate speech, any suggestion or support of physical harm, or other rule violations can result in a temporary or a permanent ban. If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them.

Sub-thread Information

If the post flair on this post indicates the wrong paywall status, please report this Automoderator comment with a custom report of “incorrect flair”.

Announcement

r/Politics is actively looking for new moderators. If you have an interest in helping to make this subreddit a place for quality discussion, please fill out this form.


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

•

u/bloomberggovernment ✔ Bloomberg Government 1h ago • Bravo

Seven incoming progressives said they voted against Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries to lead House Democrats in an internal caucus meeting Wednesday because they want party leadership to do more to reflect the demands of their constituents.

Jeffries (D-N.Y.) overwhelmingly won his caucus’ nod to become the House speaker in 2027, with 251 Democrats voting yes and 11 no, according to a lawmaker in the room. Most of those 11 holdouts are members-elect, according to a statement they published shortly after Jeffries won the nomination.

Rep.-elects Darializa Avila Chevalier, Adam Hamawy, Frederick Haynes, Melat Kiros, Donavan McKinney, Chris Rabb, and Claire Valdez were among the holdouts, who said the conversations with Jeffries about advancing their priorities are “ongoing.”

Read more in the full story.

-Elliot

•

u/vigouge 1h ago

What a biased frame. There are 84 freshman dems, so by my math that's 77 who voted for him.

•

u/mmDruhgs 5m ago

Is anyone challenging him? Like AOC said, she's voting for him because there's no other option.

→ More replies (1)

•

u/fury420 43m ago

I love how nobody bothers to point out that most of the big names in the House progressive caucus are backing Jeffries, including the lead sponsor and author of the current M4A legislation.

All while a handful of freshmen who've never met him and whose opinions of him are based on propaganda oppose him, and we're supposed to believe them over his colleagues in the progressive caucus that actually know and work with him?

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (19)

•

u/ShamrockAPD 1h ago edited 1h ago

Great. This is how we lose all momentum.

Edit- to be very clear. I’m talking about Jeffries getting the nod here.

•

u/HELP_IM_IN_A_WELL 1h ago

do you mean by electing Jeffries?

•

u/ShamrockAPD 1h ago

Yes.

•

u/HELP_IM_IN_A_WELL 1h ago

yeah, it's depressing.

I'm keeping the faith, we've still got energy to get the establishment dems out with the next primaries.

→ More replies (38)
→ More replies (1)

•

u/Describing_Donkeys 1h ago

Let's focus on removing Schumer. That can be done, but we have to make it crystal clear that it's really important to us to our senators.

→ More replies (13)

•

u/Zepcleanerfan 19m ago

Guys absolutely no one and I mean no one voted in these midterms based on who the house leadership was going to be.

People and bots on reddit and twitter care, but that's about it.

People want something to be done about prices and the affordability of healthcare and to end the iran war.

•

u/theradgadfly 1h ago

Can you consider that maybe your views are fringe and not popular?

→ More replies (7)

•

u/Immediate-Employ-952 57m ago

This is only a surprise to clueless imbeciles.

•

u/demi-paradise 36m ago

Jeffries ran unopposed, unfortunately. AOC has spoken about how difficult it is to challenge establishment Dems because of byzantine Congressional rules and internal party politics. I don't see the votes in his favor as betrayals of progressive momentum as they're not automatically enthusiastic endorsements. It don't think it was a bad political move to vote against him symbolically either. But it was a purely symbolic gesture.

It's imperative to learn how these systems work to combat misinformation that results in disillusionment. The only group that stands to win from purity testing the new batch of progressives over the Jeffries nom is the GOP. Whether Schumer makes it will be much more indicative of the battle up ahead.

•

u/wotguild 1h ago • Bravo

Or you realise you aren't part of the momentum? 11 to 251 LOL.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (8)

•

u/Jwalla83 Colorado 54m ago

Thank you Kiros, feels good to see my primary vote pan out to early action in line with my values.

•

u/drawkbox 4m ago

Darializa Avila Chevalier

She also wants the US out of NATO, support of Ukraine to stop and abandoning allies to continue just like Putin and Trump does. Odd those geopolitical goals line up like that and it was part of getting funding.

Her ideas are massively extreme so I expected that one.

→ More replies (2)

•

u/Manta_of_Eternity 1h ago

They had nothing to lose, it's not like Jeffries was going to give them any kind of influence even if they did vote for him.

•

u/OsuLost31to0 1h ago edited 50m ago

Disagree. My rep, Don Leonard, who just won against an incumbent GOP candidate, was told by other party leaders they would “make his life a living hell” if he didn’t support Jeffries.

I’d argue they actually have more to lose than most, they could be out of Congress as quickly as they are in by opposing him.

Edit: Leonard just posted he voted AGAINST Jeffries, my guy

•

u/JuniorMint1992 47m ago

I hope Ohio recognizes that Don Leonard is an actual leader and keep him in Congress despite all the money that's going to be spend to oppose him now.

