THE KILLING MOON
Based on the song by Echo & the Bunnymen
Setting:
Hollow Creek, Indiana, August–September 1986.
Synopsis:
Set in the small town of Hollow Creek, Indiana, in the fall of 1986, The Killing Moon follows the disappearance and murder of eighteen-year-old Noah Merrick. When his body is discovered in a barn, his girlfriend, Lana Whitmore, becomes the center of a disturbing investigation. As Sheriff David Ward searches for the truth, a hidden journal reveals the dark and complicated nature of Noah and Lana’s relationship. Through shifting timelines, a courtroom trial, and the grief left behind, the play explores obsession, guilt, small-town secrets, and how the truth can remain hidden behind the stories people tell.
CHARACTERS:
NOAH MERRICK, 18 — A restless, observant teenager who writes constantly. He is funny when he feels safe and cutting when he feels cornered. He wants to leave Hollow Creek but cannot imagine what leaving would make him.
LANA WHITMORE, 17 — Quiet, watchful, and difficult to read. She has learned to conceal her emotions so thoroughly that even her moments of tenderness feel unsettling. She wants to be loved without being abandoned and does not know how to separate the two.
CASEY LANGLEY, 17 — Noah’s close friend. Practical, perceptive, and loyal, though sometimes too willing to stay out of other people’s business. Casey is left to question what friendship should have meant.
SHERIFF DAVID WARD, 40s — The sheriff of Hollow Creek. He takes his job seriously but has spent his career working in a town where everyone knows everyone and certain questions are discouraged.
RACHEL MERRICK, 40s — Noah’s mother. A working-class woman who knows her son’s faults and loves him without needing to pretend he is perfect.
CLAIRE, 17 — A student at Hollow Creek High School. Socially confident, outspoken, and more observant than she initially lets on.
MORGAN, 17 — A student and regular at the local bonfires. Funny, impulsive, and uncomfortable with serious conversations.
EVAN, 17 — A student who knows Noah and the others. He tends to follow the crowd until circumstances force him to make up his own mind.
MRS. KEEGAN, 50s — An English teacher who recognizes the difference between dramatic writing and writing that might be a warning.
DEPUTY COLLINS, 30s — A deputy who assists Sheriff Ward.
DISTRICT ATTORNEY — The prosecutor in Lana’s trial.
DEFENSE ATTORNEY — Lana’s attorney.
JUDGE HARRINGTON — The presiding judge.
BAILIFF / CLERK (DOUBLED AS DEPUTY COLLINS)
JURY FOREMAN (DOUBLED AS NOAH)
Additional students, townspeople, and jurors may be played by members of the ensemble or doubled as needed depending on cast size.
SCENE ONE — KELLER FARM, BONFIRE NIGHT
August 26, 1986.
Darkness.
A radio crackles. A song begins playing, distorted by distance and the cheap speakers.
The sound of a car door slamming. Laughter. Tires crunching over gravel.
Lights rise on a wide field outside Hollow Creek. A large bonfire burns at center stage. Pickup trucks sit around the edges, their headlights cutting through the dark. A few teenagers dance badly. Others lean against truck beds, passing drinks and arguing over the music.
CLAIRE, MORGAN, and EVAN stand near a truck. Morgan holds a plastic cup.
CLAIRE: This tastes like nail polish remover.
MORGAN: Then quit drinking it.
CLAIRE: I didn’t say I was going to stop.
EVAN: That’s the spirit.
CLAIRE: You drink anything people hand you.
EVAN: It’s called being polite.
MORGAN: It’s called having no standards.
EVAN: Says the person who bought this stuff.
MORGAN: I didn’t buy it. I traded for it.
CLAIRE: With who?
MORGAN: Does it matter?
CLAIRE: Usually.
EVAN: Can we talk about something else? Every time I come out here, you two have an argument about something stupid.
CLAIRE: You say that like you don’t enjoy it.
EVAN: I enjoy it when somebody else is losing.
Evan looks toward the fire.
EVAN: Somebody find a gas can? Fire’s dying down.
CLAIRE: Don’t you dare.
MORGAN: It’s a bonfire, Claire. The entire point is that it’s on fire.
CLAIRE: The point is that it doesn’t spread to the cornfield.
EVAN: That’s probably a point worth considering.
They laugh.
NOAH enters from stage left, pushing a red bicycle. He wears an old bomber jacket that is too large for him. He drops the bike against a fence post, looks around, and lights a cigarette.
Morgan spots him.
MORGAN: Well, well. Hollow Creek’s favorite stray dog.
CLAIRE: Shut up.
