r/psychoanalysis • • Mar 22 '24

Welcome / Rules / FAQs

19 Upvotes

Welcome to r/psychoanalysis! This community is for the discussion of psychoanalysis.

Rules and posting guidelines We do have a few rules which we ask all users to follow. Please see below for the rules and posting guidelines.

Related subreddits

• r/lacan for the discussion of Lacanian psychoanalysis

• r/CriticalTheory for the discussion of critical theory

• r/SuturaPsicanalitica for the discussion of psychoanalysis (Brazilian Portuguese)

• r/psychanalyse for the discussion of psychoanalysis (French)

• r/Jung for the discussion of the separate field of analytical psychology

FAQs

How do I become a psychoanalyst?

Pragmatically speaking, you find yourself an institute or school of psychoanalysis and undertake analytic training. There are many different traditions of psychoanalysis, each with its own theoretical and technical framework, and this is an important factor in deciding where to train. It is also important to note that a huge number of counsellors and psychotherapists use psychoanalytic principles in their practice without being psychoanalysts. Although there are good grounds for distinguishing psychoanalysts from other practitioners who make use of psychoanalytic ideas, in reality the line is much more blurred.

Psychoanalytic training programmes generally include the following components:

  1. Studying a range of psychoanalytic theories on a course which usually lasts at least four years
  2. Practising psychoanalysis under close supervision by an experienced practitioner
  3. Undergoing personal analysis for the duration of (and usually prior to commencing) the training. This is arguably the most important component of training.

Most (but by no means all) mainstream training organisations are Constituent Organisations of the International Psychoanalytic Association and adhere to its training standards and code of ethics while also complying with the legal requirements governing the licensure of talking therapists in their respective countries. More information on IPA institutions and their training programs can be found at this portal.

There are also many other psychoanalytic institutions that fall outside of the purview of the IPA. One of the more prominent is the World Association of Psychoanalysis, which networks numerous analytic groups of the Lacanian orientation globally. In many regions there are also psychoanalytic organisations operating independently.

However, the majority of practicing psychoanalysts do not consider the decision to become a psychoanalyst as being a simple matter of choosing a course, fulfilling its criteria and receiving a qualification.

Rather, it is a decision that one might (or might not) arrive at through personal analysis over many years of painstaking work, arising from the innermost juncture of one's life in a way that is absolutely singular and cannot be predicted in advance. As such, the first thing we should do is submit our wish to become a psychoanalyst to rigorous questioning in the context of personal analysis.

What should I read to understand psychoanalysis?

There is no one-size-fits-all way in to psychoanalysis. It largely depends on your background, what interests you about psychoanalysis and what you hope to get out of it.

The best place to start is by reading Freud. Many people start with The Interpretation of Dreams (1900), which gives a flavour of his thinking.

Freud also published several shorter accounts of psychoanalysis as a whole, including:

• Five Lectures on Psychoanalysis (1909)

• Introductory Lectures on Psychoanalysis (1915-1917)

• The Question of Lay Analysis (1926)

• An Outline of Psychoanalysis (1938)

Other landmark works include Three Essays on the Theory of Sexuality (1905) and Beyond the Pleasure Principle (1920), which marks a turning point in Freud's thinking.

As for secondary literature on Freud, good introductory reads include:

• Freud by Jonathan Lear

• Freud by Richard Wollheim

• Introducing Freud: A Graphic Guide by Richard Appignanesi and Oscar Zarate

Dozens of notable psychoanalysts contributed to the field after Freud. Take a look at the sidebar for a list of some of the most significant post-Freudians. Good overviews include:

• Freud and Beyond by Margaret J. Black and Stephen Mitchell

• Introducing Psychoanalysis: A Graphic Guide by Ivan Ward and Oscar Zarate

• Freud and the Post-Freudians by James A. C. Brown

What is the cause/meaning of such-and-such a dream/symptom/behaviour?

