r/rollerderby
•
u/Among_Us_Fat_Ass
•
1d ago
WFTDA civil war I oppose the WFTDA name change. Here’s why.
Hi skaters and haters,
I’m writing this in response to this thread posted yesterday about whether the WFTDA should change its name.
note: previous version of this post was removed, I adjusted it as requested by moderators.
Admittedly, I got heated in the comments because I feel very strongly about this and I don’t like it when I’m not heard.
Given it wasn't highlighted in the thread by the original OP, the WFTDA president posted a response, which I encourage you to read, it's a good read and a balanced view on the issue: https://wftda.com/a-response-to-the-wftda-name-change-debate/ I also want to point out that the article posted by the original OP u/GayofReckoning excluded important context which the WFTDA president raised and addressed. I feel that the original thread and article was therefore either intentionally or unintentionally misleading and we should take this effort with a grain of salt.
WFTDA leadership also let us know their next steps as well as proposed ballot language, with additional clarifications as to the challenges/hurdles faced in bringing the proposal to a vote.
Today I want to make my voice heard loudly whether or not it’s what people want to hear, because I feel this debate needs to have more than just one side represented, and I think trans women are disproportionately affected by this change and therefore should be centered in this discussion alongisde enbies and other gender-diverse peeps.
Note: I DO NOT CLAIM TO REPRESENT THE VIEWS OF ALL TRANS WOMEN, WE ARE NOT A MONOLITH.
I am a black, indigenous trans woman who has had to fight overtime to be heard and represented. I have fought every second to be affirmed not just as a woman but as a whole person.
No league has ever been so accepting the way WFTDA has. Everywhere else, if you’re born male, but try to compete with women, you’re told that you’ve got an unfair advantage, that you need to play with the dudes, all that bullshit.
But not in WFTDA. Here all that matters is - how hard can you hit, and how quick can you dodge? There’s a place for everybody here. Even my own league has its share of enbies and transmascs, and I love that WFTDA is so inclusive and continues to be.
Picking up roller derby, I finally felt I’d found my place not just as an athlete, but as a woman.
I am unambiguously accepted as a woman here, by people both inside the league and outside. I can tell people, “yeah I play in women’s roller derby!” rather than “oh… yeah… I play in uh, mens/open”. This experience is euphoric and affirming for me. To not have this would be a significant loss to me.
And yet, so many trans women, myself included have found themselves being actively stripped of their gender, myself included.
Cis people using “they/them” to describe a binary trans woman… Hearing “they” all the time from people. Being told to use the gender neutral toilet instead of the women’s. Being told to compete in open instead of women’s.
Having my gender actively stripped away from me is a form of misgendering and happens to us trans women daily.
That’s why I got so frustrated when I saw people in the other thread saying, “well, it’s more important that we don’t misgender nonbinary people, than affirming trans women…”
This argument was lame. It made it seem as though trans affirmation isn't important, and that taking away something that genders us isn't a big deal...but it’s actually how trans women get misgendered, through a distinct *lack* of gendering. It's a microaggression. It's shit. I don't like it and no trans woman likes being reduced to... not a woman.
This is why affirmation is so important to me as a trans woman, and why I am hostile to this effort. Changing the name of the WFTDA is actually taking away something that affirms trans women like myself.
Even one of the trans women who is on the name change committee stated that the fact that it was called the WFTDA is what attracted them here in the first place!
Affirmation is a reason for so many trans women to live. It’s a reason for me to live. Trivialising how WFTDA affirms us trans women by claiming that we support misgendering because we don't want to change the name, is not only intellectually dishonest, it’s not cool. We’re allowed to feel affirmed by the name and we’re allowed to feel passionate about it.
Other trans women in the previous thread noted that if another league for women opened up in response, they’d prefer to skate with them. I note that these trans women did not have their voice elevated.
When I tried to oppose this in the thread, I got shot down and told that I didn’t care about nonbinary people or trans masc people or how this impacts them. This isn’t true. Of course I care, which is why I would oppose any effort to throw you peeps out of WFTDA.
What I am trying to do is to make it clear why I oppose this effort, and I am trying to represent one perspective of an issue that affects all of us. Yes, I disagree, but that doesn’t mean I don’t care.
Here’s the controversial shit I want to say, which I think some people are thinking it but are afraid to say it.
CAVEATS: I am willing to be wrong. I am willing to hear you guys out. But please don’t just reply with, “so you hate enbies then?” because that’s not what I’m saying. I’m trying to represent the interests of trans women like myself who share a similar opinion. I may be in the minority. I may not be.
I DO NOT CLAIM TO REPRESENT THE VIEWS OF ALL TRANS WOMEN, WE ARE NOT A MONOLITH.
However, my lived experience puts me in a good position to speak for those who do agree with me. With that being said, here’s the dot points:
- If you aren't a woman, I don’t see why you want to skate with women. IORDA (previous MFTDA) is open to all genders, both cis and trans women/nonbinary/masc skaters regularly skate with them. (Geographic limitations such as league availability isn’t a strong argument, that’s out of our control regardless of the name change)
- If you choose to voluntarily join an organisation that has the name “women” in it, how is the organisation misgendering you? This seems like an active choice on your part particularly when IORDA is now available as an alternative. I am yet to see a convincing argument as to why it’s actively misgendering nonbinary people when joining WFTDA is a voluntary choice.
- I don’t see any arguments from the pro-name change side as to why it’s totally not misgendering trans women to take away our affirmation, given we get our gender stripped away from us in the form of getting they/them’d by people.
- Given that logic, isn’t it also misgendering trans women to take away something that’s affirming them? Telling them to go into the gender neutral bathroom rather than the women’s? The argument is on the same track. You’re taking away something that affirms our gender, which in your logic is misgendering too. How do you reconcile that?
- If you do support the effort to change the name, you need to reconcile the fact that this will impact SOME people in a negative way. You can’t be intellectually dishonest and claim that it’s this big win for ~everyone~. This is not a settled issue (like many things in queer discourse) and we shouldn’t act like it. Some people are going to lose out no matter the outcome, and you need to be real about that and include those people in your cost-benefit analysis.
I REPEAT: I DO NOT CLAIM TO REPRESENT THE VIEWS OF ALL TRANS WOMEN, WE ARE NOT A MONOLITH.
Addressing u/GayofReckoning directly here (original OP from previous thread, main advocate for changing the name) and those who are spearheading this effort - If you are going to persist with changing the name, then I ask this:
Can you acknowledge that changing the name requires trans women to concede something to you? Because it *will* impact trans women like me. I will lose a source of affirmation that keeps me going.
If you want trans women such as myself to support you in this effort, what tangible actions are you going to take on our behalf to protect, elevate and center trans women in WFTDA? Will you advocate for trans women to receive positions on committees, guaranteed representation, promotion, or other such causes? I'd love to see concrete examples as this would make me feel more reassured that I'm not giving something up for nothing.
If you are serious about inclusion, then you need to be willing to commit twice as hard for us trans women because at the end of the day someone’s going to lose out here and you have to be willing to stick your neck out for us if you want the same in return. I don't want lip service because I've gotten plenty of that, I want to hear what you'll actually do.
I may very well be in the minority here, as a black trans woman I always have been, but I feel passionate enough about this that I want to make my voice heard despite what I anticipate to be fierce opposition.
When all is said and done, no matter the outcome, I will keep skating.
P.S. - It may take some time for me to engage with replies as I want to do so constructively. Don’t take my silence as wanting to ignore ya’ll, I wanted to get my voice out there for discussion’s sake no matter the popularity of my opinion.
