r/queensland
•
u/Boydy73
•
9h ago
Question Can we stop blaming everything on "the other side" and actually work together to fix something in this state?
I've been following a few discussions here recently, particularly around child abuse, child protection and the ambulance crisis, and something genuinely pisses me off about the way we approach politics in Queensland, and Australia as a whole.
Apparently, absolutely everything is the fault of whichever political party you don't blindly support.
If Labor is in power, everything is Labor's fault. If the LNP takes office, suddenly everything is the LNP's fault. Doesn't seem to matter whether the problem started yesterday or has been developing for 20 fucking years.
And god forbid someone acknowledges something positive the other side has achieved.
How the fuck are we supposed to make actual improvements when we're more interested in slinging shit like monkeys in a fucking zoo than understanding what actually went wrong?
Let's start with the ambulance crisis.
Some amazing quotes in some posts about this issue, you get what you vote for, all Crisafullis fault, like WTF people, were you even on this plant the last decade?
The actual ramping ramping figures tell an interesting story.
- 2015: approximately 16%
- 2019: approximately 27%
- 2021: approximately 39%
- 2023: approximately 44%
- 2024: approximately 43%
- August 2025: 45.6%
- August 2026: 42.0%
The historical figures are approximate annual rates, while the last two are monthly figures.
Ramping increased massively during Labor's time in office. That's not a political opinion, it's what the governments own figures show.
The current LNP government has achieved improvements in some reporting periods, including a ramping rate of 35.5% for the June 2026 quarter.
That's worth acknowledging.
But the problem is nowhere near solved, and the recent deaths involving ambulance delays are appalling. Those families deserve answers, proper investigations and accountability, not politicians and their cult followers using these tragedies to score points.
And before anyone brings up Campbell fucking Newman, let's talk about that too.
Yes, Newman's LNP government made cuts to Queensland Health.
Between June 2012 and June 2013, Queensland's health workforce fell by 4,689 full-time equivalent positions, approximately 6.4%.
There were also disputes over doctors' employment contracts and concerns about graduate nursing opportunities.
Those decisions matter. You cannot simply replace experienced health care workers overnight, and rebuilding recruitment and training pathways takes time.
It's also worth pointing out that most of those initial workforce reductions had been reversed by December 2014, although staffing relative to population had not fully recovered.
So I'm not suggesting Newman did no damage. Far from it.
But Labor returned to government in February 2015 and remained there until October 2024.
That's almost a decade.
Surely it's reasonable to acknowledge that Labor inherited workforce problems and needed time to address them, while also asking what was accomplished during those following nine years?
The health care workforce grew considerably during Labor's time in office, yet ambulance ramping and elective surgery waiting lists continued to grow as well.
Of course, there were other factors: COVID, population growth, ageing, increasing demand and hospital capacity constraints.
But at what point do inherited problems also become the responsibility of the government that has spent nearly a decade trying to address them?
That doesn't excuse Newman's decisions. Nor does it mean every subsequent problem was purely Labor's fault.
It means both the original decisions and the response of successive governments deserve scrutiny.
And exactly the same principle should apply to the current LNP government. They inherited serious problems, but they now have responsibility for addressing them, demonstrating progress and explaining failures.
Now let's look at child abuse and child protection.
The recent Queensland Child Safety Commission of Inquiry revealed some disturbing findings.
Between 2015 and 2025, the number of children in residential care increased by 229%.
The inquiry made 52 recommendations for reform.
Those are serious, long-term systemic problems. They didn't suddenly appear when the LNP won government in October 2024.
The current government established the inquiry and has accepted 32 recommendations, with another 16 accepted in principle.
That deserves acknowledgement, just as the implementation and eventual outcomes deserve scrutiny.
Announcing a reform isn't the same as delivering one.
But here's what really bothers me about the discussions surrounding child abuse.
Why does protecting children so often turn into an argument about which political party is worse?
Why do we seem more interested in identifying the political affiliations, religions or backgrounds of offenders than discussing how we actually prevent abuse, detect it earlier and protect victims?
There are legitimate questions about institutions, safeguarding failures and whether particular organisations protected offenders. Those absolutely deserve investigation.