Psychoanalysis is not in the business of assigning meanings in this way. It holds that:

• There is no one-size-fits-all explanation for any given phenomenon

• Every psychical event is overdetermined (i.e. can have numerous causes and carry numerous meanings)

• The act of describing a phenomenon is also part of the phenomenon itself.

The unconscious processes which generate these phenomena will depend on the absolute specificity of someone's personal history, how they interpreted messages around them, the circumstances of their encounters with love, loss, death, sexuality and sexual difference, and other contingencies which will be absolutely specific to each individual case. As such, it is impossible and in a sense alienating to say anything in general terms about a particular dream/symptom/behaviour; these things are best explored in the context of one's own personal analysis.

My post wasn't self-help. Why did you remove it? Unfortunately we have to be quite strict about self-help posts and personal disclosures that open the door to keyboard analysis. As soon as someone discloses details of their personal experience, however measured or illustrative, what tends to happen is: (1) other users follow suit with personal disclosures of their own and (2) hacks swoop in to dissect the disclosures made, offering inappropriate commentaries and dubious advice. It's deeply unethical and is the sort of thing that gives psychoanalysis a bad name.

POSTING GUIDELINES When using this sub, please be mindful that no one person speaks for all of psychoanalysis. Psychoanalysis is a very diverse field of theory, practice and research, and there are numerous disparate psychoanalytic traditions.

A NOTE ON JUNG

  1. This is a psychoanalysis sub. The sub for the separate field of analytical psychology is r/Jung.
  2. Carl Gustav Jung was a psychoanalyst for a brief period, during which he made significant contributions to psychoanalytic thought and was a key figure in the history of the psychoanalytic movement. Posts regarding his contributions in these respects are welcome.
  3. Cross-disciplinary engagement is also welcome on this sub. If for example a neuroscientist, a political activist or a priest wanted to discuss the intersection of psychoanalysis with their own disciplinary perspective they would be welcome to do so and Jungian perspectives are no different. Beyond this, Jungian posts are not acceptable on this sub and will be regarded as spam.

SUB RULES

Post quality

This is a place of news, debate, and discussion of psychoanalysis. It is not a place for memes.

Posts or comments generated with Chat-GPT (or alternative LLMs) will generally fall under this rule and will therefore be removed

Psychoanalysis is not a generic term for making asinine speculations about the cause or meaning of such-and-such a phenomenon, nor is it a New Age spiritual practice. It refers specifically to the field of theory, practice and research founded by Sigmund Freud and subsequently developed by various psychoanalytic thinkers.

Cross-disciplinary discussion and debate is welcome but posts and comments must have a clear connection to psychoanalysis (on this, see the above note on Jung).

Links to articles are welcome if posted for the purpose of starting a discussion, and should be accompanied by a comment or question.

Good faith engagement does not extend to:

• Users whose only engagement on the sub is to single-mindedly advance and extra-analytical agenda

• Users whose only engagement on the sub is for self-promotion

• Users posting the same thing to numerous subs, unless the post pertains directly to psychoanalysis

Self-help and disclosure

Please be aware that we have very strict rules about self-help and personal disclosure.

If you are looking for help or advice regarding personal situations, this is NOT the sub for you.

• DO NOT disclose details of personal situations, symptoms, diagnoses, dreams, or your own analysis or therapy

• DO NOT solicit such disclosures from other users.

• DO NOT offer comments, advice or interpretations, or solicit further disclosures (e.g. associations) where disclosures have been made.

Engaging with such disclosures falls under the heading of 'keyboard analysis' and is not permitted on the sub.

Unfortunately we have to be quite strict even about posts resembling self-help posts (e.g. 'can you recommend any articles about my symptom' or 'asking for a friend') as they tend to invite keyboard analysts. Keyboard analysis is not permitted on the sub. Please use the report feature if you notice a user engaging in keyboard analysis.

Etiquette

Users are expected to help to maintain a level of civility when engaging with each-other, even when in disagreement. Please be tolerant and supportive of beginners whose posts may contain assumptions that psychoanalysis questions. Please do not respond to a request for information or reading advice by recommending that the OP goes into analysis.