NOAH: Don’t stop on my account.
EVAN: Didn’t think you’d show, man.
NOAH: Yeah, well. Thought I’d grace you with my presence.
MORGAN: We’re honored.
NOAH: You should be.
CLAIRE: Where’ve you been?
NOAH: Home.
CLAIRE: That’s not an answer.
NOAH: It’s the only one you’re getting.
EVAN: You ride that thing all the way out here?
NOAH: No, I flew.
EVAN: Funny.
NOAH: I thought so.
Noah takes a beer from the cooler without asking and walks toward the fire.
MORGAN: Hey! You owe me for that!
NOAH: Put it on my tab.
MORGAN: You don’t have a tab!
NOAH: Then it’s a very affordable night for me.
The group laughs. Noah smiles, but the expression disappears almost immediately.
Across the field, LANA sits alone on the hood of a car. She wears a dark skirt and a pale blouse. A Coke rests between her hands. She watches the fire without seeming to see it.
Noah notices her.
He looks away, takes a drink, then looks back.
CLAIRE: You going to talk to her?
NOAH: Who?
CLAIRE: Don’t be stupid.
NOAH: I’m not going to talk to anybody.
CLAIRE: Okay.
NOAH: Why do you say it like that?
CLAIRE: Like what?
NOAH: Like you know something.
CLAIRE: I know you.
NOAH: You really don’t.
CLAIRE: Maybe not as well as I thought.
Noah looks toward Lana again.
CLAIRE: Noah.
NOAH: What?
CLAIRE: If things are bad, you can tell somebody.
NOAH: Things aren’t bad.
CLAIRE: All right.
NOAH: I mean it.
CLAIRE: I heard you.
She lets the subject go. Noah walks toward Lana.
He stops a few feet from her.
LANA: Didn’t think you’d come.
NOAH: You knew I would.
LANA: Guess I did.
He sits beside her on the car hood. They don’t look at each other.
NOAH: I wrote something.
LANA: I bet you did.
NOAH: I mean it. This one’s good.
LANA: You always say that.
NOAH: Because they keep getting better.
LANA: Or you keep getting worse.
NOAH: That’s the nicest thing you’ve said to me all week.
Lana looks down at her drink.
LANA: Show me.
Noah pulls back his sleeve. Words are written along his forearm in black ink.
Lana reads it.
LANA: “I’m not a person. I’m a fuse. Don’t love me unless you want to burn.”
LANA: Dramatic.
NOAH: It’s a poem.
LANA: It’s a sentence.
NOAH: You don’t have to be cruel every time I show you something.
LANA: I wasn’t being cruel.
NOAH: You never are. That’s the problem. You just say things, and then I’m the one who gets upset.
LANA: Maybe you get upset too easily.
NOAH: Maybe you say things because you know I’ll get upset.
Lana finally turns toward him.
LANA: Do you want me to tell you it’s good?
NOAH: No.
LANA: Then what do you want?
NOAH: I don’t know.
LANA: That’s the problem, Noah. You never know what you want.
NOAH: I know what I don’t want.
LANA: And what’s that?
NOAH: This.
He gestures between them.
LANA: Then go.
NOAH: You always tell me to go.
LANA: Because you always threaten to.
NOAH: I’m not threatening you.
LANA: You say you’re leaving town. You say you’re leaving me. You say you’re going to get out and never look back.
NOAH: Maybe I am.
LANA: Then why are you still here?
Noah has no answer.
The bonfire pops loudly. Someone cheers across the field.
LANA: Do you think people can be cursed?
NOAH: What?
LANA: Cursed. Like they were born wrong.
NOAH: No.
LANA: You answered pretty quickly.
NOAH: Because it’s a stupid question.
LANA: Maybe you’re afraid of the answer.
NOAH: You’re not cursed, Lana. You’re just cruel.
She turns sharply.
LANA: And you let me be.
Noah looks at her. The accusation lands harder than he expected.
NOAH: I don’t know how to quit you.
LANA: That’s your problem.
NOAH: You kiss me like I’m the last thing keeping you alive.
LANA: You kiss me like you’re testing how much I can take.
He looks away.
NOAH: I don’t know what you want from me.
LANA: I want you to stop making me feel like I’m the worst thing that’s ever happened to you.
NOAH: Sometimes you are.
Lana goes still.
NOAH: I’m sorry.
LANA: Don’t apologize because you don’t like the way I look at you.
NOAH: I’m apologizing because I meant it.
LANA: That’s worse.
Silence.
NOAH: I can’t keep doing this.
LANA: Then don’t.
NOAH: You say that like it’s easy.
