I recently watched Savage Gooses vid on Nimblefying Savage Worlds and though I didn't finish it, it gave me some sleepless hours and maybe an awesome Idea.
For reference: I haven't played Savage worlds yet, but informed and read quite a bit about it, since I'm looking for a generic System, that can power my multitude of one-shot and Campaign Ideas. (Fate and Charge RPG didn't quite do that - maybe thanks to user error) I have played DnD quite a bit and Nimble one time, which made me very excited for the system (I only wish it was setting agnostic).
So I've cone here to ask for your wisdom and pick apart, confirm and improve my attempt of Nimblefying Savage Worlds.
I will focus on Combat, since that's where I've read the most complaints about.
I've read, that whiff and ping is quite the problem, because often people who don't optimize just attack and miss, or the groups optimize for all supporting only one damage dealer, which there are groups better with this, but from what I've read, this is a valid concern.
First HP, Parry and Toughness:
Don't boo yet, but yes this system has a form of HP and wounds are gone...
Nimble is so fast, cause it unifies the To Hit and Damage Roll, which bogs down DnD and Savage Worlds to some extent.
Unifying Parry and Toughness into one would help, but that would loose the difference between Dodgy and heavy Armored Characters.
So i propose the following.
Parry Becomes Dodge and Toughness becomes Armor (also to differentiate them better)
Dodge is Vigor + The higher of Agility or Intelligence (Attributes used as MAX on the Dice here)
Armor is Vigor + The higher of Spirit or Strength
(Depending on balancing Dodge could also be Vigor + Agility + Intelligence and Armor Vigor + Spirit + Strength)
Attacks would be a Fight + Damage roll in one and only be measured against the higher of Dodge or Armor.
If you roll over the Defense (Dodge or Armor), the overflow damage is subtracted from the Defense and thus also work as the HP. (But Dodge and Armor work differently how they work with damage applied)
Dodge actually gets worse when damaged, making Characters that rely on dodge easier to hit on following attacks when damaged. (Which kinda makes sense in my view)
With armor however you have to still beat the max armor, but crits ignore it (like in Nimble)
(Optional Armor Rule: When rolling damage for half or more of the Armor of the opponent, the Armor is damaged and either is halved on future rolls or completely damaged, having to rely on Dodge for the target number
Initiative, Actions and Bennies:
You have three Actions like in Nimble, that refresh at the end of your turn.
Bennies can't be used for soaking hits or wounds, but Heal one Vigor Roll on yourself for 2 Bennies and 1 when healing an ally.
Attacking multiple times on your turn with -2 and -4 penalty (may have to up that to -4 and - 8)
Reactions are pretty much the same as in Nimble reforming the supportive boni you can give your party members in Savage Worlds into the framework of Nimbles Reactions Defend, Interpose, Opportunity Attack and Help (Help being able to apply after roll).
Defend works like in Savage World, giving you a +4 bonus on your Defense (Dodge or Armor).
All these Ideas are pretty fresh, so I have problems, organizing them in a good way, but I hope my idea comes across.
What do you think of my take?
What am I being ignorant of?
How would you improve my ideas?