Clinical material

Under no circumstances may users share unpublished clinical material on this sub. If you are a clinician, ask yourself why you want to share highly confidential information on a public forum. The appropriate setting to discuss case material is your own supervision.

Harassing the mods

We have a zero tolerance policy on harassing the mods. If a mod has intervened in a way you don't like, you are welcome to send a modmail asking for further clarification. Sending harassing/abusive/insulting messages to the mods will result in an instant ban.


r/psychoanalysis • • 3h ago

I built a free site with open-access psychoanalysis resources and a "genealogy" of analysts back to Freud

27 Upvotes

Hi, I’m not an analyst, just someone from Strasbourg, France, curious about psychoanalysis (Lacanian in particular). With the help of AI, I’ve built a website that lists open-access resources (Freud’s complete works, Lacan’s seminars in several languages) and a tool to trace the “genealogy” of analysts back to Freud.

For Freud’s works and Lacan’s seminars, I took them from staferla.free.fr. For the genealogy of analysts, I mostly relied on Wikidata and on R. G. Klein, whose list (The Names of the Analysts) gave me a lot of information I couldn’t find recorded anywhere else, so many thanks to him.

That’s about it. The tool is completely free and open, and the aim is for it to be as complete as possible. Don’t hesitate if you have corrections, feedback, suggestions, etc. I’m all ears.

https://psychoanalytikon.org


r/psychoanalysis • • 1h ago

When countertransference is too much

1 Upvotes

Is there any writing about how to help patients who have attachment trauma from a previous therapist who couldn't handle their countertransference? Or how those patients could help themselves - what kind of working through they need.


r/psychoanalysis • • 17h ago

Can therapy ever truly be politically neutral?

13 Upvotes

I recently came across an article criticizing Jonathan Shedler’s position on politicized therapy, and it got me thinking about the concept of neutrality in the therapy room.
I agree that therapists shouldn’t impose their political beliefs or personal agendas on clients. But I’m curious where we draw the line between maintaining therapeutic neutrality and acknowledging the very real impact of systemic oppression on psychological suffering.
For example, when a client’s distress is partly rooted in experiences of discrimination or marginalization, can focusing primarily on intrapsychic processes risk minimizing the external realities contributing to their suffering?
I’m particularly interested in this from a psychodynamic perspective, where neutrality has historically been an important concept.
How do you all navigate this in your clinical work? Is political neutrality actually possible, or even desirable, in psychotherapy?
For context, here’s the article⁠ that prompted my thinking


r/psychoanalysis • • 22h ago

New Orleans Birmingham Institute

3 Upvotes

Has anyone studied here or know someone who does? I grew up professionally in New York and have a relational bent. I’m curious what their theoretical orientation is, what the curriculum is like, what the supervision has been like, what the culture is like. I also can’t find info on their website about when cohorts start or if they even have one right now. I reached out to them about the two year program, and they told me that the next class starts in 2028. I have already done a two year program, and would love to jump in to analytic training.


r/psychoanalysis • • 21h ago

Seeking a Philosophy Tutor/Mentor – Deleuze, Psychoanalysis & ENS Paris Preparation

0 Upvotes

I hope this email finds you well.

I am currently a second-year undergraduate student in Liberal Arts and Humanities at Charles University in Prague, with a strong academic interest in continental philosophy, particularly Gilles Deleuze, psychoanalysis, and contemporary French philosophy.

I am planning to apply to Université Paris 8 and/or participate in the École Normale Supérieure (ENS Paris) International Selection. To prepare for these opportunities, I am seeking an experienced philosophy tutor or academic mentor who would be willing to provide regular, one-on-one academic guidance in English.

My main areas of interest include:

  • French philosophy: Deleuze, Guattari, Foucault, and related thinkers.
  • Psychoanalysis: Freud, Lacan, and the intersections between psychoanalysis and continental philosophy.
  • Close reading: Rigorous engagement with primary philosophical texts.
  • Academic development: Improving philosophical writing, critical argumentation, and oral examination skills.
  • Application preparation: Guidance regarding the academic expectations and selection procedures of ENS Paris and Université Paris 8.

