r/proteomics • • 21h ago

Why is my ~370 kDa ECM-associated protein detectable using mild lysis buffer but not RIPA, NP-40, SDS, 8 M urea, or guanidine HCl?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm a PhD student working on a very large protein (~370 kDa in humans) whose precise molecular function remains poorly understood. Understanding its biological function is one of the main focuses of my PhD project.

Based on current in silico predictions, this protein has several interesting features:

  • It is a large, multidomain protein.
  • It contains an N-terminal signal peptide and is predicted to be secreted into the extracellular matrix (ECM).
  • Its N-terminal domains contain predicted O-glycosylation sites.
  • The commercially available antibody I use targets a N-terminal domain. Unfortunately, no C-terminal antibody is currently available.

Here's the problem I've encountered:

I initially worked with HEK293 cells transfected with the full-length gene. In this overexpression system, I could readily extract and detect the protein intracellularly by Western blot using conventional RIPA buffer.

However, things became much more challenging when I moved to my in vivo zebrafish models, where I generated several CRISPR mutants to investigate the protein's function.

Despite testing multiple extraction conditions, I consistently struggled to detect the endogenous protein by Western blot.

Extraction conditions tested:

  • RIPA buffer
  • NP-40-based buffer
  • SDS-containing buffer
  • 8 M urea
  • Guanidine HCl

Interestingly, I was finally able to detect the protein when I switched to a relatively mild, detergent-free lysis buffer containing Tris-HCl, NaCl, EDTA, sodium phosphate, and DTT.

All extraction buffers were supplemented with protease and phosphatase inhibitor cocktails.

What puzzles me is why a protein that is difficult to detect following extraction with relatively harsh, detergent-containing, or strongly denaturing buffers becomes detectable using a much milder extraction condition.

I initially expected that stronger solubilisation conditions would improve the recovery of such a large, potentially ECM-associated protein, rather than the opposite.

I've been considering several possible explanations:

  1. Protein solubility or aggregation: Could the protein undergo aggregation or precipitation under certain extraction conditions, reducing its recovery in the soluble fraction?
  2. ECM association: Could its association with extracellular proteins or macromolecular complexes influence its extraction behaviour?
  3. Protein stability: Could particular buffer components promote protein degradation, fragmentation, or loss during sample preparation?

I'm also aware that detecting a protein by Western blot does not necessarily mean it was extracted more efficiently, so I'm interested in ways to distinguish extraction efficiency from downstream detection issues. FYI, I used Bio-Rad Miniprotein SDS-PAGE and Wet Transfer using Towbin buffer.

My main questions are:

  • Has anyone experienced a similar situation where a high-molecular-weight protein was detectable using a mild extraction buffer but not stronger detergent-based or denaturing conditions?
  • What biochemical approaches would you recommend to systematically investigate protein solubility, aggregation, or precipitation? Would sequential extraction followed by analysis of soluble and insoluble fractions be a good starting point?
  • How would you distinguish genuine differences in protein extraction efficiency from issues related to sample preparation, electrophoresis, membrane transfer, or antibody recognition?
  • Are there any particular considerations when working with very large, potentially glycosylated, ECM-associated proteins?

I'd especially appreciate insights from anyone working with high-molecular-weight proteins, ECM proteomics, or challenging protein extraction.

Any suggestions, troubleshooting experiences, or relevant literature recommendations would be greatly appreciated!

Thanks in advance!