r/Reformed • • 5h ago

Question How negatively do you personally feel towards Roman Catholicism these days? (Especially post-Vatican II RCism)

1 Upvotes

Undoubtedly there are genuine believers within the RC church (through I cannot say that in my all my interactions I say that constitute close to a significant number in my own country, otherwise one would be hearing about them more often), Yes RCs have historically faced huge prejudice in western Europe., and yes there is a little continuing ignorance among Protestants (although it appears to be far rarer these days). Yes Vatican II sees Protestants as separated Bretheren. Yes in 1999, the RC church in its official teaching switched over to justification by faith. Yes personal spirituality does vary between individual RCs. Yes there is an Alpha Course for Catholics. In short I harbour no ill will towards Roman Catholics.

However in my own country (UK), I'd argue strongly we appear to have far more of a problem in the past 15 -20 years with 'doctrinal minimalism' than 'doctrinal separatism' (in other words we seem to have swapped one extreme for another extreme). I am consistently astonished (as well as frustrated!) by comments made by well respected evangelical church leaders in my own country as well as from mature believers that I have interacted with over the the years ranging from 'its like a disagreement on baptism' to 'we need to apologise/feel guilty for damage caused by the Reformation' to 'I've got Catholic friends, and they seem alright' or some Christians find spiritual value in viewing of Mary as a co-mediatrix and that suits them to 'I don't care if Christians become Baptist, or Roman Catholic'. I was due to work for Protestant parachurch ministry schools outreach charity, and again I was absolutely astonished by the comments of the leader: that if children from a nominal Catholic background became Christians their family needs to get more involved in their Catholic church. I was most unhappy and couldn't in good conscience sign up for this. Again not because I don't want people to become Christians, but because this is misleading people. There are a great many things the RC church continues to get badly wrong even in 2026.

Interesingly, I'm actually part of a FIEC church in the UK whose pastor is from a RC background who says that one of the reasons the church is not part of Churches Together is because of its associations with the Roman Catholic churches locally.

I'm not sure whether this whether these types of comments are with good Godly intentions (in which I'm clearly being divisive and obstructing the Gospel), plain theological ignorance or just a sinful fear of conflict/what other people think? I'm very much a extreme systemising type and find it incredibly hard to empathise and read/relate to people's emotions. Perhaps some of these people just ' simply don't know how to think theologically?

I've gone back and forth over the past 15 years in my view of Roman Catholicism. 5 years ago, I was off the view OK, well it least its Trinitarian, and we would certainly be very aligned on traditional view of marriage, abortion, and assisted suicide, and I'd rather people were RC than Mormon or JW. Currently, I feel extremely negatively towards RCism, and am drifting towards the view it is a fundamentally a different religion. In which case of course the standard principles of loving one's neighbour and praying that for opportunities to share the Gospel would still apply, but it very hard to see how we could ever be in spiritual unity.

I'd also be interested to hear from how you feel Roman Catholicism compares to high church/sacramental Protestant traditions (e.g: Anglo-Catholic Anglican, Lutheran?)


r/Reformed • • 7h ago

Question Theology of The Body: Europe VS America

1 Upvotes

Hello. To be clear, I know that my presence as a transperson on this subreddit is potentially controversial. However, as someone who used to be heavily reformed, I have a great deal of respect for how this subreddit is run and felt that this was one of very few places where my question would be taken seriously for its own merit.

I am preparing to finish outlining a course syllabus for a theology of the Body/sexual ethics course at the entry graduate level (first year Mdiv/MTS/MA). I have been looking through my assigned readings and found a rather gaping hole. I have literally nothing to offer when it comes to a volume comparing theologies of the body between European reformed thinkers (post-calvin) and those that rise predominantly in American contexts (post-Edwards).

I was wondering if any of you could recommend a balanced and thoughtful scholarly volume on reformed theologies of the body from the 1800s-1900s that draws on both American and European thinkers.

I am a big proponent of knowing a tradition and steelmanning it for students in courses where my personal stances and biases are going to be obvious from the get go.

With peace,

Transveela


r/Reformed • • 17h ago

Question Question théologique

5 Upvotes

Depuis quelque temps, je réfléchis sur la spiritualité/théologie/croyances. D'origine calviniste, je suis passé par les luthériens, les catholiques... Et je ne me retrouve nulle part.

En fait je me sens trop traditionnelle pour le protestantisme et trop moderne pour la catholicisme.

Des idées ?


r/Reformed • • 17h ago

Daily Prayer Thread - (2026-11-18)

3 Upvotes

If you have requests that you would like your brothers and sisters to pray for, post them here.


r/Reformed • • 1d ago

Encouragement My daughter has been diagnosed with Congenital Insensitivity to Pain with Anhidrosis.