I have already published a research article in the International Journal for Philosophy of Religion and hope to develop my philosophical research further through sustained academic mentorship.

Ideally, I would like to arrange weekly or biweekly individual sessions, preferably online, with the possibility of establishing a long-term mentoring relationship.

English-language instruction is essential, although I would also be interested in gradually engaging with French-language philosophical literature.

I am happy to pay for private tutoring. If you are interested, I would be grateful if you could contact me with a brief introduction to your academic background, relevant research experience, and your proposed hourly rate.

Thank you very much for your time and consideration. I would be delighted to discuss the possibility of working together.


r/psychoanalysis • • 1d ago

Asociación Libre (Podcast): "Sobre la Psicosis no Desencadenada", feat. Ignacio Neffen (Argentina)

3 Upvotes

"Sobre la Psicosis no Desencadenada", rough translation: "On Untriggered Psychosis".

Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oVXWjeQRaM4&t=2520s

I just found this podcast, and I'm still listening to it. So far, they're taking a Lacanian approach. From what they say, both the interviewer and the interviewee are analysts.

I'm not sure how good the rest of the podcast's content is, but so far it seems decent, or at least it seems to feature trained professionals rather than people who are unfamiliar with the subject or simply improvising. Whether or not we agree with their perspective is another matter, or how much expertise these professionals actually have.

I noticed that the video has the option to switch the audio track to English or Arabic, but I think translations can significantly alter the wording in this kind of discussion, especially when it comes to Lacanian theory.

I'm thinking about making a written translation at some point.


r/psychoanalysis • • 2d ago

Silence and the question of pace in analysis

12 Upvotes

I'm curious about the role of silence and pacing, particularly when working with someone whose thoughts unfold indirectly through associations. Some people need time to develop a thought, moving between seemingly unrelated subjects before arriving at what they are trying to articulate. Pauses and silences are part of their way of thinking, not necessarily moments of having nothing to say.

Consider two analysts, both belonging to the same Lacanian tradition, but with very different styles from the very first sessions. One is consistently quiet, allowing long silences and the analysand's associations to unfold, intervening only occasionally. The other adopts a much more conversational style from the outset, bringing their own associations and questions into the exchange, rarely allowing more than ten seconds of silence.

How do these different approaches shape the analytic process? Who decides the pace of an analysis? What is the function of silence? And how can we distinguish between an intervention that opens something up and one that prematurely directs or closes down what might otherwise have emerged?


r/psychoanalysis • • 2d ago

Papers about managing countertransference?

16 Upvotes

I am curious what psychoanalytic folks have to say about the beginning processes of becoming aware of and managing countertransference. I am not perfect about managing my countertransference yet. I am a new clinician and wanting to be exposed to different ideas around managing interpersonal reactions/attitudes in the therapy room. Open to whatever resources this brings to mind.

Edited for clarity.


r/psychoanalysis • • 4d ago

Question about the Wolfman

9 Upvotes

Hello, I’ll start by mentioning that I’m not an analyst, just an enjoyer of Freud and other psychoanalytic writing. Currently reading the Wolfman with a reading group, and have a question regarding the history of the infantile neurosis. I know that Freud had abandoned the seduction theory by this point, but he seems fairly insistent in this case that the Wolfman’s memory of seeing his parents have intercourse was real and not any kind of unconscious fantasy. At the same time, he suggests that even if it was an unconscious fantasy, it makes no difference to the treatment which seems obviously true. But I guess I just wonder, is he so insistent that the wolfmans memories are real because there was no actual instance of abuse in the memory? if someone could explain why he seems so resistant to the idea that the memory might be a “regressive-type fantasy” I would greatly appreciate. Thanks!


r/psychoanalysis • • 6d ago

Is it possible as a clinician to practice both Lacanian analysis and other forms like object relations depending on the patient?

