r/polyamory • u/FeistyLunch933 • 12h ago
vent My wife ended my relationship and I cant forgive her.
I'd like to preference this by saying I'm completely new to the community and this was my first poly experience outside a threesome one night stand, so go easy on me.
Me (30F)and my wife(29F) have been together for 10 years and married for 4 year. Our sex-life had gotten a bit dull, so we had a conversation of opening the relationship to just having a bit of fun with someone, preferably with another couple and keep it casual.
My wife had mentioned before that she wanted to open for the purpose of sex and sex alone, I didn't want to so we didn't but cut to the present (about 5 years later) and the idea grew on me and I decided to give it a shot.
We made an account on feeld and matched with another couple. We made a group chat together before meeting and we all got on like a house on fire. Let's call this couple Alex(24F) and Sarah(24F)
All 4 of us had common interests but my wife and Sarah had more in common and myself and Alex had more in common (only natural). My wife doesn't smoke weed, me and Alex do, my wife HATES horror movies me and Alex love them. I HATE reading, my wife and Sarah loved reading and happened to be reading the same books, I hate romcoms, my wife and Sarah loved them.
I'm thinking this is literally the perfect match, as we didn't want to sleep with people purely based on looks. Personality is a huge attraction factor for me, more so than looks.
We texted for awhile and decided to meet up, after meeting them in person I was SUPER attracted to Alex and so was my wife, but the 2 of us didn't feel the attraction for Sarah had left the phone screen and in person I just really wasn't feeling it.
We told them that we were really sorry but we couldn't go forward with this, but would love to be friends as we did really get on as friends.
Alex then messaged me privately and asked me directly was the reason I wanted to not go forward, because I wasn't attracted to Sarah. I decided to be truthful and I told her that yes, I just don't feel the sexual attraction there with her. Alex then expressed to me, that she had been unhappy with Sarah for awhile and was going to leave her. They were only together for 6 months so it really wasn't a big deal for either of them. We stayed friends with Alex and Sarah for awhile after that. We communicated with them both daily, helping Sarah. Arranging meet ups. I helped Alex move out of there apartment and we spent a lot of time together.
During this period my wife went to a festival in the UK. (We live in Ireland). I expressed to her that now we have this 'open' title on our relationship i didn't want her to take that and go wild with it while Iwasn'tt there, that was literally my biggest fear, so we agreed, she wasn't going to pursue anything over there. DAY 1 , she gets with some randomer. I was upset, but we got over it quickly because I love her and yes she broke my boundary but she's my wife, and we talked it over and I forgave her.
Upon her returning from download Alex and myself and my wife, all 3 of us had an immediate sexual attraction and I admit we should have given it more time but Alex was open to being FWB with me and my wife so the 3 of us became a casual thing that moved very fast. The sex was off the charts, the banter while drinking and chilling was amazing. Me and my wife literally said to eachother she just slots so well into our lives. Alex and myself were smoking up one night and we admitted to eachother that we had feelings, she had feelings for me and my wife, and the 2 of us had feelings for her. So we decided to make it official and the 3 of us were in a relationship.
Things were going amazing at the beginning, it was like everything I liked that my wife hated Alex filled that gap, and visa versa for my wife. Alex seemed happy out and we were always having a good time
Then came the problems......
About a month in, my wife brings up that because were all together, we can do solo stuff with eachother. Up until then we had only been together all 3 of us. I agreed as I had no problem with it and there was no hesitation on anyone. My wife went to spend the night in hers alone one night, i did the same. I work late nights so they would have time together alone while I was working, and everything was fine.
My wife all of a sudden had feelings of jealously. Me and Alex have a much higher sex drive so we were having sex quiet often, usually when my wife was asleep as she works a 9-5 and I work late, she was usually asleep or going to sleep by the time I got home. Along with the jealously, she became extremely irrational, starting taking tallies of how much affection I was showing Alex vs showing her. She became upset if me and Alex fell asleep cuddling (Alex was always in the middle btw, cause she's the smallest of the 3 of us) she started getting upset at the way I looked at Alex sometimes and I will admit. I was falling hard, and I was falling fast.
I NEVER thought I had the capacity to love 2 people, but here I was. Hopelessly obsessed with my wife and falling hard for Alex. It was a really confusing and emotional time for me. And now my wife had started acting crazy. Waking us up asking Alex why she wasn't sharing her pillow instead of mine. Ignoring me for giving Alex a kiss hello before her, things got bad. Me and Alex desperately wanted things to work, so we started walking on eggshells around her trying to please her ever wish. She started putting rules on us, dictating how often we could see eavhother, how often we could have sex and neither me or Alex dared question it because we desperately wanted to be together.
The day after Halloween, i woke up and walked into my sitting room to find my wife ending the relationship. I was livid... how could she do that without me being involved in the conversation. How could she think it was ok to do that, she didn't care that she was effectively breaking up with my girlfriend for me.
Me and Alex said that we wanted to continue seeing eavhother and my wife said she realised from this whole experience that she's monogamous and it was all a mistake and she only wants to be with me, so now , I had a choice to make, stay with my wife and leave Alex. Or end my marriage and stay with Alex.
I can't express how hurt, betrayed and unimportant my wife made me feel. My brain was running a million miles an hour and I couldn't think so I told her I was leaving with Alex for the night cause I needed to think and I wasn't ready to end my relationship with her. So me and Alex left.
We cried, and cuddled, and cried some more. I don't think I've every cried harder over a breakup and technically I hadn't even done it yet. The next day I told Alex I needed to go home and talk to my wife about everything. I told her I needed space to clear my head and that we needed to go back to being friends. I went back to my wife, we argued , a lot, she just wasn't taking in what I was saying. She thinks I'm angry because I want Alex over her, but thats not it. I'm angry because she completely left me out of making this decision when it directly effects me. Were supposed to be a partnership and she made this whole experience feel like a dictatorship with wild crazy rules that I was stupid to agree to.
Now here I am wanting to leave my wife, and struggling with it.
I really.dont know how me and my wife can survive this. I love her, I do, but honestly, how can I forgive her for this. If she's going to leave me out of a decision like this. And now the festival is coming back into my head, which I know its not fair because I forgave her but I just can't help but think, she's broken all my boundaries threw all of this, made really important decisions without me and was dictating every part of my behaviour. Is this the life I want ? Do I want to be with someone who's just gonna tell me how it is all the time without a care for my feelings??
Alex said she would wait for me, and that she loves me and will be there if and when I leave my wife. I've told her multiple time not to do that. To go be single, move on , and if we both so happen to be single in the future I would love to be with her. But I need time and space to think about whether or not I wanna save my marriage. I love Alex to death! I miss her every damn day and its so hard.
My wife has flown to family out of the country for a week, to give me time and space as I expressed to her I need to think about what I want, and if I want to stay in the marriage after everything thats happened. But i just dont see how I can stay (She then put all my clothes in the shower and turned it on) I just don't see how we can come back from this. Everytime I look at her all I see is a person who broke my heart.
Sorry for the long vent, I'm really just lost right now. No matter what I'm heartbroken, and no matter what I do, I'm breaking someone's heart.
I've never been in a more difficult situation, any advice or help would be so appreciated.