•

u/zeekayz 36m ago

What's funny is when he's going to be opposed it will be both GOP money (with AIPAC) and Dem money (Jeffries/Schumer with AIPAC) that will combine their budgets to sponsor the candidate running against him. He's going to have to fight the budgets of both parties.

•

u/mjb1225 7m ago

To be fair, Abdul did that exact thing. He just needs the support of his constituents to fight against the money. That and a true legislative message that isn't "we aren't the other guys"

→ More replies (2)

•

u/MudLOA California 37m ago

It’s going to be money on both the Dem and GOP side sadly.

→ More replies (5)

•

u/DemosthenesOrNah 27m ago

yeah I don't want a leader who will make his own collations life hell just bc he doesn't get the limelight. that's disgusting

•

u/maluquina 33m ago

I'm very impressed with Leonard, he is gonna be a rockstar in the party. Melat Kiros, Richard Ojeda & Randy Villegas are also great freshmen/woman.

•

u/EuphoricTravel1790 44m ago

Only if people stop voting for them.

→ More replies (2)

•

u/galaapplehound 31m ago

Oooo, a shiny shiny spine in the Democratic party. I like it!

•

u/f3nnies 55m ago

Which means that they are the only true patriotic House members we have right now. Something about we don't negotiate with terrorists, which is what Jeffries is.

→ More replies (16)

•

u/Ganjake 37m ago

I'm so jealous.

Mine is a long established Dem and took almost 200k from the Israeli lobby. I called. Guess who she voted for.

•

u/spaceguitar Georgia 27m ago

This is exactly what's going to happen to any Democrat who doesn't play ball and work with Establishment Dems to further billionaire and Israeli interests.

•

u/atatassault47 29m ago

These progressives won their primary and general with the DNC funding their opposition. They already beat the Corpo Dems' apparatii, there's nothing the DNC can do in 2 years' time.

→ More replies (3)

•

u/deathcomestooslow 5m ago

This is exactly what he should do. And be loud about the "living hell" as it happens. You think Jeffries and Schumer have a low approval rating now (and its impressively low for schumer) but that will absolutely turn "moderate" politically unengaged people against representatives like that as people hear about it happening over and over.

→ More replies (10)

•

u/ShiningRayde 1h ago

They had their image to lose, at least.

•

u/TheHuffness 1h ago

Dont worry the media will make sure the bloc is sufficiently demonized once they're in office 🙃

•

u/BillsKingsStrugleBus 1h ago

You'd think "the squad" held majority sway with how much the media focused on 5 congressmen.

→ More replies (1)

•

u/spikybootowner 24m ago

Wait isn't Darializa Avila Chevalier part of this block? The lady who thought Russia invaded Ukraine because of American bullying? Isn't she demonizing herself? 😂

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

•

u/ides205 New Jersey 1h ago

This was good for their image. They're the only Dems in Congress with a spine.

•

u/Academic_Olive_43 1h ago

You mean, lose their image by voting for a slimeball like Jeffies.

•

u/ShiningRayde 1h ago

Yes, precisely what I was implying. If they voted for him, they would lose credibility with their voting base.

→ More replies (5)

•

u/SirWEM 55m ago

Well we lose even more accountability. Because Jeffries will still be controlled opposition. Besides he has already declared his desire to fund Israel’s socialist country.

•

u/The_Bard 1h ago

I mean freshman still get subcommittee appointments. Which is very important for shaping policy, especially if it aligns with their districts. Losong out on helping your district to vote for nobody over Jeffries is pretty pointless

•

u/Manta_of_Eternity 1h ago

So I live in Kiros' district, where voters chose her over a longtime establishment incumbent with plum committee appointments. Disagree with that choice if you want, but for this district it's safe to say that voters care more about having their representative take a long-term stand against corporate money than they do about committee assignments.

•

u/thissexypoptart 1h ago

What a warped framing of what’s happening. Many of these folks were voted in to stand up to the do nothing establishment.

“Oh please sir, give me a subcommittee position and I’ll vote for you” is explicitly not what a lot of their voters voted for.

→ More replies (4)

•

u/charlieyeswecan 59m ago

How is that pointless? Jeffery is a tool a tool for a lot of nefarious interests. Nobody wants him and voting for him just says yeah I go along with his slimeball ways, as supporting the status quo. He’ll win the leadership bid but we can watch his actions. His actions are gonna speak louder than his words cause all his words are just words and his action show that he doesn’t care about working class people.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

•

u/ShiningRayde 1h ago • Bravo

The fucking guy quoted a segregationist in his love for Israel, he shouldnt be anywhere NEAR the levers of power.

•

u/Thealbumisjustdrums 1h ago

Who did he quote? 

•

u/chairmanhao3 1h ago edited 54m ago

George Wallace: https://youtu.be/Fhze-cPHVtc?is=HRcnaHIb028S5uwb

Hakeem Jefferies: https://www.reddit.com/r/videos/s/Etd93dAUgX

He's a far right religious and ethnic extremist. Running a "progressive" party.

