I'm Moe, and I've been playing RS since around 2009.
I recently watched a video by a creator playing RS3 in "Old Man Mode." At one point, he commented on how lodestones "ruin the journey and exploration factor of the game." You run to Varrock once, unlock the lodestone, and never have to make that journey again.
And honestly, I think he has a point.
Back in my day, unlocking a teleport to a location actually meant something. Every time I needed to go somewhere to sell my stuff, I had to make the journey. It made the early game feel like an adventure. You gradually learned where everything was, discovered new paths, and occasionally stumbled across something that made you go, "Ooo, what's this?!"
It paced the early game really well, giving players time to explore the world and discover everything between the major cities.
As I leveled up, I started unlocking spells that let me teleport to cities, stockpiling teleport tablets to get to Varrock faster, completing task sets that rewarded useful items like the Explorer's ring with its cabbage patch teleport, and finishing quests that unlocked transportation networks like fairy rings and spirit trees.
But lodestones kind of break that progression.
All you have to do is walk up to one and click on it. There are a few exceptions where you have to build them yourself, but even those aren't particularly difficult.
Besides taking away from early-game exploration, lodestones also make a lot of the teleportation methods you unlock through magic, quests, and achievements feel far less rewarding.
The cabbage patch teleport used to be incredibly useful for getting to Port Sarim or Draynor. Now it's mostly useful for reaching the nearby farming patch.
Barbarian Village used to feel like this somewhat remote place, away from civilization without any particularly convenient teleport options. Now you make that journey once, and afterward it's just a short jog from a lodestone.
I understand that, for higher-level players, lodestones are a fantastic QoL feature. Nobody wants to spend half their playtime running between cities.
But for new players, I feel like they take away something important from a game with such a massive and interesting world to explore.
As players level up, they naturally unlock more convenient ways of getting around. Eventually, they stop making those long journeys because they've earned better alternatives. Being able to unlock a lodestone with a single click skips much of that sense of progression and accomplishment.
And I think OSRS is a pretty good example of this. It doesn't have lodestones, but that doesn't mean players are forced to walk everywhere forever. Through quests, Magic, achievement diaries, and other systems, players gradually build up a network of transportation options.
Sure, people complain about walking and running out of energy in OSRS, too. And I don't think making people walk the same route fifteen times is particularly good game design.
But there's something satisfying about progressing from having to walk everywhere to eventually being able to teleport almost anywhere you want. The convenience itself becomes a reward.
I'm not suggesting we remove lodestones. I just think they should be a little harder to unlock.
Fort Forinthry is a great example of this system done right. You complete a quest, begin developing the fort, progress through a few tasks, and eventually gather the materials needed to construct the lodestone.
Anachronia has a similar system, and the Bandit Camp lodestone is locked behind Desert Treasure.
These lodestones feel like something you've actually earned, rather than a convenient shortcut handed to you just for showing up.
Maybe unlocking Varrock's lodestone should require completing a quest in the area. That would give some quests an additional, genuinely useful reward. And in regions where a quest doesn't make sense, perhaps lodestones could be unlocked through Easy or Medium Area Tasks instead.
Some could even remain freely accessible, particularly in areas important to new players. The point isn't to make traveling frustrating, but to make unlocking these shortcuts feel like meaningful progression and I think this could fit really well into the Road to Restoration.
RS3 struggles enough with attracting and retaining new players, and I cringe a little every time I see an endgame creator praising Jagex for making "the endgame easier to access."
I feel like we should be focusing more on making the early game fun and engaging, rather than constantly trying to rush players through it.
Last year, I started a Group Ironman with some friends, and it took us MONTHS before we were at a point where we could reliably start PvMing. I know Ironman progression is slower than a normal account, but it reminded me just how much of this game exists before the endgame.
And I think those first few months are incredibly important. They're the difference between someone who gets invested in the world and sticks around long enough to experience the endgame, and someone who quits RS3 before they've even reached GWD1.
We should be making the journey more enjoyable, not just making the destination easier to reach.
Anyways.. hope this doesnt just get burried..