31 Upvotes

This is not a woe, is me post or anything of that nature. I'm not ever sure why I am posting to this community about this honestly, I'm just in a state of shock and could use the encouragment from a brother or two.


r/Reformed • • 20h ago

Question Church Recommendations in Minnesota?

2 Upvotes

I am looking for solid biblical church options in the twin cities or west metro as I am prayerfully considering leaving my current church.


r/Reformed • • 1d ago

Discussion I’m having a rough time finding a church in Portland Oregon.

25 Upvotes

If you can just pray for me to help find a church family and to help my wife come back to church I would appreciate that very much my wife lately doesn’t want to go church anymore we don’t have any friends in Portland Oregon and she’s been feeling isolated lately without much community she lived at before we’ve talked about moving from this city but I finally found a job I absolutely love and i enjoy living here.

We’ve been to 3-4 different churches here and she didn’t like any of them I’ve been to more like 6 and there’s always something I find wrong in the church that I end up just visiting for the day there’s only been about one church I did enjoy but my wife doesn’t want to continue going to church.


r/Reformed • • 1d ago

Discussion Are neurodivergent conditions a result of the fall?

6 Upvotes

It's generally agreed among theologians that physical illnesses are a result of the fall, even the ones we are born with. This then makes me wonder, what about neurological conditions?

The implications of this question for neurodivergent people are obviously significant in terms of how they think about themselves so I thought it would be an interesting discussion point.


r/Reformed • • 1d ago

NDQ No Dumb Question Tuesday (2026-11-17)

12 Upvotes

Welcome to r/reformed. Do you have questions that aren't worth a stand alone post? Are you longing for the collective expertise of the finest collection of religious thinkers since the Jerusalem Council? This is your chance to ask a question to the esteemed subscribers of r/Reformed.


r/Reformed • • 1d ago

Daily Prayer Thread - (2026-11-17)

6 Upvotes

If you have requests that you would like your brothers and sisters to pray for, post them here.


r/Reformed • • 2d ago

Encouragement What Will Heaven Be Like? (Christians Miss This)

Thumbnail youtube.com
20 Upvotes

r/Reformed • • 1d ago

Question What are your advent traditions?

2 Upvotes

What are your favorite books for family advent devotions?

Do you do the advent candles? Jesse tree? Elf on a shelf? Something else?

I have kids age 2 - 8 and I’m looking for ideas


r/Reformed • • 2d ago

Question Adam, original sin and death

4 Upvotes

If Adam had never sinned, would he, and we, have been bound forever to Earth or would we eventually have been allowed to leave it behind and go to Heaven?


r/Reformed • • 2d ago

Daily Prayer Thread - (2026-11-16)

4 Upvotes

If you have requests that you would like your brothers and sisters to pray for, post them here.


r/Reformed • • 3d ago

Discussion Thoughts on the Wes Huff plagiarism issue

51 Upvotes

Ever since Dan McClellan, the atheist apologist, pointed out an alleged plagiarism of Wes, the internet has Caught up with the issue like wildfire. Catholic apologists are in cloud 9 and celebrating as if the Second coming has arrived.

What's your take on this? Wes seem to be on the wrong on this issue, but the politics of cross-denominational infighting especially from the Romans and atheists like Dan and others is something unprecedented.

How do we support/navigate Protestant scholars and content creators in light of this scrutiny and assault from both the Romans and atheists?


r/Reformed • • 2d ago

Mission Missions Monday (2026-11-16)

2 Upvotes

Welcome to r/reformed. Missions should be on our mind every day, but it's good to set aside a day to talk about it, specifically. Missions includes our back yard and the ends of the earth, so please also post here or in its own post stories of reaching the lost wherever you are. Missions related post never need to wait for Mondays, of course. And they are not restricted to this thread.

Share your prayer requests, stories of witnessing, info about missionaries, unreached people groups, church planting endeavors, etc.


r/Reformed • • 3d ago

Question What Bible do Conservative Presbyterians use?

9 Upvotes

I have finally decided what denomination I align with and it’s none other than the Presbyterians. Problem at the moment is that all the “Reformed” churches near me have turned liberal and I’m not going to church to be told the word of God one minute then see two dudes going at it the next. I want to get an NKJV Bible as I like the KJV but the thee and thou give thee a headache. Is there a specific translation that’s best and what other tips do you have for a new Reformed Christian?


r/Reformed • • 3d ago

Question I'm literally a prodigal son and don't know where to begin.

60 Upvotes

Wanderer looking for a little help.

I'm 35, son of an OPC pastor, attended Christian schools all my life, and generally really knew my stuff. But I think I always showed people what they wanted to see, going through the motions, never truly accepting the Gospel. Maybe the prescribed nature of it all desensitized me to its message... I don't know. I pretty much stopped reading my Bible over a decade ago and formally left the church 5 years ago. Other than the pain it caused my parents, I felt nothing.