I have been permanently banned from this sub for this. R/Politics is zionazi trash. Bye

•

u/Pandasaref1ne 14m ago

This sub has been fascist aligned since the ToS changed a few years ago to cozy up to the Trump admin. Handing out bans left and right for defending democracy but allowing nazi apologists, rapist aligned clowns to spread hate and lies all day and night.

This sub is modded by majority proud boys and oathkeepers.

•

u/welltimedappearance 1h ago • Bravo

Jeffries sucks and likes his AIPAC dollars, but to say he's a far right religious and ethnic extremist is so far off the reservation. Much like people who make shit up about Trump to 'make fun of him'... THEY ALREADY DO ENOUGH ON THEIR OWN without having to lie about it

•

u/A_Rogue_GAI 28m ago

Jeffries seeming 'moderate' is a product of the overton window having shifted radically to the right in the past 25 years. If this guy ran in the 90s he'd be a Republican.

→ More replies (26)

•

u/TheWorstToCome New Mexico 1h ago

Damn it's crazy because he didn't actually quote Wallace

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (61)

•

u/padizzledonk New Jersey 34m ago

I mean, he recently said that he sees Israel as NYCs 6th Borough

I fucking hate that he is going to be Speaker of the House

•

u/maluquina 24m ago

I find that to be so abhorrent! Talk about being tone deaf!! A black man quoting a segregationist!!!

•

u/Defiant_Cucumber6600 12m ago

He also voted to honor Kirk

•

u/lilb1190 1h ago • Bravo

I agree with voting against him but if nobody else wants the job it's pretty hard to argue

•

u/AnonEMoussie 1h ago

I’d love to know what he talked to Jared about, before voting for him.

•

u/IAmASolipsist 1h ago

That's already been reported on though, we know what they talked about. They were discussing areas of common ground since it looked like the Democrats were going to take Congress and primarily spoke about where they could agree on housing, immigration and affordability. The pretense of the meeting was Kushner asking to talk to him about the affordability crisis.

They were in contact in the first place since they worked together on the First Step Act in Trump's first term which reduced mandatory minimums sentencing for nonviolent drug offenders along with allowing judges more leeway to bypass mandatory minimums in general, made the Fair Sentencing Act apply retroactively to people convicted before it was passed, expanded job training/mental health counseling/substance abuse treatment programs for prisoners and banned shackling of pregnant prisoners along with requiring prisoners to be imprisoned within 500 miles of family whenever possible so it was easier for them to see their family.

•

u/Rick_James_Lich 1h ago

It's not uncommon to have certain parts of your meeting private. Zohran for example met with Trump and a big part of their conversation was in private.

•

u/Manta_of_Eternity 1h ago

All NYC mayors meet with Presidents. Privately conferring with an unelected guy who's publicly taken $2 billion from a foreign nation is somewhat different.

→ More replies (2)

•

u/AnonEMoussie 56m ago

And Jared isn’t “officially” in office. For all he’s doing he’s really a private citizen.

→ More replies (2)

•

u/-Tartantyco- 55m ago

They're not interested in reality, they just want to amplify the narrative they've been conditioned into.

→ More replies (2)

•

u/ultra_bee 1h ago

Other people want the job, but openly running carries massive risk of being a parriah by leadership and primaried in the future.

•

u/Pollia 1h ago

So they or is it just weirdos saying names of who should take the job

→ More replies (2)

•

u/averagecodbot 1h ago

That’s not a good look. They act so arrogant and entitled but are scared of a challenge? Why not prove how popular they are by letting other people run and lose without retribution?

→ More replies (3)

•

u/PlentyMeet3866 46m ago

Primary them all out every 2-4-6 years; electoral turnovers improve real outcomes for the public

https://old.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/1xzjahk/seven_freshmen_democrats_vote_against_jeffries/19sty6k3b196s/

•

u/aceman9753 22m ago

“Primary 98% of all House democrats” this is your brain on slopulism. Stay losing losers

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

•

u/krissyjump 5m ago

Very few people actually want the job of minority/majority leadership because it means being a political sin eater. I think people underestimate just how massive and thankless a job House/Senate leadership actually is. You're responsible for organizing the caucus, fundraising, campaigning, whipping votes, negotiating legislation, managing internal factions, and trying to steer everyone in a somewhat unified direction. It's an enormous amount of political maneuvering, most of which the public never sees.

And, going back to my first point, they're effectively the party's sin eaters. I may not particularly like either of them, but I think they're effective at what they do. The Democratic Party is more a coalition of wildly varying political ideologies than a single cohesive party, which makes building consensus difficult. You've got everything from Reagan-era conservatives to moderates, liberals, leftists, and everything in between. It's a massively diverse party representing different ideologies, interests, and regions. It isn't the same kind of top-down, fall-in-line political operation Republicans often display. Sometimes you have to provide a public-facing position for a caucus that doesn't actually have consensus behind closed doors, take the heat for it, and give members room to distance themselves. It also gives more progressive or activist members an opportunity to publicly oppose leadership without necessarily having to challenge the party's broader political strategy.