23 Upvotes

I know Lacanian analysis has sharply contrasting views with other forms of psychoanalysis like relational and object relations but I’m wondering if a psychoanalyst could practice Lacanian analysis along with others. What I mean is that you might find a patient with a certain set of symptoms to have a better time with Lacanian analysis and another patient more suitable for object relations. Something like that. Is this ever done despite how sectarian Lacanian analysis can get?


r/psychoanalysis • • 6d ago

Student in Training

6 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I am a new (ish) student to my pre-clinical course. As I am sure many of you are aware, I need to undertake an infant observation.

I am really struggling to find a kind family who would be interested in potentially helping me learn all this valuable information.

I am starting to feel like I am running out of options to find a baby and I was wondering if anyone might have some suggestions about where I may be able to look for these families.

I have tried:

Posting on Facebook groups

Posting on personal social media (although I personally don't know any pregnant people)

Going to children's centres (unfortunately many won't agree to let me talk to parents and the one that did, did not have any babies who were young enough).

I've approached a few pregnant people near a maternity hospital close to my house- A few people were kind and listened and a few flat out said no.

If you have any suggestions please help! My university is not currently providing any help which I assume is normal but want to state as a few people on Facebook groups have gotten very rude to me about this, although it is not my fault.

Thank you in advance

:) Emily


r/psychoanalysis • • 8d ago

How polyamory affects child development

34 Upvotes

Hi all! I'm curious about this topic. How the development goes for babies/kids that grow up in a polyamourous context? I mean to withness one or both parents exchanging affection with other people (aka being desired by other people) and recognizing some people as their parent's partners. I am talking about normal affection/intimacy, not the kids being exposed to sexual acts.

I am looking forward to every sort of opinion and available data while my curiosity goes to if and how processes such as primary scene and Aedipous complex gets affected.


r/psychoanalysis • • 8d ago

A Psychoanalytic view on Bulimia or some good readings?

20 Upvotes

Thanks


r/psychoanalysis • • 9d ago

The Wrath of Lacan

29 Upvotes

Hi all,

I’m currently in a doctoral program with a psychodynamic focus, and there are vague references to Lacanian influence on modern practice, but I still have not been able to find someone who can really explain in understandable terms Lacan’s ideology. Can anyone point me in the right direction on where to find Lacanian theory that is pared down to its simplest form? Or is it best that I just don’t try and breach the black box and just remain the simple object-relationalist that I currently am? Thanks for the help!


r/psychoanalysis • • 10d ago

Is there a specific term for the attribution of otherness to self-generated mental content?

4 Upvotes

I've been thinking about a type of mental experience in which something generated by a person's own mental activity acquires a quality of otherness, to the point that the person doesn't fully recognize it as something produced by themselves.

So I've been wondering whether there's already a specific term for this.

I imagine it's a phenomenon that has been discussed in different contexts, although perhaps not necessarily condensed under a single name, which I think makes some sense, since it encompasses quite different experiences, even though I believe there is a common denominator that allows several of these experiences to be grouped together.

For example, I'm thinking of experiences such as:

_ Voices and other verbal experiences: In schizophrenia/psychosis, a person may experience voices as coming from someone else, rather than recognizing them as their own mental activity. Although something like this can also occur at a non fully psychotic level.

_ Personification of mental content: A person may experience a thought as an internal presence, having its own personality maybe or agency, rather than being an aspect of their own mind.

Rather than experiencing it simply as a thought they are having, they may experience it as something that is there independently of them, and, sometimes, that communicates with them, or simple “it’s there”. E. g.: “It's as if there's someone else inside my mind.”

_ Interpretations of external events as messages: A person might attach a particular meaning to an otherwise ordinary external event / feel as though they are receiving a message from a source other than themselves.

E. g.: such as seeing a road sign and experiencing it as a message directed at them by the universe or some other agent.

Here, the experience isn't necessarily a voice or even a clearly articulated thought. Rather, what happens is that the person feels that the "message" is being produced by something external to themselves. For example: "the message comes from the universe, a spirit, objects possess consciousness and emit messages, etc."