But a few months ago, out of nowhere, I began feeling some kind of pull I can barely put into words. I want to understand. I want to believe, but I don't know where to begin. For all my upbringing and education, it almost feels like I need to start from scratch, but I don't even know what that looks like.

Other than cracking open my Bible for the first time in half a decade, are there any sermons I should start with, books I should read...?


r/Reformed • • 3d ago

Question Looking for a church

2 Upvotes

Hi I’m looking for a Reformed Presbyterian church that has sermons in Mandarin Chinese. Preferably close to UCSD. Does anyone have any recommendations?


r/Reformed • • 3d ago

Daily Prayer Thread - (2026-11-15)

4 Upvotes

If you have requests that you would like your brothers and sisters to pray for, post them here.


r/Reformed • • 3d ago

Sermon Sunday Sermon Sunday (2026-11-15)

3 Upvotes

Happy Lord's Day to r/reformed! Did you particularly enjoy your pastor's sermon today? Have questions about it? Want to discuss how to apply it? Boy do we have a thread for you!

Sermon Sunday!

Please note that this is not a place to complain about your pastor's sermon. Doing so will see your comment removed. Please be respectful and refresh yourself on the rules, if necessary.


r/Reformed • • 4d ago

Question Does the Parable of the Unmerciful Servant Prove We Can Lose Our Salvation?

12 Upvotes

Matthew 18:21-25

Then Peter came up and said to him, “Lord, how often will my brother sin against me, and I Forgive him? As many as seven times?” Jesus said to him, “I do not say to you seven times, but seventy-seven times.

“Therefore the kingdom of heaven may be compared to a king who wished to settle accounts with his servants. When he began to settle, one was brought to him who owed him ten thousand talents. And since he could not pay, his master ordered him to be sold, with his wife and children and all that he had, and payment to be made. So the servant fell on his knees, imploring him, ‘Have patience with me, and I will pay you everything.’ And out of pity for him, the master of that servant released him and forgave him the debt. But when that same servant went out, he found one of his fellow servants who owed him a hundred denarii, and seizing him, he began to choke him, saying, ‘Pay what you owe.’ So his fellow servant fell down and pleaded with him, ‘Have patience with me, and I will pay you.’ He refused and went and put him in prison until he should pay the debt. When his fellow servants saw what had taken place, they were greatly distressed, and they went and reported to their master all that had taken place. Then his master summoned him and said to him, ‘You wicked servant! I forgave you all that debt because you pleaded with me. And should not you have had mercy on your fellow servant, as I had on you?’ 34 And in anger his master delivered him to the jailers, until he should pay all his debt. 35 So also my heavenly Father will do to every one if you, if you do not forgive your brother from your heart.”

The servant has his debt forgiven, and when he doesn't forgive another's debt, the King revokes his forgiven status and puts him in jail. Jesus says the Father "would do to every one of you, if you do not forgive your brother from your heart."

This seems to say Christians can be forgiven, but upon having an unbelieving heart that doesn't forgive, God sends them to "jail" (which sounds much like Hell).


r/Reformed • • 3d ago

Discussion Magnalia Dei (New) Only $36 at CB

Thumbnail christianbook.com
0 Upvotes

Just out this week, I've been looking forward to this for a while. I have the Logos edition on the way. Everyone is selling it for $55. CB has it for $36.

This is a a fresh English translation of Herman Bavinck's posthumous second edition (1931) narrates the “magnificent works of God”—creation, covenant, redemption, and consummation—with clarity, depth, and devotional warmth.

You can read a sample of it on Amazon - https://www.amazon.com/Magnalia-Dei-Herman-Bavinck/dp/1496477731/


r/Reformed • • 4d ago

Daily Prayer Thread - (2026-11-14)

7 Upvotes

If you have requests that you would like your brothers and sisters to pray for, post them here.


r/Reformed • • 4d ago

Question Should Protestants pray with Catholics?

11 Upvotes

Hi, everyone. Blessin' from a Wesleyan.

There are a great number of threads asking whether Catholics can, should, or may pray with Protestants. What I don't see much of is the opposite.

Anecdotally, the Protestants I interact with are more than happy to pray with Catholics, such as over meals and during community service events. And Catholics I've either met in real life or read online seem largely content to do the same, with exceptions clearly laid out. The hardline "No" position in either Protestant or Catholic camps appears to be a minority.

What are your opinions? Should Protestants pray with Catholics? If "Yes," are there any exceptions you would keep in mind? If "No," how would you politely yet firmly refuse to participate in a Catholic-led prayer?