r/predental • u/Then-Scientist265 • 2h ago
💡 Advice Reconsidering dental school during my gap year. Should I look into PA school or engineering instead?
My original plan was to apply to UNC and ECU, my two in-state dental schools, in the 2027 cycle. But after working as an intern in a dental office, I’m starting to reconsider whether I want to become a dentist.
For background, I have a 3.98 GPA, a 550 on the DAT, and 500 hours as a dental intern. I mostly sterilize instruments and set up trays, but I also do a little chairside assisting and take some X-rays. I have 100 hours of dental shadowing, 100 hours volunteering as a dental assistant and taking X-rays on a dental mission trip, 100 hours of hospice volunteering, and 150 hours volunteering with refugees. I spent a year doing eye research and presented my work. I also have my BLS and dental X-ray certificates.
I haven’t found the work I’ve seen at the dental office all that interesting. I can still do well at a job even if I’m not super interested in it, so that alone wouldn’t make me change my mind. I’m more worried about the business side of dentistry, like networking and marketing yourself. I don’t feel like I’m good at that, and I wonder how much of it you still have to do as an associate.
Honestly, my biggest concern is money. I have $100k saved for dental school, and because of the cost, I’d only go if I got into UNC or ECU. Even at UNC, I think I’d still need to borrow around $200k. I just want to work as a general dentist in someone else’s office. I don’t plan on owning a practice. I might consider specializing after I’ve worked for a while and saved some money, but definitely not right out of school.
I’d like to live in New York eventually so I can be closer to my sister. I asked AI to compare how I’d do financially as an associate dentist versus a PA in New York over my first 10 years out of school. It estimated that I’d be pretty far ahead financially as a PA for the first 5–6 years once I factored in loan payments and interest. By midcareer, though, it estimated I’d earn about $40k more per year as an associate dentist. I’m curious whether that sounds realistic to people working in New York.
My sister and I immigrated to the US when we were in middle school, and our parents still live abroad. We’re first-gen college students, so we’ve had to figure a lot of this out on our own. Sometimes I think I’d feel more comfortable taking on that much debt if I’d grown up here, had more family and financial support, or had a parent who was a dentist and could tell me what I was getting into.
Lately, I’ve been regretting majoring in biology. Part of me wishes I’d studied engineering so I could’ve gone straight into a career after graduation. I planned everything around dental school, and now I keep thinking, if I don’t get into UNC or ECU, what do I do? Wait another year and reapply?
I’m starting to think becoming a PA might suit me better. Depending on the program, I think I could use my savings and borrow up to $50k. I could finish PA school in about two years and start earning a good income sooner. The downside is that I’m not sure how many of my current hours would count as direct patient care. I’d probably spend another year working as a CNA or EMT to get those hours. But I’d feel more comfortable doing that knowing I could afford more of the programs I might get into. Right now, everything depends on two schools.
If you’re an associate dentist with no plans to own a practice, would you still choose dentistry today if it meant borrowing $200k? I’m also torn between looking into PA school and switching to engineering. If anyone here considered either path, I’d love to hear what helped you decide. Thanks for any advice!