LANA: Maybe it is.
NOAH: You’d know, wouldn’t you? You could leave me tomorrow and go right back to your life. Church on Sunday. School on Monday. Everybody telling you what a good girl you are.
LANA: You think I care what they think?
NOAH: You care about everything they think.
LANA: You don’t know anything about my life.
NOAH: I know you pretend you’re fine until we’re alone. I know you get mad when I don’t call. I know you tell me to leave and then get angry when I do.
LANA: You make it sound like I planned all of that.
NOAH: I don’t know what you planned.
LANA: Maybe that’s because you never listen.
Noah takes a drag from his cigarette. His hand shakes slightly.
NOAH: I’m fading, Lana.
She stands and moves close to him.
LANA: Then let go.
She kisses him suddenly and passionately. He is caught off guard and stumbles back. His beer falls and shatters against the ground.
The music skips. Nobody nearby notices.
Noah pulls away.
NOAH: Don’t do that.
LANA: Do what?
NOAH: Kiss me like that when we’re fighting.
LANA: You kissed me back.
NOAH: That’s not the point.
LANA: It never is.
NOAH: I don’t want to die.
Lana looks at him for a long moment.
LANA: But you don’t want to live either.
NOAH: I just want it to stop.
LANA: Then let’s stop.
She holds out her hand.
Noah looks at it. Across the field, Casey sees them standing together.
CASEY: Noah!
Noah turns.
CASEY: You leaving?
NOAH: I’ll see you later.
CASEY: You said that last time.
NOAH: Casey—
CASEY: Just be careful, okay?
Noah looks at Casey. Something in his face almost changes.
NOAH: Yeah.
NOAH takes her hand.
They walk away from the bonfire and disappear into the corn.
Casey watches them go.
CLAIRE: What?
CASEY: Nothing.
CLAIRE: You look worried.
CASEY: I’m always worried about that idiot.
CLAIRE: He’ll be fine.
Casey looks toward the dark field.
CASEY: I hope so.
The bonfire burns. The radio continues playing.
Lights fade.
SCENE TWO — THE BARN
August 29, 1986. Morning.
The stage is nearly dark. A faint hiss of static comes from somewhere above.
Lights rise slowly on the Whitmore barn. Morning light enters through gaps in the old boards. Dust hangs in the air.
A rope is visible near a heavy beam. The hayloft is mostly concealed by shadow.
SHERIFF WARD enters with DEPUTY COLLINS. Ward stops immediately.
SHERIFF WARD: Jesus Christ.
He looks up.
SHERIFF WARD: Collins, get the coroner on the line.
DEPUTY COLLINS: Sheriff—
SHERIFF WARD: Now.
Collins exits. Ward remains still, looking toward the loft.
The barn door creaks.
LANA stands barefoot in a thin white nightgown. Her hair is loose. She looks pale but composed.
SHERIFF WARD: Lana. You shouldn’t be here.
LANA: I found him.
SHERIFF WARD: You what?
LANA: I found him.
SHERIFF WARD: When?
LANA: This morning.
SHERIFF WARD: What time?
LANA: I don’t know. Early.
SHERIFF WARD: You called the station?
LANA: Yes.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you go up there?
LANA: No.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you touch anything?
LANA: (Hesitates) No.
Ward studies her.
SHERIFF WARD: What were you doing out here?
LANA: I heard music.
SHERIFF WARD: Music?
LANA: Static, mostly. I thought it was an animal. I came to check.
SHERIFF WARD: You heard a Walkman?
LANA: I suppose.
SHERIFF WARD: You suppose?
LANA: I heard something. I didn’t know what it was.
SHERIFF WARD: And when you came in?
LANA: I saw him.
SHERIFF WARD: From where you’re standing?
LANA: Yes.
SHERIFF WARD: You could see the loft from here?
LANA: I could see enough.
Ward glances toward the loft again.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you scream?
LANA: No.
SHERIFF WARD: Why not?
LANA: I don’t know.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you cry?
LANA: No.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you feel anything?
Lana looks at him.
LANA: What kind of question is that?
SHERIFF WARD: A simple one.
LANA: Then ask a simple one.
Ward takes a sharp breath.
SHERIFF WARD: Go home, Lana.
LANA: Am I in trouble?
SHERIFF WARD: I didn’t say that.
LANA: But you think I am.
SHERIFF WARD: I think a boy is dead, and I need to understand why.
LANA: I didn’t kill him.
Ward studies her expression.
SHERIFF WARD: I didn’t ask you if you did.
Lana looks away.
LANA: You were going to.