Leadership serves as lightning rods, absorbing criticism for unpopular positions, compromises, and decisions that individual members, particularly those in vulnerable seats, can't afford to own. You take most of the criticism, get relatively little credit for the victories, and spend an enormous amount of time managing everyone else's political interests. I think people mistake the lack of serious opposition to Jeffries for universal satisfaction with his leadership, when the reality may simply be that it's an incredibly thankless job that very few people are particularly eager to take on.

I'm not particularly fond of either Jeffries or Schumer. I think they're often too moderate, too slow to act, and their politics don't always align with mine. But I'm also a realist who understands their role and the importance of it. A lot of what I dislike about them is arguably a function of the positions they occupy. Why don't they support Medicare for All? They don't have the votes for it, so they have to navigate that reality and take the heat from Democrats who want it while protecting those who don't to keep the majority. Why do they sometimes support legislation I dislike? Because enough Democrats may be willing to cross the aisle and support a more extreme Republican proposal that leadership ends up backing a weaker alternative the caucus can actually tolerate. That's politics. Compromise and negotiation are the name of the game.

•

u/Bakedfresh420 Ohio 1h ago

Damn. I was hoping we’d get rid of Jeffries and Schumer, guess we’re stuck with 2 years of shitty leadership in the house.

•

u/JohnWH 1h ago

No one ran against Jeffries. Voting against him is purely symbolic but someone actually needs to run as a replacement for it to have real impact.

•

u/Icy_Conference_1017 36m ago

So what you're saying is the party is chicken shit.

→ More replies (1)

•

u/SoggyBoysenberry7703 1h ago

Have they had the vote for Schumer yet?

•

u/Thealbumisjustdrums 1h ago • Bravo

Dems blowing it again. Party full of Neville Chamberlains. 

•

u/iPinch89 1h ago

Speaker and leader isnt permanent. If they dont perform, they can be removed

•

u/El-Shaman 1h ago

They’re rushing to crush the good vibes already after a massive victory, God I hope the nominee in 2028 isn’t part of the machine and is able to kick out people like Schumer and Jeffries from the party, we need someone like Trump was in 2016 in that he wasn’t afraid to call out establishment Republicans to their face, even if he turned out to be just as bad in the end.

→ More replies (3)

•

u/nevergonnastayaway 1h ago • Bravo

??? Dems stood up to Putin and republicans got on their knees. What a gross comparison

→ More replies (18)

•

u/cardimomof2 1h ago

It's not just the Dem party, it's the system.

→ More replies (1)

•

u/Corsonacon 1h ago

Just curious, who do you think should be House Majority Leader?

•

u/Basil-jones 1h ago

That’s the important question. Van Hollen stepped up, no one has done the same in the house.

→ More replies (14)

•

u/IAmASolipsist 1h ago

What specific actions have made him a bad leaders? I keep hearing vague generalities but few can give specifics outside of things like "he should have forced people to show up for a doomed vote that would have given the GOP carte blanche to replace Hegseth" which are silly if you understand anything about politics.

I get the impression people hate him for the same reason they hated Hillary Clinton, there's just been a propaganda campaign against them for long enough people have a general bad feeling hjt can't quite remember why.

•

u/JuniorMint1992 44m ago

He opposes Medicare for All, though he supported it to get him to where he is, but then suddenly and inexplicably no longer supports it now that he has actual power. He takes a prolific amount of AIPAC money and thus does not want this war to end. He called applying the law to Trump's regime 'retribution' and doesn't care about justice. He had a closed door meeting with Jared Kushner and had the audacity to say he met with this unelected criminal to discuss 'affordability'.

Jeffries has contempt for working people and serves himself only. Not to mention he's hand picked by Nancy Pelosi.

•

u/That-Living5913 26m ago

"He opposes Medicare for All"

You could have just stopped there. We don't need any more reason than that to know he's not working for the people.

→ More replies (4)

•

u/Meme_Theory 52m ago

Its reactions to AIPAC. I don't really want him as speaker, but he does vote for progressive legislation, so I'm not panicking.

•

u/Jin-Gitaxias-Mom 34m ago

Yeah I said the same thing about the Hegseth impeachment vote, everyone frothing at the mouth when it was just plain old kabuki theater that was DOA in the Senate anyway…

→ More replies (10)

•

u/PositivelyAwful 1h ago

Not like it matters, he's running unopposed...

•

u/SanFranPanManStand 12m ago

Because all these decisions are made behind closed doors before the vote. There were alternatives internally that were privately debated.

•

u/OakAndDagger 20m ago

Potentially stupid question: Was no one able or willing to run against Jeffeires?

•

u/snubdeity 1h ago

It's crazy how much discussion replacing Chuck Schumer has gotten, while almost nobody has been talking about replacing Jefferies.

I certainly want to see CVH take over as Senate Majority Leader, but I'm not crazy in thinking that replacing Jefferies is 100x more important right? What the hell is going on here

•

u/TheRoadkillRapunzel 56m ago

I JUST heard about a possible challenger for Jeffries’ leadership position, there wasn’t one earlier.