---

I imagine this must have something to do with projection, although it's more specific than that, since it would be a form of projection associated with an effect of otherness, right?

And it's important to note that, while all of this becomes much more apparent at a more acute psychotic level, it can also occur quite frequently in people whom I personally wouldn't necessarily consider psychotic.

In fact, I'd say that fairly neurotic people can experience these phenomena, which I do think have a certain psychotic flavor to them, without actually reaching the point of delusions.

---

Beyond anything, I read your thoughts and suggestions about this.

 


r/psychoanalysis • • 11d ago

Distrust in the counter transference

32 Upvotes

Hello all, I'm looking for papers or writings on the experience of distrust / suspicion in the counter transference. I have a handful of patients on my caseload where I find myself thinking, "I'm not sure I believe you" or "It feels like you're coloring this in a more flattering light than how it actually happened" when they talk about life events.

I'm not sure what to do with this feeling (if I should 'do' anything at all) and would love some insight from other analysts or psychodynamic therapists.


r/psychoanalysis • • 14d ago

Depressive character organization papers recommendations

19 Upvotes

Looking for Similar to Nancy McWilliams one, Thanks


r/psychoanalysis • • 14d ago

about ego & id

5 Upvotes

in brooklyn nine-nine, there’s a scene where a guy studying abnormal psychology mentions that the overlap of ego and id has only ever been theorised and never seen in practise. does this have any substance or is this just a joke?


r/psychoanalysis • • 15d ago

London Training

16 Upvotes

I am looking to start the steps necessary to begin training. I am interested in The Site and CFAR as possible places to do my training, and wherever I choose I will do the introductory course for a year as a way to reacquaint my brain with academic reading, after a decade in a corporate office.

I'm inquiring as to whether anyone has experience with either of these schools, or any schools in London. What did you enjoy, and what didn't you enjoy? All advice and accounts are welcome and appreciated.


r/psychoanalysis • • 16d ago

Psychoanalytic Reading Group Australia – Seeking Active Members 📚

29 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I run an online informal psychoanalytic reading group based in Australia, and we're looking for a few new members who are genuinely interested in psychoanalytic theory, clinical practice and meaningful discussion.

We've just finished reading Nancy McWilliams' Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy and will be starting our next book:

📖 The Inseparable Nature of Love and Aggression – Otto F. Kernberg

📅 Monday, 23 November 2026

🕕 6 pm AEST (Brisbane time)

💻 Online – international members welcome!

We're particularly looking for genuine, active participants who are willing to engage in discussions, share perspectives and contribute to the group. You don't need to be an expert, just curious and willing to participate!

Our aim is to build a welcoming, thoughtful community of people who share an interest in psychoanalytic thinking.

If you're interested in actively joining us, please comment below 🤎


r/psychoanalysis • • 16d ago

Need help identifying a paper or an old post.

6 Upvotes

There was a post, probably close to a year ago focusing on narcissism, but it referenced a paper that focused on how narcissists utilize language to focus on competence vs truth.

Does anyone recall the post or is familiar with the paper?

I have repeatedly searched the sub, my saved posts and I have not been able to pinpoint the post or the paper mentioned in it.


r/psychoanalysis • • 19d ago

nyc candidates, please share experience / intel about your institute if you’re open to it.

24 Upvotes

I’m thinking about applying to CMPS, NPAP, Pulsion and IPTAR, and eyeing the more relational institutes from a careful distance. I have a non-psych PhD, no MSW etc.

i‘m wondering about timeline to LP, whether the clinic is robust enough for candidates to get hours/ control cases, quality of instruction and community, and pretty much anything else that might be interesting/relevant. thank you in advance for your help!


r/psychoanalysis • • 20d ago

Transference Focused Psychotherapy training

20 Upvotes

Has anyone trained in this work? I am very keen to do it and have been reading a lot. A lengthy internship would be best but is not possible at my life stage. Any suggestions?