SHERIFF WARD: Maybe.
LANA: Then ask.
Ward doesn’t answer immediately.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you see anyone else out here this morning?
LANA: No.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you see Noah yesterday?
LANA: Yes.
SHERIFF WARD: Where?
LANA: At school.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you talk?
LANA: A little.
SHERIFF WARD: About what?
LANA: Nothing important.
SHERIFF WARD: Was he upset?
LANA: Noah was always upset.
Ward writes something in his notebook.
SHERIFF WARD: Go home. I’ll need to speak with you again.
LANA: I understand.
She turns to leave.
SHERIFF WARD: Lana.
She stops.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you love him?
Lana remains facing away from him.
LANA: Yes.
SHERIFF WARD: Then I hope you understand why I’m going to ask you a lot of questions.
LANA: I understand.
She exits into the sunlight.
Collins returns.
DEPUTY COLLINS: Coroner’s on the way.
SHERIFF WARD: Good.
DEPUTY COLLINS: Was that the girlfriend?
SHERIFF WARD: Yes.
DEPUTY COLLINS: She seems calm.
SHERIFF WARD: People don’t all react the same way.
DEPUTY COLLINS: You think she knows something?
SHERIFF WARD: I think everybody knows something. The question is whether they know what it means.
Ward looks up toward the loft.
The hiss of static grows louder.
Blackout.
SCENE THREE — POLICE STATION INTERROGATION
August 30, 1986. Hollow Creek Police Station, 9:14 a.m.
A small interrogation room. One metal table, two chairs, a buzzing fluorescent light.
LANA sits straight-backed, her hands folded in her lap. Her wrists are bandaged.
WARD enters carrying a notepad and a tape recorder.
SHERIFF WARD: Morning, Lana.
LANA: Morning, Sheriff.
SHERIFF WARD: Thanks for coming in.
LANA: You asked me to.
SHERIFF WARD: I did.
He places the recorder on the table.
SHERIFF WARD: This is just so we have an accurate record of what we discuss.
LANA: I understand.
He presses RECORD.
SHERIFF WARD: Sheriff David Ward, Hollow Creek Police Department. Interview with Lana Whitmore regarding the death of Noah Merrick. August thirtieth, nineteen eighty-six, nine-fourteen a.m.
He leans back.
SHERIFF WARD: Let’s start with the bonfire. What time did you arrive?
LANA: Just after nine. Claire and Morgan picked me up.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you stay with them?
LANA: For a while.
SHERIFF WARD: And then?
LANA: I sat on a car.
SHERIFF WARD: Alone?
LANA: Until Noah came over.
SHERIFF WARD: What time was that?
LANA: Around ten-thirty.
SHERIFF WARD: What did you talk about?
LANA: Things.
SHERIFF WARD: Lana.
LANA: We talked about our relationship.
SHERIFF WARD: Were you arguing?
LANA: We were talking the way people talk when they’re angry.
SHERIFF WARD: Witnesses saw you leave together.
LANA: Yes.
SHERIFF WARD: Where did you go?
LANA: We walked.
SHERIFF WARD: Where?
LANA: Away from the bonfire.
SHERIFF WARD: That’s not a location.
LANA: It was a field, Sheriff. There’s a lot of it.
Ward watches her.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you go to the Whitmore barn?
Lana pauses briefly.
LANA: Not that night.
SHERIFF WARD: You were there three days later.
LANA: I found him there.
SHERIFF WARD: Did Noah have any reason to be at the barn?
LANA: He liked being alone.
SHERIFF WARD: Did he often go there?
LANA: Sometimes.
SHERIFF WARD: Why?
LANA: You’d have to ask him.
SHERIFF WARD: Lana, I’m asking you because I can’t ask him anymore.
Silence.
LANA: I know.
Ward opens a folder and places a photograph on the table, turned toward her.
SHERIFF WARD: Noah was strangled. There were injuries consistent with a struggle.
Lana doesn’t look at the photograph.
SHERIFF WARD: You knew him better than most people. Did he have enemies?
LANA: Everybody has enemies.
SHERIFF WARD: Did he have anyone who wanted him dead?
LANA: Not that I knew of.
SHERIFF WARD: Did he ever tell you he was afraid of someone?
LANA: No.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you hurt him?
LANA: No.
SHERIFF WARD: Did he hurt you?
LANA: No.
SHERIFF WARD: Your wrists are bandaged.
Lana looks down at them.
LANA: I cut them on a fence.
SHERIFF WARD: When?
LANA: I don’t remember.
SHERIFF WARD: You don’t remember when you injured yourself?
LANA: It wasn’t important.