Van Hollen put himself out there like a week ago and senators have had time to listen to their constituents and support him.

It’s hard to convince your representative to vote for someone else when there’s only one candidate.

•

u/snubdeity 49m ago

Was there an conversation over replacing Schumer because CVH declared, or did he declare because there was a conversation over replacing Schumer?

This is not philosophical, there is an easy to find order of this timeline. CVH 100% announced his challenge because there was broad talk about Chuck not being the guy.

We needed to have the same conversation about Jefferies, but apparently everyone was okay with this guy.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

•

u/HolyMoleyGuacamoly 1h ago

senate has way more wiggle room and less ability to punish those voting against leadership.

•

u/sfzen 45m ago

I think the general sentiment is that Schumer is the more widely disliked of the two, and replacing him is more realistically achievable than replacing Jefferies (or than replacing both, which may be seen as a risky play that demands divided attention).

•

u/Witty-Lawfulness2983 12m ago

Shumer’s “strongly worded letters” for all of Trump’s misdeeds is a big reason. No balls. Jeffries was all about MFA for a decade, and then in 2021 he doesn’t cosponsor any kind of bill. Financial records from 2022 to now show $1,534,187 from 771 AIPAC connected donors. $427,000 in this last cycle alone.

•

u/FlexLikeKavana 23m ago

I think the general sentiment is that Schumer is the more widely disliked of the two,

Only in spaces like Reddit and conservative media. In the real world, that's not the case.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

•

u/Cumdump90001 New York 38m ago

The petition to replace Jeffries got over 1.2 million signatures. The one for Schumer got 200k. People have been talking about both. But Jeffries has been getting the most heat from what I’ve seen.

•

u/Disastrous-Fox8505 30m ago

That's...not true at all. There was a literal petition going around against having Jeffries as speaker. Both exist at the same time

•

u/BeastCoast 30m ago

Literally every single post since the election has been people talking about both Jeffries and Schumer. The fuck are you on about?

•

u/TankAggravating790 23m ago

Do you live under a rock or just not read? Its been literally everywhere that both Jeffries and Schumer are wanted out

•

u/consultingeyedraven 40m ago

Honestly?its because Jeffries will be the first black speaker. It’s far easier to go after Schumer among liberal circles.

•

u/lesrisen 10m ago

Schumer needs a majority of the 56 senators that caucus with Democrats. A simple Majority within his own party. Far easier numbers. And far more room for dissenting votes.

Speaker needs a majority of the House, between both parties. A consensus pick is more mandatory here because you can already count on 0 Republican votes, and therefore have to get at least 180 votes out of 260, to act as a counterweight to the Republicans.

•

u/a_talking_face Florida 9m ago

It's been widely known for a while that Jeffries already had the votes he needed for speaker. Schumer is the only one that was at risk at all, which is why most of the discussion has been about him.

•

u/Kaleidoscope-360 7m ago

Because nobody else wanted to run and very few names were seriously thrown out there, even by thr people that want him gone the most. Whereas in the Senate, nobody else wanted to run, then El Sayed publicly recommended Van Hollen and lots of other Dems went "You know what? You're right." And Van Hollen was like "Sure if this is where I am needed and enough people want it for me."

•

u/MrRogers4Life2 5m ago

CVH endorses jeffries, almost everybody who has any idea what theyre doing in the house voted for jeffries, maybe jeffries is based and good at his job?

•

u/LetsstartFreshboys 5m ago

You kidding? I saw a LOT of talk on Reddit trying to replace Jeffries

•

u/Necessary_Proof_9550 4m ago

No one is running against Jeffries for House Speaker, its hard to replace him when theres no one willing to take his spot.

•

u/BringBackAoE 52m ago

When Jeffries and/or Schumer win, I hope people here will realize this massive brigading against these two was an online effort to sow division - quite likely from Russia.

Russia LOVES Reddit, and have taken over moderation of several subs.

https://cepa.org/article/pro-putin-disinformation-warriors-take-war-of-aggression-to-reddit/

That r/politics has shifted from being very strict on only allowing quality journals we now see a high rate of posts linking journals known to spread Russian disinformation (Common Dreams, Intercept, Jacobin, etc).

•

u/Lonely-Tennis2171 49m ago

Nah dude, people have legitimate grievances against both Schumer and Jeffries. Nothing to do with Russia and pretending that this isn’t organic and you don’t need to change anything will just make people more disillusioned with Dem leadership.

→ More replies (3)

•

u/kipjak3rd 15m ago

What an absolute disingenuous bullshit rhetoric.

People are tired of spineless establishment Dems in leadership positions too beholden to corporate and AIPAC money.  God forbid people are wanting new leadership after seeing how useless they are at helping anyone other than the donor-class

You deadass giving examples of Russian disinformation journalists that are literally just leftist sites lmao 

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (1)

•

u/mad_titanz 1h ago

Sucks that Democrats don’t have the backbone to get rid of Jeffries and Schumer

•

u/FlemethWild 29m ago

Schumer’s vote isn’t even until December and no one ran against Jeffries.