But reducing the entire discussion to "your side has more offenders than mine" achieves what, exactly?
A child doesn't become any less of a victim because the offender belongs to a political party or group you dislike.
And genuine systemic failures don't magically disappear because the government responsible happens to be the one you support.
Which brings me to something else: changing policies simply because the other side introduced them.
How often does a new government come into office and immediately start reviewing, restructuring, renaming or replacing the previous government's initiatives?
Sometimes that's entirely justified. Bad policies should be abandoned, and governments are elected with mandates to make changes.
But how often do we properly assess whether something is working before deciding it needs to be replaced?
How much money, institutional knowledge and momentum are lost during these transitions?
And how often are we asking for immediate results from policies that realistically require five, ten or even twenty years to achieve meaningful outcomes?
Take healthcare.
Training a paramedic takes years. Producing experienced specialist clinicians takes considerably longer. Building hospitals, expanding aged-care capacity and developing the workforce to operate those facilities cannot happen overnight.
The same applies to child protection.
Recruiting and retaining qualified caseworkers, developing appropriate residential and family-based care, improving safeguarding and changing institutional practices are long-term undertakings.
A government should be expected to show progress during its term, but we also need to recognise the difference between short-term results and long-term reform.
I'm not suggesting we give governments a free pass. Quite the opposite.
Hold them accountable for their decisions, their promises, their expenditure and their actual results.
But distinguish between problems they inherited, problems they created and problems they failed to address.
If Labor introduces a policy that works, the LNP should be willing to not just acknowledge it, but retain it. And vice versa.
And if either introduces something that doesn't work, we should be willing to acknowledge that regardless of which party we support. So many people seem almost hysterically glleful that 4 people died so they can say "Ha!! You get what you fucking deserve you morons who voted for Shitafulli!!" or whatever other funny name he's being called.
I'd like to see genuine bipartisan commitments on issues such as healthcare, child protection, emergency services and major infrastructure.
Not agreement on absolutely everything. That's unrealistic.
But some shared long-term objectives, measurable targets and reporting standards that survive elections would be a good start.
Because if every incoming government changes direction, how are we supposed to establish whether the original approach would have worked?
And I think we, the voters, have a responsibility here too.
We shouldn't need to know which party introduced a policy before deciding whether it's a good idea.
We shouldn't dismiss genuine improvements because they're delivered by a party we dislike.
And we shouldn't excuse failures simply because they're committed by a party we support.
I'm not interested in defending Labor or the LNP for the sake of it. I personally think across Australia, the reason why we have seen the rise of ON isn't because many actually support them, its more because we are sick of the revolving door of Labor>LNP>Labor?LNP and nothing seems to change so fuck it, lets try a wild card.
I'm interested in whether Queensland is actually improving.
Because continually blaming everything on "the other side" might win you an argument on Reddit, but it doesn't get an ambulance to someone's house any quicker, and it doesn't protect a single child.
I have to say though, the balls on Miles to enter into this issue when he was a senior minister and Labor party member during Labor and was the minister for Health and Ambulances for four years...... Fuck me.
SOURCES
ABC Fact Check — Newman Government health workforce cuts and subsequent recovery:
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-10-29/fact-check-queensland-health-workers-cuts/12819864
Queensland Government — Historical ambulance ramping and hospital performance:
https://www.plan.health.qld.gov.au/hospital-rescue-plan/failed-capacity-expansion-program
ABC — Ambulance ramping comparisons, 2024–2026:
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-10-09/qld-health-ambulance-ramping-data-for-august/107248682
Queensland Health — June 2026 ramping performance:
https://www.health.qld.gov.au/newsroom/news/ambulance-ramping-down-to-six-year-low
ABC — Queensland Child Safety Commission of Inquiry findings:
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-06-03/child-safety-inquiry-report/106753068
ABC — Government response to Child Safety Commission of Inquiry:
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-07-30/child-safety-response-queensland-government/106974868
Queensland Audit Office — Health 2025:
https://www.qao.qld.gov.au/reports-resources/reports-parliament/health-2025