SHERIFF WARD: It might be.
LANA: Then write it down.
Ward makes a note.
SHERIFF WARD: You and Noah had a difficult relationship.
LANA: Yes.
SHERIFF WARD: How long had you been together?
LANA: Almost a year.
SHERIFF WARD: And in that year, did you break up?
LANA: A few times.
SHERIFF WARD: How many?
LANA: I don’t know.
SHERIFF WARD: Three? Four? Ten?
LANA: Does it matter?
SHERIFF WARD: It matters if one of you was trying to leave and the other wouldn’t let them.
Lana looks at him.
LANA: Noah could leave whenever he wanted.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you want him to?
LANA: No.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you tell him that?
LANA: Yes.
SHERIFF WARD: What did he say?
LANA: That I couldn’t keep him.
SHERIFF WARD: Was he right?
Lana says nothing.
SHERIFF WARD: Lana, I’m going to ask you something, and I need you to answer honestly.
LANA: You keep saying that.
SHERIFF WARD: Because I keep getting half-answers.
LANA: Maybe that’s all there is.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you ever threaten Noah?
LANA: I said things when I was angry.
SHERIFF WARD: What things?
LANA: I don’t remember every word.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you ever threaten to hurt him?
Silence.
LANA: I don’t think so.
SHERIFF WARD: You don’t think so?
LANA: I can’t remember every fight we had.
SHERIFF WARD: I think you remember more than you’re telling me.
LANA: And I think you’ve already decided what kind of person I am.
Ward leans back.
SHERIFF WARD: I haven’t decided anything.
LANA: Then why does everybody keep asking me questions like the answers don’t matter?
SHERIFF WARD: Because we’re trying to find out what happened.
LANA: You want the story to make sense. You want there to be a beginning, a middle, and an end. You want one thing to point to another thing, and then you want to be able to say you understand.
SHERIFF WARD: That sure as hell would help.
LANA: Some things don’t make sense.
SHERIFF WARD: That doesn’t mean we stop asking.
Lana looks at the recorder.
LANA: Is it still recording?
SHERIFF WARD: Yes.
LANA: Good.
She looks back at him.
LANA: Then you’ll have it all.
Ward studies her.
SHERIFF WARD: That’s enough for now.
He switches off the recorder.
SHERIFF WARD: We’ll talk again.
LANA: I’m sure we will.
She stands. Ward watches her leave.
He looks down at his notes and then at the recorder.
SHERIFF WARD: What aren’t you telling me?
Blackout.
SCENE FOUR — CASEY’S DISCOVERY
August 30, 1986. Hollow Creek High School Library, 10:03 a.m.
A quiet library. A clock ticks. Students work at tables, whispering.
CASEY enters carrying a stack of books. Casey looks around, then notices a backpack abandoned in a corner of the library.
Casey recognizes it.
CASEY: Oh, no.
Casey walks toward it, then stops.
CASEY: No. Absolutely not.
Casey takes two steps away, then looks back.
CASEY: Just leave it alone.
Casey returns to the backpack and crouches beside it.
CASEY: This is a terrible idea.
Casey opens it.
Inside are gum wrappers, a church bulletin, a ChapStick cap, loose papers, and a battered copy of Wuthering Heights.
Casey picks up the book.
CASEY: Of course.
Casey opens it. The pages have been hollowed out to make space for a small black notebook.
Casey stares at it.
CASEY: Lana, what are you doing?
Casey pulls the notebook out, looks toward the library door, and opens it.
CASEY: I’m not reading this.
Casey closes it.
Silence.
Casey opens it again.
CASEY: Ok. Just one page.
Casey reads.
CASEY: “Noah kissed me like he was already dead.”
Casey stops.
The library sounds fade away.
CASEY: What?
Casey turns the page.
CASEY: “He says he wants to leave. He says it like leaving is a place he can get to if he just keeps walking. I told him he couldn’t go. He said I didn’t own him.”
Casey looks around, suddenly aware of the room.
CASEY: This isn’t funny.
Casey turns another page.
CASEY: “The rope was softer than I expected.”
Casey shuts the notebook.
For a moment, Casey does not move.
CASEY: No.
Casey opens it again, searching for context.
CASEY: “I don’t know where Noah ends and I begin anymore.”
Casey backs away from the table.
CASEY: No, no, no.
A LIBRARIAN looks up.
LIBRARIAN: Is everything all right?
CASEY: Yes.
LIBRARIAN: You look pale.
CASEY: I didn’t sleep.
LIBRARIAN: You should go home if you’re feeling ill.
CASEY: I can’t.