I’m more and more convinced that few people actually what’s going on when they comment.

Y’all are all about vibes.

→ More replies (9)

•

u/accountabilitycounts America 1h ago

And they nominated no alternative. 

•

u/tj1007 Arizona 1h ago

No one wanted the job. They can’t nominate someone who doesn’t want it.

•

u/ItsCammyMeele 1h ago

And that's the problem with these people. They don't want power, they just want to endlessly criticize others.

•

u/tj1007 Arizona 1h ago edited 1h ago

I don’t think this is a problem. It’s not like any of the freshman who voted no could run. It would be a laughable attempt. But they know the voter base is not happy with leadership and they took a stand.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

•

u/imsuperflytnt 1h ago • Bravo Regret

Part of the problem is that people don’t want to be nominated out of fear of being retaliated against should they fall short. It feels pretty toxic to foster that sort of leadership environment regardless of anyone’s political stripes.

•

u/A-Generic-Canadian 53m ago

Another part is speaker is a shit job that is often the peak of your career.

It is very hard to leverage speakership into presidency.

Few Congresscritters want to take such a risk for such a pittance of a reward.

•

u/rootheday21 1h ago • Bravo

Yeah isnt it typically a secret ballot? I get that it could be used to hold them accountable to their voters but it also could be used to threaten those who openly voted against them once they win.

•

u/imsuperflytnt 1h ago

The ballots are secret, but it’s the nominees who face the greatest risk of retribution. The current structure is completely misaligned with an open process free of retaliation.

Imagine a process in which the first round is nominating five names. The top three vote getters then advance to a second round, presenting a case and vision to the caucus. The next round of ranked-choice voting determines the speakership and the 2nd/3rd place finishers are granted preferred committee assignments as well as party fundraising/resource guarantees.

A system like this would not only welcome challengers but reward them for stepping up. Part of the reason so many people run for president (besides ego and narcissism) is that no one really seems all that concerned about what happens if they lose.

→ More replies (6)

•

u/fury420 1h ago

This literally was a secret ballot, these 7 are just choosing to tell people how they voted.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

•

u/Agnos Michigan 1h ago

fear of being retaliated

11 voted against Jeffries, they did not seem to fear being retaliated...

•

u/theradgadfly 1h ago

It was a secret vote and 7 of them made a statement loudly claiming they didn't vote. They have no fear of retaliation. In fact, their support is based on them bashing Democrats.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

•

u/NoOnesKing Maryland 1h ago

Someone has to actually run and no one did. Not their fault

•

u/TheRealSaphier 1h ago

One of the dissenters could’ve ran for it. They don’t want the position because of how unpopular it makes the person in that position.

•

u/NoOnesKing Maryland 1h ago

There is absolutely no scenario where a FRESHMAN is getting elected speaker. The last time that happened was before the Civil War.

Would just be a waste of time.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (6)

•

u/can-o-ham 1h ago

You don't have to have a replacement in order to vote no. It was a yes or no vote.

•

u/vigouge 1h ago

That's because this was ginned up by outside groups and grifters. It wasn't grassroot one bit.

→ More replies (21)

•

u/Shacreme New Hampshire 1h ago

No offense. I don’t like Jefferies as well, but this was kinda expected? Like with a 255-260 seat majority, how would you expect to Oust Jefferies? The Progressive faction isnt that big enough to oust or place pressure on him. Getting Schumer out seems more likely imo.

•

u/fury420 52m ago

Also despite how the online narrative paints him, Jeffries is part of the progressive faction, he literally spent 10 years as part of the progressive caucus, has the support of progressive caucus leadership, etc...

•

u/Cabezone 27m ago

Name anything Jeffries has actually accomplished and don't tell me the Blue Wave.

•

u/Brobeast 16m ago

In terms of doing his job? 

FIRST STEP Act - giving a chance for federal prisoners to earn early release.

Ukraine military assistance in 2024 - in the face of republican opposition, can be argued that its allowed ukraine to fend off Russia to current day.  (Leftists probably hate this one lol)

Affordable Care Act subsidies extended by 3 years in 2026, for people that would have ultimately probably have died if kicked off insurance.

He also led "stop and frisk" reform in NY, during his time as a NY assemblyman. 

•

u/aslan_is_on_the_move 1h ago

Out of 84 freshman Democrats. Did any of the 7 flip a seat? The media is desperate to sow division. Jeffries won by an overwhelming majority.

•

u/Guilty_Plankton_4626 Virginia 1h ago

No, none of them flipped a seat.

•

u/asparagus_pee_stinks Colorado 1h ago

It's easy to win when no one runs against you 🤷‍♀️

•

u/BRNK 15m ago

And when you threaten the careers of anyone voting against you.

•

u/SanFranPanManStand 6m ago

The decision was made in private before. No one ran against him IN PUBLIC.

•

u/NanoCurrency 52m ago

But I was told DSA policies are extremely popular with the entire country. /s

→ More replies (2)

•

u/sabin357 10m ago

Jeffries won by an overwhelming majority.