LIBRARIAN: Why not?
CASEY: I just can’t.
The librarian returns to work.
Casey stares at the notebook. Finally, Casey slips it inside the backpack and leaves the library.
Lights shift to Casey’s garage that evening.
A single bare bulb hangs from the ceiling. Boxes and old tools line the walls. Casey sits cross-legged on the floor with the journal and a flashlight.
Casey reads in silence for a long time.
CASEY: “He said we weren’t good for each other. I thought: then why does he keep looking at me like I’m fire and he’s cold?”
Casey turns the page.
CASEY: “I reached for the rope. I don’t remember the first pull. Only the second.”
Casey drops the notebook.
The sound of the bonfire returns faintly.
CASEY: Oh my God.
Casey stands, pacing.
CASEY: It could be a story. It could be something she wrote. People write things they don’t mean all the time. Even Noah wrote things he didn’t mean.
Casey stops.
CASEY: But what if she means it?
Casey picks up the notebook again.
CASEY: What if this is what happened?
Casey looks toward the audience.
CASEY: I knew they were bad for each other. Everybody knew. You could hear them fighting from the other side of a hallway. Then the next day they’d be sitting together like nothing happened.
Casey sits.
CASEY: Noah told me he was tired. He told me he wanted out.
Casey turns another page.
CASEY: Why didn’t he tell me how bad it was?
Silence.
CASEY: Maybe he did.
Casey remembers.
CASEY: He said he didn’t know how to leave without making things worse.
Casey closes the journal.
CASEY: I thought he meant he didn’t want to hurt her feelings.
Casey stands and puts the journal inside the backpack.
CASEY: I have to take this to somebody.
Casey reaches for the door, stops, and turns back.
CASEY: If I give it to the sheriff, they’ll know I read it.
Casey looks down at the backpack.
CASEY: If I don’t, and it turns out to be true—
Casey cannot finish the sentence.
After a moment, Casey leaves with the journal.
Blackout.
SCENE FIVE — THE QUIET HOUR
August 26, 1986. The Whitmore barn, shortly after midnight.
The stage is dark. Moonlight enters through gaps in the boards. The bonfire is now only a distant orange glow.
NOAH and LANA enter through the barn doors. They are both upset. Noah walks ahead of her.
NOAH: Why do you always twist everything I say?
LANA: Because you never say what you mean.
NOAH: I mean exactly what I say.
LANA: No, you don’t.
NOAH: I said I was tired.
LANA: And I asked you of what.
NOAH: Of this. Of us.
Lana stops walking.
LANA: You don’t mean that.
NOAH: Why do you get to decide what I mean?
LANA: Because I know you.
NOAH: You know what I do when I’m scared. You know what I say when I’m angry. You know how to make me feel guilty. That isn’t the same thing.
LANA: You think I don’t know you?
NOAH: I think you know how to keep me here.
LANA: You came here on your own.
NOAH: Because you called me.
LANA: I didn’t force you to answer.
NOAH: You knew I would.
Lana looks away.
LANA: Then don’t answer next time.
NOAH: There isn’t going to be a next time.
She turns back to him.
LANA: You said that last month.
NOAH: I meant it then, too.
LANA: But you’re still here.
NOAH: Because I keep thinking there’s a version of us where we stop hurting each other.
LANA: There is.
NOAH: Then why haven’t we found it?
Silence.
LANA: Maybe because you keep looking for a reason to leave.
NOAH: Maybe because you keep giving me one.
Noah walks toward the ladder.
LANA: Where are you going?
NOAH: Home.
LANA: We haven’t finished talking.
NOAH: We’re never finished talking.
LANA: Don’t do this.
NOAH: Do what?
LANA: Walk away.
NOAH: You told me to leave.
LANA: I didn’t mean right now.
NOAH: When did you mean it? When would it be okay for me to leave?
Lana has no answer.
NOAH: You don’t want me to leave, but you don’t want me to stay. You want me to keep proving that I won’t go, no matter what you say to me.
LANA: I want you to choose me.
NOAH: I did. Over and over and over again.
LANA: Then why do you keep threatening to leave?
NOAH: Because I can’t keep living like this.
He turns toward the ladder.
LANA: Noah.
He stops.
LANA: If you go, don’t come back.
NOAH: Okay.
He starts moving again.
LANA: I mean it.
NOAH: I know.
LANA: Noah, stop.
He stops at the foot of the ladder.
LANA: You’re not going to find anyone better out there.
NOAH: Maybe I don’t need to find anyone better. Maybe I just need to find someone different.
LANA: And what happens to me?
NOAH: You live your life.
LANA: You make it sound so easy.
NOAH: It won’t be easy.
LANA: Then stay.
NOAH: I can’t.
Lana looks around the barn. Her gaze settles on a length of rope near a beam.
LANA: You said you loved me.
NOAH: I do.
LANA: Then stay.
NOAH: That’s not what love means.
LANA: You don’t get to tell me what it means.
NOAH: Well somebody has to.
She steps closer.
LANA: You think you’re better than me.
NOAH: No.
LANA: You think you’re going to leave this town and write your little poems and become somebody, and I’ll be stuck here with everybody remembering what I did wrong.
NOAH: I never said that.
LANA: You don’t have to.
NOAH: You’re doing it again.
LANA: Doing what?
NOAH: Making me responsible for things I haven’t done.
Noah turns away.
NOAH: We’re not good for each other.
LANA: Then why do we keep coming back?
NOAH: Because we’re scared. Because we don’t know what we’re supposed to do when we’re not together. Because sometimes the bad parts feel easier than being alone.
Lana stares at him.
LANA: Is that what you think this is?
NOAH: I don’t know what this is anymore.
LANA: You used to know.
NOAH: I used to think I did.
He begins climbing down the ladder from the loft platform.
Lana moves toward the rope.
LANA: Noah.
NOAH: What?
LANA: Look at me.
He turns.
For a brief moment, they simply look at each other.
LANA: I don’t know how to do this without you.
NOAH: You’ll learn.
LANA: Don’t say that.
NOAH: (Putting his headphones on) Lana—
She suddenly loops the rope around his neck from behind and pulls. Noah thrashes, scratching at her arms, gasping. The struggle is messy, desperate. He claws, chokes — then goes limp. Lana holds the rope too long, then finally lets it go. She kneels beside his body, brushing his hair back, silence.
Lana stands frozen.
Noah lies motionless on the floor.
She approaches him slowly and kneels beside him.
LANA: Noah?
No answer.
LANA: Noah.
She touches his shoulder.
LANA: Stop it.
Silence.
LANA: Please.
She backs away.
The tape runs out and the Walkman begins to hiss with static.
Lana looks at it.
LANA: No.
She kneels beside Noah again, brushing his hair away from his forehead.
LANA: I love you.
She straightens his jacket. She closes her eyes for a moment, then opens them.
She stands and looks toward the barn door.
The distant sound of the bonfire has vanished.
Lights fade slowly to black.
SCENE SIX — THE SHERIFF’S OFFICE
September 1, 1986. 6:43 a.m.
WARD sits alone at his desk. An old desk fan turns slowly. A manila envelope lies in front of him, marked in large handwriting: READ THIS FIRST.
He opens it.
Inside is a hollowed copy of Wuthering Heights and the black journal.
He reads in silence for a while. Then he begins reading aloud.
SHERIFF WARD: “He said he was leaving. Said I was poison.”
He turns the page.
SHERIFF WARD: “I don’t remember grabbing the rope. Just the sound it made when it tightened.”
He stops reading. He looks at the page again.
SHERIFF WARD: “He looked at me like I was just a little girl in a too-big dress.”
He lowers the journal.
SHERIFF WARD: “And when it was over, I cried. But not for him. For me. Because I didn’t regret it.”
Ward closes the book.
He sits still for a long moment.
The telephone rings. He answers.
SHERIFF WARD: Ward.
He listens.
SHERIFF WARD: Yes. I have it.
He listens again.
SHERIFF WARD: No, I haven’t spoken to her since the interview.
Another pause.
SHERIFF WARD: I understand what the state needs. No, I’m not asking you to make a decision before you’ve seen the evidence.
He looks at the journal.
SHERIFF WARD: Yes. I’ll bring it in myself.
He hangs up.
COLLINS enters carrying two cups of coffee.
DEPUTY COLLINS: You look terrible.
SHERIFF WARD: Good morning to you, too.
DEPUTY COLLINS: You been here all night?
SHERIFF WARD: Most of it.
Collins notices the journal.
DEPUTY COLLINS: Is that what Casey found?
SHERIFF WARD: Yes.
DEPUTY COLLINS: You’ve read it?
SHERIFF WARD: Every page.
DEPUTY COLLINS: And?
SHERIFF WARD: And I’m not sure what to make of all of it.
DEPUTY COLLINS: It sounds pretty clear.
SHERIFF WARD: Some of it does.
DEPUTY COLLINS: Sheriff, she wrote that she used the rope.
SHERIFF WARD: I can read.
DEPUTY COLLINS: Then what’s the problem?