He ran unopposed, so I should hope so.

•

u/zenbowman 4m ago

This, and 2 of the 7 are against Ukraine aid (Dari Chevalier and Claire Valdez), so I'm not particularly concerned about their vote. Jeffries won the votes of most candidates who flipped a seat, which is much more relevant than a couple of pro-Putin tankies in solid blue districts.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

•

u/Vast-Poetry9431 1h ago

That’s because America is a Ponzi scheme in which the rich use an infinite supply of reproducing poor people to gain their riches

•

u/SanFranPanManStand 8m ago

The Democratic Party is not the Progressive Party.

The Progressive Party is occasionally useful in gaining some additional votes, but no one should be fooled into thinking they have any meaningful political power within the party leadership.

•

u/dereksmalls1985 55m ago

So much for the meaningless petitions that don't actually accomplish anything.

•

u/SanFranPanManStand 5m ago

Welcome to Petitions 101.

•

u/FixYourHeartOrDye 52m ago

AOC voted for him.

This upsets the Commondreamers.

•

u/dreamcicle11 1h ago

While I don’t necessarily think it’s true of all of them, there is a high chance they had permission in a sense to vote against him to maintain their image and stance since he had nothing to lose. It’s not that different than when Collins would act like she’s going against the GOP but really she had permission to vote against them lol.

•

u/SanFranPanManStand 9m ago

Exactly. It was a harmless vote for show because the real choice had been made behind closed doors beforehand.

•

u/scoobynoodles America 32m ago

They gonna get roughed up lol

•

u/data_diver 56m ago

Hey Democrats: There is no earned place for putting in time!!

The Democratic Party has been working for corporations so long that they are acting like they are a corporation. You don’t serve the party you serve the people you represent.

They ran Hillary and Harris like there was some corporate ladder and they were on the highest rung. And now they are doing the same to Schumer. And having Jeffries because he is loyal to the party despite the people. Is indeed a slap in the face to the people

→ More replies (2)

•

u/Zealousideal-Car2918 1h ago

freshmen always have something to lose when leadership keeps score

•

u/optimis344 1h ago

Nah. He knows he has it by dozens of votes.

This is both a good thing for those who voted against him, and for him.

•

u/BluePanda101 1h ago

This is likely the correct take.

•

u/optimis344 1h ago

People don't seem to grasp that you want resistance that can't actually stop you. If everyone votes for him, then that actually looks bad because his approval rating is low.

Now he gets to pull the "i will reach across all parts of our party" rather than be the guy who everyone approved up, and be the sole person responsible for any and every setback.

→ More replies (1)

•

u/theradgadfly 1h ago

The votes were secret. There was no reason to proudly shout from the rooftops you voted against him if you were afraid. Your analysis is bullshit.

•

u/thirdstorybelow 1h ago

Yeah they are still optimizing for winning popularity when they need to be switching to winning power. You can't spend popularity to pass legislation.

•

u/Pave_Low 1h ago

Depends.

If that was part of their platform when they ran (new leadership for the Dems!) they are fulfilling a campaign promise. That being the case, I doubt Jeffries minds. He may actually support them voting the way they did. Jeffries would understand the WORST thing to do as a newly elected congressperson is to break a campaign promise with your first act.

→ More replies (2)

•

u/BigTimeLurker23 32m ago

Closed-door, secret ballot.  The fucking cowardice is breathtaking 

•

u/Death_and_Gravity1 Massachusetts 50m ago edited 31m ago

A real show of cowardice from AOC

→ More replies (2)

•

u/Jubal__ 58m ago

my morning shit has more spine than jeffries and schumer combined. they are an embarrassment

•

u/scoff-law California 22m ago

It's incredibly frustrating to see both the fatalism about this outcome, and how many folks seem to believe that the Speaker is the King of Congress.

•

u/Long-Dock 1h ago

Jeffries won? Damn that’s disappointing :/

Israel today, Israel tomorrow, Israel forever, I guess…

lapdog

•

u/SanFranPanManStand 6m ago

It's insane you thought he might not win.

You need to get your news from outside Reddit.

Him willing was at 99% on Polymarket.

→ More replies (4)

•

u/Relevant_Tone4741 1h ago

We need more!

•

u/Mega_Bottle California 51m ago

If only that was enough.

•

u/Same_Information1223 46m ago

Show business.

•

u/FFFUUUUUCKKKYOU 30m ago

AIPAC Jeffries and the hunchback of Tel Aviv are ruining the moment.

•

u/LeonnaMc 1h ago • Bravo

This was bound to happen. We need to stay on his neck

•

u/Brokenwhitebelt 1h ago

Just fucking wasting the momentum

•

u/TrollAccount4321 1h ago

Slow and steady…

•

u/Pave_Low 1h ago

They only got to 11 so they can't even use the 'There are dozens of us!' meme.

•

u/DejectedTimeTraveler 46m ago

So only 11 Democrats voted against Jeffries, apparently. I'm so disheartened by this. I really shouldn't be. I should have seen it coming a mile away. This country deserves Donald Trump.