SHERIFF WARD: The problem is that a journal isn’t a witness. It’s evidence, and we need to know where it came from, when it was written, and whether the entries describe something that happened or something she imagined.
DEPUTY COLLINS: You think she made it up?
SHERIFF WARD: I think we don’t get to decide that because a sentence sounds convincing.
Collins takes a sip of coffee.
DEPUTY COLLINS: What about the fact that she found him?
SHERIFF WARD: That matters.
DEPUTY COLLINS: And the fact that she lied about going to the barn?
Ward looks up.
SHERIFF WARD: She told you that?
DEPUTY COLLINS: She told you she wasn’t there that night. The journal puts her there.
SHERIFF WARD: Then we ask her about it.
DEPUTY COLLINS: And if she admits it?
SHERIFF WARD: Then we record the statement and let the prosecutor determine what charges are appropriate.
DEPUTY COLLINS: You make it sound simple.
SHERIFF WARD: It isn’t.
He picks up the telephone.
SHERIFF WARD: Get me the state attorney. And bring in a recorder.
Lights fade.
SCENE SEVEN — HOLDING CELL
Later that morning. Hollow Creek Jail.
A dim holding cell. LANA sits on a narrow cot wearing a county sweatshirt. Her hair is untidy, but her expression is composed.
WARD enters with a Styrofoam cup of coffee. He stops outside the cell.
SHERIFF WARD: You hungry?
LANA: No.
SHERIFF WARD: You should eat something.
LANA: I’m not hungry.
He sets the coffee on a small shelf.
SHERIFF WARD: We found your journal.
Lana blinks once.
LANA: So?
SHERIFF WARD: You know what’s in it.
LANA: I wrote it.
SHERIFF WARD: You wrote about the barn.
LANA: I write about a lot of things.
SHERIFF WARD: You wrote about the rope.
LANA: Yes.
SHERIFF WARD: You wrote that you reached for it.
LANA: Yes.
SHERIFF WARD: Why?
LANA: Because I wanted to remember.
SHERIFF WARD: Remember what?
LANA: How it felt.
Ward watches her.
SHERIFF WARD: How what felt?
LANA: Being there.
SHERIFF WARD: Were you there when Noah died?
Lana looks away.
SHERIFF WARD: Lana.
LANA: I was there.
SHERIFF WARD: Why did you tell me you weren’t?
LANA: Because I didn’t want to tell you.
SHERIFF WARD: That’s not a reason.
LANA: It’s the only one I have.
SHERIFF WARD: Did you kill him?
Silence.
LANA: You already know what you think.
SHERIFF WARD: I want to hear what you say.
LANA: No, you want to hear me say it.
SHERIFF WARD: Say what?
LANA: That I did it. That I wanted to. That I’m the kind of person who could do something like that.
SHERIFF WARD: Your journal says you did.
LANA: You think words make everything real?
SHERIFF WARD: Words can tell us what happened.
LANA: They can also make something sound different from what it was.
SHERIFF WARD: Then explain it.
Lana looks at him.
LANA: I don’t know how.
SHERIFF WARD: Try.
Long silence.
LANA: I loved him.
SHERIFF WARD: I believe you cared about him.
LANA: No. You don’t understand. I loved him. I loved him when he was kind, and I loved him when he was cruel. I loved him when he told me he was leaving. I loved him when he looked at me like he couldn’t stand to be in the same room as me.
SHERIFF WARD: That doesn’t make what happened all right.
LANA: I didn’t say it did.
SHERIFF WARD: Then why are you talking about love?
LANA: Because everybody keeps asking me why. And I don’t know how to explain it without telling you that I loved him.
SHERIFF WARD: Love doesn’t answer the question.
LANA: Maybe there isn’t an answer you’ll accept.
Ward grips the bars.
SHERIFF WARD: The state’s attorney will be here soon. You’ll have to give a statement.
LANA: I already gave one.
SHERIFF WARD: You left things out.
LANA: I left things out of everything.
Ward watches her.
SHERIFF WARD: Why?
LANA: Because if you tell people everything, they find something to use against you.
SHERIFF WARD: That isn’t always true.
LANA: It’s true enough.
She looks at the coffee.
LANA: Is it cold?
SHERIFF WARD: Probably.
LANA: I don’t like cold coffee.
Ward almost smiles, then doesn’t.
SHERIFF WARD: I’ll get you another.
LANA: You don’t have to.
SHERIFF WARD: I know.
He exits.
Lana sits alone.
LANA: I didn’t mean for it to end like that.
She looks toward the empty doorway.
LANA: I didn’t.
Blackout.