•

u/ThistleroseTea 1h ago

Even more critical now to contact your senator and tell them to NOT elect Schumer!

•

u/SHUT_DOWN_EVERYTHING 38m ago

An absolute crushing blow to show how incredibly out of touch this sub is with reality.

•

u/IridescentReflection 1h ago

The Insurgents 🫡

•

u/foreverandadayalone Canada 23m ago

?? How are the people who haven't been sworn in and don't start until January voting on anything??

•

u/OwlInDaWoods 7m ago

They arent really. Its a closed door secret vote for him being nominated. He won the nomination. They dont officially vote until January. 

•

u/ministryofchampagne 1m ago

The speaker of house vote is done before they are sworn in because the speaker of the house is who swears in all members at Congress(house) at the same time.

The existing clerk, does a roll call vote, speaker is selected, members sworn in, new clerk elected.

However I think this vote was just the democrats selecting their nominee for the speaker of the house. Both parties can submit nominations but typically the majority wins.

•

u/Ambitious-Parsley139 10m ago

I guess we just voting for the same old shit. Gonna be a Biden administration all over again.

•

u/Misterarthuragain 8m ago

Has any ever asked him to tell the truth about his meeting with Jared Kushner? Why'd he do it? What did he expect to happen? What did happen?

•

u/Milked_Cows Virginia 3m ago

So nothing will get done the next 6 years then we’ll be back to red? Awesome

•

u/InevitablePresent917 0m ago

No, that's 7 out of ~256 House Democrats. Their protest votes are irrelevant even if they vote no on everything for the next 2 years. (The more fundamental issue is the WH being able to veto anything the House and Senate do for the next 2 years and GOP defections for a veto override being wildly unlikely.)

•

u/shadowboxer47 2m ago

If you're a House Progressive and you voted against Jeffries without organizing an alternative or standing up and volunteering for the job yourself or, I have to wonder how serious you are about any of this.

It looks extremely performative and empty from where I am sitting.

Incredibly disappointing all around.

•

u/CrazySporkDude 1m ago

Democrats will never learn. They will once again snatch defeat from the jaws of victory.

•

u/0202_tihssitidder 0m ago

House and Senate Leadership each are worth around $20M/year in bribes. This fight will get intense.

I suspect more than just Fetterman will leave the Dems over Israel's $$.

•

u/croolshooz ✔ Verified Cartoonist 26m ago

The vote was a foregone conclusion. Considering how the Black vote influenced the mid-terms not appointing Jeffries as the first Black Speaker would have been a really stupid decision.

•

u/CrazyBitchCatLady 13m ago

Sure, sure. That why Clarence Thomas is a great SC Justice. Because he's black and for no other reason. Jeffries sucks. I hope he will at least respond to the pressure the voters are putting on him. I'm willing to give him a chance (we have no other choice), but we need to keep the pressure on him to do what's right.

→ More replies (1)

•

u/asmodeuscarthii 4m ago

Black ppl aren’t idiots, we know not all kinfolk are kinfolk and we don’t Hakeem for token representation, stop making us sick. 

•

u/LetsstartFreshboys 5m ago

Nah Redditors were absolutely clamoring to replace Jeffries

→ More replies (4)

•

u/UltimatePunchMachine 1h ago

These are the Greta Thunburgs of politics.

Get mad

"Ok that's your solution?"

"That's your job not mine"

•

u/EcoSoso 1h ago

Greta Thunberg also puts her money where her mouth is on issues important to her, she was on the flotilla.

→ More replies (2)

•

u/HolyMoleyGuacamoly 1h ago

man the “don’t make anything better” centrists are out in full force today

→ More replies (7)

•

u/OSPF99 1h ago

That is literally this entire sub. People just want to be angry; they're force fed by algorithm engagement bait and are angry all the time while providing no actual solutions.

•

u/Able_Ad_4874 1h ago

Good for her 🩷🩷🩷 she’s on the right side

•

u/pargofan 13m ago

I thought this was a secret ballot. How would anyone know they were "freshman" democrats?

•

u/Striking-Kiwi-9470 10m ago

Maybe they read the article where it says they announced it themselves?

•

u/steveparker88 12m ago

"...they want party leadership to do more to reflect the demands of their constituents."

Wait, what??

•

u/Ogbl 6m ago

What a broken system when two people, jeffries and schumer can block the changes that millions of americans just voted for.

•

u/Oceanbreeze871 I voted 1h ago

After all the big populist campaign talk as outsiders, they got their first lesson on how Congress actually works

→ More replies (3)

•

u/lhomardamericain 1h ago

This is how you make sure you come last for committee assignments and spend the next two years in irrelevance

•

u/dragunityag 50m ago

Their Freshmen congressman, they were last for committee assignments already.

•

u/OrneryError1 1h ago

If that's true, it's even more evidence that Democrats need new leadership.

•

u/Ishaq128 1h ago

This is how more dsa candidates win as they show voters they are on their side.